Mantra Group Pty Ltd v Tailly Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mantra Group Pty Ltd v Tailly Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCA 291

Citation: Mantra Group Pty Ltd v Tailly Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCA 291
Parties: MANTRA GROUP PTY LTD ACN 110 396 999, MANTRA IP PTY LTD ACN 129 980 981 and SUNLEISURE OPERATIONS PTY LTD ACN 113 285 153 v TAILLY PTY LTD ACN 105 940 181 and STEPHAN ANDREW GRANT
File number: QUD 224 of 2009
Judge: REEVES J
Date of judgment: 26 March 2010
Corrigendum 31 August 2010
Catchwords:

TRADE MARKS – s 120 Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – Did the respondents use the sign as a trademark? – Consideration of how the internet operates – Use by the respondents of words either substantially identical with or deceptively similar to registered trade mark in domain names and on websites – Whether use of the sign is use as a ‘badge of origin’ – The Court is required to objectively examine the purpose and nature of the use – Words of a trade mark may be used to describe goods or services but still serve as a badge of trade origin

TRADE MARKS – s 122 Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – Did the respondents use the sign in good faith to indicate the geographical origin of the accommodation services it was offering? – ‘Geographical’ is intended to describe a broad concept such as a country, town or region and to protect the common right of the public to use words forming part of the common heritage – A good faith use must involve an honest use – A use will not be in good faith if the respondent used the sign to take deliberate advantage of a secondary meaning – Consideration of whether particular prominence has been given to the sign

TRADE MARKS – s 87 and s 24 Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – Have the words comprising the Applicants’ trade mark become generally accepted within the relevant trade as the sign that describes or is the name of the apartment complex? – Consideration of what is meant by ‘relevant trade’ and ‘the name of an article’ – Trade Marks Act is Commonwealth legislation that applies nationally therefore ‘relevant trade’ unlikely to refer to trade carried on in a narrowly defined area – Trade Marks Act directed to trade in goods and services – ‘Building’ is too large and substantial and comprising too many pieces to be an ‘article’ for the purposes of the section

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Consideration s 37M Federal Court of Australia Act and the just, quick, inexpensive and efficient resolution of the proceedings – Fast track procedure – Endeavour to deliver judgment within six weeks of the trial

Legislation:

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 53, 53(aa), 53(d)

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) ss 6, 17, 24, 24(4), 87(1), 87(2), 89, 120, 120(1), 122(1), 122(1)(a), 122(1)(a)(i), 122(1)(b), 122(1)(b)(i), 126

Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth) ss 64(1)(a), 64(1)(b)
Trade Marks Act 1994 (UK)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mantra Group Pty Ltd v Tailly Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 291
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Mantra Group Pty Ltd v Tailly Pty Ltd (No 2) involves a dispute between two companies over the use of the trade mark "Circle on Cavill" in relation to accommodation services offered at the Circle on Cavill complex. The dispute was heard by the Federal Court of Australia, which was required to determine whether the respondents, Tailly, had infringed the trade mark rights held by the applicants, Mantra. The central legal issues that the Court had to decide related to the use of the sign as a trademark, the use of the sign in good faith to indicate the geographical origin of the accommodation services, and whether the words comprising the trade mark had become generally accepted within the relevant trade as the sign that describes or is the name of the apartment complex.

In determining whether the respondents used the sign as a trademark, the Court considered how the internet operates and the use by the respondents of words either substantially identical with or deceptively similar to the registered trade mark in domain names and on websites. The Court found that the use of the sign by the respondents amounted to their use as an emblem or a badge of origin for the accommodation services they were offering at the Circle on Cavill complex, which constituted an infringement of the applicants' trade mark rights.

Regarding the use of the sign in good faith to indicate the geographical origin of the accommodation services, the Court considered whether the respondents had used the sign to indicate the geographical origin of the services they were offering at the Circle on Cavill complex and whether they had used the sign in good faith. The Court concluded that the respondents had not used the sign in good faith as they had used it to take deliberate advantage of a secondary meaning and had given particular prominence to the sign.

Finally, the Court considered whether the words comprising the applicants' trade mark had become generally accepted within the relevant trade as the sign that describes or is the name of the apartment complex. The Court found that the trade marks had not become generally accepted within the relevant trade as the sign that describes or is the name of the apartment complex.

Based on these findings, the Court made several orders, including the transfer of registration of the Circle on Cavill domain names to the applicants, a permanent restraint on the respondents from using the Circle on Cavill marks or other similar marks in relation to the advertising, promotion, or supply of accommodation, and a permanent restraint on the respondents from assisting other persons in doing the same. The Court also ordered an account of profits for bookings sourced via the Circle websites or other websites or directly related to the infringing use of the Circle on Cavill marks.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The respondents transfer registration of the Circle on Cavill domain names, and any other domain name which is substantially identical with or deceptively similar to the Circle on Cavill marks, to the second applicant, within seven days of the date of this order.

