Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd v Rocco Pezzano Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BRENNAN CJ,
McHUGH, GUMMOW, KIRBY AND HAYNE JJ

UNITY INSURANCE BROKERS PTY LIMITED   APPELLANT

AND

ROCCO PEZZANO PTY LTD  RESPONDENT

Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd v Rocco Pezzano Pty Ltd (P64-1996)
 [1998] HCA 38
20 May 1998

ORDER

Appeal dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Western Australia

Representation:

C J L Pullin QC with D M Bradley for the appellant (instructed by
Barker Gosling)

R H B Pringle QC with D A Dawes for the respondent (instructed by
Michael Rennie)

Notice:  This copy of the Court’s Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

CATCHWORDS

Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd v Rocco Pezzano Pty Ltd

Insurance - Insurance Brokers - Breach of duty or contractual obligation by broker to disclose insured's full claims history to insurer - Compromise settlement by insured of claim against insurer and remainder of claimed damages sought from broker - Whether settlement reasonable - Whether sufficient evidence brought by insured to demonstrate the strength of the insurer's defence of non-disclosure - Whether broker's breach of duty or contractual obligation relevantly caused insured's loss - Whether settlement rendered the remainder of insured's damages too remote.

Words and phrases - "A reasonable insurer".

Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth), s 28.

  1. BRENNAN CJ.   Hayne J has set out the relevant facts, which I need not repeat, and has reached a conclusion with which I respectfully agree.  Although I am in substantial agreement with what his Honour has written, my reasons differ in some respects.  I point out those differences.

  2. The appellant broker's failure to disclose to the insurer the full claims history of the respondent insured had an immediate consequence:  the insured obtained a policy that was arguably defeasible at the option of the insurer and there was no certainty that the insurer would not attempt to exercise the option.  The policy did not provide the sure cover which the broker was retained to procure.  If the insurer was not liable under the policy to provide a full indemnity to the insured, the insured was entitled to full indemnity from the broker by reason of the broker's breach of its retainer or its negligence.  When the insurer denied liability "by reason of material non-disclosure of prior claims", the insured brought proceedings in which it joined the insurer and the broker as defendants.  If the action against the insurer had gone to trial and the insurer had succeeded in denying liability, the insured would have been entitled to obtain full indemnity against the broker.

  3. When a claim is met by an arguable defence, a compromise is a natural and foreseeable result.  Therefore it is a natural and foreseeable result of whatever creates an arguable defence to a claim that the claim will be compromised.  In the present case, whatever weakness there was in the insured's case against the insurer was attributable to the broker's negligent breach of its retainer or its negligence.  The acceptance…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd v Rocco Pezzano Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] HCA 38
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal by Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd ("the broker") against a decision of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The dispute arose from the broker's failure to disclose the respondent, Rocco Pezzano Pty Ltd's ("the insured"), full claims history to the insurer, NZI Insurance Australia Limited ("the insurer"). This non-disclosure led the insurer to refuse indemnity for extensive fire damage to the insured's premises. The insured subsequently settled its claim against the insurer for $900,000, a sum significantly less than the full indemnity sought, and then pursued the broker for the shortfall, alleging breach of contract and duty.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether the insured had adequately proven its loss resulting from the broker's breach, and if so, how that loss should be calculated. Specifically, the court had to determine if the insured could rely on the settlement sum with the insurer to quantify its damages, or if it was required to prove what it would have received had the claim against the insurer been litigated to judgment. The broker argued that the insured's loss should be measured by the difference between a hypothetical judgment against the insurer and the settlement amount, rather than the difference between the full indemnity and the settlement amount.

The High Court reasoned that the broker's breach of contract, by failing to exercise reasonable care and skill in obtaining the insurance policy, directly caused the insured's loss. This loss was not a mere loss of a chance, but the difference between the value of the secure insurance cover that should have been provided and the cover that was ultimately limited due to the insurer's defence of non-disclosure under section 28 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth). The court held that the focus should be on assessing the measure of the insured's loss consequent upon the fire and the insurer's denial of liability, rather than on valuing a hypothetical chance of a better outcome. The question was whether the insured acted reasonably in compromising its claim, given the insurer's defence, and the extent to which the broker's actions diminished the value of the insurance policy.

