Altina Australia Pty Ltd v Tina Drinks Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Altina Australia Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application numbers 2224727 (32), 2253912 (32) and 2253913 (32) – This Is Not Alcohol, T.I.N.A. ,  T.I.N.A. THIS IS NOT ALCOHOL– in the name of TINA Drinks Pty Ltd

Delegate: Bianca Irgang
Representation:

Opponent: Written submissions by Mengel Law

Applicant: Scott Buchanan of Buchanan Law Firm Pty Ltd

Decision: 2025 ATMO 66
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) - Section 52 opposition – ss 41, 42, 44 and 60 grounds of opposition argued – no grounds of opposition established – trade marks to proceed to registration.

Background

  1. TINA Drinks Pty Ltd (‘the Applicant’), filed trade mark application numbers 2224727, 2253912 and 2253913 respectively on 1 November 2021 and 4 March 2022. Current details of the applications (‘the Applicant’s Trade Marks’) are set out below.

    Trade mark:   (‘First Trade Mark’)

    Trade mark application no: 2224727

    Filing Date:  1 November 2021

    Specification:  Class 32: Aerated beverages (non-alcoholic)

    Trade mark:  T.I.N.A. (‘Second Trade Mark’)

    Trade mark application no: 2253912

    Filing Date:  4 March 2022

    Specification:  Class 32: Aperitifs, non-alcoholic; Carbonated non-alcoholic drinks; Essences for making beverages; Preparations for making non-alcoholic beverages; Aerated beverages (non-alcoholic); Aerated drinks (non-alcoholic); Non-alcoholic cocktails; Cocktails, non-alcoholic; Non-alcoholic beverages flavoured with tea; Non-alcoholic punches

    Trade mark:  T.I.N.A. THIS IS NOT ALCOHOL (‘Third Trade Mark’)

    Trade mark application no: 2253913

    Filing Date:  4 March 2022

    Specification:  Class 32: Aperitifs, non-alcoholic; Carbonated non-alcoholic drinks; Essences for making beverages; Preparations for making non-alcoholic beverages; Aerated beverages (non-alcoholic); Aerated drinks (non-alcoholic); Non-alcoholic cocktails; Cocktails, non-alcoholic; Non-alcoholic beverages flavoured with tea; Non-alcoholic punches (‘Applicant’s Goods’)[1]

    [1] I will refer to the goods specifications of the First Trade Mark, Second Trade Mark and Third Trade Mark collectively as the ‘Applicant’s Goods’.

  2. Acceptance of the applications for possible registration was advertised on 2 April 2022 and 5 August 2022. Subsequently, Altina Australia Pty Ltd (‘the Opponent’) filed its Notices of Intention to Oppose registration followed by its Statements of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’). The Applicant then filed its Notices of Intention to Defend. Thereafter, the Opponent and the Applicant filed evidence in accordance with the provisions of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (Cth) (‘the Regulations’).

  3. I heard the opposition by teleconference as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks on 19 February 2025. The Opponent was not present at the hearing but did provide written submissions by way of its legal representatives Mengel Law. The Applicant was represented by Scott Buchanan of Buchanan Law Firm Pty Ltd.

    Grounds of Opposition

  4. The SGP nominated a number of grounds of opposition under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘the Act’) but only those grounds of opposition under ss 41[2], 42(b), 44 and 60 were pursued at the hearing. The Opponent bears the onus of establishing at least one of the grounds of opposition.[3] The standard of proof is the ordinary civil standard of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Altina Australia Pty Ltd v Tina Drinks Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ATMO 66
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned three consolidated opposition proceedings before Bianca Irgang, Hearing Officer, in the Australian Trade Marks Office. Altina Australia Pty Ltd (the Applicant) sought to register three trade marks, while Tina Drinks Pty Ltd (the Opponent) opposed these applications. The Opponent's opposition was primarily based on section 44 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth), which deals with identical or deceptively similar trade marks for similar goods or services.

The legal issues before the Hearing Officer were whether the Applicant's trade mark applications should be rejected under section 44 of the Act. To succeed on this ground, the Opponent was required to demonstrate that it owned registered or pending trade marks that were substantially identical or deceptively similar to the Applicant's marks, that these marks covered similar or closely related goods or services, and that the Opponent's trade marks had an earlier priority date. The Hearing Officer also had to consider the general decision-making power under section 55 of the Act, which requires the Registrar to decide whether to refuse or register a trade mark having regard to the grounds of opposition.

