TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Trade mark application number 1497299 (9; 16; 41; 42; 44) - NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICES DIRECTORY - in the name of National Health Call Centre Network Ltd.
Delegate: | Heath Wilson |
Representation: | Applicant: Michael Hall of Counsel instructed by Brett Doyle of Clayton Utz. |
Decision: | 2014 ATMO 6 Section 41 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 – limited inherent adaptation to distinguish – other circumstances and evidence of use not sufficient to show trade mark capable of distinguishing – application rejected. |
Background
The National Health Call Centre Network Ltd (‘the Applicant’) filed an application to register a trade mark (‘the Trade Mark’) on 20 June 2012, the current details of which are:
Trade Mark No. 1497299
Trade Mark: NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICES DIRECTORY
Specification of Goods and Services:
Class 9: Computer hardware, software and firmware including apps for tablet computers, mobile phones and other portable electronic devices; downloadable electronic publications; apparatus for recording and/or reproduction of sound and/or images including DVDs, compact discs, cassettes and magnetic data carriers; fridge magnets
Class 16: Printed matter and publications; stationery
Class 41: Education and training services, seminars and conferences including such services provided online; occupational health and safety services; information services related to the foregoing services
Class 42: Health information networks and portals including technology (computer) support services; consultancy in relation to occupational health and safety; information services related to the foregoing services
Class 44: Mental health services and psychology/psychiatric services; information services related to the foregoing servicesThe trade mark application was examined under the provisions of section 31 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’). A ground for rejection was initially raised under (the pre-15 April 2013) section 41(5) of the Act[1] on the basis that the expression comprising the Trade Mark indicated “that the goods and services [the Applicant] provide are, or are in relation to, a nationwide directory for health services.”
[1] As the Trade Mark was filed prior to the amendments introduced by the Raising the Bar Legislation commencing on 15 April 2013, the now repealed provisions of section 41 of the Act apply (See Clearlight Investments Pty Ltd v Sandvik Mining and Construction Oy [2013] ATMO 50).
In response, the Applicant submitted two statutory declarations of John Cowell (General Counsel of the Applicant), the first dated 12 March 2013 with exhibit JC-1 and the second dated 24 July 2013 with annexures A to D. Neither was sufficient to overcome the ground for rejection and the Applicant requested to be heard under section 33(4) of the Act.
Prior to the hearing, the Applicant supplied the statutory declaration of Brett Doyle dated 14 November 2013 with exhibit BD-1 and later supplied the Office (on 3 December) with a third statutory declaration of John Cowell dated 15 November 2013 along with a new exhibit JC-1. Mr Doyle stated at the hearing that the third statutory declaration of John Cowell was intended to replace and update…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read National Health Call Centre Network Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] ATMO 6
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the arbitral award should be set aside pursuant to section 18 of the *Commercial Arbitration Act 2013* (Qld) (the Act). Specifically, the Court had to determine if the respondent had been afforded a reasonable opportunity to present its case, and if the tribunal had exceeded its powers by making an award on a matter not submitted to arbitration.
The Court considered the principles of natural justice and the scope of an arbitrator's jurisdiction. It found that the respondent had been given ample opportunity to present its case throughout the arbitration process, including through written submissions and participation in hearings. Furthermore, the Court determined that the matters dealt with in the award fell within the scope of the arbitration agreement, as they were directly related to the dispute that had been referred to arbitration. The Court applied the principles that an award should only be set aside on limited grounds and that the burden of proof rests on the party seeking to set aside the award.
The Court dismissed the respondent's application to set aside the arbitral award and ordered that the respondent pay the applicant's costs of the application.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Applicant's product, the National Health Services Directory, is a directory that enables users to locate their nearest health services and provides related information. The directory was officially launched in December 2012, and an App for mobile devices was made available from August 2012. The initial promotion of the product was primarily targeted at health care professionals, with limited publicity to the general public. The Applicant provided evidence of some use of the trade mark, but this use varied from describing the product to advertising it. Much of the evidence showed the trade mark being used descriptively rather than as a badge of origin. Additionally, the trade mark was often used alongside a stylised magnifying glass device, which the Applicant has also applied to register as a separate trade mark.
Despite the Applicant's efforts to demonstrate use and distinctiveness, the Delegate found that the evidence did not sufficiently show that the trade mark could distinguish the Applicant's goods and services from those of other traders. The use of the trade mark was limited and primarily descriptive, with little evidence of marketing to the general public. Consequently, the Delegate rejected the trade mark application under section 41(5) of the Trade Marks Act 1995, concluding that the trade mark was not capable of distinguishing the Applicant's goods and services.
