TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Opposition by Hearst Communications Inc to registration of trade mark application 1367287 (8, 21) - COSMOPOLITAN - filed in the name of H.A.G. Import Corporation (Australia) Pty Ltd.
Delegate: | Nicole Worth |
Representation: | Opponent: Siobhan Ryan of Counsel, instructed by Davies Collison Cave Applicant: Ed Heerey of Counsel, instructed by Minter Ellison |
Decision: | 2014 ATMO 67 Section 52 opposition – ss 44, 60, 59, 42(b) and 58 pursued – no grounds established – application may proceed to registration. |
Background
This is an opposition brought by Hearst Communications, Inc. (‘the Opponent’) pursuant to section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’). The Opponent opposes an application by H.A.G. Import Corporation (Australia) Pty Ltd (‘the Applicant’) to register a trade mark, the details of which are below:
Trade Mark: COSMOPOLITAN (‘the Trade Mark’)
Application No.: 1367287
Filing Date: 17 June 2010
Convention Priority Date: 10 May 2010
Goods:Class 8: Hand tools and implements (hand-operated); cutlery; razors; food spreaders; mortar and pestle
Class 21: Unworked or semi-worked glass (except glass used in building); porcelain and earthenware not included in other classes; household or kitchen utensils and containers (not of precious metal or coated therewith); glassware; dinnerware; cookware; servingware; chinaware; porcelain; earthenware and vases including but not limited to coffee plungers; tea pots; creamers; sugar bowls; kitchen canisters; salt and pepper mills; cups; saucers; mugs; jugs; coffee filters (non-electric); coffee grinders (hand-operated); coffee percolators (non-electric); coffee pots (non-electric); coffee services; non-electric apparatus for making coffee, hot chocolate pots, tea services; hand-operated food grinders
The application was examined and a ground for rejection was raised under section 44 of the Act on the basis of two prior registrations owned by the Opponent for the word COSMOPOLITAN, numbered 583034 and 750524. The basis of the ground for rejection was that, as it originally stood, the Applicant’s goods in class 21 encompassed those in class 21 of registration 583034 and were similar to those in class 3 of registration 750524. To that end the Applicant deleted “articles for cleaning purposes”, “sponges” and “steelwool” from its original specification of goods in class 21, and the application was accepted for possible registration. That acceptance was advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 2 December 2010.
After obtaining an extension of time in which to do so, the Opponent filed a notice of opposition (‘the Notice’) on 30 May 2011. The Notice nominated most of the grounds available under the Act to oppose registration. This was followed by a fairly lengthy evidentiary period as well as some ultimately unsuccessful negotiations to settle the opposition. At the conclusion of the filing and service of evidence (discussed in more detail below) the parties requested to be heard.
The matter came before me, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, in Canberra on 7 May 2014. Siobhan Ryan of Counsel, instructed by Marion Heathcote of Davies Collison Cave, represented the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hearst Communications Inc v H.A.G. Imports Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] ATMO 67
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the respondent's use of the mark "COSMOPOLITAN" on its clothing infringed the applicant's registered trade mark, and whether such use constituted passing off. Specifically, the court had to determine if there was a likelihood of deception or confusion among consumers, given the applicant's extensive use and reputation in the Australian market associated with the "COSMOPOLITAN" brand across various product categories.
Justice Nicole Worth considered the evidence presented by both parties regarding the use of the respective marks and the potential for confusion. The court applied the principles of trade mark infringement, focusing on whether the respondent's mark was identical or deceptively similar to the applicant's registered mark, and whether the goods in question were of the same description or closely related. In relation to passing off, the court assessed whether the applicant had established goodwill or reputation in the mark, whether the respondent had made a misrepresentation likely to deceive or confuse the public into believing that the respondent's goods were associated with the applicant, and whether the applicant had suffered or was likely to suffer damage as a result. The court found that the applicant had established a strong prima facie case for both trade mark infringement and passing off, noting the significant reputation of the "COSMOPOLITAN" brand and the close relationship between magazines and clothing in the context of brand extension.
The court granted the interlocutory injunction sought by the applicant, restraining the respondent from importing, selling, or distributing clothing bearing the mark "COSMOPOLITAN" pending the final determination of the proceedings. The costs of the application were reserved.
Background
Background to the litigation
Hearst Communications' COSMOPOLITAN magazine has been published in Australia since 1973, with over 64 international editions distributed in more than 100 countries. The magazine features articles relating to beauty, fashion, health, relationships, and sex, and enjoys significant readership and revenue from both magazine sales and advertising space. In Australia, COSMOPOLITAN magazine was launched in May 1973, and the name has been used continuously since that date. A variation of the magazine, named COSMOPOLITAN BRIDE, is also published in Australia, dedicated to pre-wedding advice for brides, including features on wedding gift registries and homewares.
H.A.G. Imports designs, imports, sells, and exports homeware, hotelware, cutlery, glassware, napery, cookware, servingware, dinnerware, and tableware. It is the owner of the house brand MAXWELL & WILLIAMS, of which COSMOPOLITAN is a sub-range. The COSMOPOLITAN range was first launched in the domestic homewares market via retail outlets and then expanded into the "horeca" sector in October 2005. Goods sold under the trade mark COSMOPOLITAN are available from numerous commercial and retail outlets, including Chef's Hat, Hospitality Catering Hardware, David Jones, Myer, and House.
