Alcon Inc v Bausch & Lomb (Australia) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Alcon Inc v Bausch & Lomb (Australia) Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 1299

TRADE MARKS – whether use by the respondent of the letters “BSS” on the label of one of the containers in which it supplied its AQSIA™ brand balanced salt solution was trade mark use and thus infringed the applicant’s registered trade mark for “BSS” in Class 5 for ophthalmic irrigating solution – whether the respondent established that it used the letters “BSS” in that way in good faith in order to indicate the kind, quality, intended purpose or some other characteristic of its AQSIA™ brand balanced salt solution and should therefore be held not to have infringed the applicant’s “BSS” trade mark by reason of s 122(1)(b)(i) of the Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth) – whether the letters “BSS” as at March 1988 or at any time thereafter were used as a descriptive acronym for “balanced salt solution” in the relevant trade in Australia for sterile ophthalmic irrigating solutions – whether the respondent established that, as at the date of its Cross-Claim, the letters “BSS” were not distinctive of the applicant’s “BSS” balanced salt solution product – whether the respondent established the pleaded grounds for cancelling the applicant’s “BSS” trade mark – respondent held to have infringed the applicant’s “BSS” trade mark – respondent not entitled to an order cancelling the registration of that trade mark

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s 55(1)
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), ss 6, 7, 17, 24, 41, 57, 87, 88, 89, 120, 122 and 234
Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth)
Trade Mark Regulations 1995, cl 8.2 

Air Express International (Australia) Pty Ltd v Australian European Insurance (Brokers) Pty Ltd (1999) 49 IPR 435 cited
Anheuser-Busch Inc v Budejovický Budvar (2002) 56 IPR 182 followed
Burger King Corporation v Registrar of Trade Marks (1973) 128 CLR 417 followed
Chancellor, Masters and Scholars of the University of Oxford (t/as Oxford University Press) v Registrar of Trade Marks (1990) 24 FCR 1 cited
Clark Equipment Company v Registrar of Trade Marks (1964) 111 CLR 511 followed
Colorado Group Ltd v Strandbags Group Pty Ltd (2007) 164 FCR 506 followed
Crooks Michell Peacock Stewart Pty Ltd v Kaiser (t/as Commercial Art & Industrial Design) (1994) 29 IPR 225 cited
HCA Colours Australia Pty Ltd v Holland Colours NV (2003) 59 IPR 507 cited
Johnson & Johnson Australia Pty Ltd v Sterling Pharmaceuticals Pty Ltd (1991) 30 FCR 326 applied
Kenman Kandy Australia Pty Ltd v Registrar of Trade Marks (2002) 122 FCR 494 followed
Registrar of Trade Marks v W & G Du Cros Ltd [1913] AC 624 cited
TGI Friday’s Australia Pty Ltd v TGI Friday’s Inc (2000) 100 FCR 358 applied

ALCON INC v BAUSCH & LOMB (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD (ACN 000 650 251)

NSD 1843 of 2006

FOSTER J
12 NOVEMBER 2009
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1843 of 2006

BETWEEN:

ALCON INC
Applicant/Cross-Respondent

AND:

BAUSCH & LOMB…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alcon Inc v Bausch & Lomb (Australia) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1299
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Alcon Inc initiated legal proceedings against Bausch & Lomb (Australia) Pty Ltd in the Federal Court of Australia, asserting that Bausch & Lomb had infringed on Alcon's trademark for "BSS" used for a balanced salt solution. The dispute centred on whether Bausch & Lomb's use of "BSS" constituted trademark infringement and whether the trademark was inherently distinctive or had become descriptive over time. The respondent argued that the trademark was not inherently distinctive and had become generic, thus losing its distinctiveness and exclusive rights.

The court had to determine the admissibility of certain evidence tendered by the respondent, including journal articles, dictionaries, and textbook excerpts, to establish the use of "BSS" in Australia. Alcon contended that this evidence was irrelevant as trade marks are territorial and foreign use should not influence the distinctiveness within Australia. The respondent argued that the evidence was relevant to show the general acceptance of "BSS" as a descriptive term for balanced salt solution.

The court ruled that the overseas materials were not admissible to establish the use in the Australian market, as the evidence was vague and did not directly relate to Australia. The court held that only local use could be considered in determining the distinctiveness of the trademark within Australia. Consequently, the court rejected the overseas publications as evidence for establishing the lack of distinctiveness of Alcon's trademark.

The court declared that Bausch & Lomb's use of "BSS" constituted trademark infringement and permanently restrained Bausch & Lomb from using the mark or any substantially similar sign without Alcon's license. The cross-claim by Bausch & Lomb was dismissed, and Bausch & Lomb was ordered to pay Alcon's costs of the proceedings. The case was stood over for further directions.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. DECLARES that, by using the letters “BSS” on the label affixed to the 19 ml plastic bottle of its AQSIA™ brand balanced salt solution, the respondent infringed Australian Registered Trade Mark No 483823 (the applicant’s registered trade mark).

