Caporaso Pty Ltd v Mercato Centrale Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Caporaso Pty Ltd v Mercato Centrale Australia Pty Ltd [2024] FCA 138

File number: SAD 188 of 2022
Judgment of: CHARLESWORTH J
Date of judgment: 26 February 2024
Catchwords: INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – trade marks – originating application alleging infringement of trade marks including the plain word mark mercato – whether the respondent has used, as a trade mark, a sign that is deceptively similar to any one of the applicant’s trade marks sued upon – cross-claim for cancellation of trade marks or rectification of the Register of Trade Marks in respect of them – whether the cross-respondent was the owner of the trade mark mercato at the time that it applied for registration of it – whether the trade mark mercato is inherently capable of distinguishing the goods and services of the cross-respondent from the goods and services of other traders – whether the word mercato, in its ordinary signification, is commonly understood to mean market among those with an interest in the relevant goods and services – whether other traders should be permitted to use the word in its ordinary signification to describe their goods and services – whether evidence of trade usage of the word supports a conclusion that the word has an established meaning among a target audience comprised of English speaking Australians – whether the registration of a trade mark resulted from representations or evidence that were false in material particulars – meaning of “material particulars” in s 62(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – infringement action dismissed – cross-claim allowed in part
Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 8, 59, 60, 69, 79, 155, 190

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37M, 37N

Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Act 2012 (Cth)

Trade Marks Act 1955-1958 (Cth) s 26

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) ss 7, 10, 17, 19, 20, 26, 27, 31, 33, 41, 52, 54, 55, 57, 58, 58A, 59, 60, 61, 62, 62A, 88, 89, 120, 206, 207, 210, 219

Cases cited:

Accor Australia & New Zealand Hospitality Pty Ltd v Liv Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 56; 345 ALR 205

Anakin Pty Ltd v Chatswood BBQ King Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1467; 250 ALR 620

Anchorage Capital Partners Pty Ltd v ACPA Pty Ltd (2018) 259 FCR 514

Apple Inc v Registrar of Trade Marks (2014) 227 FCR 511

Australian Meat Group Pty Ltd v JBS Australia Pty Ltd (2018) 268 FCR 623

Australian Woollen Mills Ltd v F S Walton & Co Ltd (1937) 58 CLR 641

CA Henschke & Co v Rosemount Estates Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 1539: 52 IPR 42

Cantarella Bros Pty Ltd v Lavazza Australia Pty Ltd (No 3) [2023] FCA 1258

Cantarella Bros Pty Ltd v Modena Trading Pty Ltd (2014) 254 CLR 337

Cantarella Bros Pty Ltd v Modena Trading Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 8; 299 ALR 752

Clark Equipment Co v Registrar of Trade Marks (1964) 111 CLR 511

Coca-Cola…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Caporaso Pty Ltd v Mercato Centrale Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 138
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Caporaso Pty Ltd v Mercato Centrale Australia Pty Ltd involves a dispute between Caporaso Pty Ltd and Mercato Centrale Australia Pty Ltd concerning the alleged infringement of trade marks, including the plain word mark "mercato". The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The central issue in this case is whether Mercato Centrale has used, as a trade mark, a sign that is deceptively similar to any one of the trade marks sued upon by Caporaso. Additionally, Mercato Centrale has filed a cross-claim for the cancellation of the trade marks or rectification of the Register of Trade Marks in respect of them. The court was required to determine whether Mercato Centrale was the owner of the trade mark "mercato" at the time it applied for its registration, whether the trade mark "mercato" is inherently capable of distinguishing the goods and services of Mercato Centrale from those of other traders, and whether the word "mercato" has an established meaning among English-speaking Australians.

The court found that the word "mercato" does not have an established meaning in English, even though it is common knowledge that it means "market" in Italian. The absence of the word in English dictionaries makes it difficult for Mercato Centrale to prove that the word has any ordinary signification among English-speaking Australians. The court also found that the extensive use of the word "mercato" by other traders does not support a conclusion that the word has an established meaning among English-speaking Australians. The court further held that the registration of a trade mark resulted from representations or evidence that were false in material particulars. The court dismissed the infringement action and allowed the cross-claim in part.

The court ordered that the originating application be dismissed, and the cross-claim be allowed to the extent provided for in paragraph 3 of the orders. The court also ordered that the Register of Trade Marks be amended to reflect the reasons for judgment published today. The parties have been granted liberty to apply to vary the order in paragraph 3 to reflect the reasons for judgment published today, such liberty to be exercised on or before 4 March 2024. Additionally, any party seeking an order for costs is to file and serve an affidavit specifying the order sought on or before 12 March 2024.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The originating application is dismissed.

2. The cross-claim is:

(a) allowed to the extent provided for in paragraph 3 of these orders;

(b) otherwise dismissed.

3. Subject to paragraph 4, in respect of Trade Mark No 1760112, the Register of Trade Marks be amended so that the description of services in Class 43 read as follows:

Services for providing food and drink (other than services relating to the provision of food and drink at cafés, restaurants, bars or hotels); catering services; preparation of takeaway and fast foods; take away food and drink services; bakery services; bakery services relating to cakes and pastries; consultancy services relating to the operation of restaurants, cafes, take away food services, bars and hotels; temporary accommodation.

