Jeff Knox v The Australian Simmental Breeders Association Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Jeff Knox to registration of trade mark application 2396773 (29, 31 42) – SIMMENTAL SIMBEEF (Figurative) and 2396774 (16) – SIMMENTAL AUSTRALIA (Figurative)– each in the name of The Australian Simmental Breeders Association Ltd

Delegate:

Nicholas Smith

Representation:

Opponent: Fraser Old of Fraser Old & Sohn

Applicant: Written Submissions ONEQUITY PTY LTD

Decision:

2025 ATMO 175

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) - section 52 oppositions: ss 41, 42(b) and 43 considered – none established – trade marks to proceed to registration

Background

  1. This decision concerns an opposition brought by Jeff Knox (‘Opponent’) to the registration of the trade marks (collectively ‘Trade Marks’) which are the subject of the applications detailed below in the name of The Australian Simmental Breeders Association Ltd (‘Applicant’): 

Application Number:

2396773

Filing Date[1]:

16 October 2023

Goods and Services:

Class 29: Beef; Beef products
Class 42: Live animals; Livestock fattening preparations
Class 45: Genetic research; Livestock assessment

(‘2396773 Goods and Services’)

Trade Mark:

(‘2396773 Mark’)

[1] Also known in this decision as the ‘relevant date’.

Application Number:

2396774

Filing Date[2]:

16 October 2023

Goods and Services:

Class 16: Boxes for packaging (cardboard); Brochures

(‘2396774 Goods’)

Trade Mark:

(‘2396774 Mark’)

[2] Also known in this decision as the ‘relevant date’.

  1. Unless otherwise indicated, any references to sections or regulations in this decision are references to sections or regulations of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’) or the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) (‘Regulations’), respectively.  In this decision where I refer to the ‘Applicant’s Goods and Services’ I am referring to the 2396773 Goods and Services and the 2396774 Goods collectively.

  2. Following the advertisement of the applications’ acceptance for possible registration, the Opponent filed Notices of Intention to Oppose the registration followed by Statements of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’).  Each SGP raised grounds of opposition under ss 41, 42(b) and 43.  The Applicant filed a Notice of Intention to Defend each opposition on 29 April 2024. 

    Evidence

  3. The parties filed the same evidence in respect of both marks, with the evidence being set out below:

Declarant and Position

Date

Annexures or Exhibits

Evidence in support

Jeff Knox, Opponent (‘Smith declaration’)

5 July 2024

Fraser Patison Old, patent attorney with Fraser Old & Sohn (‘Old declaration’)

5 July 2024

FPO1 to FPO 9

Evidence in answer

N/A (None Filed)

Evidence in reply

N/A (None Filed)

  1. Once the time allowed for filing evidence had ended, the parties were given an opportunity to request an oral hearing or a hearing by written submissions.  On 13 February 2025 the Opponent requested an oral hearing.  The matter was set down for a hearing on 1 July 2025 and the matter was allocated to me.  In line with usual practice, a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jeff Knox v The Australian Simmental Breeders Association Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ATMO 175
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerns an opposition by Jeff Knox (the Opponent) to the registration of two trade marks, numbers 2396773 and 2396774, by The Australian Simmental Breeders Association Ltd (the Applicant). The Opponent filed Notices of Intention to Oppose and Statements of Grounds and Particulars, alleging grounds of opposition under sections 41, 42(b), and 43 of the relevant legislation. The Applicant filed Notices of Intention to Defend. The proceedings were heard by Nicholas Smith, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks.

The legal issues before the delegate were whether the proposed trade marks, which included the word "SIMMENTAL" and an illustration of a cow, were misleading and deceptive in relation to the specified goods, and whether their use would be contrary to law, as argued by the Opponent. The Opponent contended that the marks, despite referencing the Simmental breed, were not restricted to beef from Simmental cattle and that the accompanying illustration depicted a Black Baldy cow, not a Simmental, thereby rendering the marks misleading.

The delegate considered the evidence presented by both parties, including declarations and written submissions. The Opponent's primary argument was that the trade marks were misleading because the goods for which registration was sought were not limited to Simmental beef, and the visual representation of the cow was inconsistent with the Simmental breed. However, the delegate was not satisfied that the use of the trade marks by the Applicant would be contrary to law. Consequently, the Opponent failed to establish the ground of opposition under section 42(b). As the Opponent failed to establish any of the nominated grounds of opposition, the delegate determined that both trade mark applications could proceed to registration.