2. The respondents are permanently restrained:

(a) from using CIRCLE ON CAVILL, or a term that is substantially identical with or deceptively similar to CIRCLE ON CAVILL, as a trade mark in the advertising, promotion or supply of accommodation, including as part of a domain name, metatag, search engine keyword or business name;

(b) from using the trade marks depicted in Registration Nos. 944267 and 1079454, or a mark that is substantially identical with or deceptively similar thereto, as a trade mark in the advertising, promotion or supply of accommodation; and

(c) from using the term MANTRA or a term that is substantially identical with or deceptively similar thereto, as a trade mark in the advertising, promotion or supply of accommodation, including as part of a domain name, metatag, search engine keyword or business name.

3. The respondents are permanently restrained from assisting another person from doing what is restrained in paragraph 2 above.

4. An account of profits for bookings sourced via the Circle websites or other websites or directly related to infringing use of the Circle on Cavill marks, in relation to accommodation provided in resorts managed by the applicants.

5. In these orders the following expressions have the meanings stated:

(a) “Circle on Cavill domain names” means the following domain names:

· circleoncavile.com.au

· circleoncavillapartments.com.au

· circleoncavillretail.com.au

· ecircleoncavil.com

· ecircleoncavill.com

· ecircleoncavill.com.au

· circleoncavill.mobi

· cavillapartments.com

· circleapartments.com.au

· circleoncaville.com.au.

(b) The “Circle on Cavill marks” means:

· the three registered trade marks held by the second applicant – one word mark Registration Number 944268 and two word and devices marks Registration Numbers 944267 and 1079454 – incorporating the words “Circle on Cavill”.

(c) The “Circle websites” means the websites linked to the Circle on Cavill domain names as shown in Schedules 1 to 10 attached:

· circleoncavile.com.au – Schedule 1

· circleoncavillapartments.com.au – Schedule 2

· circleoncavillretail.com.au – Schedule 3

· ecircleoncavil.com – redirects to a1goldcoastholiday.com – Schedule 4

· ecircleoncavill.com – Schedule 5

· ecircleoncavill.com.au – Schedule 6

· circleoncavill.mobi – Schedule 7

· cavillapartments.com – Schedule 8

· circleapartments.com.au – Schedule 9

· a1goldcoastholiday.com.au – which redirects to circleoncavillapartments.com.au – Schedule 10.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Williams J added:Needless to say, if the defendant uses the words of the plaintiff’s trade mark as indicating origin it is still an infringement notwithstanding that the defendant always adds his own name.Conclusion Taking into account all these matters, I consider a member of the public looking at Tailly’s various domain names and the contents of the various websites to which they are linked, would conclude that this combined use of the words “Circle on Cavill” as described above amounted to their use as an emblem or a badge of origin for the accommodation services Tailly was offering at the Circle on Cavill complex. It follows that I have concluded that Tailly has made all these uses of the words “Circle on Cavill” as a trade mark, contrary to s 120(1) of the Trade Marks Act. I should add two riders to this conclusion. First, it does not apply to those quite separate parts of the various websites where Tailly has only used those words descriptively: see, for example, [57] above. Secondly, it does not apply to the domain name a1goldcoastholidays.com.au which obviously does not contain those words, or any variation of them.2. did tailly use the words “Circle on Cavill” in good faith to indicate the geographical origin of the accommodation services it was offering at the Circle on Cavill complex?Relevant legislative provision Section 122(1) of the Trade Marks Act provides a defence to Tailly if its use of a Mantra trade mark occurred in various defined circumstances. Tailly has sought to rely upon the circumstances described in s 122(1)(b)(i). That sub-section provides:In spite of s 120, a person does not infringe a registered trade mark when:(b)the person uses a sign in good faith to indicate:(i)the kind, quality, quantity, intended purpose, value, geographical origin, or some other characteristic, of goods or services; …The issues that arise In this case, this provision raises two sub-issues as follows: (a)Did Tailly use the sign to indicate the geographical origin of the accommodation letting services it was offering at the Circle on Cavill complex?(b)Did Tailly use the sign in good faith?Tailly bears the onus of establishing both of these matters.“Geographical origin … of … services” The first sub-issue requires me to determine the meaning of the words “geographical origin … of … services”. Before the passage of the Trade Marks Act in 1995 (“the 1995 Act”), s 64(1)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth) (“the 1955 Act”) provided a similar defence to that offered by s 122(1)(b). It applied to: “The use in good faith by a person of a description of the character or quality of his goods or services”. The words “kind … quantity, intended purpose, value, geographical origin …” were added by the 1995 Act. Apart from identifying that the general purpose of the 1995 Act was to allow Australia to comply with its World Trade Organisation obligations, the Second Reading Speech for the 1995 Act does not shed any light on why these specific words were included in the new section. However, it seems likely that they may have been adopted from the equivalent section of the Trade Marks Act 1994 (UK) (“the UK Act”), which had been passed by the UK Parliament a year earlier. Section 11(2)(b) of the UK Act provided as follows:(2) A registered trade mark is not infringed by(b)the use of indications concerning the kind, quality, quantity, intended purpose, value, geographical origin, at time of production of goods or of rendering of services, or other characteristics of goods or services, or …

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.