Global Retail Brands Australia Pty Ltd v Bed Bath ‘N' Table Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Global Retail Brands Australia Pty Ltd v Bed Bath ‘N’ Table Pty Ltd [2024] FCAFC 139

Appeal from:

Bed Bath ‘N’ Table Pty Ltd v Global Retail Brands Australia Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 1587

Bed Bath ‘N’ Table Pty Ltd v Global Retail Brands Australia Pty Ltd (No 3) [2024] FCA 226

File number: VID 278 of 2024
Judgment of: NICHOLAS, KATZMANN AND DOWNES JJ
Date of judgment: 31 October 2024
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW – misleading or deceptive conduct – where, by its use of trade mark “HOUSE BED & BATH” (appellant’s mark) in relation to soft homewares in a market in which respondent’s trade mark “BED BATH ‘N’ TABLE” (respondent’s mark) has a significant reputation, appellant found to have contravened ss 18(1) and 29(1)(g) and (h) of Australian Consumer Law – where primary judge found appellant’s mark not deceptively similar to “BED BATH ‘N’ TABLE” but found appellant’s use of its mark misleading and deceptive – whether latter finding erroneous – where primary judge found that respondent had no independent reputation in “BED BATH” or “BED & BATH”, that there had been substantial and common third party use of “bed” and “bath” and “bed & bath” as navigational or category descriptors – where primary judge found that respondent’s reputation was “crucial” to conclusion that it engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct – relevance of respondent’s reputation in respondent’s mark – where primary judge did not find that appellant intended to mislead or deceive consumers – where primary judge found that appellant’s “wilful blindness” to risk of confusion provided a highly relevant expert opinion on whether appellant’s conduct was likely to mislead or deceive – where respondent contended that some consumers tended to shorten “BED BATH ‘N’ TABLE” to “BED BATH” and that primary judge should have found appellant intended to mislead or deceive consumers – relevance of “wilful blindness” finding – whether finding of misleading or deceptive conduct should be affirmed

TRADE MARKS – infringement – where primary judge found that appellant did not infringe respondents’ marks – whether primary judge erred in holding that appellant’s mark was used as a single composite trade mark – whether incorporation of “BED & BATH” likely to confuse consumers – whether similarities in respective marks would imply an association with respondent and/or its mark – whether primary judge placed undue weight on presence of “HOUSE” mark within appellant’s mark – whether primary judge should have found that respondent intended to mislead and deceive – whether primary judge should have found that appellant’s mark and respondent’s mark were deceptively similar

Legislation:

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Sch 2 (Australian Consumer Law), ss 18 and 29

Cases cited:

Aldi Foods Pty Ltd v Moroccanoil Israel Ltd (2018) 261 FCR 301; [2018] FCAFC 93

Australian Woollen Mills Ltd v FS Walton & Co Ltd (1937) 58 CLR 641

Berlei Hestia Industries Ltd v Bali Co Inc (1973) 129 CLR 353

BM Auto…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Global Retail Brands Australia Pty Ltd v Bed Bath ‘N' Table... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCAFC 139
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Global Retail Brands Australia Pty Ltd (GRBA) appealed against a decision of the primary judge in which she found that GRBA had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct and trade mark infringement by using the mark "HOUSE BED & BATH" in relation to its soft homewares retail stores. Bed Bath 'N' Table Pty Ltd (BBNT) cross-appealed against the primary judge’s decision to dismiss its claims for trade mark infringement. The central issue in this case was whether GRBA’s use of the mark “HOUSE BED & BATH” constituted misleading or deceptive conduct under sections 18(1) and 29(1)(g) and (h) of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The Court also considered whether GRBA’s mark was deceptively similar to BBNT’s mark “BED BATH ‘N’ TABLE”, thereby constituting trade mark infringement.

The Court found that the primary judge’s conclusion that GRBA’s conduct was misleading or deceptive was not supported by the evidence. The Court held that BBNT had not established that it had a reputation in “BED BATH” or “BED & BATH” alone. The Court also found that the primary judge’s evaluation of the confusion evidence was flawed as she gave it limited weight despite acknowledging that it showed some instances of consumer confusion. The Court held that the evidence did not justify the primary judge’s finding that GRBA’s conduct was likely to mislead or deceive. Additionally, the Court found that the primary judge was correct in concluding that GRBA’s mark was not deceptively similar to BBNT’s mark and therefore did not constitute trade mark infringement. The Court held that BBNT’s cross-appeal should be dismissed as the primary judge’s decision to dismiss the claims for trade mark infringement was correct.

The Court allowed GRBA’s appeal, dismissed BBNT’s cross-appeal, set aside the declarations, injunction, and other orders made by the primary judge, and ordered that the originating application be dismissed. The Court also ordered that GRBA pay BBNT’s costs of the proceeding, and that BBNT pay GRBA’s costs of the appeal and the cross-appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The cross-appeal be dismissed.

