Southern Cross Refrigerating Co v Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read
91 CLR 592

Appl 17. IPR 382. Foll 18 IPR 59 Appt 19 IPR 299 SOUTHERN CROSS REFRIGERATING Fell IT IPR 667 Cons 18 IPR 265 Appt. 21 IPR 223 Appl. 22 IPR 643 Appl. 23 IPR 149.

TOOWOOMBA FOUNDRY PROPRIETARY

RESPONDENT. LIMITED Trade Mark-Registration-Application-Opposition by registered proprietor of

similar trade mark-' " Same goods or description of goods "-Likelihood of deception-Trade Marks Act 1905-1948, SS. 25, 114.

It is not sufficient in order to reach the conclusion that an applicant's goods SYDNEY, Nov. 2, 3, 4,

are of the same description as those of an opponent within the meaning of 5, 16.

S. 25 of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948, merely to find that in the course of marketing there is a likelihood of deception taking place; the inquiry is much more limited and must be answered in favour of the applicant unless upon an 1954,

examination of the material matters the conclusion is justified that the SYDNEY,

applicant's goods ought to be regarded as being of the same description as Nov. 10,11;

those of the opponent.

In determining whether the use of a trade mark is "likely to deceive", within the meaning of S. 114, consideration may be required of matters additional to and distinct from those which are relevant to an inquiry under S. 25. It may be of importance to see whether the registered mark is general or special in character and to ascertain the extent of its reputation. Again it may be important to see whether the goods in respect of which it is regis- tered constitute a narrow class or a wide variety of goods, and whether the goods of both the applicant and the opponent will be likely to find markets substantially in common areas and among the same classes of people. The application should be refused if there is a real risk that as a result of the using of the mark a number of persons among those who might be expected to buy or use the goods will be caused to wonder whether it might not be the case that the two products come from the same source.

Decision of Kitto J. affirmed.

91 CLR 593

APPEAL from Kitto J.

An application for the registration of a trade mark consisting of the words Southern Cross in respect of gas absorption refrigera- tors and electric refrigerators and parts thereof was lodged on 23rd April 1947 by one R. A. Houghton under his trade name of Southern Cross Refrigerating Co.

The application was opposed by Toowoomba Foundry Pty. Ltd., upon the ground, in effect, that the registration applied for was precluded by the provisions of S. 25, or alternatively, of S. 114, of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948.

The objection was upheld by the Registrar upon both grounds. The Law Officer, however, considered that S. 25 did not apply, and that S. 114 did not prevent the registration of the mark if it were made subject to the condition that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Southern Cross Refrigerating Co v Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1954] HCA 82
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Southern Cross Refrigerating Co. (applicant) sought to register the trade mark "Southern Cross" for refrigerators and parts thereof. Toowoomba Foundry Pty. Ltd. (opponent), the registered proprietor of the "Southern Cross" trade mark for machinery and engines, opposed the application. The opposition was based on sections 25 and 114 of the *Trade Marks Act 1905-1948* (Cth). The Registrar upheld the opposition on both grounds. The Law Officer allowed the application subject to a condition that the mark be applied only to domestic refrigerators. The opponent appealed to the High Court, where Kitto J. reversed the Law Officer's decision, refusing registration. The applicant then appealed to the Full Court of the High Court.

The legal issues before the Full Court were whether the applicant's goods (refrigerators) were of the "same description" as the opponent's goods (machinery and engines) for the purposes of section 25, and whether the use of the "Southern Cross" mark on refrigerators was "likely to deceive" within the meaning of section 114, thereby disentitling the applicant to registration.

The Full Court affirmed the decisions of the Law Officer and Kitto J. that section 25 was inapplicable, finding that refrigerators were not goods of the same description as the opponent's machinery and engines, despite some overlap in trade channels. The Court clarified that the inquiry under section 25 is limited and distinct from the inquiry under section 114. Regarding section 114, the Court held that the likelihood of deception is a separate consideration. Applying established principles, the Court found that the opponent had established a wide reputation for its "Southern Cross" branded goods, particularly in country districts. Evidence demonstrated that the use of "Southern Cross" on refrigerators was likely to cause confusion among a substantial portion of the public, leading them to believe the refrigerators originated from the opponent. The Court concluded that the probability of deception was real and could not be eliminated by the condition imposed by the Law Officer. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the application for registration was refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

Southern Cross Refrigerating Co. lodged an application on 23 April 1947 to register the words "Southern Cross" as a trade mark in respect of gas absorption refrigerators and electric refrigerators and parts thereof. Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd opposed the application on the grounds that the registration was precluded by sections 25 and 114 of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948. The Registrar upheld the objection on both grounds, but the Law Officer allowed the application subject to the condition that the mark should be applied to domestic refrigerators only. Toowoomba Foundry appealed against the Law Officer's decision to the High Court. Toowoomba Foundry had registered trade marks consisting of the words "Southern Cross" and the device "S" over a cross for various goods, including windmills, engines, milking machines, and others. Southern Cross Refrigerating Co. argued that Toowoomba Foundry's trade marks did not cover the same goods or description of goods as the ones in question, and therefore section 25 did not apply. The Court agreed that Toowoomba Foundry's registered trade marks did not cover the same goods or description of goods as those sought by Southern Cross Refrigerating Co. The Court further held that even if the goods were not of the same description, the likelihood of confusion under section 114 was still a valid consideration. Toowoomba Foundry had built up a wide reputation for its goods, especially windmills and other water-supply equipment, milking machines, internal-combustion engines and electric generators and motors, under the name "Southern Cross" over the past fifty years. The Court found that there was a real risk that the use of the mark "Southern Cross" on refrigerators by Southern Cross Refrigerating Co. would cause confusion among a substantial portion of the public, and the appeal was dismissed with costs.

