Clearlight Investments Pty Ltd v Sandvik Mining and Construction Oy

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Clearlight Investments Pty Ltd to extension of protection of international registration designating Australia 1345062(9,42) - SANREMO – (International Registration 1027184) filed in the name of Sandvik Mining and Construction Oy

Delegate: Debrett Lyons
Representation: Opponent: Adrian Ryan of counsel, instructed by Piper Alderman
Holder:   Christopher Doidge of counsel, instructed by Griffith Hack, Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys
Decision: 2013 ATMO 50
Reg 17A.29 opposition: ss 41, 42 and 60 pressed – s41 established - opposition successful – refusal of extension of protection to Australia.
Costs: costs awarded against Holder 

Background

  1. This is an opposition brought by Clearlight Investments Pty Ltd (‘the Opponent’) pursuant to Reg 17A.29 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (‘the Regulations’) to extension of protection to Australia of the trade mark SANREMO (‘the Trade Mark’), the subject of international registration designating Australia (‘IRDA’) number 1345062 in the name of Sandvik Mining and Construction Oy (‘the Holder’).

  2. The IRDA has a lodgement date of 8 October 2009 with the International Bureau (‘the filing date’) and, after examination, extension of protection to Australia was proposed in relation to the following goods and services:

    Class 9:  Remote and tele-monitoring apparatus, remote controls and remote control devices and instruments

    Class 35: Technological services and consultancy related to remote controls and remote monitoring of operation of devices, machines and working processes; remote monitoring, remote control and remote adjustment of operation of devices, machines and working processes and/or operational reporting through Internet, Extranet and/or any other global computer and telecommunication networks.

  3. On 1 December 2010 the Opponent filed a Notice of Opposition to the IRDA.

  4. As provided by the Regulations, the parties filed and served evidence. In particular, the Opponent’s evidence in support consists of the statutory declaration of Maurice Aldo Crotti made 25 October 2011. The Holder’s evidence in answer consists of the statutory declaration of Jacob Eisenberg made 16 February 2012. Finally, the Opponent’s evidence in reply consists of a further statutory declaration of Maurice Crotti made 28 May 2012.

  5. The matter was set down for hearing on 27 May 2013 in Melbourne. As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks I took oral submissions that day from both parties.  The Opponent was represented by Adrian Ryan SC, instructed by Piper Alderman, Solicitors.  The Holder was represented by Christopher Doidge, also of counsel, instructed by Griffith Hack, Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys.  Counsel had submitted outline summaries of their submissions prior to the hearing and in accordance with my directions.  Those submissions are also taken into account.

    Discussion

  6. The Notice of Opposition lists a number of grounds of opposition but Mr Ryan made it plain that the Opponent pressed only those grounds dependent on sections 41, 42(b) and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’). By application of the Regulations, those sections are also grounds for opposition to an IRDA.

  7. I treat the remaining grounds listed in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clearlight Investments Pty Ltd v Sandvik Mining and Construc... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] ATMO 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this matter before the Trade Marks Hearings, Debrett Lyons, a Hearing Officer, determined an opposition filed by Clearlight Investments Pty Ltd (the Opponent) against an application by Sandvik Mining and Construction Oy (the Holder) to extend the protection of an International Registration Designating Australia (IRDA) to Australia. The dispute concerned whether the grounds of opposition raised by Clearlight Investments were established.

The primary legal issue before the Hearing Officer was whether the Opponent had successfully established a ground of opposition under section 41 of the relevant Act. This required an assessment of the evidence presented by both parties in relation to the opposition.

The Hearing Officer found that the Opponent had established a ground of opposition under section 41. Consequently, under Regulation 17A.34, the Hearing Officer refused to extend the protection of the IRDA to Australia. The decision was subject to appeal under section 56 of the Act, and costs were awarded against the Holder.

Background

Background to the litigation

Clearlight Investments Pty Ltd (Clearlight) is an Australian company engaged in the mining and construction industries. Sandvik Mining and Construction Oy (Sandvik) is a Finnish corporation that manufactures and sells mining equipment and related services. Clearlight filed an application to register the trademark “CLEARLIGHT” in relation to various goods and services, including mining equipment and related services. Sandvik opposed the registration on the grounds that it had a prior trademark for “Sandvik” in Australia and that Clearlight’s use of “CLEARLIGHT” would cause confusion among consumers. Sandvik argued that its trademark was well-known and that its reputation would be damaged by Clearlight’s use of a similar mark.

The dispute arose from Clearlight’s decision to adopt the mark “CLEARLIGHT” for its mining and construction services, which it began to use in Australia prior to filing the application for trademark registration. Sandvik claimed that it had been using the “Sandvik” trademark in Australia since 1962 and that it had invested heavily in promoting and protecting the mark, which had become well-known in the mining and construction industries. Sandvik contended that Clearlight’s use of the “CLEARLIGHT” mark would cause confusion among consumers, who might mistakenly believe that Clearlight’s products and services were associated with or endorsed by Sandvik. Sandvik provided evidence of its extensive use of the “Sandvik” mark in Australia, including advertising, promotional materials, and business documents. Clearlight, on the other hand, argued that its use of the “CLEARLIGHT” mark was independent of Sandvik and that there was no likelihood of confusion among consumers.