The delegate ordered that trade mark application numbers 2396773 and 2396774 may proceed to registration not less than one month from the date of the decision, subject to any notice of appeal. The Applicant was awarded costs in respect of both trade mark applications against the Opponent.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Jeff Knox v The Australian Simmental Breeders Association Ltd involves two trade mark applications, numbers 2396773 and 2396774, filed by Jeff Knox for beef products, both containing the word "SIMMENTAL". The Australian Simmental Breeders Association Ltd (Opponent) opposed these applications, filing Notices of Intention to Oppose and Statements of Grounds and Particulars (SGP) on 29 April 2024, citing grounds under sections 41, 42(b), and 43 of the relevant Trade Marks Act. Each SGP argued that the marks were misleading and deceptive since they implied the beef products were exclusively from the Simmental breed, while the illustrations depicted cattle that appeared to be Black Baldy cows, not Simmental cattle.

Jeff Knox (Applicant) responded by filing a Notice of Intention to Defend each opposition. Both parties submitted identical evidence regarding the marks. Following the conclusion of evidence submissions, the Opponent requested an oral hearing, which was scheduled for 1 July 2025. In preparation for the hearing, the Applicant opted for written submissions, while the Opponent submitted theirs on 20 May 2025. At the hearing, Fraser Old represented the Opponent. The decision maker, Nicholas Smith, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, considered the written submissions and any oral arguments made by the parties.

The Opponent, a long-standing grazier in the Australian beef industry, argued that the marks were misleading because they suggested exclusivity to Simmental beef, despite the illustrations showing cattle with characteristics not associated with Simmental cattle. The Applicant maintained that the marks were appropriate for the beef products and did not mislead consumers about the breed of cattle. Following the deliberation, the decision maker concluded that the Opponent had not proven the grounds of opposition under section 42(b), and therefore, the Applicant’s marks could proceed to registration. Costs were awarded to the Applicant under the general rule that costs follow the event.

The matter of Jeff Knox v The Australian Simmental Breeders Association Ltd originated from the opposition to the Applicant's applications for the registration of trade marks number 2396773 and 2396774. Following the publication of the applications, the Opponent filed Notices of Intention to Oppose and subsequently Statements of Grounds and Particulars, raising opposition grounds under sections 41, 42(b), and 43 of the relevant legislation. The Applicant responded by filing Notices of Intention to Defend each opposition. Both parties submitted evidence and, after the deadline for filing evidence, the parties were given the option to request an oral hearing or a hearing by written submissions. The Opponent opted for an oral hearing, which was scheduled for 1 July 2025. The parties subsequently filed their written submissions, with the Applicant submitting on 5 March 2025 and the Opponent on 20 May 2025. The hearing was conducted by the delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, who decided to assess the opposition based on the written submissions and any oral submissions made by the parties during the hearing. The decision ultimately ruled in favour of the Applicant, dismissing the grounds of opposition raised by the Opponent and allowing the trade marks to proceed to registration, subject to the possibility of an appeal.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Following the advertisement of the applications’ acceptance for possible registration, the Opponent filed Notices of Intention to Oppose the registration followed by Statements of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’). Each SGP raised grounds of opposition under ss 41, 42(b) and 43. The Applicant filed a Notice of Intention to Defend each opposition on 29 April 2024. Evidence The parties filed the same evidence in respect of both marks, with the evidence being set out below: Once the time allowed for filing evidence had ended, the parties were given an opportunity to request an oral hearing or a hearing by written submissions. On 13 February 2025 the Opponent requested an oral hearing. The matter was set down for a hearing on 1 July 2025 and the matter was allocated to me. In line with usual practice, a letter was sent to the parties on 14 May 2025 which contained a schedule for the provision of written summaries of submissions to be filed prior to the hearing. The Applicant indicated that they only wished to file written submissions and following payment of the required fee filed written submissions on 5 March 2025 (‘Applicant’s Submissions’). The Opponent filed written submissions on 20 May 2025 (‘Opponent’s Submissions’). At the hearing Fraser Old represented the Opponent. I am a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks and I am to decide the opposition as required by s 55 which provides that, unless the proceedings are discontinued, dismissed, or have lapsed under s 54A the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a)to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b)to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established. In doing so I take account of the written record comprised of the materials mentioned in the preceding paragraphs and any oral submissions made by the parties.The Opponent The Opponent is a grazier who has been involved in the Australian beef industry for approximately 40 years. The relevant claims/statements in the Knox declaration can be summarised as follows:· Beef cattle in Australia come in various breeds including the Simmental breed, which is a European breed identified by its light brown colour with white head and white patches of variable shape. Simmental cattle are not black. · Trade Mark No. 2396773 contains the word SIMMENTAL, indicating that it is to be used for beef from the Simmental breed. However, the goods for which the mark is sought to be registered are not restricted to beef from Simmental cattle. Moreover, the illustration of the cow appears to depict that the cow has a black hide and that the cow’s head is that of a Black Baldy cow and thus is not that of a cow from the Simmental breed. The 2396773 Mark is thus misleading and deceptive.· Trade Mark No. 2396774 contains the word SIMMENTAL, indicating that it is to be used for beef from the Simmental breed. Like the previous mark the goods for which this mark is sought to be registered are not restricted to beef from Simmental cattle. Moreover, the illustration of the cow indicates that the cow is likely a Black Baldy cow and thus is not that of a cow from the Simmental breed. The 2396774 Mark is misleading and deceptive.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons I am not satisfied that use of the Trade Marks by the Applicant would be contrary to law. Therefore, the Opponent has failed to establish the ground of opposition under s 42(b).Decision and Costs The Opponent has failed to establish any of the grounds of opposition it nominated in the SGP. Trade mark application numbers 2396773 and 2396774 may proceed to registration not less than one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar is served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration shall not occur until either the appeal is withdrawn or discontinued. Otherwise the disposition of the application should be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction. The Applicant has sought an award of costs in its favour. I see no reason to depart from the general rule that costs follow the event. I accordingly award costs in respect of trade mark number 2396773 against the Opponent under s 221 in the relevant amounts under Schedule 8 of the Regulations. In respect of trade mark number 2396774 I award costs against the Opponent to be taxed in the same manner as indicated in Hume Industries (Malaysia) Berhad v James Hardie & Coy Pty Ltd[15]. [15] [2001] ATMO 78 (Hearing Officer Williams).Nicholas SmithHearing OfficerDelegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks2 September 2025

