TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Opposition by Mayne Co. Investments Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application number 2100745 (class 44) – INTEGRATED SMILES & DEVICE – in the name of Dinsmit Pty Ltd as trustee for the McIvor Dental Surgery Trust
Delegate: | Katrina Brown |
Representation: | Opponent: Melissa Marcus of Counsel, instructed by MacMillan Trade Marks Attorneys Applicant: Chris Round and Pete Knowles, K&L Gates |
Decision: | 2022 ATMO 226 Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – opposition under section 52 – grounds pursued under ss 42(b), 44, 60 and 62A – no ground established – trade mark to proceed to registration |
Background
This decision is in respect of an opposition under s 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’) by Mayne Co. Investments Pty Ltd (‘Opponent’) to registration of the following trade mark:
Trade mark no: 2100745
Trade mark:
(‘Trade Mark’)
Applicant:Dinsmit Pty Ltd as trustee for the McIvor Dental Surgery Trust (‘Applicant’)
Filing date: 2 July 2020
Specification: Class 44 - Dentistry; dental hygiene services; dental surgery services; implant dentistry services, periodontic dental services; prosthodontic dental services; oral and maxillofacial surgery services; orthodontic services; x-ray services; patient services relating to patient imaging (including by x-ray, ultrasound, computed tomography scans), analysis and reporting of results of such imaging; information and consultancy services relating to health care and dentistry; cosmetic dentistry; cosmetic treatment services; cosmetic injection treatment services including skin enhancement treatments; botulinum toxin injections treatments; dermal filler injections treatments; facial filler injection treatments; temporomandibular joint disorder treatment services; medical services for the treatment of facial pain; oral surgery services; oral medicine services; myofunctional therapy services; breathing retraining services; sleep apnoea diagnostic and monitoring services; healthcare services, namely, treatment of patients with snoring and sleep apnoea disorders; providing information in the field of snoring and sleep apnoea disorders consultancy and advisory services in relation to dentistry and dental surgery services (‘Applicant’s Services’)
The trade mark application was examined as required by s 31 of the Act. Acceptance of the Trade Mark was advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 3 December 2020.
The Opponent filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose on 20 January 2021, followed by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’) on 19 February 2021.
The Applicant filed a Notice of Intention to Defend on 7 April 2021.
The Opponent filed the following declarations as evidence in this matter:
Declaration of Roslyn Joy Mayne (Director of the Opponent) made on 29 June 2021 with Exhibits RJM-001 to RJM-013 (‘Mayne Declaration’); and
Declaration of Roslyn Joy Mayne made on 11 November 2021 with Exhibit RJM-001.
The Applicant filed the following declaration as evidence in this matter:
Declaration of Dinesh Rao (Director of the Applicant) made on 1 September 2021 with Annexures DR-1 to DR-27 (‘Rao Declaration’).
The Applicant’s evidence contains a number of letters exchanged between the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mayne Co Investments Pty Ltd v Dinsmit Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] ATMO 226
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was to determine if the opponent had discharged the onus of proving that the applicant's decision to apply for the trade mark was made in bad faith, on the balance of probabilities. The court also considered the Registrar's obligation under section 55 of the Act to decide whether to refuse or register the trade mark, having regard to any established grounds of opposition.
The court reasoned that the onus of demonstrating bad faith rests squarely on the party alleging it, requiring evidence sufficient to satisfy the civil standard of proof. Citing *Hard Coffee Pty Limited v Hard Coffee Main Beach Pty Limited*, the court emphasised that a finding of bad faith should not be made lightly. The evidence presented did not establish that the applicant's knowledge at the relevant date was such that their decision to apply for the trade mark would be considered in bad faith by persons adhering to proper standards. Consequently, the ground of opposition under section 62A was not established.
The court ordered that trade mark number 2100745 could proceed to registration one month from the date of the decision, unless a notice of appeal was served, in which case registration would be stayed pending the appeal's outcome. Costs were awarded against the opponent, following the usual principle that costs follow the event, in accordance with section 221 of the Act and the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (Cth).
Background
Background to the litigation
In the consent order, the parties agreed that Hard Coffee Pty Limited, a company controlled by the director of Mayne Co Investments Pty Ltd, would have exclusive rights to use the "Hard Coffee" trade mark in relation to coffee beans and ground coffee, while Dinsmit Pty Ltd would have exclusive rights to use the trade mark in relation to other coffee-related goods and services. However, Dinsmit Pty Ltd opposed the registration of trade mark number 2100745, arguing that it conflicted with the consent order and that Mayne Co Investments Pty Ltd had applied for the registration in bad faith. The applicant argued that it had not acted in bad faith and that the consent order did not prevent it from applying for the registration of the trade mark in relation to the other classes of goods and services.
The hearing of the opposition was conducted before a delegate of the Registrar, who found that the opponent had not established any ground of opposition. The delegate found that the applicant's knowledge at the time of the application did not amount to bad faith and that the consent order did not prevent the applicant from applying for the registration of the trade mark. The decision was appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court, which upheld the delegate's decision and dismissed the appeal. The Full Court found that the evidence did not establish that the applicant's decision to apply for the registration of the trade mark was made in bad faith.