National Health Call Centre Network Ltd (the Applicant) filed a trade mark application on 20 June 2012 for the expression "NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICES DIRECTORY" in relation to a range of goods and services. The application was examined and a ground for rejection was raised under section 41 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 on the basis that the trade mark did not appear to be capable of distinguishing the Applicant's goods and services from those of other traders. In response, the Applicant submitted several statutory declarations and evidence in support of their case. A hearing was held on 19 November 2013 before Heath Wilson, a Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The Applicant was represented by Michael Hall of Counsel with Brett Doyle of Clayton Utz. The Delegate found that while the trade mark possessed some inherent adaptation to distinguish the Applicant's goods and services, it was not sufficient on its own to distinguish them from those of other traders. The Applicant also failed to provide sufficient evidence of use or intended use of the trade mark that would demonstrate its capacity to distinguish the goods and services. As a result, the Delegate rejected the trade mark application under section 41 of the Act. This is not a final determination and the Applicant has the right to appeal the decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the trade mark 'NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICES DIRECTORY' inherently adapted to distinguish the Applicant's goods or services from those of other persons?
2. If not inherently adapted to distinguish, does the combined effect of the extent to which the trade mark is inherently adapted to distinguish the designated goods or services, the use or intended use of the trade mark by the Applicant, and any other circumstances, demonstrate that the trade mark does or will distinguish the designated goods or services?
3. Is the Applicant's evidence of use of the trade mark sufficient to demonstrate that the trade mark distinguishes the designated goods or services from those of other persons?
4. Are there any other circumstances that support the conclusion that the trade mark is capable of distinguishing the Applicant's goods or services from those of other persons?
Held
1. Is the trade mark 'NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICES DIRECTORY' inherently adapted to distinguish the Applicant's goods or services from those of other persons?
The court concluded that the trade mark has a modicum of inherent adaptation to distinguish the Applicant's goods and services, but is not fully inherently adapted. Result: Further consideration under section 41(5) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 is required.
2. If not inherently adapted to distinguish, does the combined effect of the extent to which the trade mark is inherently adapted to distinguish the designated goods or services, the use or intended use of the trade mark by the Applicant, and any other circumstances, demonstrate that the trade mark does or will distinguish the designated goods or services?
The court concluded that the combined effect of the extent to which the trade mark is inherently adapted to distinguish the designated goods or services, the use or intended use of the trade mark by the Applicant, and any other circumstances, do not demonstrate that the trade mark does or will distinguish the designated goods or services. Result: The application is subject to rejection under section 41(5) of the Trade Marks Act 1995.
3. Is the Applicant's evidence of use of the trade mark sufficient to demonstrate that the trade mark distinguishes the designated goods or services from those of other persons?
The court concluded that the Applicant's evidence of use of the trade mark is not sufficient to demonstrate that the trade mark distinguishes the designated goods or services from those of other persons. Result: The application is subject to rejection under section 41(5) of the Trade Marks Act 1995.
4. Are there any other circumstances that support the conclusion that the trade mark is capable of distinguishing the Applicant's goods or services from those of other persons?
The court concluded that there are no other circumstances that support the conclusion that the trade mark is capable of distinguishing the Applicant's goods or services from those of other persons. Result: The application is rejected under section 33 of the Trade Marks Act 1995.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Delegate's decision to reject the trade mark application primarily rests on the conclusion that the trade mark "NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICES DIRECTORY" is not inherently adapted to distinguish the Applicant's goods and services from those of other persons. The Delegate considered the ordinary meaning of the expression and its potential use by other traders, finding that the expression would likely be desired by other traders in the context of health services directories. However, the Delegate also found that the trade mark has a limited degree of inherent adaptation to distinguish when considering the Applicant's services in classes 41, 42, and 44, which are not directly related to health services directories.
In light of this finding, the Delegate proceeded to consider whether the combined effect of the extent to which the trade mark is inherently adapted to distinguish the designated goods or services, the use or intended use of the trade mark by the Applicant, and any other circumstances, demonstrate that the trade mark does or will distinguish the designated goods or services. The Delegate found that the Applicant's evidence of use of the trade mark was not sufficient to demonstrate that the trade mark distinguishes the designated goods or services from those of other persons. The Delegate noted that the Applicant's promotional efforts had primarily targeted health professionals, and there was limited evidence of the trade mark being used as a badge of origin for the Applicant's goods and services.
Additionally, the Delegate found that there were no other circumstances that supported the conclusion that the trade mark is capable of distinguishing the Applicant's goods or services from those of other persons. The Delegate concluded that the trade mark application should be rejected as it was not capable of distinguishing the Applicant's goods or services from those of other persons under the provisions of section 41 of the Trade Marks Act 1995.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that a trade mark application may be rejected if the trade mark is not inherently adapted to distinguish the applicant's goods or services from those of other persons, and the combined effect of the extent to which the trade mark is inherently adapted to distinguish the designated goods or services, the use or intended use of the trade mark by the applicant, and any other circumstances, do not demonstrate that the trade mark does or will distinguish the designated goods or services.