Binggrae Co Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Trade mark application number 2337475 (class 29) – Shape: three dimensional shape of a bottle - in the name of Binggrae Co., Ltd

Delegate:

Tracey Berger

Representation:

Applicant: King & Wood Mallesons

Decision:

2024 ATMO 165

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – request to be heard under s 33(4) – s 41 ground for rejection considered – trade mark to some extent inherently adapted to distinguish – insufficient evidence of use – application rejected

Background

1. This matter is an ex parte proceeding pursuant to s 33 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)[1] concerning an application by Binggrae Co Ltd (‘Applicant’) to register the trade mark detailed below:

Number:           2337475 (‘Application’)

[1] Unless otherwise indicated, any references to sections or regulations, below, are references to sections or regulations of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’) or the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) (‘Regulations’), respectively.

Trade Mark:  (‘Trade Mark’)

Filing Date:      24 February 2023

Goods: Milk beverages (milk predominating); milk; milk products (‘Goods’)

2.     The Application was examined pursuant to s 31 and a ground for rejection was raised by the Examiner under s 41.  The Examiner objected that the Trade Mark is not capable of distinguishing the Goods because the mark is the shape of a container with a wide mid-section that tapers towards the base and has a narrow top, and is predominantly functional in nature.  The Examiner opined that it is common for traders of milk products to use varying shapes and sizes of beverage containers and other traders should be able to use this shape in connection with their similar goods and services.

3.     In response, the Applicant filed submissions, but the Examiner maintained the objection noting Part 21.3.8 of the Trade Marks Manual of Practice and Procedure which reads:

Packaging may include the container in which the goods are sold or the outer packaging which covers the goods and the container. Shape is just one aspect of packaging and the more unusual the shape of the container or box applied for as a trade mark, the more likely it is to be capable of distinguishing [the Goods]. However, there are currently many different ways of styling and presenting containers and packaging and so most variations on the ordinary will not meet registrability requirements.

4.     The Examiner considered that whilst the Trade Mark had some ‘slight nuances’ from the standard containers used for the Goods, the ordinary signification of the mark is a container and the particular shape ‘is not so fanciful as to stand out to consumers as indicating the origin of the contained goods.’

5.     Further submissions by the Applicant did not persuade the Examiner to withdraw the objection and a third examination report issued.  Following this further adverse report, the Applicant request a hearing by written submissions which were filed on 29 August 2024 with a declaration of James Henry Blaxland Parker made on 27 August…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Binggrae Co Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ATMO 165
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Binggrae Co Ltd sought to register a three-dimensional shape of a bottle as a trade mark for milk beverages and related products. The application was initially examined and rejected by the Examiner on the grounds that the shape was not capable of distinguishing the applicant's goods from those of other traders, primarily due to its functional nature and the common use of various container shapes in the milk product industry. The applicant requested a hearing by written submissions to argue for the registrability of the mark.

The delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks was required to determine whether the trade mark application should be rejected under section 41 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth). Specifically, the delegate had to assess whether the trade mark was inherently adapted to distinguish the applicant's goods, and if not sufficiently so, whether its use or intended use, along with other circumstances, would lead it to distinguish the goods. The core legal issue was whether the shape of the bottle, with its particular features, was so unique and non-functional that it would be recognised by consumers as indicating the origin of the goods, rather than merely serving a functional purpose or being a shape that other traders might legitimately wish to use.

The delegate applied the principles established in cases such as *Clark Equipment Co v Registrar of Trade Marks* and *Chocolaterie Guylian NV v Registrar of Trade Marks*, which require consideration of whether other traders, acting honestly, would likely desire to use the mark or a similar mark for their own goods. The delegate noted that shapes dictated by function or the nature of the goods cannot operate as trade marks. While the applicant argued that the bottle's specific features, including its "Bicone Shape," "Flat Band," and "Embossed Pattern," were not functional and contributed to its inherent distinctiveness, the delegate found that these features, along with the "Flat Cap," were not sufficiently unique or visually arresting. The delegate concluded that the shape, despite some distinguishing features, was not inherently adapted to distinguish the goods to a sufficient degree and that other traders might legitimately wish to use a similar shape for their milk products.