2. ORDERS that the respondent by itself, its officers, servants and agents, be permanently restrained from using in the course of trade without the licence of the applicant the mark “BSS” or any sign substantially identical or deceptively similar to the applicant’s registered trade mark in relation to ophthalmic irrigating solution.

3. ORDERS that the Cross-Claim be dismissed.

4. ORDERS that the respondent pay the applicant’s costs to date of and incidental to the proceedings (including the Cross-Claim).

5. STANDS over the proceedings for further directions to 9.30 am on 25 November 2009 before Foster J.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Excerpts from two textbooks were also tendered as Exhibits SS-12 and SS-13. In each of those textbooks, there is one reference to “balanced salt solution (BSS)”. In one case, there are three subsequent references to “BSS”. Other Evidence The respondent also tendered evidence of a general nature which provides some indication in a global sense of the number of occasions in the period 2002–2007 on which various online versions of the published material were searched by someone as well as evidence that many of the publications were held in various libraries throughout Australia. In addition, the respondent established that the journal called Clinical and Experimental Ophthalmology was published nine times a year and was distributed regularly to its members.Submissions (Admissibility) The respondent submitted that the journal articles, dictionaries and textbook excerpts were all admissible. The applicant maintained its objection to the tender of all of these publications with the exception of the journal article published in Australia in the February 1984 edition of the Australian Journal of Ophthalmology (Exhibit SS-4 to Ms Stubbs’ first affidavit) (as to which see [49]–[50] above) and some of the journal articles comprised in Exhibit SS-5 to Ms Stubbs’ first affidavit. The applicant objected to the tender of this material on the sole ground that none of it was relevant because even if all of this material were to be accepted, none of it could rationally affect (directly or indirectly) the assessment of the probability of the existence of a fact in issue in the proceedings (s 55(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)). The respondent submitted that the material in respect of which the applicant maintained its objection was probative of the fact that, throughout the period from at least March 1988 to December 2006, persons in the relevant trade in Australia used the letters “BSS” as a descriptive acronym of a substance viz “balanced salt solution”. It was said that, if that fact could be established, the respondent would then probably be able to persuade the Court that:(a)As at 6 December 2006, the letters “BSS” did not distinguish the balanced salt solution supplied by the applicant under the name “BSS” from sterile ophthalmic irrigating solutions supplied by others;(b)As at 22 March 1988, the letters “BSS” were not capable of distinguishing the balanced salt solution supplied by the applicant under the name “BSS” from sterile ophthalmic irrigating solutions supplied by others; and(c)By 6 December 2006, the letters “BSS” had become generally accepted within the relevant trade in Australia as being generic or merely descriptive of a substance, namely, “balanced salt solution”. If these matters were established, the respondent would very likely be entitled to an order that the applicant’s BSS trade mark be cancelled. Some of these matters would also be relevant to the respondent’s defence to the applicant’s infringement case (in particular, the defence under s 122(1)(b)(i)).

Decision

Reasons for decision

FOSTER J
The applicant submitted that all of the journal articles originally published overseas, the overseas dictionaries and the excerpts from the two textbooks originally published overseas should all be rejected as not being relevant to distinctiveness as at 6 December 2006 because none of those publications could conceivably be relevant to the Court’s determination of that question. The applicant also submitted that, given that a trade mark is a purely territorial concept which is legally operative and effective only within the territory within which it is used and for which it is registered or for which it is to be registered, it was of no moment that, in various publications originally published overseas, there was demonstrated a use of the letters “BSS” which could arguably support the respondent’s contention that the letters had become descriptive of “balanced salt solution”. In support of its objection, the applicant relied upon the following passage in the judgment of Gibbs J (as he then was) in Burger King Corporation v Registrar of Trade Marks (1973) 128 CLR 417 at 422–423:On the other hand, the evidence that the word has been extensively used in the United States of America and has there become widely known as indicating the goods of the applicant only, is in my opinion in a different situation. On this point counsel for the Registrar referred me to certain authorities whose effect is summed up in the following passage from the judgment of Tomlin J. (as he then was) in Impex Electrical Ltd. v. Weinbaum [(1927) 44 R.P.C. 405, at p. 410], which has been accepted, by this Court as well as in the United Kingdom, as a correct statement of the law (see Re Notox Ltd.’s Application [(1930) 48 R.P.C. 168, at p. 178]; Re Gaines Animal Foods Ltd’s Application [(1951) 68 R.P.C. 178, at p. 179]; de Cordova v. Vick Chemical Co. [(1951) 68 R.P.C. 103, at p. 107]; and The Seven Up Co. v. O.T. Ltd. [(1947) 75 C.L.R. 203, at pp. 215, 216]): “For the purpose of seeing whether the mark is distinctive, it is to the market of this country alone that one has to have regard. For that purpose foreign markets are wholly irrelevant, unless it be shown by evidence that in fact goods have been sold in this country with a foreign mark on them, and that the mark so used has thereby become identified with the manufacturer of the goods.”Those cases are authority for the proposition that in deciding whether a mark is distinctive, user within the jurisdiction only is to be taken into account. However, in the present case the question is a different one, namely, whether evidence of user overseas is admissible on the issue whether a trade mark is capable of becoming distinctive.Decision on Admissibility I think that these submissions made on behalf of the applicant in support of its objection to all of the overseas material sought to be tendered by the respondent are correct. In my view, it is a long bow for the Court to draw to find that use in the relevant trade in Australia can be established by the availability here of journals, dictionaries and textbooks published overseas which, to some extent, may have been read or looked at by persons participating in that trade. The evidence as to who read this material and when is vague and general. Further, the dictionaries and textbooks can only prove use in the places to which they relate. There was no evidence to suggest that these latter sources related to Australia. For these reasons, I will not admit these overseas materials into evidence for the purpose of establishing that the letters “BSS” did not, as at 6 December 2006, distinguish the applicant’s BSS balanced salt solution from sterile ophthalmic irrigating solutions supplied by others within s 234(2) of the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FOSTER J