The Hearing Officer found that the Opponent had not established any grounds for opposition. While the Opponent relied on three registered trade marks, the evidence indicated that only one of these registrations had an earlier priority date than one of the Applicant's trade marks and covered the same goods. Crucially, the Hearing Officer determined that the Opponent's trade marks were not substantially identical or deceptively similar to the Applicant's trade marks in respect of the relevant goods. Consequently, the Hearing Officer decided that the Applicant's trade mark applications could proceed to registration. The Applicant was awarded costs, with full costs for one opposition and 20% of the scale costs for the remaining two, given the commonality of evidence.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case between Altina Australia Pty Ltd and Tina Drinks Pty Ltd revolves around oppositions to trade mark applications filed by Altina Australia. Tina Drinks, the opponent, has raised objections under section 44 of the Trade Marks Act 1995, arguing that Altina Australia's proposed trade marks are substantially identical or deceptively similar to its own registered trade marks. Tina Drinks owns three registered trade marks with earlier priority dates, covering similar goods in Class 32. Specifically, Registration Number 1954148 has an earlier priority date compared to one of Altina Australia's trade marks and all three of Tina Drinks' trade marks have earlier priority dates than the other two trade marks applied for by Altina Australia.

Altina Australia, represented by Christina Trabucco, a director, and Mike Bennie, a director of P&V Wine + Liquor Merchants, submitted evidence to counter Tina Drinks' claims. Trabucco's declaration, accompanied by exhibits, and Bennie's statutory declaration, provide context and details supporting Altina Australia's position that its trade marks are distinct and do not infringe on Tina Drinks' rights. In response, Tina Drinks' solicitor, Lindsay Stuart Douglas Mengel, filed multiple declarations with exhibits to substantiate the claims of similarity and potential infringement. The evidence includes detailed comparisons and arguments regarding the visual and conceptual resemblance of the trade marks in question.

Throughout the proceedings, both parties presented their respective cases, with Altina Australia asserting the distinctiveness of its trade marks and the lack of a likelihood of confusion among consumers. Tina Drinks maintained that the similarity between the trade marks could lead to consumer confusion, thus justifying the opposition. The case was thoroughly examined through the evidence and arguments provided, setting the stage for the Hearing Officer to assess the merits of the opposition based on the presented facts and legal standards.

Altina Australia Pty Ltd v Tina Drinks Pty Ltd originated from three separate applications for trade mark registration by Altina, which were subsequently opposed by Tina Drinks Pty Ltd. The oppositions were consolidated and heard together. Tina Drinks relied on section 44 of the Trade Marks Act 1995, asserting that Altina’s proposed trade marks were either substantially identical with or deceptively similar to Tina Drinks' existing trade marks, which had earlier priority dates and covered the same goods in class 32. The oppositions were supported by declarations from Tina Drinks' solicitor and additional declarations from various directors and experts. Altina responded with its own evidence, including declarations from its directors and a lawyer, arguing against the substantial identity or deceptive similarity of the trade marks.

Throughout the proceedings, the court was presented with extensive evidence, comprising statutory declarations and accompanying exhibits from both parties. Tina Drinks filed separate declarations for each opposition, while Altina provided a consolidated response. The case proceeded with a thorough examination of the evidence, focusing on the procedural aspects of the opposition rather than the substantive merits of the trade mark similarity. The court examined the priority dates and the nature of the goods covered by the respective trade marks, along with any relevant market perceptions or confusion that might arise from the use of similar trade marks. Various interlocutory steps and applications were addressed, ensuring that all procedural requirements were met before reaching the final decision.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence filed in this matter consists of the following declarations being:Evidence in Support·Declaration of Lindsay Stuart Douglas Mengel, solicitor for the Opponent, made on 8 May 2023 and its Exhibits LM-1 to LM-43 (‘Mengel’).Evidence in Answer·Statutory Declaration of Christina Trabucco, director of the Applicant, made on 25 July 2023 and its Exhibits CT-1 to CT-17.·Statutory Declaration of Mike Bennie, director of P&V Wine + Liquor Merchants, made on 8 August 2023.·Statutory Declaration of Scott Buchanan, lawyer for the Applicant, made on 14 August 2023.Evidence in Reply·Declaration of Lindsay Stuart Douglas Mengel, solicitor for the Opponent, made on 18 October 2023 and its Exhibits LM-1 to LM-20 (‘Mengel 2’). It is noted that the Opponent’s solicitor has filed separate declarations in respect of each opposition rather than single declarations covering the three consolidated oppositions. As such there appears to be three separate versions of Mengel and Mengel 2 but with minor differences only. Unless stated otherwise, references to the Mengel declarations relate to the declarations pertaining to trade mark number 2253913 which were also addressed and referenced by the Applicant during the Hearing. DiscussionSection 44 Section 44 of the Act relevantly provides:44 Identical etc. trade marks (1) Subject to subsections (3) and (4), an application for the registration of a trade mark (applicant’s trade mark) in respect of goods (applicant’s goods) must be rejected if: (a) the applicant’s trade mark is substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to: (i) a trade mark registered by another person in respect of similar goods or closely related services; or (ii) a trade mark whose registration in respect of similar goods or closely related services is being sought by another person; and (b) the priority date for the registration of the applicant’s trade mark in respect of the applicant’s goods is not earlier than the priority date for the registration of the other trade mark in respect of the similar goods or closely related services. To establish its opposition in terms of section 44 of the Act the Opponent must show all of the following:·a trade mark (or trade marks), either registered or pending registration, in the name of a person other than the present applicant, and in relation to which the opposed trade mark is either substantially identical or deceptively similar;·the trade mark(s) in the name of the other person must be in respect of similar goods or closely related services; and·the priority date(s) of the other person’s trade mark(s) is (are) the earlier. The Opponent is the registered owner of the following three registrations relied on in support of its s 44 ground of opposition: I will refer to these trade mark collectively as the ‘Opponent’s Trade Marks’ for ease of reference throughout the decision. As verified on the Register of Trade Marks all of the Opponent’s Trade Marks have an earlier priority date to the Second Trade Mark and the Third Trade Mark and cover the same goods in class 32 to the Applicant’s Goods. Only Registration Number 1954148 has an earlier Priority Date to the First Trade Mark and covers the same goods in class 32.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 55 of the Act provides:55 Decision (1) Unless subsection (3) applies to the proceedings, the Registrar must, at the end, decide: (a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or (b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.Note: For limitations see section 6. The Opponent has not established any grounds of opposition. The trade mark applications may accordingly proceed to registration one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration of the Applicant’s Trade Marks shall not occur until the appeal has been decided or discontinued.Costs The Applicant requested its costs in the event of success in these three opposition matters. All three opposition matters had essentially common evidence and this being the case I award against the Opponent in terms of Schedule 8 of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 in the at full costs, as per scale, for the opposition to application 2224727 and apply 20% of the scale[27] in the remaining two oppositions. [27] Hume Industries (Malaysia) Berhad v James Hardie & Co Pty Ltd (2001) 53 IPR 591.Bianca IrgangHearing OfficerOppositions and HearingsTrade Marks and Designs31 March 2025

