Orders
Orders of the court
1. The Applicant’s application be dismissed.
2. The First Respondent’s application by cross-claim be dismissed in so far as it concerns registered trade mark number 1388154 (for “CORNER HOTEL”) and registered trade mark number 1623364 (for “CORNER PRESENTS”).
3. Within 14 days, the First Respondent is to file and serve a notice stating whether it maintains its application by cross-claim in so far as it concerns registered trade mark number 1442211 (for “CORNER”) and registered trade mark number 1669900 for (“THE CORNER”).
4. Within 21 days, the parties are to file and serve an agreed timetable for the resolution of:
(a) the First Respondent’s application by cross-claim (if maintained by the First Respondent); and
(b) the costs of the proceeding,
or, in the absence of agreement, the timetable proposed by each party.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
For the reasons that follow, I dismiss Swancom’s application, including its application for cancellation or amendment of the Registered Jazz Corner marks. In relation to JCHPL’s cross-claim for cancellation of the Swancom marks in respect of the registered services in class 41, I dismiss the claim in respect of the CORNER HOTEL and the CORNER PRESENTS marks. In relation to the CORNER and THE CORNER marks, the parties will be afforded an opportunity to make further submissions on the question whether the registration of those marks in respect of services in class 41 should be amended, or a condition or limitation should be entered on the registration, to preserve the freedom of hotels, cafés, bars and restaurants, who may provide ancillary entertainment services (for example, free live music or sporting events shown on large screens) to use the word “corner” in their trading name.B. OVERVIEW OF EVIDENCE Evidence in the proceeding was given primarily by way of affidavit with relatively confined cross-examination. No challenge was made to the credit of any of the witnesses who were cross-examined, and no material challenge was made to their reliability. Documentary evidence was largely exhibited to the affidavits, and a small number of additional documents were tendered. During the course of the applicant's opening submissions, senior counsel for the applicant, aided by a solicitor for the applicant, presented to the Court a live scroll-through view of certain pages of the website appearing at (The Jazz Corner Hotel website). Screenshots were made of the pages of the website that the Court was taken to and, with the agreement of the respondents, those screenshots were exhibited to an affidavit of Anthony Watson (a partner at the firm of K&L Gates, solicitors for the applicant) affirmed 19 March 2020. In addition, on the application of the respondents and pursuant to rule 14.03 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the Court conducted a view of the businesses conducted by each of the first to third respondents at the William Street building on the morning of 17 March 2020. A video recording of the view was made by Mr Watson and was exhibited to his affidavit of 19 March 2020. A video recording was also made by Havva Celik, a legal representative of the respondents, and was exhibited to her affidavit sworn 19 March 2020. Swancom adduced evidence from the following witnesses:(a)Timothy Northeast is the managing director of Swancom. Mr Northeast affirmed two affidavits dated 11 December 2019 and 26 February 2020. He gave evidence about the history of the Corner Hotel, its acquisition by Swancom, its operations under the ownership of Swancom and the use of the Swancom marks. Mr Northeast also gave evidence about bands and musicians that have performed at both the Corner Hotel and Bird’s Basement in Melbourne. Mr Northeast was cross-examined.(b)Fiona Duncan has worked in the Australian music industry for over 32 years, primarily as a general manager for various bands and musicians, including Spiderbait, The Breadmakers, Spazzys and The Puritans. Ms Duncan affirmed an affidavit dated 21 November 2019, giving opinion evidence about the reputation of the Corner Hotel as a music venue. Ms Duncan was cross-examined.(c)Richard Moffat has worked in the Australian music industry for over 30 years, primarily working as a “Booker”, booking live music venues in Melbourne for artists to perform at and, since 2000, as a “Festival Programmer”, which involves booking artists to perform at live music festivals around Australia. Mr Moffatt affirmed an affidavit dated 26 November 2019, giving opinion evidence about the reputation of the Corner Hotel as a music venue. Mr Moffat was cross-examined.(d)James Young has worked in the Australian music industry for over 35 years, principally as an owner/operator of live music venues, but also as a breakfast show presenter for Melbourne community station Triple R from 1990 to 1995, and later as a programmer for that station from 1995 to 1998, a booking agent for artists to perform at third party venues and a manager for various bands and artists. Mr Young affirmed an affidavit dated 4 December 2019, giving opinion evidence about the reputation of the Corner Hotel as a music venue. Mr Young was cross-examined.