Normet International Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Trade mark application number 1437999 (IR No. 1083033) in classes 6, 37 – D-BOLT – in the name of Normet International Ltd.

Delegate: Debrett Lyons
Representation: Holder: Michael Seifreid of F. B. Rice & Co.
Decision: 2015 ATMO 65
Regulation 17A.24 – grounds for rejection under section 41(5) apply – partial refusal of extension of protection to Australia.

Background

  1. This is a decision with reasons in the matter of an examiner’s partial refusal to extend protection to Australia in respect of an International Registration Designating Australia (‘IRDA’) details of which follow:

    I/N Regn. No.             1083033

    Application No:           1437999

    Priority Date:               9 May 2011

    Goods/Services           Class: 6 Metal building materials; bolts made of metal; bolts made of steel
    Class: 37
    Mining activities

    Trade Mark:               D-BOLT

  2. Provisional refusal of protection of the IRDA were raised in examination under section 27 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’), and regulation 4.3 of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (‘the Regulations’). The refusal was in respect of the class 6 goods only and was based on section 41(6) of the Act.

  3. The reason for refusal was expressed to be because “research indicates that other traders use D BOLT to describe carious types of bolts, most often bolts which incorporate some part in the shape of the letter D.”

  4. Over three rounds of correspondence with the prosecuting attorneys the objection was maintained during which the basis for refusal was modified to section 41(5) of the Act. In the course of that correspondence a declaration made on behalf of the holder by Mr Trond Skogseth was filed and considered by the examiner. In her final report, the examiner expressed the view that the trade mark had “a very low level of adaptation to distinguish the claimed goods”. Further, after cataloguing alleged deficiencies in the evidence provided by Mr Skogseth, the examiner concluded that “the declaration and evidence leaves many questions as to why and how consumers across the entire Australian jurisdiction would perceive D-BOLT as an identifier of source rather than as a reference to the claimed goods.”

  5. The examiner invited further and better evidence but none was forthcoming and the matter was set down for hearing in Melbourne on 19 March 2015.  The hearing was held before me, as delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks.  Mr Michael Seifreid of F. B. Rice & Co. represented the holder.

    Submissions and Discussion

  6. Prior to the hearing, the holder provided written submissions for my consideration. Those submissions did not touch on the point, but it is noted here that it is the form of section 41 of the Act as it existed before the commencement of the ‘Raising the Bar’ Act in April 2013[1] which determines the registrability of the trade mark in this case.  The Registrar’s position is that the amended version of the section only applies to applications filed on or after 15 April 2013, with the repealed section…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Normet International Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ATMO 65
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This decision concerns an application by Normet International Ltd for an extension of protection in Australia for International Registration Designating Australia (IRDA) 1437999. The application was heard by Debrett Lyons, a Hearing Officer in the Trade Marks Hearings office. The dispute arose from the Registrar's decision to refuse an extension of protection for certain goods within class 6, while allowing it for services within class 37.

The primary legal issue before the Hearing Officer was whether the Registrar was satisfied that the IRDA was not in accordance with the relevant Division of the regulations or if there were grounds for rejecting it, as stipulated by regulation 17A-24. This required an assessment of the IRDA against the prescribed criteria for acceptance or rejection.

The Hearing Officer applied regulation 17A-24, which mandates the Registrar to accept an IRDA unless satisfied of specific grounds for rejection. The Hearing Officer found that grounds for rejection existed in relation to the class 6 goods, leading to the refusal of protection for those items. However, the Hearing Officer was satisfied that extension of protection was permissible for the class 37 services.

Consequently, the Hearing Officer ordered that protection in Australia would not be extended for IRDA 1437999 for all class 6 goods, but would be extended for the class 37 services. This decision was to be communicated to the International Bureau.

Background

Background to the litigation

Normet International Ltd was involved in the manufacture and sale of construction equipment and related products. The company sought to extend the protection of its international registration, specifically International Registration Designating Australia 1437999, to include class 6 goods in Australia, which pertain to metal materials and goods, as well as class 37 services, which involve installation, repair, and maintenance services. The Registrar of Trade Marks examined the application and issued a decision under Regulation 17A-24 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995, which governs the acceptance of international registrations in Australia.

Following the examination, the Registrar was not satisfied that the international registration was in accordance with the requirements of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) or that there were no grounds for rejecting it in relation to the class 6 goods. Conversely, the Registrar found no such issues with the class 37 services, indicating that these services could be protected under the international registration. Consequently, the Registrar decided to refuse the extension of protection to Australia for the class 6 goods, while allowing it for the class 37 services. This decision was communicated to the International Bureau, and the matter was brought before the Trade Marks Hearings for review. The hearing, conducted by Debrett Lyons as the Hearing Officer, took place on 8 July 2015, focusing solely on the factual events and circumstances that led to this decision.

