Aldi Stores Ltd Partnership v Frito-Lay Trading Co Gmbh

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Aldi Stores Ltd Partnership v Frito-Lay Trading
Company GmbH [2001] FCA 1874

TRADE MARKS – infringement – registered mark “TWISTIES” in respect of snacks of extruded cheese-flavoured kind – alleged infringer uses “CHEEZY TWISTS” in respect of similar product – primary judge found infringement – whether use of “CHEEZY TWISTS” as a trade mark or as a descriptor – whether inquiry as to deceptive similarity limited by reference to the particular finding of trade mark use made – whether primary judge determined question of deceptive similarity as a matter of his own impression – application of presumption that person attempting to create deceptive similarity by choosing particular mark has succeeded, recognised by Dixon J and McTiernan J in Australian Woollen Mills Ltd v FS Walton & Co Ltd (1937) 58 CLR 641 – whether primary judge entitled to decide issue of deceptive similarity exclusively by applying that presumption – whether trial judge entitled to draw inference of attempt to create deceptive similarity – whether deceptive similarity existed – defence under s 122(1)(f) of Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – whether alleged infringer would have obtained registration of “CHEEZY TWISTS” – whether the “capable of distinguishing” test laid down in s 41 of the Act would have been satisfied

WORDS AND PHRASES – “capable of distinguishing” – “inherently adapted to distinguish”

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) ss 6 (“sign”), 41, 120

Top Heavy Pty Ltd v Killin (1996) 34 IPR 282 cited

James Watt Constructions Pty Ltd v Circle-E Pty Ltd [1970] 3 NSWR 481 referred to
Berzins Specialty Bakeries Pty Ltd v Monty’s Continental Bakery (Vic) Pty Ltd (1987) 15 FCR 402 referred to
JB Stone & Co Ltd v Steelace Manufacturing Co Ltd (1929) 46 RPC 406 (CA) referred to
Bass, Ratcliff & Gretton Ltd v Nicholson & Sons Ltd (1932) 49 RPC 88 (HL) referred to
Picot Ltd v Goya Ltd [1967] RPC 573 referred to
Kolotex GloAustralia Pty Ltd v Sara Lee Personal Products (Australia) Pty Ltd(t/a Hilton Hosiery) (1993) 26 IPR 1 referred to
The Shell Co of Australia Ltd v Esso Standard Oil (Australia) Ltd (1963) 109 CLR 407 referred to
Johnson & Johnson Australia Pty Ltd v Sterling Pharmaceuticals Pty Ltd (1991) 30 FCR 326 referred to
Unilever Aust Ltd v Karounos [2001] FCA 1132 referred to
British Sugar Plc v James Robertson & Sons Ltd [1996] RPC 281 distinguished
Wrigley’s (A’asia) Ltd v Lifesavers (A’asia) Ltd (1936) 37 SR (NSW) 9 referred to
Pepsico Australia Pty Ltd v Kettle Chip Co Pty Ltd (1996) 33 IPR 161 referred to
Sports Break Travel Pty Ltd v P & O Holidays Ltd (2000) 50 IPR 51 referred to
Australian Woollen Mills Ltd v FS Walton & Co Ltd (1937) 58 CLR 641 discussed
Wingate Marketing Pty Ltd v Levi Strauss & Co (1994) 49 FCR 89 referred to
Berlei Hestia Industrial Ltd v The Bali Co Inc (1973) 129 CLR 353 referred to
Marc A…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aldi Stores Ltd Partnership v Frito-Lay Trading Co Gmbh and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 1874
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Aldi Stores Ltd Partnership v Frito-Lay Trading Co GmbH, the central issue revolved around the use of the words "Cheezy Twists" on packaging by Aldi, which Frito-Lay claimed was an infringement of their trademark "Twisties". The dispute was brought before the court to determine whether the term "Cheezy Twists" constituted a trademark or merely a descriptive term, and whether there was sufficient similarity between "Cheezy Twists" and "Twisties" to cause confusion or deception among consumers. The primary judge found in favor of Frito-Lay, concluding that the term "Cheezy Twists" was indeed used as a trademark by Aldi and that there was a significant resemblance between "Cheezy Twists" and "Twisties" that was likely to deceive or confuse consumers.