The matter before the High Court is an appeal against a decision of Kitto J. who heard an appeal from the Registrar of Trade Marks. The original application for the registration of a trade mark consisting of the words "Southern Cross" in respect of gas absorption refrigerators and electric refrigerators and parts thereof was lodged by R. A. Houghton under his trade name of Southern Cross Refrigerating Co. on 23 April 1947. The application was opposed by Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd., who argued that the registration should be precluded under sections 25 and 114 of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948. The Registrar upheld the objection, finding that both sections stood in the way of the application. The Law Officer, however, considered that section 25 did not apply and was satisfied that section 114 did not prevent the registration if it were made subject to the condition that the mark should be applied to domestic refrigerators only. He accordingly granted the application upon this condition. Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd. appealed against this decision to the High Court, which heard the appeal in 1953. The Full Court of the High Court dismissed the appeal with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the goods for which registration of the trade mark "Southern Cross" is sought are of the same description as those for which the opponent has registered marks.
2. Whether the use of the trade mark "Southern Cross" by the applicant is likely to deceive or cause confusion under Section 114 of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948.
3. Whether the applicant has discharged the onus of proving that there is no reasonable probability of confusion.
4. If the applicant's goods are not of the same description as those of the opponent, whether there is still a likelihood of deception or confusion under Section 114 of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948.
5. Whether the appellant's use of the trade mark "Southern Cross" has already caused confusion among the public.

Held
1. Whether the goods for which registration of the trade mark "Southern Cross" is sought are of the same description as those for which the opponent has registered marks.
The court concluded that the applicant's goods are not of the same description as those of the opponent, and thus S. 25 of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948 does not apply. Appeal allowed on this issue.

2. Whether the use of the trade mark "Southern Cross" by the applicant is likely to deceive or cause confusion under Section 114 of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948.
The court concluded that there is a real likelihood of deception or confusion, as the trade mark "Southern Cross" has a wide and varied significance, and the use of the mark by the applicant would likely deceive the public. Appeal dismissed on this issue.

3. Whether the applicant has discharged the onus of proving that there is no reasonable probability of confusion.
The court concluded that the applicant has not discharged the onus of proving that there is no reasonable probability of confusion. Appeal dismissed on this issue.

4. If the applicant's goods are not of the same description as those of the opponent, whether there is still a likelihood of deception or confusion under Section 114 of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948.
The court concluded that even though the goods are not of the same description, there is still a likelihood of deception or confusion under S. 114. Appeal dismissed on this issue.

5. Whether the appellant's use of the trade mark "Southern Cross" has already caused confusion among the public.
The court concluded that there is substantial evidence of actual confusion caused by the appellant's use of the trade mark "Southern Cross." Appeal dismissed on this issue.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered whether the registration of the trade mark "Southern Cross" by Southern Cross Refrigerating Co. should be granted, in light of the existing registration of similar marks by Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd. The court determined that the applicant's goods were not of the same description as those of the opponent, and hence Section 25 of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948 did not apply. However, the court found that under Section 114, the use of the trade mark "Southern Cross" by the applicant was likely to deceive or cause confusion.

The Court of Appeal held that the onus was on the applicant to prove that there was no reasonable probability of confusion. The court noted that it was sufficient if the result of the user of the mark would be that a number of persons would be caused to wonder whether it might not be the case that the two products came from the same source. The court found that the evidence presented by the respondent was convincing and established the probability of confusion.

The court considered whether the applicant had discharged the onus of proving that there was no reasonable probability of confusion. The court found that the applicant had not discharged this onus, and hence, the registration should be refused.

The Court of Appeal also considered whether there was a likelihood of deception or confusion even if the applicant's goods were not of the same description as those of the opponent. The court found that there was a real risk that the use of the mark by the applicant would lead to confusion among the public.

Finally, the court considered whether the appellant's use of the trade mark "Southern Cross" had already caused confusion among the public. The court found that the evidence established that actual confusion had occurred, and that the respondent had made out a clear case of likelihood of deception.

In conclusion, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and held that the registration of the trade mark "Southern Cross" by Southern Cross Refrigerating Co. should be refused. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the use of a trade mark which is similar to an existing registered mark may be likely to deceive or cause confusion, even if the goods are not of the same description, and the applicant must prove that there is no reasonable probability of confusion.