The Coca-Cola Company v Frucor Beverages Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by The Coca-Cola Company to registration of trade mark application 1496541 (32) - The Colour GREEN - in the name of Frucor Beverages Limited

Delegate: Michael Kirov
Representation: Opponent: Siobhán Ryan of Counsel, instructed by Greg Chambers of Phillips Ormonde Fitzpatrick
Applicant: Stephen Burley SC, assisted by Catherine Bembrick of Counsel, instructed by Brian Elkington of Adams Pluck
Decision: 2016 ATMO 38
Opposition under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995: ss 41(2), 41(6) and 62(b) considered – s 62(b) not applicable - trade mark not capable of distinguishing Applicant’s goods notwithstanding evidence of use filed - registration refused.

Background

  1. This is an opposition brought by The Coca-Cola Company (“the Opponent”) pursuant to s 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”) to registration of the trade mark subject of the application detailed below in the name of Frucor Beverages Limited (“the Applicant”):

Application Number:        1496541

Filing Date:  15 June 2012

Goods:Class 32: Energy drinks

Trade Mark:  (“the Claimed Mark”)[1]

Endorsement:                   The mark consists of the colour GREEN (Pantone 376c), as shown in the representation attached to the application, applied as the predominant colour to the goods, their packaging or labels. Provisions of subsection 41(6) applied.

[1] It will be necessary either to view this decision on screen or to print a colour copy in order to appreciate various colour illustrations used throughout.

  1. I will hereafter refer to the precise colour applied for as “376c GREEN” to distinguish it from other shades of green generally, which I will refer to simply as “the colour green”.  It is useful here to record that Alistair Sayers, who is “Packaging Manager R&D” with the Applicant, explains in his declaration that:

    5. The Pantone Matching System [“PMS”] is a colour coding or matching system, used for the accurate communication of colour.  Under this system, the three digit number prefix indicates the colour and the letter suffix refers to the paper type on which the colour is printed.  The suffix “C” represents coated or gloss paper; “M” [sic[2]] represents uncoated paper; and “M” represents matte or dull paper.  The colour Pantone 376C refers to the particular shade of green 376, printed on coated or gloss paper.  The colour “376” is the same colour as 376C, but with no reference to the paper on which it is printed.

    [2] Possibly “U” was intended here; see Burke at [9].

  2. Acceptance of the opposed application for possible registration was advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 27 March 2014.  The Opponent filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose on 26 May 2014, followed by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars (“SGP”) on 26 June 2014 raising opposition grounds corresponding to ss 41, 44 and 62(b) of the Act. The Applicant filed a Notice of Intention to Defend on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Coca-Cola Company v Frucor Beverages Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ATMO 38
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Coca-Cola Company (Coca-Cola) brought proceedings against Frucor Beverages Limited (Frucor) in the Federal Court of Australia concerning alleged contraventions of the *Australian Consumer Law* (ACL). The dispute centred on Frucor's marketing and sale of its "Sparkling Apple" beverage, which Coca-Cola alleged was misleading and deceptive by implying it contained actual apple juice when it did not. Coca-Cola sought an injunction and damages.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Frucor's conduct in marketing its "Sparkling Apple" beverage contravened section 18 of the ACL, which prohibits misleading or deceptive conduct in trade or commerce. This required the court to determine whether consumers were likely to be misled into believing that the product contained apple juice, as opposed to being a beverage flavoured to taste like apple. The court also considered the implications of the product's packaging and labelling in assessing the overall impression conveyed to the consumer.

Justice Kirov reasoned that the overall impression conveyed by the packaging and marketing of Frucor's "Sparkling Apple" beverage was crucial. He found that while the name "Sparkling Apple" and the visual representation of apples on the packaging might suggest the presence of apple juice, the absence of any explicit claim of apple juice content, coupled with the ingredient list which did not include apple juice, meant that consumers were not likely to be misled. The court applied the principle that the assessment of misleading conduct must consider the likely effect on the ordinary or reasonable consumer, taking into account the entire context of the representation.

The court ultimately dismissed Coca-Cola's application, finding that Frucor had not contravened section 18 of the ACL.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Coca-Cola Company, an American multinational corporation known for its production and distribution of various beverages, brought an opposition against Frucor Beverages Limited, a New Zealand-based company, in relation to Frucor's trade mark application 1496541 for the colour green (Pantone 376c) in the name of Frucor Beverages Limited. The application was for registration of the trade mark in respect of energy drinks under Class 32. The dispute primarily centred around whether the colour green, as claimed in the application, was capable of distinguishing Frucor's energy drinks from those of other manufacturers, and whether the representation of the colour in the application complied with statutory requirements. The opposition was heard by a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Michael Kirov, on 23 February 2016. The Coca-Cola Company alleged that the green colour represented in the application was not consistent with the claimed shade of Pantone 376c and that the colour green generally lacked distinctiveness for energy drinks due to its widespread use by other manufacturers for various purposes. Frucor Beverages Limited defended the application, asserting that the colour green had become distinctive of its energy drinks through extensive use and promotion since 1999. The delegate found that the colour green represented in the application did not match the claimed Pantone 376c shade and that the colour green lacked distinctiveness for energy drinks due to its common use by other manufacturers for descriptive or aesthetic purposes. The delegate concluded that the opposition was successful on the grounds that the trade mark was not capable of distinguishing Frucor's energy drinks and that it did not comply with statutory requirements. Consequently, the delegate refused to register the trade mark application.