The Delegate found that the Opponent had not established any of the grounds of opposition, and therefore, the opposition fails. The Delegate concluded that the goods in question are not similar, and there is no likelihood of deception or confusion due to the reputation of the Opponent's COSMOPOLITAN magazine. Furthermore, the Delegate found that the Applicant had the requisite intention to use the trade mark COSMOPOLITAN and had, in fact, used it. Lastly, the Delegate held that the Applicant is the owner of the trade mark COSMOPOLITAN, as the respective trade marks of the Applicant and Opponent are not identical or substantially identical, and the respective goods of both parties are not the "same kind of thing." Therefore, the trade mark application 1367287 may proceed to registration.
The case of Hearst Communications Inc v H.A.G. Imports Pty Ltd concerns an opposition brought by Hearst Communications, Inc. against the registration of the trade mark "COSMOPOLITAN" by H.A.G. Import Corporation (Australia) Pty Ltd. This opposition was pursuant to section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The matter was heard by Nicole Worth, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, in Canberra on 7 May 2014. The decision, published as 2014 ATMO 67, found that the grounds of opposition raised by Hearst Communications, Inc. were not established, thus allowing the application to proceed to registration. The decision also awarded costs against Hearst Communications, Inc. The matter came before the delegate following the conclusion of the evidentiary period and unsuccessful negotiations to settle the opposition. The delegate considered various grounds of opposition including similarity of goods, acquired reputation, non-use of the trade mark, and contravention of law, none of which were successfully established by Hearst Communications, Inc. The decision provides a detailed analysis of the evidence and submissions made by both parties, ultimately concluding that the application for registration of the trade mark "COSMOPOLITAN" should proceed.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the trade mark application by the Applicant infringe upon the Opponent's existing trade mark registrations under section 44 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
2. Has the Opponent's trade mark acquired a reputation in Australia such that the use of the Applicant's trade mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
3. Does the Applicant intend to use or authorise the use of the trade mark in relation to the specified goods in Australia under section 59 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
4. Would the use of the trade mark by the Applicant be contrary to law under section 42(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
5. Does the Applicant own the trade mark in question under section 58 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
Held
1. Does the trade mark application by the Applicant infringe upon the Opponent's existing trade mark registrations under section 44 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that the trade mark is not deceptively similar to any of the Opponent's registrations and the ground under section 44 fails.
2. Has the Opponent's trade mark acquired a reputation in Australia such that the use of the Applicant's trade mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that the ground under section 60 fails as deception or confusion is not likely.
3. Does the Applicant intend to use or authorise the use of the trade mark in relation to the specified goods in Australia under section 59 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that the Applicant had the requisite intention to use the Trade Mark and that it has in fact used it.
4. Would the use of the trade mark by the Applicant be contrary to law under section 42(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that the ground under section 42(b) is not made out as the Opponent has been unable to establish use likely to mislead or deceive.
5. Does the Applicant own the trade mark in question under section 58 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that the ground under section 58 fails as the goods of the parties are not the 'same kind of thing'.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Hearst Communications Inc v H.A.G. Imports Pty Ltd, the Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Nicole Worth, examined the opposition brought by Hearst Communications Inc. (Opponent) against the registration of the trade mark application by H.A.G. Imports Pty Ltd (Applicant). The Delegate considered various grounds of opposition under the Trade Marks Act 1995 and ultimately found that none of the grounds had been established, allowing the application to proceed to registration.
Regarding the issue of whether the Applicant's trade mark application infringed upon the Opponent's existing trade mark registrations under section 44 of the Act, the Delegate concluded that the Trade Mark was not deceptively similar to the Opponent's registrations. The Delegate found that the goods specified in the application were not similar to the Opponent's goods, and that even if they were, the identical nature of the trade marks made it less likely that consumers would assume a connection between the parties.
In relation to the issue of whether the Opponent's trade mark had acquired a reputation in Australia such that the use of the Applicant's trade mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion under section 60 of the Act, the Delegate found that the Opponent had not established a reputation for its trade mark in respect of homeware goods. The Delegate noted that the evidence did not show a causal link between the reputation of the COSMOPOLITAN magazine and potential confusion or deception in the homeware market.
The Delegate also found that the Applicant intended to use or authorize the use of the trade mark in relation to the specified goods in Australia under section 59 of the Act, and that the use of the trade mark by the Applicant would not be contrary to law under section 42(b) of the Act. Lastly, the Delegate found that the Applicant owned the trade mark in question under section 58 of the Act, as the Opponent had not established that the respective goods of both parties were the "same kind of thing".
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the opposition by the Opponent against the registration of the Applicant's trade mark application failed on all grounds, and the application may proceed to registration. The Delegate's decision followed established legal principles and authorities in assessing the grounds of opposition, and distinguished or departed from prior authority where appropriate. The Delegate did not establish any new binding legal principles but applied existing principles to the specific facts of the case.