Consequently, the delegate determined that the trade mark application should be rejected under section 41(4) of the Act. This decision was based on the combined effect of the trade mark's limited inherent adaptation to distinguish, the lack of persuasive evidence of actual use in Australia that had established distinctiveness, and the circumstances indicating that the shape was not so fanciful as to prevent other traders from using similar forms for their goods.

Background

Background to the litigation

Binggrae Co Ltd (Applicant) applied to register a three-dimensional trade mark in the shape of a bottle for its milk products. The application was examined and rejected by the Examiner on the ground that the trade mark was not capable of distinguishing the goods from other milk products due to its functional nature and commonality in the industry. The Applicant disputed the Examiner’s objection, arguing that the shape had distinctive features that set it apart from ordinary containers used for milk products. The Applicant submitted that the trade mark, which has a bicone shape, a flattened band, an embossed pattern, and a flat cap, was inherently distinctive and not readily recognisable as a container, thus capable of distinguishing the goods. Despite the Applicant’s arguments and evidence from articles and expert declarations, the Examiner remained unconvinced that the trade mark had sufficient inherent distinctiveness to distinguish the goods from other milk products. The Examiner noted that milk products are commonly packaged in various forms and shapes, and the distinctive features of the trade mark could be adopted by other traders. The Applicant requested a hearing, and the matter was referred to a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks for reconsideration. The delegate agreed with the Examiner that while the trade mark had some level of inherent adaptation to distinguish, it was not sufficient to overcome the rejection ground under section 41 of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The evidence of use in foreign markets, predominantly in Korea, did not demonstrate that the trade mark had distinguished the goods in a way that would prevent other traders from using a similar shape for their products. The delegate rejected the application, finding that there was no basis to accept the trade mark under section 41(4).

This matter is an ex parte proceeding pursuant to section 33 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) concerning an application by Binggrae Co Ltd ('Applicant') to register the trade mark of a three-dimensional bottle shape for milk beverages under application number 2337475 ('Application'). The Application was filed on 24 February 2023 and examined by an Examiner under section 31 of the Act. The Examiner raised a ground for rejection under section 41, objecting that the Trade Mark was not capable of distinguishing the Applicant's Goods because the mark is the shape of a container predominantly functional in nature. In response, the Applicant filed submissions which were not sufficient to persuade the Examiner to withdraw the objection. Following this, the Applicant requested a hearing by written submissions which were filed on 29 August 2024 with a declaration of James Henry Blaxland Parker made on 27 August 2024 with Exhibits JP-1 and JP-2 ('Parker'). This matter has been allocated to me to determine as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks based on the aforementioned materials. My decision is a fresh consideration of the ground for rejection under section 41.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the trade mark inherently adapted to distinguish the goods from other goods in the marketplace?
2. Does the trade mark possess any level of distinctiveness that would prevent other traders from using a similar shape for their goods?
3. Is the trade mark sufficiently distinctive such that consumers are likely to associate the shape with the origin of the goods?
4. To what extent has the applicant used the trade mark in Australia or internationally, and does this use support the argument that the trade mark distinguishes the goods?
5. Are there other relevant circumstances that should be considered in determining whether the trade mark should be rejected under s 41(4)?
6. Does the trade mark comply with the requirements of registrability under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)?

Held
1. Is the trade mark inherently adapted to distinguish the goods from other goods in the marketplace?
The court concluded that the trade mark has some level of inherent adaptation to distinguish the goods, but it is not sufficiently distinctive. The result is that the application cannot be rejected solely on this ground, but further analysis under s 41(4) is required.

2. Does the trade mark possess any level of distinctiveness that would prevent other traders from using a similar shape for their goods?
The court concluded that the trade mark does not possess a high enough level of distinctiveness to prevent other traders from using a similar shape for their goods. The result is that the trade mark is not distinctive enough to bar competitors from using similar shapes.