The matter before the court is an opposition brought by The Coca-Cola Company against the registration of a trade mark application filed by Frucor Beverages Limited. The application seeks to register the colour green (Pantone 376c) as a trade mark for energy drinks. The opposition was heard by a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Michael Kirov. The primary issues in the opposition relate to the registrability of the claimed mark under sections 41 and 62(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995. Section 41 addresses the capacity of a mark to distinguish goods or services, while section 62(b) concerns the acceptance of an application on the basis of false evidence or representations. The Opponent argued that the claimed mark was not capable of distinguishing the Applicant's goods, and that the application was accepted on the basis of false representations regarding the colour of the claimed mark. The Applicant maintained that the claimed mark had become distinctive through use and that there was no false representation. The delegate found that the opposition was successful on the basis that the claimed mark was not capable of distinguishing the Applicant's goods due to the uncertain definition of the mark and insufficient evidence of distinctiveness. The decision resulted in the refusal of the trade mark application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Green Swatch is a significantly different shade of green from 376c GREEN, as claimed in the endorsement to the application.
2. Whether the discrepancy between the Green Swatch and the claimed colour 376c GREEN is a "fatal flaw" that necessitates refusal of the application under s 41(2) of the Trade Marks Act 1995.
3. Whether the Applicant has established that the Claimed Mark was distinctive of its energy drinks as at the filing date of the application.
4. Whether the Applicant's use of different colours for its variant energy drinks influences whether the colour green is perceived as a trade mark.
5. Whether the Applicant's survey evidence establishes that the Claimed Mark had become distinctive of its energy drinks by the filing date.

Held
1. The Green Swatch is a significantly different shade of green from 376c GREEN, as claimed in the endorsement to the application. The court found the Green Swatch to be a significantly darker shade of green than 376c GREEN.
2. The discrepancy between the Green Swatch and the claimed colour 376c GREEN is a "fatal flaw" that necessitates refusal of the application under s 41(2) of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The court held that the discrepancy in colour was sufficient to substantially affect the identity of the claimed mark and made it uncertain and potentially unenforceable.
3. The Applicant has not established that the Claimed Mark was distinctive of its energy drinks as at the filing date of the application. The court found that the Applicant's use of the colour green was not likely to be perceived by relevant consumers as trade mark use due to the Applicant's own use of different colours for its variant energy drinks and the prominence of the "V" logo.
4. The Applicant's use of different colours for its variant energy drinks influences whether the colour green is perceived as a trade mark. The court found that the use of different colours for the variants likely affected consumers' perception of the colour green as a trade mark, as it would be perceived as part of the Applicant's corporate get-up rather than as a badge of origin distinguishing the Applicant's energy drinks.
5. The Applicant's survey evidence does not establish that the Claimed Mark had become distinctive of its energy drinks by the filing date. The court found that the survey results did not demonstrate that a substantial number of consumers perceived the colour green as a trade mark for the Applicant's energy drinks.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Delegate found the opposition to the registration of the trade mark "the colour GREEN" by Frucor Beverages Limited ("the Applicant") to be successful, based on section 41(2) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (the Act). The Delegate concluded that the colour green, as claimed in the endorsement to the application, was not a significantly different shade of green from the Green Swatch as shown in the application. The Delegate held that the discrepancy between the Green Swatch and the claimed colour 376c GREEN was a "fatal flaw" that rendered the application incapable of distinguishing the Applicant's energy drinks and necessitated refusal of the application under s 41(2) of the Act. The Delegate found that the Applicant had not established that the Claimed Mark was distinctive of its energy drinks as at the filing date of the application. The Delegate held that the Applicant's use of different colours for its variant energy drinks influenced whether the colour green was perceived as a trade mark. Finally, the Delegate held that the Applicant's survey evidence did not establish that the Claimed Mark had become distinctive of its energy drinks by the filing date. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a colour trade mark must be capable of distinguishing the applicant's goods or services from the goods or services of other persons. The court distinguished prior authority by finding that the discrepancy between the Green Swatch and the claimed colour 376c GREEN was a "fatal flaw" that necessitated refusal of the application under s 41(2) of the Act. The court also found that the Applicant's use of different colours for its variant energy drinks influenced whether the colour green was perceived as a trade mark, which distinguished this case from prior authority.