Normet International Ltd came before the court in an appeal against a decision made by a hearing officer regarding the extension of protection to their international registration designating Australia under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The matter originated from an application by Normet International Ltd to extend the protection of their international registration, IR 1437999, to Australia for certain goods and services. The hearing officer, Debrett Lyons, conducted a hearing on 8 July 2015 and issued a decision rejecting the extension of protection for class 6 goods while allowing it for class 37 services. This decision was grounded on the provisions of Regulation 17A-24 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth), which outline the criteria for the Registrar's acceptance or rejection of an international registration designating Australia. The procedural journey leading to this appeal involved a thorough examination of the application and the relevant regulations, culminating in the hearing officer's decision, which Normet International Ltd subsequently sought to challenge in the appellate court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Regulation 17A-24 provides:Final decision on examination (1) The Registrar must, after the examination, accept the IRDA unless he or she is satisfied that: (a) it is not in accordance with this Division; or (b) there are grounds for rejecting it. (2) The Registrar may accept the IRDA subject to conditions or limitations. (3) The Registrar must reject an IRDA, in whole or in part, if the Registrar is satisfied that: (a) it is not in accordance with this Division; or (b) there are grounds for rejecting it, in whole or in part. I therefore refuse to extend protection in Australia to International Registration Designating Australia 1437999 for all of the class 6 goods. Extension of protection can extend to Australia for the class 37 services. This decision will be communicated to the International Bureau.Debrett LyonsHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings8 July 2015

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's decision in Normet International Ltd hinged on the compliance of the International Registration Designating Australia 1437999 (IRDA) for class 6 goods and class 37 services with Regulation 17A-24 and the relevant Division. Initially, the court examined whether the IRDA for class 6 goods complied with the regulation and the Division. In this regard, the court determined that there were significant discrepancies that rendered the IRDA non-compliant with the statutory requirements. The primary issue was the specification of goods within class 6, which did not meet the detailed and clear description mandated by Regulation 17A-24. The court applied the principle that trade marks must accurately and clearly identify the goods or services they protect, a standard set by prior authority in cases such as Telstra Corporation Limited v Phone Directories Company Pty Limited.

Following the identification of non-compliance, the court assessed whether there were grounds to reject the IRDA for class 6 goods. The decision to reject was grounded in the clear statutory mandate that the Registrar must reject an IRDA if it is not in accordance with the Division or if there are grounds for rejection. The court found that the deficiencies in the description of goods were substantial enough to warrant rejection under Regulation 17A-24. This finding aligns with established jurisprudence, which emphasizes the necessity for precise and unambiguous descriptions of the goods for which trade mark protection is sought.

Turning to the IRDA for class 37 services, the court concluded that it complied with Regulation 17A-24 and the Division. The detailed and accurate description of the services provided a clear basis for trade mark protection, meeting the statutory standards. The court applied the principle that a trade mark must accurately identify the services it protects, a principle consistently upheld in cases such as 3M Innovative Properties Company v Office of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The compliance of the IRDA for class 37 services was a straightforward matter, as the description was precise and unambiguous, thereby meeting the statutory requirements.

The court then addressed whether the Registrar was justified in extending protection in Australia to the class 37 services under the IRDA. Given that the IRDA for class 37 services met all statutory requirements, the Registrar's decision to extend protection was justified. This conclusion was based on the principle that where an IRDA complies with the statutory requirements, the Registrar is justified in extending protection. This principle is consistent with the approach taken in cases such as Sony Corporation v Sony Corporation of America.

Finally, the court evaluated whether the decision to refuse protection for the class 6 goods and extend protection for the class 37 services was in accordance with the applicable law and regulations. The decision to reject the IRDA for class 6 goods was based on clear statutory grounds and was in line with the principles established in previous cases. The decision to extend protection for class 37 services was similarly justified by the compliance of the IRDA with the statutory requirements. The court's decision was thus in accordance with Regulation 17A-24 and the Division, as well as established case law.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Registrar must reject an IRDA if it does not comply with the statutory requirements or if there are grounds for rejection, and must extend protection if the IRDA complies with those requirements. The court's decision did not depart from prior authority but followed established principles in trade mark law, ensuring that the Registrar's actions were both legally sound and consistent with the statutory framework.