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's analysis began by examining whether the Opponent’s Trade Mark Registration Number 1954148 had an earlier priority date than the Applicant’s First Trade Mark. According to the evidence, all of the Opponent’s Trade Marks had earlier priority dates than the Applicant’s Second and Third Trade Marks. However, only Registration Number 1954148 had an earlier priority date compared to the Applicant’s First Trade Mark. This was confirmed through the verification of the Register of Trade Marks, establishing that this particular trade mark indeed preceded the Applicant's First Trade Mark in terms of priority.

Next, the court assessed whether the Opponent’s Trade Marks were substantially identical or deceptively similar to the Applicant’s Trade Marks. The court examined the visual, phonetic, and conceptual aspects of the marks, taking into account the distinctiveness and the overall impression they create on the public. The Opponent argued that the similarity between the marks was sufficient to cause confusion among consumers. However, the Applicant countered that the differences between the marks were significant enough to distinguish them in the marketplace. The court found that while the marks shared some similarities, they were not substantially identical or deceptively similar to the extent that they would likely cause confusion among consumers.

The court then considered whether the goods covered by the Opponent’s Trade Marks were similar or closely related to those covered by the Applicant’s Trade Marks. Both parties agreed that the goods fell within the same class, specifically Class 32, which pertains to alcoholic beverages. The Opponent argued that since the goods were in the same class, they were similar. The Applicant, however, contended that the specific nature of the goods differed enough to warrant a distinction. The court concluded that the goods were indeed similar, as they both pertained to alcoholic beverages, thereby meeting the criteria for opposition under Section 44 of the Act.

The court evaluated whether the Opponent had established any grounds for opposition under Section 44 of the Act. The Opponent needed to demonstrate that the Applicant’s trade marks were substantially identical or deceptively similar to the Opponent’s Trade Marks, and that the Opponent’s marks had an earlier priority date. The court found that while the Opponent’s Trade Mark Registration Number 1954148 was earlier than the Applicant’s First Trade Mark and covered the same goods, the similarity between the marks did not reach the threshold of being substantially identical or deceptively similar. Therefore, the Opponent had not established the necessary grounds for opposition.

Considering the above findings, the court determined that the Applicant’s Trade Marks should proceed to registration. Since the Opponent had not successfully demonstrated that the Applicant’s marks were substantially identical or deceptively similar, and since the Applicant's First Trade Mark was not opposed by an earlier mark that met the similarity criteria, the court ruled in favour of the Applicant. The Applicant's trade mark applications could proceed to registration, subject to the possibility of an appeal by the Opponent.

Lastly, the court addressed the issue of costs. The Applicant requested its costs in the event of success. Given that all three opposition matters had common evidence, the court awarded full costs against the Opponent for the opposition to application 2224727, and applied a 20% reduction for the remaining two oppositions, in accordance with the provisions of Schedule 8 of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 and the precedent set in Hume Industries (Malaysia) Berhad v James Hardie & Co Pty Ltd. This decision ensured that the Applicant was compensated for the costs incurred in defending against the unsuccessful oppositions.