4. The parties have liberty to apply to vary the order in paragraph 3 so as to reflect the reasons for judgment published today, such liberty to be exercised on or before 4 March 2024.

5. On or before 12 March 2024 any party seeking an order for costs is to file and serve an affidavit specifying the order sought.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is common ground that the relevant consumers are ordinary members of the Australian public. The Court is not concerned to identify the meaning of a word in a specialised context.Dictionary and census evidence The word mercato means “market” or “marketplace” in Italian. It does not appear in the 2020 edition of the Macquarie Dictionary. Nor does the Spanish word mercado (having the same translated meaning). Data from the 2021 census shows that 228,042 people in Australia spoke Italian at home in the census period, and 171,370 spoke Spanish. Those are not significant numbers given the total Australian population. The same edition of the Macquarie Dictionary contains several definitions for words having Italian origins (mostly relating to food and drink) such as “bruschetta”, “cappuccino” and “spaghetti”. I would have no difficulty concluding that those words have commonly understood meanings in Australia to English speaking people. Mercato Centrale submitted that the absence of a word from an English dictionary is not decisive. Whilst I accept that submission, I consider the absence of the word makes it considerably more difficult for a party in Mercato Centrale’s position to establish that the word in its ordinary signification is directly descriptive of the relevant Challenged Goods and Services. Critically, the ordinary signification of the word is not the meaning it has in the minds of speakers of the Italian language. The absence of the word in English dictionaries is plainly relevant to the question of whether the word has any ordinary signification to what the majority in Cantarella High Court described as the target audience, although it is not necessarily decisive.Trade usage Mercato Centrale relied on what it described as “extremely wide use of the word MERCATO by many different traders from all around Australia” as indicative of other traders’ desire to use the word or marks incorporating the word at, prior to and after the relevant priority dates. The usage evidence has four sources. First, there is the testimony contained in affidavits of at least the following traders each of whom was cross-examined at trial:(1)Mr Giovanni Pasquale Caporaso, the managing director of Caporaso;(2)Ms Caterina Borsato, a restaurateur with more than 30 years’ experience in the operation of Italian restaurants in Melbourne;(3)Mr Eddie Muto, a director of Mercato Centrale;(4)Mr Richard Mee, the former owner of a business trading under the name MERCATO @ daylesford in Victoria from 2004 to 2018; and(5)Mr Nicholas Basile, a current and former director of companies associated with Panetta Mercato, a specialty grocer with stores in New South Wales. Second, there are the results of searches of public records undertaken by a solicitor for Mercato Centrale, Ms Noelene Smythe. Third, there is the result of searches undertaken by Professor Valentyna Melnyk, a marketing expert called to give opinion evidence as part of Mercato Centrale’s case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In Australian Meat Group, the Full Court held that the mark “AMG” was not deceptively similar to the mark “AMH”. The Full Court accepted evidence that the letters “AM” were commonly used in the Australian meat industry to delineate “Australian meat”. Cited acronyms included AMPC (Australian Meat Processor Corporation) and AMIC (Australian Meat Industry Council). The Full Court found (at [85]) that this common use was:… a relevant consideration when considering the question of deceptive similarity … because it affects the significance and weight to be given to the element ‘AM’ that is found in each of the competing marks. …Submissions and conclusions Caporaso submitted that mercato is the only word in each of the Caporaso Marks and so is the central feature in each of them. For present purposes it is enough to observe that the word is the only feature of the Plain Word Mark. It may be accepted that even an imperfect recollection of the notional use of the mark would encompass the word mercato in its written or aural representations. The submission about the central feature of the other Caporaso Marks will be considered in due course. It was then submitted, in comparing the mark mercato centrale: … it is well established that the first part of a mark is ‘as a rule, far the most important for the purpose of distinction’. … The case cited for the quoted passage was Conde Nast Publications Pty Ltd v Taylor [1998] FCA 864; 41 IPR 505, Burchett J (at 511), in turn citing a passage from In the Matter of London Lubricants (1920) Limited’s Application to Register a Trade Mark (1925) 42 RPC 264, Sargant LJ (at 279). The passage cited hardly establishes or evidences a rule to which this Court is bound. It concerns the emphasis that may be placed on the first syllable of a word in a particular case. To my mind, the question of whether the first part of a mark is “far the most important” must turn on the facts of the particular case. There can be no rule about that. It was then submitted that the word centrale does not make the mark mercato centrale so distinguishable so as to diminish the likelihood of confusion, for two reasons. First, it was said that the word mercato was impactful and so more memorable. Second, it was said that the word centrale would be more readily understood by ordinary Australians as being a foreign word which translates to central given the obvious visual and aural similarities between the Italian and English words. It was submitted that the target audience may well understand the word centrale to be a “descriptive add-on”. I do not wholly accept those submissions. The allegedly infringing mark must be considered as a whole. It consists of two Italian sounding words, not one. Neither word has a proven meaning in English, at least on the evidence before me. The contention that the target audience would regard the word centrale as a mere descriptive add on comes up against the problem that in ordinary English adjectives do not follow nouns. One does not need to be a scholar in grammar to appreciate that. Unlike the signs considered in most of the cases relied upon by the parties, the signs under comparison do not include words having any proven ordinary signification to English speaking consumers. Both of the words are distinctive. Both are Italian sounding. Neither would be readily recognised as a noun or an adjective.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.