Food Channel Network Pty Ltd v Television Food Network GP

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Food Channel Network Pty Ltd v Television Food Network GP [2010] FCAFC 58

Citation: Food Channel Network Pty Ltd v Television Food Network GP [2010] FCAFC 58
Appeal from: Television Food Network, G.P. v Food Channel Network Pty Ltd (No 2) [2009] FCA 271
Parties: FOOD CHANNEL NETWORK PTY LTD ACN 079 015 339 v TELEVISION FOOD NETWORK G.P.
File number(s): QUD 103 of 2009
QUD 132 of 2009
Judges: KEANE CJ, STONE AND JAGOT JJ
Date of judgment: 2 June 2010
Catchwords: TRADE MARKS – opposition proceedings – the appellant claimed the respondent was not the owner of a disputed trade mark at the date the mark was applied for – the appellant claimed the respondent had no intention to use the mark at the date the mark was applied for – the appellant claimed the respondent’s mark was deceptively similar to its own – whether the appellant was entitled to have the respondent’s mark removed from the register.
Legislation: Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) ss 27, 33, 44, 52, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 88
Cases cited:

Aston v Harlee Manufacturing Co (1960) 103 CLR 391; [1960] HCA 47, followed
Carnival Cruise Lines Inc v Sitmar Cruises Ltd (1994) 31 IPR 375
Cooper Engineering Co Pty Ltd v Sigmund Pumps Ltd (1952) 86 CLR 536; [1952] HCA 15, followed
Crazy Ron’s Communications Pty Ltd v Mobileworld Communications Pty LTd (2004) 209 ALR 1, followed
Danjaq LLC v Resource Capital Australia Pty Ltd (2004) 61 IPR 651, cited
E & J Gallo Winery v Lion Nathan Australian Pty Limited [2010] HCA 15, followed
Health World Ltd v Shin-Sun Australia Pty Ltd [2010] HCA 13, followed
Health World Ltd v Shin-Sun Australia Pty Ltd (2008) 75 IPR 478, considered
Joseph Constantine Line v Imperial Smelting Corp Ltd [1942] AC 154, cited
Kenman Kandy Australia Pty Ltd v Registrar of Trade Marks (2002) 122 FCR 494, considered
Jafferjee v Scarlett (1937) 57 CLR 115, considered
Kowa Co v NV Organon (2005) 223 ALR 27, cited
Lomas v Winton Shire Council [2002] FCAFC 413, followed
Michael Sharwood & Partners Pty Ltd v Fuddruckers Inc (1989) 15 IPR 188, cited
Pfizer Products v Karam [2006] FCA 1663, considered
Sapient Australia Pty Ltd v SAP AG (2002) 55 IPR 638, cited
Shell Co of Australia Ltd v Rohm and Haas Co (1948) 78 CLR 601, followed
Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd v Rocco Pezzano Pty Ltd (1998) 154 ALR 361; [1998] HCA 38, cited

Place: Brisbane
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 118
Counsel for the Appellant: J Baird SC, with L Stephens
Solicitor for the Appellant: Potts & Co
Counsel for the Respondent: A Franklin SC, with J S Cooke
Solicitor for the Respondent: Bennett & Philp Solicitors

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

QUD 103 of 2009

ON APPEAL FROM THE…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Food Channel Network Pty Ltd v Television Food Network GP and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCAFC 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Food Channel Network Pty Ltd v Television Food Network GP, the respondent, Television Food Network GP, sought to oppose the registration of a trade mark application by the appellant, Food Channel Network Pty Ltd. The dispute centred on whether the respondent was the owner of the trade mark at the date of application, whether the respondent had the intention to use the trade mark, and whether the respondent's mark was deceptively similar to the appellant's own trade mark. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issues involved interpreting the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) and determining whether the respondent had discharged the evidentiary onus of proving ownership and intention to use the trade mark at the time of application. Specifically, the court had to decide if the respondent could be considered the owner of the trade mark under section 58 of the Act and whether the respondent had the requisite intention to use the mark under section 59.

The court found that the respondent had not successfully discharged its evidentiary burden to prove ownership of the trade mark at the time of application. The evidence was too confused to determine ownership with certainty, and the policy of the Act required that the owner be identifiable at the filing date. The court concluded that the respondent had not demonstrated ownership and intention to use the trade mark, leading to the conclusion that the application could be opposed under section 58 of the Act. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the decision of the primary judge was set aside. The opposition to the registration of the trade mark was dismissed, and the respondent was ordered to pay the appellant's costs of the trial and appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The decision of the primary judge be set aside.