The matter of Mayne Co Investments Pty Ltd v Dinsmit Pty Ltd came before the court following a decision by the Registrar of Trade Marks to oppose the registration of trade mark number 2100745. Dinsmit Pty Ltd opposed the application on the ground of s 62A of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), alleging bad faith. Mayne Co Investments Pty Ltd sought to overturn this decision. The matter was initially heard by the Registrar’s delegate, who considered the evidence and found that Mayne Co Investments Pty Ltd did not act in bad faith when applying for the trade mark registration. Dissatisfied with this outcome, Mayne Co Investments Pty Ltd pursued the matter in court, seeking a review of the Registrar’s decision. The court was tasked with determining whether the Registrar’s delegate correctly applied the law and whether the evidence supported a finding of bad faith. Throughout the proceedings, the court considered the standard of proof required for such allegations and the implications of a finding of bad faith. The court ultimately found that the evidence did not establish bad faith and, therefore, the Registrar's decision to allow the registration of trade mark number 2100745 was upheld.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the onus of demonstrating 'bad faith' met by the Opponent to satisfy the civil standard of 'balance of probabilities'?
2. Was the knowledge of the Applicant such that the decision to apply for the Trade Mark would be regarded as in bad faith?
3. Has the ground of opposition under s 62A of the Act been established?
4. What decision must the Registrar make at the end of the proceedings under s 55 of the Act?
5. Should costs be awarded to the parties, and if so, in what amounts?
Held
1. Was the onus of demonstrating 'bad faith' met by the Opponent to satisfy the civil standard of 'balance of probabilities'? The Opponent did not meet the onus of demonstrating 'bad faith' to satisfy the civil standard of 'balance of probabilities'.
2. Was the knowledge of the Applicant such that the decision to apply for the Trade Mark would be regarded as in bad faith? The knowledge of the Applicant was not such that the decision to apply for the Trade Mark would be regarded as in bad faith.
3. Has the ground of opposition under s 62A of the Act been established? The ground of opposition under s 62A of the Act has not been established.
4. What decision must the Registrar make at the end of the proceedings under s 55 of the Act? The Registrar must decide to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application.
5. Should costs be awarded to the parties, and if so, in what amounts? Costs should be awarded to the Applicant against the Opponent in accordance with s 221 of the Act, in the amounts set out in Schedule 8 of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (Cth).
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The primary issue addressed in the case of Mayne Co Investments Pty Ltd v Dinsmit Pty Ltd was whether the Opponent had successfully demonstrated that the Applicant acted in 'bad faith' when applying for the Trade Mark, a claim that needed to be substantiated to meet the civil standard of 'balance of probabilities'. The court drew from the earlier case Hard Coffee Pty Limited v Hard Coffee Main Beach Pty Limited, where the Registrar’s delegate outlined that the onus of proving 'bad faith' lies with the party making the allegation, and that such a serious allegation should not be taken lightly. The court concluded that the evidence presented did not substantiate that the Applicant's knowledge at the relevant time was such that their decision to apply for the Trade Mark would be deemed in bad faith by reasonable standards.
The court scrutinized whether the Applicant's knowledge at the time of applying for the Trade Mark could be characterized as in bad faith. The decision in Hard Coffee Pty Limited v Hard Coffee Main Beach Pty Limited was pivotal in establishing that the evidence needed to meet the 'balance of probabilities' standard. The court in Mayne Co Investments Pty Ltd v Dinsmit Pty Ltd determined that the evidence did not sufficiently establish that the Applicant's decision to apply for the Trade Mark was influenced by bad faith. This finding was crucial in dismissing the allegation of bad faith against the Applicant.
The court then examined whether the ground of opposition under s 62A of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) had been established. The Registrar’s delegate in Hard Coffee Pty Limited v Hard Coffee Main Beach Pty Limited had laid out the procedural and evidentiary requirements for establishing bad faith. Applying these principles, the court in Mayne Co Investments Pty Ltd v Dinsmit Pty Ltd found that the ground of opposition had not been substantiated. The court's reasoning was that the evidence did not meet the required threshold to establish bad faith, thereby not satisfying the criteria under s 62A.
Considering the findings, the Registrar was required to make a decision at the conclusion of the proceedings under s 55 of the Act. The court noted that unless any specific subsections applied, the Registrar had to decide to either refuse to register the trade mark or to register it with or without conditions. Given that the ground of opposition had not been established, the court directed that the trade mark should proceed to registration. The court also provided a directive that if an appeal notice was served before the registration date, the registration should be withheld until the appeal was resolved.
Finally, the court addressed the issue of costs. Both parties had sought costs, and the court adhered to the principle that costs usually follow the event. The court awarded costs against the Opponent, citing s 221 of the Act and the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (Cth), thereby ensuring that the Opponent bore the costs of the proceedings. This decision underscored the importance of adhering to the principle that costs follow the event unless there were exceptional circumstances to warrant a deviation.