(e)Leigh Treweek is a publisher with over 24 years' experience in the music industry. Since 2015, Mr Treweek has operated a music management business called "Handshake Management", working with a number of artists. Since 2018, Mr Treweek has also owned and worked in a business called "Handshake Media", which publishes one of Australia's largest music media publications called "The Music" and which has over 2.2 million subscribers. Prior to that, Mr Treweek was a director of Street Press Australia which owned Impress Magazine, which also included a comprehensive Victorian gig guide. Mr Treweek affirmed an affidavit dated 12 December 2019, giving opinion evidence about the reputation of the Corner Hotel as a music venue. Mr Treweek was not cross-examined.(f)Michael Thomas has been a professional musician for over 40 years perhaps most famously as the lead singer and lead guitarist of the band Weddings Parties Anything, a multi-award winning band that received four Australian Recording Industry Association Music Awards, and as a solo performer after the band's break-up in 1999. Mr Thomas has also been a part-owner in three hotels and live music venues over various periods from 1998, being the Merri Creek Tavern in Melbourne, the Yarra Hotel in Abbottsford and the Oxford Hotel in Perth. Mr Thomas estimated that he had performed at the Corner Hotel at least 25 times from late 1986 to 2008. Mr Thomas affirmed an affidavit dated 12 December 2019, giving opinion evidence about the reputation of the Corner Hotel as a music venue. Mr Thomas was cross-examined.(g)Daniel Rogers is a music promoter with over 18 years' experience in that role in Australia and overseas. He owns and works in the following businesses which operate within the music industry in Australia: Lunatic Entertainment (a music management company which has been operating for 18 years and provides services to artists that include the organisation of tours and other live music events); Laneway Presents (a music touring company which has been operating for eight years and provides services to artists that includes promotion and touring in small live music venues through to arena and outdoor field concerts); St Jerome’s Laneway Festival (an annual music festival which has been operating for 16 years and is currently held in six cities across Australia and New Zealand); and Fairgrounds Festival (an annual music festival which has been operating for four years). Mr Rogers affirmed an affidavit dated 13 December 2019, giving opinion evidence about the reputation of the Corner Hotel as a music venue. Mr Rogers was not cross-examined.(h)Shane Homan has been an Associate Professor in Media and Cultural Studies in the School of Media, Film and Journalism at Monash University since 2008, where he is also a member of the Culture, Media, Economy research group. He has been researching Australian music venues since 1994. Mr Homan affirmed an affidavit dated 12 December 2019, giving opinion evidence about venues for live music in Melbourne and the role and reputation of the Corner Hotel in the live music industry. I admitted Mr Homan’s affidavit while reserving the assessment of the weight to be given to his evidence. As discussed further below, in my view Mr Homan’s evidence has limited significance to the issues to be determined in this proceeding. Mr Homan was cross‑examined. (i)Leonard Hickey is a solicitor employed by the law firm K&L Gates, the solicitors for Swancom in the proceeding. Mr Hickey affirmed an affidavit dated 25 October 2019. Mr Hickey adduced evidence relating to the businesses conducted by the respondents including photographs of building signage, brochures and webpage screenshots. Mr Hickey was not cross-examined. (j)Timothy Appleby is a solicitor employed by the law firm K&L Gates, the solicitors for Swancom in the proceeding. Mr Appleby affirmed an affidavit dated 26 February 2020. Mr Appleby gave evidence about the jazz club in New York which trades as "Birdland" and its use of the phrase "Jazz Corner of the World". Mr Appleby also gave evidence about Australian trade mark applications and registered trade marks that include the word "corner" or the words "the corner". Mr Appleby was not cross-examined.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Third, and as a corollary of the second reason, Swancom’s application was effectively to exclude live music services from the scope of the registration of the Registered Jazz Corner marks, but I have concluded that such services are not within the scope of the registration.G. CONCLUSION In conclusion, Swancom’s claim that the respondents have infringed the Swancom marks is dismissed, principally on the basis that the Jazz Corner marks used by the respondents are not deceptively similar to the Swancom marks. Swancom’s claim for cancellation or amendment of the Registered Jazz Corner marks under s 88(2)(a) of the TMA is also dismissed. In relation to the claim by JCHPL for cancellation of the Swancom marks, the claim in respect of the CORNER HOTEL and the CORNER PRESENTS marks is dismissed. However, in relation to the CORNER and THE CORNER marks, the parties will be afforded an opportunity to make further submissions on the question whether the registration of those marks in respect of services in class 41 should be amended, or a condition or limitation should be entered on the registration, to preserve the freedom of hotels, cafés, bars and restaurants that may provide ancillary entertainment services (for example, free live music or sporting events shown on large screens), to use the word “corner” in their trading name. The parties will also be afforded an opportunity to make submissions as to the award of costs of the proceeding.