3. The declarations, injunction and other orders in paragraphs 1-12 (inclusive), 14 and 16 made by the primary judge on 13 March 2024 be set aside and in lieu thereof order that:

(a) The originating application be dismissed.

(b) The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of the proceeding.

4. The respondent to the appeal pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal and the cross-appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, we conclude that GRBA’s appeal should be allowed, the declaratory and injunctive relief granted by the primary judge should be set aside, and the claims for relief based on alleged contraventions of the ACL and passing off should be dismissed. We also conclude that the primary judge’s decision to dismiss the claims for relief under the TMA was correct and that BBNT’s cross-appeal should therefore be dismissed.FACTUAL BACKGROUNDBBNT BBNT has traded under, and by reference to, the words “BED BATH ‘N’ TABLE” since 1976. The primary judge found that BBNT has approximately 30% of the Australian market share for speciality homewares and allied products based on the store numbers. Its competitors include Adairs, Pillow Talk, Linen House and Sheridan, which specialise in the sale of bed linen, bathroom products and household linen. Her Honour found that BBNT is a significant business that occupies a dominant position in the speciality soft homewares sector (J [26]-[28]). The term “soft homewares” encompasses textile goods, such as bedding and bed linen (for example, sheet sets, pillowcases and quilt covers); bathroom products (bath linen, such as towels, and bathroom accessories, such as soap dishes and shower caddies); household linen (for example, table cloths, table runners, napkins, teas towels and place mats); kitchenware (for example, cutlery, plates and bowls, serving ware and glasses, cups and mugs); and other homewares (for example, cushions, throws, vases and candles). By contrast, “hard homewares” refers to items such as pots, pans, plates and knives (J [24]-[25]). Since the mid-1990s the BBNT brand has been consistently presented in accordance with the company’s brand guidelines in block capital letters on a plain background as follows: BBNT stores typically display the brand prominently above the store entrance. The primary judge found the following presentation to be typical of BBNT’s physical stores: The primary judge found that store signage used by BBNT typically appears in illuminated letters in white and green (J [31]). The primary judge also found that, until the launch of House B&B by GRBA, BBNT was the only retailer in Australia to use the words “bed” and “bath” in its name for over 40 years (J [75]). The primary judge found that the BBNT brand had been used on packaging of BBNT’s goods, point of sale material, invoices and bags. The brand has been advertised and promoted extensively through the distribution of catalogues and email communications with customers. The brand has also been advertised and promoted in magazines including Better Homes & Gardens and Vogue Living and has also been featured in television programs including Channel 7’s “Postcards” and “House Rules” (J [33]-[34]). More recently, the focus of BBNT’s advertising has been on its website, social media and email communications (J [34]), including with members of a customer loyalty scheme established by BBNT which has almost 3 million members in Australia (J [42]). BBNT has operated an online store since 2013, and a Facebook page since 2017. It also operates Instagram and Pinterest accounts and undertakes digital advertising through Facebook and Google (J [43]-[47]).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

