My Brilliance Pty Ltd v Brilliance Publishing Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by My Brilliance Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application 1369408 - BRILLIANCE AUDIO - in the name of Brilliance Publishing Inc.

Delegate: Jock McDonagh
Representation: Opponent: Kevin Ashby of IP Strategies International Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys
Applicant: Angus Lang of counsel instructed by King & Wood Mallesons Lawyers
Decision: 2015 ATMO 63
Section 52 opposition – Grounds pursued under sections 41, 42, 43, 44, 58A, 58, 59, 60, and 62 not established

Background

1. This matter is an opposition under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) to the registration of the trade mark BRILLIANCE AUDIO in the name of Brilliance Publishing Inc (‘the Applicant’). Relevant details of the application are set out below.

Trade mark:  BRILLIANCE AUDIO (‘the Trade Mark’)
Trade mark application:        1369408
Filing Date:  30 June 2010

Specification:  Class 9: Publications and electronic publications, being audibly rendered books featuring literary works recorded on tapes, cassettes, digital discs, compact discs, optical discs, MP3 discs, and computer-readable media; downloadable electronic publications in the nature of audibly rendered books featuring sounds, text, music, and spoken word content for literary works

Class 41: Publishing and electronic publishing services, being publication of text and graphic works of others on tapes, cassettes, digital discs, compact discs, optical discs, MP3 discs, and computer-readable media and on-line, featuring sounds, text, music, and spoken word content for literary works

  1. The application was examined in compliance with section 31 of the Act and after the provisions of section 44(4) had been applied it was advertised as accepted for possible registration in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 2 May 2013. My Brilliance Pty Ltd (‘the Opponent’) filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose the registration of the application on 1 July 2013. Thereafter the Opponent and Applicant filed, respectively, a Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘the Statement’) and a Notice of Intention to Defend and filed evidence as provided by the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (‘the Regulations’).

  2. I heard the matter in Canberra on 9 April 2015 as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. Kevin Ashby of IP Strategies International Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys represented the Opponent by telephone. The Applicant was represented by Angus Lang of counsel instructed by King & Wood Mallesons Lawyers.

    Grounds of Opposition

    4. The Opponent nominated grounds of opposition under sections 41, 42, 43, 44, 58A, 58, 59, 60, 62, and 62A of the Act. The onus is upon the Opponent to establish one or more of its grounds of opposition on the ‘balance of probabilities’.[1]

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read My Brilliance Pty Ltd v Brilliance Publishing Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ATMO 63
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

My Brilliance Pty Ltd (the Applicant) sought to register a trade mark, and Brilliance Publishing Inc (the Opponent) opposed this application. The dispute concerned whether the Applicant had established sufficient use of its trade mark in Australia prior to the filing date of its application, as required by the relevant legislation. The decision was made by Jock McDonagh, a Hearings Officer at the Trade Marks Hearings.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Opponent had established any of the grounds on which the application was opposed. Specifically, the court had to determine whether sales of the Applicant's goods through Australian distributors constituted use by the Applicant in Australia, whether direct online sales to Australian customers qualified as use in Australia, whether the use of the trade mark accompanied by a starburst device amounted to use of the mark itself, and whether the Applicant's evidence had been fabricated.

The Hearings Officer found that the Opponent had not established any of its grounds of opposition. The Opponent's strategy focused on attacking the Applicant's evidence, arguing that sales through intermediaries like Baker & Taylor and Ingram Book Group did not constitute use by the Applicant in Australia, and that direct online sales were not sufficiently "targeted at" Australia. The Opponent also contended that the presence of a starburst device alongside the trade mark meant it was not use of the mark itself, and that key elements of the Applicant's evidence were fabricated. However, the Hearings Officer concluded that the Opponent had not established its case to any extent.

Consequently, the Hearings Officer decided to register the trade mark application, as no grounds of opposition had been established. The application was to proceed to registration one month from the date of the decision, unless an appeal was filed, in which case registration would be stayed pending the outcome of the appeal. The Applicant was awarded its costs against the Opponent.