The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appeal is brought by Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd ("the broker") against an order of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia. That order dismissed the broker's appeal against a judgment holding it liable in damages for breach of a contract made with the respondent. The broker contends that, although it breached its contract with the insured by failing to exercise reasonable care and skill in obtaining an insurance policy, the insured failed to prove that it had suffered a loss from that breach. That contention is based on the ground that the insured sought to prove its loss simply by proving the difference between the sum that it would have received from the insurer, if due care had been exercised, and the sum that it did receive in settlement of the claim with the insurer. The broker contends that to calculate its loss the insured was required to prove the sum that it would have received if it had litigated the matter against the insurer and that the insured cannot rely on the settlement sum in calculating the difference.Factual background The broker agreed to obtain insurance for the respondent, Rocco Pezzano Pty Ltd, ("the insured") in respect of the insured's business premises in East Cannington, near Perth. Pursuant to the agreement, the broker obtained a special risks insurance policy from NZI Insurance Australia Limited ("the insurer"). Among the risks covered by the policy was damage by fire to the insured's plant, machinery, stock, contents and premises. During the currency of the policy, a fire at the premises extensively damaged many of those items. The insurer refused to indemnify the insured for the damage because "of material non-disclosure of prior claims". The non-disclosure was caused by the broker who disclosed to the insurer only one of 12 claims that the insured had made against insurers during the previous 13 years. As a result of the insurer's refusal to indemnify it, the insured sued the insurer for breach of its promise of indemnity and the broker for breach of its duty to exercise reasonable care and skill in obtaining the policy. The insurer, relying on s 28 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) ("the Act"), asserted that it was entitled to reduce its liability under the policy to nil by reason of the non-disclosure. In these circumstances, the legal advisers of the insured, including senior counsel advised it to settle the action against the insurer for $900,000. The shortfall between the amount of the settlement and a full indemnity was more than $800,000. The insured contends that, because the broker placed it in the position where it had to settle for this sum, the broker is liable to it for the difference between the amount of the full indemnity and the sum of $900,000 received in the compromise settlement. In the action between the insured and the broker[6], Mr Pezzano, a director of the insured, gave evidence that he had been advised that the insured should accept the sum of $900,000 rather than "losing everything because there was no disclosure" of the full claims history. He also testified that the insured's lawyers had told him that the insurer "wouldn't pay any more than that". Senior counsel and the insured's solicitors who gave this advice were not called as witnesses. Nor was there any other evidence concerning the reasons for the settlement. There was, however, evidence that the initial offer from the insurer was $740,000 and that this had been eventually increased to the sum of $900,000 which was then accepted.[6]Rocco Pezzano Pty Ltd v Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd (1995) 8 ANZ Ins Cas 61-288.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GUMMOW J BRENNAN CJ (dissent) HUGH J (dissent) KIRBY J
The appellant complains that the respondent should not have recovered from it the difference between the settlement sum and the sum for which the insurer would have been liable under the policy had there been no failure to disclose, without establishing that the settlement sum represented the extent of the reduced liability of the insurer.The judgments in the Supreme Court of Western Australia At the trial, the appellant submitted that the evidence established that the insurer would have accepted the proposal, albeit, perhaps, at an increased premium so that, at most, s 28(3) reduced the liability of the insurer by no more than the amount of any difference in the premium. On that footing, the appellant submitted that it had procured for the respondent a fully enforceable contract of insurance, notwithstanding the non‑disclosure, and that any loss suffered by the respondent was a consequence of its own decision to compromise the claim against the insurer in the light of the defences raised against it. These had included not only non‑disclosure, but an allegation that the fire was the result of arson. However, the trial judge had decided the case on a different footing. His Honour had said[36]:"The question is not whether [the insurer] considered that it was or was not entitled to reduce its liability to nil but, rather, that of whether [the respondent] acted reasonably in compromising its claim against [the insurer] for $900,000."[36](1995) 8 ANZ Insurance Cases ¶61‑288 at 76,213. As this passage indicates, attention to the fundamental issue was distracted at the trial (and later in the Full Court[37]) by emphasis upon collateral considerations. These should be mentioned briefly.[37]Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd v Rocco Pezzano Pty Ltd (1997) 9 ANZ Insurance Cases ¶61‑343. The Full Court classified the respondent's case against the appellant as the "[loss of] the chance to make a claim without having to meet the defence of non‑disclosure"[38]. However, this was not a loss of a chance case as that expression is to be understood after Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL[39]. In such cases, damages for breach of contract are assessed by reference to the probabilities or possibilities, even if less than 50 per cent, that the advantage or benefit would have been realised if the plaintiff had been given the chance which the contract promised.[38](1997) 9 ANZ Insurance Cases ¶61‑343 at 76,757.[39](1994) 179 CLR 332 at 349. See also Waribay Pty Ltd v Minter Ellison [1991] 2 VR 391 at 398‑399. The contract of brokerage was not to provide the respondent with a chance or opportunity, uncertain of realisation, to obtain a commercial advantage or benefit. The respondent enlisted the appellant's services to obtain secure insurance cover. The broker failed to exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence, with the result that the cover provided by the policy was limited by the reduction in the liability of the insurer by s 28(3) of the Act. The difference between the value of what should have been provided and what was provided was the respondent's loss. The court should not have been "concerned with valuing a chance or prospect that the respondent might have lost"[40]. The question was one of assessing the measure of the respondent's loss in the events that happened consequent upon the fire of 20 September 1992 and the denial by the insurer of all liability under the policy.[40]Johnson v Perez (1988) 166 CLR 351 at 364‑365.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GUMMOW J, KIRBY J