3. The opposition to the application for registration of the mark 967804 be dismissed.

4. The respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the trial and of the appeal.

Note:

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The order for costs dated 5 February 2008 be set aside.

3. The respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the trial and of the appeal.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Her Honour went on:[84]In summary, I do not consider that [Network] has discharged its evidentiary onus and established that [Channel] was the owner of trade mark 967804 at the filing date. In my view, while there is evidence to suggest that [Network] was the owner of trade mark 967804 both at the filing date and thereafter, the evidence also supports a conclusion that a finding as to ownership is not possible (other than, possibly, that the owner was Mr Lawrence himself). I consider that this is a defect in the application to register trade mark 967804.…[90]I note the submissions of [Network] that Mr Lawrence tended to confuse his own business interests with those of his companies. However in my view the policy of the Act is clear. Section 58 requires that, at filing date, the owner of the trade mark must be identifiable, and must be the applicant. As I have already observed, this does not mean that, within a corporate group, there cannot be transfer of ownership and assignment of the application within the group as is commercially necessary. However in my judgment there must at least be evidence of this, as well as compliance with the Act.[91]“Ownership” is a key concept within the Act, requiring certainty. The policy of the Act is clearly to vest an owner of a trade mark with important rights and powers (cf for example sections 20, 21, 22, 27, 58, 58A). I do not accept that the Act sanctions a position such that a person who is not the owner of a trade mark can nonetheless apply for registration of a trade mark (and may thus be opposed under s 58), but the application itself is somehow subsequently validated by later identification of the owner and that owner being assigned the application by the trade mark applicant. In circumstances where the position of ownership is so confused that the owner of the trade mark cannot be identified at the filing date (or indeed throughout the application process as appears to be the case here as a result of the conflicting evidence as to ownership), the application may be opposed pursuant to s 58 of the Act. The judge concluded her consideration of the s 58 ground of opposition in the following terms:[92]In my view the respondent has not discharged its evidentiary onus. I am not satisfied in this case that [Channel] was the owner of trade mark 967804 at the filing date. While there is evidence that the respondent was the owner at the filing date, in my view the confusion in the evidence tendered by the respondent is too great for me to make a positive finding to this effect. However, even if the respondent were the owner at all times prior to and/or during the application process the defect in the original application is not cured by the assignment of the trade mark application to the respondent. This defect is fatal to the trade mark application. The applicant to these proceedings has substantiated its claim pursuant to s 58 of the Act. If the evidence was not sufficiently clear to enable a finding of fact to be made about ownership of the mark at the time of registration then Television had to fail on that issue: it bore the onus of proof. The primary judge reached the opposite conclusion. Her Honour reached that conclusion, in part at least, because of the unnecessary distraction of Television’s argument about shifting onus. There are a number of other reasons why we consider that her Honour erred in reaching that conclusion.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In relation to opposition proceedings s 55 of the Act provides:55 Decision(1)Unless the proceedings are discontinued or dismissed, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b)to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.(2)Without limiting subsection (1), if the application was opposed on the ground specified in paragraph 62(a) (that the application, or a document filed in support of the application, was amended contrary to this Act), the Registrar may revoke the acceptance of the application and examine the application again under section 31. Section 56 of the Act provides:56 AppealThe applicant or the opponent may appeal to the Federal Court from a decision of the Registrar under section 55. Division 2 of Part 5 of the Act contains the following provisions in relation to the grounds on which the registration of a trade mark may be opposed:57 Registration may be opposed on same grounds as for rejectionThe registration of a trade mark may be opposed on any of the grounds on which an application for the registration of a trade mark may be rejected under this Act, except the ground that the trade mark cannot be represented graphically.…58 Applicant not owner of trade markThe registration of a trade mark may be opposed on the ground that the applicant is not the owner of the trade mark.…59 Applicant not intending to use trade markThe registration of a trade mark may be opposed on the ground that the applicant does not intend:(a) to use, or authorise the use of, the trade mark in Australia; or(b)to assign the trade mark to a body corporate for use by the body corporate in Australia;in relation to the goods and/or services specified in the application. Part 8 of the Act provides for the amendment, cancellation and revocation of registration of a trade mark. Of relevance for present purposes is s 88 which is in the following terms:88 Amendment or cancellation – other specified grounds(1)Subject to subsection (2) and section 89, a prescribed court may, on the application of an aggrieved person or the Registrar, order that the Registrar be rectified by:(a) cancelling the registration of trade mark; or(b)removing or amending an entry wrongly made or remaining on the Register; or (c)entering any condition or limitation affecting the registration of a trade mark that ought to be entered.