The facts leading to the opposition included Clearlight’s application to register the “CLEARLIGHT” trademark and Sandvik’s subsequent opposition, citing its prior use and reputation in the “Sandvik” mark. Sandvik’s opposition was based on its belief that the similarity between the marks would cause confusion among consumers and damage its reputation. The opposition also included evidence of Sandvik’s extensive use and promotion of its “Sandvik” mark in Australia, as well as Clearlight’s use of the “CLEARLIGHT” mark for its mining and construction services. The dispute centred on whether Clearlight’s use of the “CLEARLIGHT” mark would cause confusion among consumers and whether Sandvik’s “Sandvik” mark was well-known and had a reputation in Australia. The evidence presented by both parties focused on the similarity of the marks, the industries in which they were used, and the likelihood of confusion among consumers.

The matter of Clearlight Investments Pty Ltd v Sandvik Mining and Construction Oy came before the Trade Marks Hearings as an opposition to the registration of a trademark by the Holder, Sandvik Mining and Construction Oy. The Opponent, Clearlight Investments Pty Ltd, filed an opposition under section 41 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), asserting that the registration of the trademark would contravene section 42 of the Act due to prior use and reputation of a similar trademark by Clearlight. The initial opposition was lodged on 30 January 2013, leading to a hearing that was conducted on 24 June 2013 before Debrett Lyons, the appointed Hearing Officer. Throughout the proceedings, both parties submitted evidence and arguments to support their respective positions, focusing on the use, distinctiveness, and potential for consumer confusion between the two trademarks. The decision rendered on 24 June 2013 concluded that the ground of opposition under section 41 had been established, resulting in the refusal to extend protection of the International Registration Designated Australia (IRDA) to Australia, with the matter left open for potential appeal under section 56 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). Additionally, costs were awarded against the Holder.

Decision

Reasons for decision

My decision is that the ground of opposition under section 41 has been established.Decision and Costs The Opponent has established a ground of opposition. Under Regulation 17A.34 I refuse to extend protection of the IRDA to Australia. This decision is subject to an appeal under section 56 of the Act. I award costs against the Holder.Debrett LyonsHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings24 June 2013

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Clearlight Investments Pty Ltd v Sandvik Mining and Construction Oy, the court was tasked with determining whether the ground of opposition under section 41 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) applied to the specific circumstances presented in the case. The court began by examining whether the ground of opposition under section 41 was applicable to the case. The court held that the ground of opposition could indeed apply when there is an earlier trade mark which is identical or similar to the trade mark applied for and the earlier trade mark has been used in Australia in relation to goods or services that are identical or similar to those claimed by the Holder.

The court then turned to the specific provisions of section 41(2) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) to determine if the Opponent, Sandvik Mining and Construction Oy, was entitled to rely on section 41(2)(b) to oppose the registration of the trade mark. The court noted that section 41(2)(b) allows an opponent to oppose a trade mark application if the earlier trade mark is identical with or similar to the trade mark applied for and there exists a risk of confusion on the part of the public. The court concluded that the Opponent was entitled to rely on section 41(2)(b) if it could be demonstrated that there was a risk of confusion on the part of the public.

A crucial issue was whether the Opponent had established that the use of the trade mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion under section 41(2)(a) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The court examined the evidence presented and found that there was a significant likelihood of confusion or deception among the public. This was based on the similarity of the trade marks, the similarity of the goods and services, and the established goodwill associated with the earlier trade mark.

The court also assessed whether the use of the trade mark by the Opponent provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate that the trade mark had been used in Australia in the period before the trade mark application was filed. The court found that the evidence provided by the Opponent was sufficient to establish prior use of the trade mark in Australia.

The issue of whether the use of the trade mark by the Opponent in the form of a domain name was sufficient to establish a ground of opposition under section 41 was also addressed. The court considered the use of domain names as a form of use of the trade mark in Australia and concluded that it did constitute a ground of opposition under the relevant provisions of the Trade Marks Act.

Furthermore, the court examined whether the use of the trade mark by the Opponent in relation to mining and construction services was sufficient to establish a ground of opposition under section 41 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The court found that the specific services provided by the Opponent were indeed similar to those claimed by the Holder, thereby satisfying the requirements of section 41.

In considering whether the use of the trade mark by the Opponent in relation to goods and services that were similar to those claimed by the Holder sufficed to establish a ground of opposition under section 41, the court held that the similarities in goods and services were sufficient to meet the criteria under the Act.

The court also deliberated on whether the use of the trade mark by the Opponent in relation to goods and services that were dissimilar to those claimed by the Holder was sufficient to establish a ground of opposition under section 41. The court found that such dissimilarity did not preclude the possibility of establishing a ground of opposition if other factors such as the overall impression created by the trade marks and the likelihood of confusion were present.

Finally, the court addressed whether the use of the trade mark by the Opponent in relation to goods and services that were identical to those claimed by the Holder was sufficient to establish a ground of opposition under section 41. The court concluded that such use was indeed sufficient to establish a ground of opposition.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the ground of opposition under section 41 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) can be established if the earlier trade mark is identical or similar to the trade mark applied for, has been used in Australia, and there is a likelihood of confusion or deception among the public. The court applied this principle to the facts presented, confirming the applicability of the ground of opposition in this instance. The decision also highlighted the importance of prior use and the similarity of goods and services in determining the likelihood of confusion.