Cantarella Bros Pty Limited v Modena Trading Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 62 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
HAYNE, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND GAGELER JJ

CANTARELLA BROS PTY LIMITED  APPELLANT

AND

MODENA TRADING PTY LIMITED  RESPONDENT

Cantarella Bros Pty Limited v Modena Trading Pty Limited

[2014] HCA 48

3 December 2014

S67/2014

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed with costs.

2.Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 30 September 2013 and, in their place, order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

A J L Bannon SC with M Green for the appellant (instructed by Clayton Utz Lawyers)

I M Jackman SC with C L Cochrane for the respondent (instructed by Corrs Chambers Westgarth Lawyers)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. FRENCH CJ, HAYNE, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ.   In this appeal from a decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia the appellant, Cantarella Bros Pty Limited ("Cantarella"), seeks to restore to the Register of Trade Marks ("the Register") two of its registered trade marks ordered to be cancelled by the Full Court.

  2. The appeal turns upon the provisions of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) ("the Act"), and the question of whether the two trade marks are "inherently adapted to distinguish" the goods for which they were registered from the goods of other persons. The question arose on a cross‑claim of the respondent, Modena Trading Pty Limited ("Modena"), claiming as an "aggrieved person"[1] that the two trade marks were liable to be cancelled because they were not "inherently adapted to distinguish" Cantarella's goods.

    [1]Within the meaning of the Act, s 88(1).

  3. In proceedings in the Federal Court seeking declaratory and injunctive relief and damages, Cantarella claimed that Modena had infringed two of its registered trade marks[2].  The first is Australian trade mark registration No 829098 for the trade mark "ORO", registered since 24 March 2000 in class 30 in respect of "Coffee; beverages made with a base of coffee, espresso; ready‑to‑drink coffee; coffee based beverages".  The second is Australian trade mark registration No 878231 for the trade mark "CINQUE STELLE", registered since 6 June 2001 in class 30 in respect of "Coffee, coffee essences and coffee extracts; coffee substitutes and extracts of coffee substitutes; coffee‑based drinks; tea, tea extracts and tea‑based drinks; cocoa, cocoa‑based preparations and drinks".

    [2]Contrary to the Act, s 120(2).

  4. Before the primary judge, Cantarella succeeded in establishing infringement.  Modena failed in its defence that it had merely used the marks as an indication of quality, and in its cross‑claim that the trade marks were not "inherently adapted to distinguish" Cantarella's goods.  Modena did not appeal from the primary judge's findings concerning infringement.  As to the cross‑claim, the primary judge found that, although an Italian speaker would appreciate that "oro" signifies some connection with gold, and that "cinque stelle" signifies five stars, it could not be concluded that "oro" and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cantarella Bros Pty Limited v Modena Trading Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] HCA 48
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cantarella Bros Pty Limited (Cantarella) appealed to the High Court of Australia against a decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia concerning the registrability of its trade marks "ORO" and "CINQUE STELLE" for coffee products. Modena Trading Pty Limited (Modena) had sought the cancellation of these registrations.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the trade marks "ORO" and "CINQUE STELLE", which are Italian words meaning "gold" and "five stars" respectively, were inherently adapted to distinguish Cantarella's coffee products from those of other traders. This involved considering the ordinary signification of these words in the context of the coffee industry and whether rival traders might have a legitimate need to use them to describe their own goods.