(2)An application may be made on any of the following grounds, and on no other grounds:(a)any of the grounds on which the registration of the trade mark could have been opposed under this Act;(b)an amendment of the application for the registration of the trade mark was obtained as a result of fraud, false suggestion or misrepresentation;(c)because of the circumstances applying at the time when the application for rectification is filed, the use of the trade mark is likely to deceive or cause confusion;(e)if the application is in respect of an entry in the Register – the entry was made, or has been previously amended, as a result of fraud, false suggestion or misrepresentation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Division 2 of Part 5 of the Act contains the following provisions in relation to the grounds on which the registration of a trade mark may be opposed:57 Registration may be opposed on same grounds as for rejectionThe registration of a trade mark may be opposed on any of the grounds on which an application for the registration of a trade mark may be rejected under this Act, except the ground that the trade mark cannot be represented graphically.…58 Applicant not owner of trade markThe registration of a trade mark may be opposed on the ground that the applicant is not the owner of the trade mark.…59 Applicant not intending to use trade markThe registration of a trade mark may be opposed on the ground that the applicant does not intend:(a) to use, or authorise the use of, the trade mark in Australia; or(b)to assign the trade mark to a body corporate for use by the body corporate in Australia;in relation to the goods and/or services specified in the application. Part 8 of the Act provides for the amendment, cancellation and revocation of registration of a trade mark. Of relevance for present purposes is s 88 which is in the following terms:88 Amendment or cancellation – other specified grounds(1)Subject to subsection (2) and section 89, a prescribed court may, on the application of an aggrieved person or the Registrar, order that the Registrar be rectified by:(a) cancelling the registration of trade mark; or(b)removing or amending an entry wrongly made or remaining on the Register; or (c)entering any condition or limitation affecting the registration of a trade mark that ought to be entered.(2)An application may be made on any of the following grounds, and on no other grounds:(a)any of the grounds on which the registration of the trade mark could have been opposed under this Act;(b)an amendment of the application for the registration of the trade mark was obtained as a result of fraud, false suggestion or misrepresentation;(c)because of the circumstances applying at the time when the application for rectification is filed, the use of the trade mark is likely to deceive or cause confusion;(e)if the application is in respect of an entry in the Register – the entry was made, or has been previously amended, as a result of fraud, false suggestion or misrepresentation. In Health World Ltd v Shin-Sun Australia Pty Ltd [2010] HCA 13 at [22]-[26], French CJ, Gummow, Heydon and Bell JJ explained the theory of this legislative scheme (footnotes omitted):… [T]he legislative scheme reveals a concern with the condition of the Register of Trade Marks. It is a concern that it have “integrity” and that it be “pure”. It is a “public mischief” if the Registrar is not pure, for there is “public interest in [its] purity”. The concern and the public interest, viewed from the angle of consumers, is to ensure that the Register is maintained as an accurate record of marks which perform their statutory function – to indicate the trade origins of the goods to which it is intended that they be applied.This concern and this interest are reflected in the following scheme. If an application is made to have a mark registered which does not meet the criteria for registration, there are two opportunities for registration to be prevented. And if a mark has been registered which does not meet the criteria for remaining on the Register, a further opportunity exists to have the Registrar adjust it.The first opportunity arises when an application is lodged. Section 31 of the Act creates a duty on the Registrar to examine and report on whether the application has been made in accordance with the Act, and whether there are grounds under Pt 4 Div 2 for rejecting it. The Registrar must accept the application unless satisfied that the application has not been made in accordance with the Act, or there are grounds for rejecting it (s 33).Even if the application is accepted, a second opportunity arises. Section 34 creates a duty on the Registrar to advertise the decision to accept the application in the Official Journal of Trade Marks. This enables those who wish to oppose registration to do so pursuant to s 52 of the Act. Section 52 has no standing requirement. If opposition proceedings are not brought, or if they fail, the trade mark is registered (s 68).However, a third opportunity to ensure the purity of the Register arises, for recourse can be had to s 88 or s 92. Those sections require applicants under them to be “aggrieved”. It is not the case that any applicant who wants the Register rectified or a mark removed is “aggrieved” merely by reason of that desire: the word has a filtering function. But against that legislative background, it is not clear why the word should be construed restrictively rather than liberally.