Canterella Bros. Pty Ltd v Sunbeam Corporation Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Cantarella Bros. Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application 1013086(7) - GELATERIA - filed in the name of Sunbeam Corporation Limited.

Delegate: Rachel Dunn
Representation: Opponent: Carmen Champion of Counsel, instructed by Lisa Lennon of Gilbert and Tobin Lawyers
Applicant: Khajaque Kortian of Spruson and Ferguson
Decision: S52 Opposition – s44 ground not established; s41 ground partially established. Each party to bear its own costs.

Background

  1. Sunbeam Corporation Limited (the applicant), applied for registration of the following trade mark:

Application Number:

1013086

Priority Date:

27 July 2004

Goods:

2.     Class: 7  Machines including ice-cream making machines, gelato making machines and machines for making other iced confectionery

Trade Mark:

GELATERIA

Endorsement:

TheThe applicant has advised that the translation of the ITALIAN worword appearing in the trade mark is ICE CREAM PARLOUR.*

Acceptance Advertised:

3.     6 January 2005

  1. The time in which to file a notice of opposition was extended on the basis of negotiations between the parties, however these were not successful.  Within the extended time in which to do so Cantarella Bros Pty Ltd (the opponent) filed a notice of opposition based on several grounds including that the trade mark is not capable of distinguishing the applicant’s goods from those of other traders.

  2. Evidence in support was served and filed promptly.  The applicant chose not to serve any evidence in answer; it simply relied upon the Trade Marks Office Register of trade marks, and requested a hearing.

  3. I heard the matter in Sydney on 20 July, where the applicant was represented by Khajaque Kortian of Spruson and Ferguson and the opponent briefed Carmen Champion of Counsel, who was instructed by Lisa Lennon of Gilbert and Tobin Lawyers.

    Evidence

  4. Evidence in support consists of a statutory declaration in the name of Leslie John Schirato with four exhibits.  Mr Schirato attests to his familiarity with the Italian language, the Australian food industry, and the common use of the term “gelato” by Australian cafes.  The exhibits show use of the word GELATERIA in the Yellow and White Pages directories; use of the term in advertising; and dictionary definitions, although I note the applicant has never disputed the meaning of the term and in fact has confirmed a definition in the endorsement of the application.

  5. Mr Schirato’s evidence goes towards only one ground of opposition, that of s 41.  There is no evidence provided for any of the other grounds, however in the notice of opposition the registration that is relied upon for the s 44 ground is identified as being for the series of words GELATORIA and GELATTORIA.  Therefore, this decision will involve grounds under ss 44 and 41 only.  I find that in the absence of any evidence the other grounds have not been established.

    Discussion

    Section 44

  6. To establish a ground under s 44 the opponent has to satisfy me that priority lies with the opponent’s trade mark; the trade marks themselves…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Canterella Bros. Pty Ltd v Sunbeam Corporation Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] ATMO 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before Rachel Dunn, Hearing Officer at the Trade Marks Hearings, concerning an opposition by Sunbeam Corporation Ltd against the trade mark application by Canterella Bros. Pty Ltd. The dispute centred on Canterella Bros.' application to register a trade mark, with Sunbeam Corporation Ltd opposing the registration on several grounds.

The primary legal issues before the Hearing Officer were whether the applicant's trade mark should be refused registration under sections 44 and 41 of the relevant legislation. Specifically, under section 44, the court had to determine if the opponent's earlier trade marks were deceptively similar to the applicant's mark and if they covered the same or similar goods. Under section 41, the court considered the distinctiveness of the applicant's mark in relation to the goods for which it was sought.

The Hearing Officer found that the opponent had established the ground of opposition under section 44. Priority clearly lay with the opponent's earlier filed trade mark. The Hearing Officer was satisfied that the trade marks were deceptively similar, noting minimal visual, oral, and aural differences between the marks and considering the Italian origin of the terms. The crucial factor for this ground was the similarity of goods, with the opponent's mark covering ice cream and ice confections, including gelato, and the applicant's mark covering machines for making ice cream, confections, and gelato. The Hearing Officer found that a connection would be perceived by consumers as one set of goods was used to manufacture the other. The ground under section 41 was also considered, with evidence presented regarding the common use of the term "gelato" in the Australian food industry.