The legal issues before the court encompassed the interpretation of the term "Cheezy Twists" as either a trademark or a descriptive term, the extent to which the use of "Cheezy Twists" infringed on Frito-Lay's trademark "Twisties", and the applicability of the primary judge's reliance on an admission by Aldi's buying director. Aldi argued that "Cheezy Twists" was a fair description of their product and not a trademark, while Frito-Lay contended that the term was deliberately chosen to mimic and capitalise on the reputation of "Twisties". The court was required to dissect the evidence and submissions from both parties to determine the veracity of these claims and their implications for trademark law.

The court, in its reasoning, determined that the term "Cheezy Twists" was used by Aldi as a trademark and that there was a substantial likelihood of confusion between "Cheezy Twists" and "Twisties". The court found that the description of the product as a "twist" was appropriate despite the manufacturing process, and the use of "Cheezy" was not a standard term but rather an invented word intended to capitalise on the reputation of "Twisties". The admission by Aldi's buying director that "Cheezy Twists" was used to distinguish their goods from those of other traders was deemed a relevant and persuasive factor. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, the orders made by the primary judge were set aside, and Aldi was ordered to pay Frito-Lay's costs of the proceeding and the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The orders made on 24 July 2001 in proceeding N 180 of 2001 be set aside and, in lieu of those orders, it be ordered that:

(a) the application be dismissed; and

(b) the applicant in that proceeding pay the costs of the respondent to that proceeding.

3. The respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

“Sign” is defined in s 6 of the Act to include “word”.The judgment appealed from It was the submission of Aldi before the learned primary judge that, while the word “Chazoos” was a trade mark appearing on the packet, the words “Cheezy Twists” were not used as a trade mark, but rather merely as a description of the product contained in the packet. It was argued that although extruded, the word “twists” was a fair description of the shape of the product, and compared with the use by Aldi of descriptive words for other cheese flavoured products of different shapes sold by it, eg “rings” and “balls”. Further, it was submitted, the product had a cheese taste and was thus properly described as “cheezy”, the substitution of “z” for “s” not being of significance. The process of manufacture was properly described, it was said, as a twisting process. For Frito-Lay, it was submitted that the word “twist” was not an apt description of the product, which was produced by extrusion, not twisting. It was said that the context in which the words appear on the packaging, and particularly the use on the front of the package of the words “cheese flavoured snacks” assisted the conclusion that the use of the words “Cheezy Twists” was use as a trade mark. “Cheezy” was, it was submitted, an invented word, not to be found in the dictionary. Significantly, it was said, Aldi had set out to reproduce, so far as was possible, the precise product marketed under the trade mark, one of the best known marks in the savoury snack food market. The packaging was devised with an eye to the Twisties packaging. One version of the packaging was, indeed, rejected because it was too close to Twisties packaging. In designing the product and its get-up, it was said Aldi had its eye set firmly upon the market leader, Twisties. So, it was argued, it should be found that Aldi adopted the name “Cheezy Twists” and the get-up of the Cheezy Twists packaging, in order to appropriate part of the trade reputation of Frito-Lay and that hence it should be presumed that the use of the name was likely to deceive or confuse consumers and thus to constitute an infringement of the trade mark. The fact that Aldi had used both “Chazoos” and “Cheezy Twists” on the packaging did not mean that it could not use both as trade marks, or that “Chazoos” was a mark and “Cheezy Twists” a description of the product. The learned primary judge found for Frito-Lay on both questions. In his Honour’s view, the words “Cheezy Twists” as they appeared on the packaging were used by Aldi as a trade mark and further there was a sufficient resemblance to the trade mark to make the use by Aldi of the words “Cheezy Twists” likely to deceive or cause confusion to the public. His Honour’s conclusion that Aldi had used the words “Cheezy Twists” as a trade mark was reached as follows: 1.While the method of manufacture of both products did not involve twisting, the Aldi product was aptly described as a twist and was so described in the trade.2.However, it was possible for there to be two trade marks used on packaging. In the present case the word and logo “Chazoos” was clearly a trade mark. The words “Cheezy Twists” were used separately and distinctly from the “Chazoos” word and logo mark, although complementary to it. In that context both the “Chazoos” mark and the words “Cheezy Twists” were used as trade marks.3.Mr Joyce, the buying director of Aldi, had made a direct admission (of a relevant fact), namely, that the use of the expression “Cheezy Twists” on the Aldi packaging was “employed by [Aldi] in seeking to distinguish its goods in the eyes of the consumer from the products of other traders”. This admission was said to be consistent with the evidence of a Ms O’Regan as to the process by which the name “Cheezy Twists” was chosen. His Honour’s use of the “admission” is the subject of challenge by Aldi.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established