Background

Background to the litigation

My Brilliance Pty Ltd, referred to as the Applicant, filed an application for the registration of a trade mark in Australia. The Applicant, which was previously known as Brilliance Audio Inc and was acquired by Amazon.com in 2007, provides various personal, social, and psychic services and consultancy, utilising printed and audio-visual media to support its 'My Brilliance' services. The Applicant has been distributing its goods in Australia since 1999 through Baker & Taylor and since January 2003 through Ingram Book Group, Inc. Additionally, the Applicant has made its goods available for purchase online since 2001 and physically through Australian distributors from 1999.

Brilliance Publishing Inc, referred to as the Opponent, opposed the Applicant's trade mark application. The Opponent provides similar services and consultancy, also using printed and audio-visual media. The Opponent's primary strategy was to attack the credibility and reliability of the Applicant's evidence to establish grounds under sections 44 and 62 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The Opponent argued that the Applicant's sales through Baker & Taylor and Ingram Book Group did not constitute use in Australia, and that sales made directly to Australian customers from the Applicant's websites were not targeted at Australia. Furthermore, the Opponent contended that the use of a starburst device accompanied the trade mark, negating its independent use, and suggested that the Applicant's evidence had been fabricated.

The proceedings in My Brilliance Pty Ltd v Brilliance Publishing Inc originated from an opposition to the registration of a trade mark application lodged by My Brilliance Pty Ltd, which was subsequently acquired by Brilliance Publishing Inc. The opposition was brought by an entity providing various personal, social, and psychic services and consultancy under the trade name 'My Brilliance'. This case involved an application to the Trade Marks Hearings, a specialist division within the Australian court system, tasked with adjudicating on disputes related to trade marks. The matter was heard by Jock McDonagh, a Hearings Officer, on 2 July 2015. The opposition primarily sought to establish grounds under sections 44 and 62 of the relevant trade marks legislation, challenging the Applicant's evidence and attempting to impeach its credibility and reliability. Prior to the final hearing, extensive evidence was filed by both parties, including declarations from various witnesses and internet search results. The Opponent focused on attacking the Applicant's evidence, particularly the sales and distribution of goods in Australia by Baker & Taylor and Ingram Book Group, as well as the direct sales from the Applicant's websites. Ultimately, the Hearings Officer found that the grounds of opposition were not established, allowing the trade mark application to proceed to registration unless an appeal was lodged within a specified period.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The time at which the grounds of opposition must be established is the date of filing of the application for registration[2].[2] See Southern Cross Refrigerating v Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd (1953) 91 CLR 592 at 595Evidence7. The evidence consists of the following declarations: The Opponent provides various personal, social and psychic services and consultancy, which also use various printed and audio-visual media to support the ‘My Brilliance’ services. After describing the nature of the Opponent’s goods and services and their history, the remainder of Holmes 1 is effectively submissions on each of the grounds of opposition and an attempt to impeach the Applicant and its evidence provided during examination, particularly that which the Applicant filed to establish the opposed application was acceptable under section 44(4) of the Act. Holmes 1 annexes voluminous results of various internet searches conducted by the Opponent. The searches are usually based on the titles of the Applicant’s goods, where the Opponent is highlighting what is contends are inconsistency of branding of the Applicant’s goods and/or wrong details such as ISBN, postcodes, and similar detail. Holmes 1, at [B.9.9] and following mentions that the Opponent learned that one of its registered trade marks had been cited during examination, and that the Applicant had attempted to obtain a letter of consent from the Applicant. The trade mark registration cited in examination is as follows: Cully provides details of Baker & Taylor distributing the Applicant’s goods in Australia since 1999. In particular, it provided audiobooks to libraries in New South Wales and Victoria since 1999. Dickert provides details of Ingram Book Group, Inc distributing the Applicant’s goods in Australia since January 2003. Pereira provides details of the Applicant’s founding as Brilliance Corporation in 1984 and its renaming as Brilliance Audio Inc in 1998. The Applicant was acquired by Amazon.com in 2007, and in 2013 changed its name to Brilliance Publishing. The Applicant’s goods have been available to purchase on line (through websites at ‘brillaince.com’ and ‘audiobooks.com’) since 2001, and physically through the Australian distributors from 1999.Discussion18. In its evidence and submissions, the Opponent’s primary strategy was attacking the evidence of the Applicant, in both its evidence filed during the course of the examination of the trade mark and evidence filed during the course of the opposition proceedings. The intention was apparently to impeach the credibility and reliability of the Applicant’s evidence in order to establish the sections 44 and 62 grounds. There was a fourfold thrust in the Opponent’s attacks on the Applicant’s evidence:· That the sales made through Baker & Taylor and Ingram Book Group do not constitute use by the Applicant in Australia. The Applicant bases this contention on E & J Gallo Winery v Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd (2010) 241 CLR 144 (‘Gallo’).· That the sales made directly by the Applicant to customers in Australia from its websites do not constitute use in Australia because they are not ‘targeted at’ Australia.· The uses of the trade mark shown in the evidence are said not to be use of the mark because they are accompanied by a starburst device.· The evidence, or key elements of it, has been fabricated.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This ground of opposition is not established.Decision 78. At the Relevant Date subsection 55(1) of the Act provided:55Decision(1)Unless the proceedings are discontinued or dismissed, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a)to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b)to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.Note:For limitations see section 6. The Opposition has not been to any extent established. The trade mark application may then proceed to registration one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration shall not occur until the appeal has been decided or discontinued and that the disposition of the application should be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction.Costs81. Having been successful in this matter the Applicant is entitled to its costs which I award against the Opponent at the scale set out in Schedule 8 to the Regulations.Jock McDonaghHearings OfficerTrade Marks Hearings2 July 2015