The respondent argued that:(a)The applicant’s BSS trade mark was not to any extent whatsoever inherently adapted to distinguish the applicant’s BSS balanced salt solution from balanced salt solutions and sterile irrigating solutions supplied by others; and (b)The applicant would have been unable to establish distinctiveness in fact as at 22 March 1988 had it been required to do so with the consequence that the applicant’s BSS trade mark is taken not to be capable of distinguishing its BSS balanced salt solution from the balanced salt solutions and sterile irrigating solutions supplied by others (s 41(5) and s 41(6), esp s 41(6)(b)). Ground 2 (Loss of Exclusive Right to Use a Trade Mark Which Has Become Descriptive After Registration) This ground is advanced as an alternative to Ground 1. The respondent relies upon s 24 and s 87 of the Act. Those sections are in the following terms:24Trade mark consisting of sign that becomes accepted as sign describing article etc.(1)This section applies if a registered trade mark consists of, or contains, a sign that, after the date of registration of the trade mark, becomes generally accepted within the relevant trade as the sign that describes or is the name of an article, substance or service.Note: For registered trade mark, sign and date of registration see section 6.(2)If the trade mark consists of the sign, the registered owner:(a)does not have any exclusive rights to use, or authorise other persons to use, the trade mark in relation to:(i)the article or substance or other goods of the same description; or(ii)the service or other services of the same description; and(b)is taken to have ceased to have those exclusive rights from and including the day determined by the court under subsection (4).Note: For registered owner see section 6.(3)If the trade mark contains the sign, the registered owner:(a)does not have any exclusive rights to use, or authorise other persons to use, the sign in relation to:(i)the article or substance or other goods of the same description; or(ii)the service or other services of the same description; and(b) is taken to have ceased to have those exclusive rights from the day determined by the court under subsection (4).Note: For registered owner see section 6.(4)For the purposes of subsections (2) and (3), a prescribed court may determine the day on which a sign first became generally accepted within the relevant trade as the sign that describes or is the name of the article, substance or service.Note:For prescribed court see section 190.…87 Amendment or cancellation—loss of exclusive rights to use trade mark(1)If section 24 or 25 applies in relation to a registered trade mark, a prescribed court may, on the application of an aggrieved person or the Registrar, but subject to subsection (2) and section 89, order that the Register be rectified by:(a)cancelling the registration of the trade mark; or(b)removing or amending any entry in the Register relating to the trade mark;having regard to the effect of section 24 or 25 (as the case may be) on the right of the registered owner of the trade mark to use the trade mark, or any sign that is part of the trade mark, in relation to particular goods or services.(2)If section 24 or 25 applies in relation to the trade mark because the trade mark contains a sign that:(a)has become generally accepted within the relevant trade as the sign that describes or is the name of an article, substance or service; or(b)describes or is the name of:(i)an article or substance that was formerly exploited under a patent; or(ii)a service that was formerly provided as a patented process;the court may decide not to make an order under subsection (1) and allow the trade mark to remain on the Register in respect of:(c)the article or substance or goods of the same description; or(d)the service or services of the same description;subject to any condition or limitation that the court may impose.Note 1:Sections 24 and 25 provide that the registered owner of a trade mark does not have exclusive rights to use, or to authorise the use of, the trade mark if it consists of, or contains, a sign that: (a)becomes generally accepted within the relevant trade as the sign that describes or is the name of an article, substance or service; or (b)is the only commonly known way to describe or identify an article formerly exploited under a patent, or a service formerly provided as a patented process, where the patent has expired more than 2 years ago.Note 2:For registered trade mark, registered owner and Register see section 6.Note 3:For prescribed court see section 190.