3. Is the trade mark sufficiently distinctive such that consumers are likely to associate the shape with the origin of the goods?
The court concluded that consumers are unlikely to associate the shape with the origin of the goods without education. The result is that the trade mark does not sufficiently distinguish the goods in the eyes of consumers.

4. To what extent has the applicant used the trade mark in Australia or internationally, and does this use support the argument that the trade mark distinguishes the goods?
The court concluded that there is insufficient evidence of use of the trade mark in Australia or internationally to support the argument that the trade mark distinguishes the goods. The result is that the extent of use does not support the application for registration.

5. Are there other relevant circumstances that should be considered in determining whether the trade mark should be rejected under s 41(4)?
The court concluded that the other circumstances, including the various packaging forms used for milk products and the likelihood of other traders using a similar shape, do not support the registration of the trade mark. The result is that these circumstances contribute to the rejection of the application.

6. Does the trade mark comply with the requirements of registrability under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)?
The court concluded that the trade mark does not comply with the requirements of registrability under s 41 and rejected the application. The result is that the application for registration is rejected.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Delegate began by analyzing whether the trade mark was inherently adapted to distinguish the goods from other goods in the marketplace. The Delegate considered the inherent characteristics of the trade mark, which is the shape of a container for milk products. The Applicant argued that the trade mark has distinguishing features such as the Bicone Shape, Flat Band, Embossed Pattern, and Flat Cap. However, the Delegate found that these features are not distinctive or unique, as similar shapes and patterns are commonly used in the industry. The Delegate concluded that the trade mark does not have sufficient inherent adaptation to distinguish the goods from other milk products, as many traders may wish to use a similar shape for their goods.

Next, the Delegate assessed whether the trade mark possesses any level of distinctiveness that would prevent other traders from using a similar shape for their goods. The Applicant argued that the trade mark has a reasonably high degree of inherent distinctiveness and has come to distinguish the goods in foreign markets. However, the Delegate found that the evidence provided by the Applicant was limited to articles about the trade mark in Korea, where the goods are popular. There was no evidence of the trade mark being used outside of Korea or in Australia to any significant extent. The Delegate concluded that the trade mark does not possess a level of distinctiveness that would prevent other traders from using a similar shape for their goods.

The Delegate then considered whether the trade mark is sufficiently distinctive such that consumers are likely to associate the shape with the origin of the goods. The Applicant submitted that the trade mark is perceived as unique, iconic, distinctive, endearing, and easily recognizable. However, the Delegate found that these perceptions are not supported by the evidence, as the trade mark is not readily apparent and does not make a direct reference or allude to the goods. The Delegate concluded that consumers are unlikely to recognize the combination of the shape and features as a trade mark until educated to do so.

The Delegate also examined the extent to which the Applicant has used the trade mark in Australia or internationally. The Applicant provided evidence of the trade mark being used in Korea, but this evidence was limited to the last 10 years and did not demonstrate any significant use outside of Korea. The Applicant also provided examples of the goods being sold on Australian websites, but these products were sold in cardboard boxes and not in the trade mark shape. The Delegate concluded that there is insufficient evidence of the trade mark being used in Australia or internationally to support the argument that the trade mark distinguishes the goods.

Finally, the Delegate considered other relevant circumstances that should be taken into account in determining whether the trade mark should be rejected under s 41(4). The Delegate found that the trade mark does have some level of inherent adaptation to distinguish the goods, but this is not sufficient to overcome the other factors considered. The Delegate concluded that there is a ground for rejecting the application under s 41 and rejected the trade mark application.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a trade mark which is the shape of a container for milk products does not possess sufficient inherent adaptation to distinguish the goods from other goods in the marketplace, and there is insufficient evidence of the trade mark being used in Australia or internationally to support the argument that the trade mark distinguishes the goods. The Delegate distinguished prior authority which found that a shape trade mark is inherently distinctive if it is sufficiently unique and does not have any functional purpose. In this case, the Delegate found that the trade mark is not sufficiently distinctive or unique and may be used by other traders for their similar goods.