Ultimately, the Hearing Officer determined that the trade mark application could proceed to registration if the applicant was prepared to limit its specification of goods to "machines including ice cream making machines, gelato making machines and machines for making other iced confectionary; all foregoing goods being for domestic use." If this limitation was not made, the application would be refused in its entirety. Both parties were directed to bear their own costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I heard the matter in Sydney on 20 July, where the applicant was represented by Khajaque Kortian of Spruson and Ferguson and the opponent briefed Carmen Champion of Counsel, who was instructed by Lisa Lennon of Gilbert and Tobin Lawyers.Evidence Evidence in support consists of a statutory declaration in the name of Leslie John Schirato with four exhibits. Mr Schirato attests to his familiarity with the Italian language, the Australian food industry, and the common use of the term “gelato” by Australian cafes. The exhibits show use of the word GELATERIA in the Yellow and White Pages directories; use of the term in advertising; and dictionary definitions, although I note the applicant has never disputed the meaning of the term and in fact has confirmed a definition in the endorsement of the application. Mr Schirato’s evidence goes towards only one ground of opposition, that of s 41. There is no evidence provided for any of the other grounds, however in the notice of opposition the registration that is relied upon for the s 44 ground is identified as being for the series of words GELATORIA and GELATTORIA. Therefore, this decision will involve grounds under ss 44 and 41 only. I find that in the absence of any evidence the other grounds have not been established.DiscussionSection 44 To establish a ground under s 44 the opponent has to satisfy me that priority lies with the opponent’s trade mark; the trade marks themselves are deceptively similar; and that they claim the same or similar goods. Priority clearly lies with the opponent’s trade mark as it was filed in 2003 and this application was not made until 2004. I am satisfied that the trade marks themselves are deceptively similar. There is minimal difference visually, orally and aurally between GELATERIA and GELATORIA, and little more between GELATERIA and GELATTORIA. This is enhanced, I believe, by the fact that the term is one in the Italian language. Whilst Mr Schirato attests to “the majority of gelato consumers having some basic knowledge of Italian terminology as it applies to food products”, it is my opinion that the average consumer will simply see GELATERIA and GELATORIA as interchangeable and would not distinguish trade origin on the slight differences present in the terms. The impression produced by these words is one of similarity, and I believe a real tangible danger exists of deception and confusion in the marketplace. Therefore, this ground of opposition turns on the question of similarity of goods. The opponent’s trade mark claims the goods of ice cream and ice confections, including among other goods, ‘gelato and other Italian-style ice confections’. The subject application covers machines including those for making ice cream, ice confections and gelato. The applicant submits that it is artificial and unreasonable to believe that consumers would use the same trade channels for both sets of goods. The opponent submits that as one set of goods is used to manufacture the other, a connection would be perceived by consumers.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Additionally, the opponent’s inaction regarding clarification of exactly what grounds of opposition were being pressed was also a concern to the applicant. I have less sympathy with the applicant in these circumstances. Whilst the applicant felt it needed to prepare written submissions for all the grounds of opposition, it was quite clear that the evidence in support went toward only the ground pursuant to s 41, and the notice of opposition only substantiated s 44. No evidence was submitted toward any of the other grounds, and as these clearly could not be established I would have expected that no work would have been put into the applicant’s written submissions on the grounds other than those under ss 41 and 44.Decision If the applicant is prepared to limit its specification of goods to read:“machines including ice cream making machines, gelato making machines and machines for making other iced confectionary; all foregoing goods being for domestic use”the trade mark application may proceed to registration one month from the date of this decision. Therefore, if the applicant wishes to make this limitation, it should inform the Trade Marks Office of such intention without delay. If the applicant chooses not to limit its specification in this manner, then I refuse the application in its entirety. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before one month from the date of this decision, I direct that the limitation and/or registration shall not occur until the appeal has been discontinued, or in the event of a decision from the Court, that the application be subject to that order. As both parties have been somewhat successful in this matter they should bear their own costs.Rachel DunnHearing Officer,Trade Marks Hearings24 January 2007

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.