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The opposition proceedings in the case of Jeff Knox v The Australian Simmental Breeders Association Ltd primarily revolved around whether the Applicant's use of the trade marks would contravene specific provisions of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The Hearing Officer, Nicholas Smith, carefully considered the evidence and submissions provided by both parties to determine the validity of the opposition raised by the Opponent. The decision addresses four key issues: whether the Applicant's use of the trade marks would be contrary to law under s 42(b), whether it would be misleading or deceptive under s 41, whether it would be contrary to honest practices under s 43, and whether the Opponent had established any of the grounds of opposition it nominated.

In addressing whether the Applicant's use of the trade marks would be contrary to law under s 42(b), the Hearing Officer found that the Opponent had not substantiated this ground of opposition. The court emphasized that the trade marks in question, which included the word "SIMMENTAL," were intended for use in relation to beef from the Simmental breed. However, the Opponent argued that the illustrations accompanying the trade marks were misleading as they depicted a cow with a black hide, which is not characteristic of the Simmental breed. The court found that while the illustrations may not accurately represent the Simmental breed, this did not render the Applicant's use of the trade marks contrary to law. The court's reasoning here hinges on the notion that the trade marks themselves, by stating "SIMMENTAL," still accurately represent the intended use for the Simmental breed, despite the potentially misleading illustrations.

Turning to whether the Applicant's use of the trade marks would be misleading or deceptive under s 41, the Hearing Officer examined the evidence presented by both parties. The Opponent contended that the illustrations accompanying the trade marks were misleading because they depicted a cow with a black hide, which is not characteristic of the Simmental breed. However, the Hearing Officer found that the descriptive use of the word "SIMMENTAL" itself was not misleading or deceptive. The court's decision here underscores the importance of the actual wording of the trade marks, rather than the illustrations, in determining whether the use of the marks is misleading or deceptive. The court held that consumers would understand the term "SIMMENTAL" to refer to beef from the Simmental breed, regardless of the potentially misleading illustrations.

The third issue considered was whether the Applicant's use of the trade marks would be contrary to honest practices under s 43. The court found that the use of the trade marks did not contravene honest practices. The Opponent argued that the Applicant's use of the trade marks was misleading and deceptive, but the court held that the descriptive nature of the trade marks themselves did not amount to a breach of honest practices. This finding is grounded in the principle that trade marks should accurately describe the goods or services they represent, and the court found that the Applicant's use of the word "SIMMENTAL" did not fall short of this requirement.

Finally, the Hearing Officer concluded that the Opponent had not established any of the grounds of opposition it nominated in the Statements of Grounds and Particulars. The court found that the Applicant's use of the trade marks did not contravene s 42(b), s 41, or s 43 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The decision highlights the need for the Opponent to provide compelling evidence to substantiate grounds of opposition, and in this case, the court found the evidence insufficient to establish any of the nominated grounds.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the descriptive use of a trade mark, such as the word "SIMMENTAL" for beef from the Simmental breed, is not necessarily misleading or deceptive if it accurately represents the goods or services it is intended for, even if the accompanying illustrations may be inaccurate. The court's decision reinforces the principle that the wording of a trade mark is crucial in determining its validity, and potentially misleading illustrations do not necessarily render the trade mark invalid if the descriptive wording itself is accurate. The court's findings in this case provide guidance for future cases involving similar issues of misleading or deceptive trade marks.