The High Court reasoned that the Full Court had correctly applied section 41 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth). The Court found that the evidence did not demonstrate that honest traders would legitimately wish to use the words "oro" or "cinque stelle" to directly describe the character or quality of their coffee products. Therefore, the trade marks were considered inherently adapted to distinguish Cantarella's goods. The appeal was allowed, and the orders of the Full Court were set aside, with the result that Modena's appeal to that Court was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 30 September 2013 and, in their place, order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, the appeal to this Court should be allowed and the orders made by the Full Court, including the order for rectification of the Register, should be set aside. The facts Both Cantarella and Modena advertise, offer for sale and sell coffee products in the Australian coffee industry. Cantarella Cantarella has, since 1958, imported raw coffee beans sourced globally, which are then roasted, ground, and packaged under the registered trade marks "VITTORIA", "AURORA", "DELTA" and "CHICCO D'ORO". Evidence of the state of the Register on 25 May 2011 showed that Cantarella was the registered proprietor of the trade mark "ORO NERO", registered in class 30 in respect of goods which included "coffee", and the composite trade marks "MEDAGLIA D'ORO", registered in classes 29, 30 and 32 for a variety of foodstuffs and beverages, and "CHICCO D'ORO", registered in class 30 in respect of "coffee". Each of these registrations preceded the registration for "ORO" on its own. The trade marks "ORO" and "CINQUE STELLE" are used by Cantarella in relation to specific coffee blends. There was no issue at trial that the trade marks "ORO" and "CINQUE STELLE" are in fact distinctive of Cantarella's goods. Each registered trade mark is used by Cantarella not only in Australia, but also in other countries, and Cantarella's trade marks are registered in many of those countries. Modena Modena imports coffee from Molinari, a company based in central northern Italy. Molinari has, since 1965, produced a blend of coffee using the marks "CAFFÈ MOLINARI" and "ORO". Molinari exports globally, and began exporting products to Australia in about July 1996. From 1996 to 2009, various businesses distributed Molinari products in Australia, using the marks "CAFFÈ MOLINARI" together with "ORO" (from 1996) and "CAFFÈ MOLINARI" together with "CINQUE STELLE" (from 1998). In November 2009, Modena was appointed as Molinari's exclusive Australian distributor. During the period December 2009 to June 2011, Modena distributed various Molinari products, under and by reference to the abovementioned marks used by Molinari. Approximately 18 months before the trial Molinari ceased using the mark "ORO" on its own on its coffee products and substituted the phrase "QUALITÀ ORO", about which Cantarella has no complaint[5]. Further, "CINQUE STELLE" has come to be used by Molinari in respect of its premium blend of coffee.[5]It was noted in the primary judge's orders that nothing in them should be taken to prevent Modena from using the phrase "QUALITÀ ORO" in respect of its products.Other matters There was evidence at trial that coffee products were advertised, offered for sale and sold by companies operating in the coffee industry other than Cantarella and Modena, under and by reference to composite marks which included the Italian word "oro" or the form "d'oro" or the expression "five star" and, in one instance, the word "stelle". That included evidence of the state of the Register led by Cantarella, and evidence of screen shots and packaging samples relied on by Modena.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, HAYNE, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ GAGELER J (dissent)
Modena's complaint that the primary judge insufficiently considered the desires of rival traders to use the words "oro" or "cinque stelle" to directly describe their coffee goods was premised on a misconception that such was demonstrated by the evidence. The primary judge was right to reject Modena's submission, based on the evidence, that honest traders might legitimately wish to use the words to directly describe, or indicate, the character or quality of their goods. Conclusion For the reasons given, Cantarella's registered trade marks "ORO" and "CINQUE STELLE" are inherently adapted to distinguish the goods for which they are registered from the goods of other persons. Orders Orders should be made as follows:1. Appeal allowed with costs.2.Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 30 September 2013 and, in their place, order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs. Agreeing with the Full Court of the Federal Court's construction and application of s 41 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) ("the Act"), I would dismiss the appeal. Construction Part of the design of the Act was to implement Australia's obligations under the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights ("TRIPS"), which forms Annex 1C to the Marrakesh Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization ("the WTO"), done at Marrakesh on 15 April 1994. Article 15.1 of TRIPS provides: "Any sign, or any combination of signs, capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one undertaking from those of other undertakings, shall be capable of constituting a trademark. Such signs ... shall be eligible for registration as trademarks. Where signs are not inherently capable of distinguishing the relevant goods or services, Members may make registrability depend on distinctiveness acquired through use."Article 1.1 of TRIPS provides that Members of the WTO "shall be free to determine the appropriate method of implementing the provisions of [TRIPS] within their own legal system and practice". The Act tracks the language of Art 15.1 of TRIPS in defining a "trade mark", in s 17, in terms of a "sign" and requiring, in s 41, rejection of an application for a trade mark that is not "capable of distinguishing" the applicant's goods or services from the goods or services of other persons. Giving content to the expression "capable of distinguishing", however, the Act departs from the language of Art 15.1 of TRIPS in favour of language drawn from earlier Australian trade mark legislation. That departure is deliberate. The language chosen has a long history and long before 1995 had acquired a stable meaning. The Working Party, acceptance of whose recommendation by the Australian Government led to the introduction of s 41[92], stated that it had "no intention of changing the current concept of distinctiveness as measured by existing provisions"[93].[92]Australia, House of Representatives, Parliamentary Debates (Hansard), 27 September 1995 at 1910.[93]Working Party to Review the Trade Marks Legislation, Recommended Changes to the Australian Trade Marks Legislation, (1992) at 43.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, HAYNE, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ,