With regard to both the BBNT mark and the House B&B mark, the primary judge did not consider that the words “bed” and “bath” as used in those marks perform a purely descriptive function. Her Honour observed that BBNT and GRBA sell bed and bath related products, but not beds or baths. She considered the words as used in the relevant marks to be “more allusive than directly descriptive” (J [431]).Consumer Evidence The primary judge noted that the parties accepted that the relevant class of consumer shopping for soft homewares is the general public or the “ordinary reasonable consumer” (J [82]). Evidence was given by various BBNT store employees relating to the alleged tendency of consumers to shorten the name BBNT and to instances of alleged customer confusion. Her Honour considered that this evidence should be treated with some caution. She characterised the evidence of the store employees as “essentially survey evidence” but “of a very low quality” because it was not randomised or representative and had been in effect “handpicked” by BBNT (J [113]). Having referred to various authorities concerned with the utility of such evidence, her Honour went on to conclude that the evidence should be given some weight as it showed that a reasonable number of consumers tended to shorten BBNT to “BED BATH” or “BED & BATH” but that this evidence was not “conclusive of establishing that tendency” (J [114]). Her Honour also considered other evidence of the alleged tendency to shorten the BBNT name which she gave either very little, or no, weight (J [115] – [119]). Her Honour concluded at J [120]:Even if I was wholly satisfied that consumers have a tendency to shorten the BBNT name, I do not consider that, in any event, BBNT has established that it has any independent reputation in “BED BATH” or “BED & BATH” alone.Her Honour added at J [124]:I therefore consider that, although consumers may have a tendency to occasionally shorten the BBNT name in informal settings such as in store or on the phone, BBNT has not established that it has a reputation, in any formal or institutional sense, in “BED BATH” or “BED & BATH” alone. Later in her reasons, her Honour referred in some detail to the store employees’ evidence of customer confusion, including that of Ms Natalie Anna Erdossy (assistant store manager, Chadstone), Ms Honor Bettina van der Plight (store manager, Doncaster) and Mr Mitchell John Andrew Tabe (assistant store manager, Doncaster). In the course of evaluating this evidence, her Honour referred to what she described as its indirect nature and said at J [333] that “[t]he starting point is that indirect evidence of alleged confusion should be given little or no weight, particularly where no explanation has been given for the failure to call direct evidence”. Her Honour also quoted (at J [271]) State Government Insurance Corporation v Government Insurance Office of New South Wales (GIO) (1991) 28 FCR 511 at 529 per French J, where his Honour observed that “if the inference is open, independently of such testimonial evidence, that the conduct is misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive, then it may be that the evidence of consumers that they have been misled can strengthen that inference”. Her Honour concluded at J [340]:I consider that the confusion evidence is admissible, but I give it limited weight. I accept that the evidence alone is not sufficient to establish deceptive similarity, misleading and deceptive conduct, or passing off. Although there are evident issues with the reliability and cogency of some of the evidence, there are examples of consumers, or other members of the public, confusing House B&B with BBNT and thinking there was some association between the two stores. Therefore, as I discuss below with respect to the ACL claim, the confusion evidence has a role in so far as it confirms other inferences available from the evidence that GRBA’s conduct caused confusion among the ordinary and reasonable consumer.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In support of the primary judge’s ultimate conclusion, BBNT also relied on her Honour’s evaluation of the alleged confusion evidence, which she found at J [520] showed that some consumers were “caused to wonder” and did question whether there was an association between House B&B and BBNT.CONSIDERATION For reasons which we will develop in the context of the cross-appeal, we consider that the primary judge’s finding that the House B&B mark was not deceptively similar to the BBNT mark was plainly correct. Having found that the House B&B mark was not deceptively similar to the BBNT mark, the primary judge went on to find not merely that the GRBA’s use of the House B&B mark was likely to cause confusion but that it was also likely to mislead or deceive. In our opinion the evidence did not justify the primary judge’s finding that GRBA had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct. Before explaining why, we will briefly refer to the legal principles relevant to this topic. First, it is necessary to identify the relevant conduct and the person or class of persons to whom the relevant conduct is directed: Campomar Sociedad Limitada v Nike International Ltd (2000) 202 CLR 45; [2000] HCA 12 (“Campomar”) at [103]. In the present case the relevant conduct consists of operating one or more soft homewares retail stores under, and by reference to, the House B&B mark. The relevant class comprises ordinary or reasonable members of the class of prospective purchasers of soft homewares. Secondly, the question whether the relevant conduct gave rise to a contravention of the ACL is to be assessed at the date the relevant conduct first occurred: Taco Co of Australia Inc v Taco Bell Pty Ltd (1982) 42 ALR 177 (“Taco Bell”) at 196 per Deane and Fitzgerald JJ. In this case that date is 14 May 2021, being the date GRBA’s Doncaster store opened using the House B&B signage. Thirdly, the respondent’s conduct must be considered against the background of the immediate and broader context in which it occurred, including relevant surrounding facts and circumstances: Self Care IP Holdings Pty Ltd v Allergan Australia Pty Ltd (2023) 277 CLR 186; [2023] HCA 8 (“Self Care”) at [82]. In the present case these will include the strength of BBNT’s reputation in the BBNT mark. Fourthly, whether or not conduct is likely to mislead or deceive is an objective question which the Court must determine for itself: Taco Bell at 202 per Deane and Fitzgerald JJ. Conduct will be likely to mislead or deceive if there is a real or not remote chance or possibility that the relevant person or class of persons will be misled or deceived: Global Sportsman Pty Ltd v Mirror Newspapers Ltd (1984) 2 FCR 82 at 87. Fifthly, while in some cases conduct may be misleading or deceptive without conveying a misleading or deceptive representation, in cases involving what is said to amount to conduct in the nature of passing off, it is necessary for the applicant to show that the respondent’s use of the impugned name or get-up is likely to convey to ordinary and reasonable members of the relevant class a false or misleading representation that the respondent’s products or services are associated in some way with the applicant or its product or services: Taco Bell at 202 per Deane and Fitzgerald JJ, cf. Henjo Investments Pty Ltd v Collins Marrickville Pty Ltd (No 1) (1988) 39 FCR 546 at 555 per Lockhart J (with whom Burchett and Foster JJ agreed). This is how BBNT’s case based on ss 18 and 29 of the ACL was pleaded.