The court addressed the issue of the reasonableness of the insured's settlement of its claim against the insurer, focusing on whether the settlement appropriately reflected the strength of the insurer's defence of non-disclosure. The insured settled for $900,000, significantly less than the potential full indemnity, due to advice from its senior counsel and solicitors, who informed the insured that it should accept the settlement to avoid losing everything. The court recognized the importance of expert advice in such situations, which led to the settlement being deemed reasonable given the circumstances and the insurer's strong defence of non-disclosure, including the allegation of arson. This decision aligns with the understanding that settlements often reflect the realistic prospects of success in litigation, particularly when faced with robust defences.

The court then turned to the question of whether the broker's breach of its contractual obligation to exercise reasonable care and skill in obtaining the insurance policy caused the insured's loss. The broker failed to disclose the full claims history to the insurer, leading to the insurer's refusal to indemnify the insured. The court found that the broker's failure was a direct cause of the insured's loss, as the broker's negligence resulted in the policy being subject to a reduction in liability under s 28(3) of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth). This causal link was pivotal in holding the broker liable for the insured's loss, reinforcing the principle that brokers must exercise due care and skill to ensure policies are properly procured.

In determining whether the insured was required to prove the sum it would have received if it had litigated the matter against the insurer, or if it could rely on the settlement sum to calculate the difference in loss, the court noted that the insured's ability to rely on the settlement sum was influenced by the strength of the insurer's defence and the expert advice received. The insured did not need to prove what it would have received in litigation; instead, it could rely on the settlement sum as a reasonable reflection of its loss, given the circumstances. This approach was consistent with the understanding that settlements often embody the realistic prospects of success in litigation, particularly in complex cases with robust defences.

The court also examined whether the settlement sum rendered the remainder of the insured's damages too remote, thereby affecting the broker's liability for the insured's loss. The court held that the remainder of the damages was not too remote, as the settlement sum was a direct consequence of the broker's breach of duty. The broker's failure to disclose the full claims history led to the insurer's refusal to indemnify the insured, which in turn resulted in the settlement. This finding underscores the principle that losses directly resulting from a breach of duty are not too remote, as long as they are a foreseeable consequence of that breach.

Finally, the court addressed whether the insured should recover the difference between the settlement sum and the sum for which the insurer would have been liable under the policy had there been no failure to disclose, without establishing that the settlement sum represented the extent of the reduced liability of the insurer. The court held that the insured was entitled to recover this difference, as it was a direct consequence of the broker's breach of duty. This decision reinforces the principle that the measure of damages for breach of contract is the loss directly flowing from the breach, without the need to establish the exact extent of the insurer's reduced liability. The court's decision in this regard was based on the understanding that the broker's failure to exercise reasonable care and skill in obtaining the policy led to a significant reduction in the insured's coverage and the subsequent loss.

In conclusion, the court's reasoning in Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd v Rocco Pezzano Pty Ltd highlights the importance of brokers exercising reasonable care and skill in obtaining insurance policies, the reasonableness of settlements in the face of strong defences, and the direct link between a broker's breach of duty and the insured's loss. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that a broker's failure to exercise reasonable care and skill in obtaining an insurance policy can result in liability for the insured's loss, even if that loss is quantified by a settlement sum. The court's approach to causation and damages in this context provides clear guidance for brokers and insureds in similar situations.