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of My Brilliance Pty Ltd v Brilliance Publishing Inc hinged on the interpretation of trade mark use in Australia and the credibility of the Applicant's evidence. The Opponent, My Brilliance, sought to establish that the Applicant's trade mark application should not proceed to registration due to the grounds of opposition outlined in section 44 and section 62 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The Hearings Officer, Jock McDonagh, dismissed the grounds of opposition, allowing the Applicant's trade mark application to proceed to registration.

The first issue addressed was whether the sales made through Baker & Taylor and Ingram Book Group constituted use of the trade mark by the Applicant in Australia. The Opponent argued that these sales did not constitute use in Australia by the Applicant, relying on the case of E & J Gallo Winery v Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd (2010) 241 CLR 144. However, the Hearings Officer found that the Applicant's use of its trade mark in association with its goods sold through these distributors was sufficient to constitute use in Australia, as the distributors acted as agents of the Applicant. The Hearings Officer distinguished Gallo, which concerned the use of a trade mark by a third party without the applicant's consent, from the present case where the Applicant controlled the sales made by the distributors.

The second issue was whether the sales made directly by the Applicant to customers in Australia from its websites constituted use of the trade mark in Australia. The Opponent argued that these sales did not constitute use in Australia because they were not 'targeted at' Australia. The Hearings Officer rejected this argument, finding that the Applicant's direct sales to Australian customers through its websites constituted use of the trade mark in Australia. The Hearings Officer emphasised that the Applicant's control over the sales process and the targeting of the Australian market through the use of the trade mark established use in Australia.

The third issue was whether the uses of the trade mark shown in the evidence were accompanied by a starburst device, and therefore not use of the mark. The Opponent argued that the presence of the starburst device rendered the uses not to be use of the mark. However, the Hearings Officer found that the starburst device did not alter the fact that the trade mark was used in association with the Applicant's goods and services. The Hearings Officer held that the use of the trade mark, even with the starburst device, constituted use of the mark in Australia.

The fourth issue was whether the evidence provided by the Applicant, or key elements of it, had been fabricated. The Opponent made numerous attacks on the credibility and reliability of the Applicant's evidence, particularly that filed during the examination of the trade mark and during the opposition proceedings. However, the Hearings Officer found no merit in the Opponent's claims of fabrication, holding that the Applicant's evidence was credible and reliable.

Finally, the Hearings Officer considered whether the grounds of opposition had been established. Having found that the Applicant's use of its trade mark in association with its goods and services in Australia was valid, and that the Opponent's attacks on the credibility of the Applicant's evidence were unfounded, the Hearings Officer concluded that the grounds of opposition had not been established. The trade mark application could therefore proceed to registration.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the use of a trade mark in association with goods and services sold through distributors and directly to customers in Australia, even if accompanied by a starburst device, constitutes use of the trade mark in Australia. Additionally, the credibility of evidence filed in support of a trade mark application can be upheld in the face of attacks on its reliability, and such evidence can establish the use of the trade mark in Australia. The Hearings Officer did not depart from or distinguish any prior authority in reaching these conclusions.