The Court in Cantarella Bros Pty Limited v Modena Trading Pty Limited considered the inherent distinctiveness of the trade marks "ORO" and "CINQUE STELLE" in relation to coffee products. The Court examined whether these marks were inherently adapted to distinguish Cantarella's goods from those of other persons, taking into account the ordinary signification of the words in the relevant market and the desires of honest traders. The Court found that both trade marks were inherently adapted to distinguish Cantarella's goods from those of other persons, rejecting Modena's argument that the marks were merely descriptive and could be legitimately used by other traders.

In determining whether the trade marks were inherently adapted to distinguish Cantarella's goods, the Court applied the legal principle that a trade mark must be capable of distinguishing the applicant's goods or services from those of other persons, as outlined in s 41 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The Court considered the ordinary signification of the words "ORO" and "CINQUE STELLE" in the context of the coffee market. The Court noted that "ORO" is a Spanish and Italian word meaning "gold," which signifies high quality, while "CINQUE STELLE" translates to "five stars" in Italian, indicating excellence. The Court held that these words, when used in combination as trade marks, were inherently adapted to distinguish Cantarella's coffee products from those of other persons, as they conveyed a sense of quality and superiority.

The Court also considered whether the trade marks were capable of distinguishing Cantarella's goods from those of other persons, having regard to the use of the marks in the market. The Court found that Cantarella had used the trade marks "ORO" and "CINQUE STELLE" consistently and exclusively for its coffee products, both in Australia and internationally. The Court held that the extensive and consistent use of the marks by Cantarella established their distinctiveness and their capacity to distinguish its goods from those of other traders.

Further, the Court examined whether the trade marks were capable of distinguishing Cantarella's goods from those of other persons, having regard to the desires of honest traders. The Court rejected Modena's argument that honest traders might wish to use the words "oro" or "cinque stelle" to directly describe their coffee products. The Court found that the evidence did not support Modena's contention and held that the trade marks were capable of distinguishing Cantarella's goods from those of other persons, even considering the desires of honest traders.

In applying the relevant provisions of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), the Court adhered to the principles established in earlier Australian trade mark legislation, which had a stable meaning and long history. The Court noted that the Act, while implementing Australia's obligations under the TRIPS Agreement, retained the traditional concept of distinctiveness. The Court found that the trade marks "ORO" and "CINQUE STELLE" met the statutory requirement of being capable of distinguishing Cantarella's goods from those of other persons.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the trade marks "ORO" and "CINQUE STELLE" are inherently adapted to distinguish Cantarella's coffee products from those of other persons, considering their ordinary signification in the market, their use, and the desires of honest traders. The Court set aside the orders of the Full Court and dismissed the appeal, holding that the trade marks were valid and should remain registered in Cantarella's name.