Toddler Kindy Gymbaroo Pty Ltd v Gymboree Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 87 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Toddler Kindy Gymbaroo Pty Ltd v Gymboree Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 618

TRADE MARKS – cancellation – transitional provisions of Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (“1995 TM Act”) – effect of prescriptive validity under s 234 of 1995 TM Act – whether s 234 of 1995 TM Act contains sole grounds on which a mark originally registered under the Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth) (“1955 TM Act”) may be removed from Register – whether, on facts, prescriptive validity has been lost – whether actual use is an essential requirement of s 234(2)(e) of 1995 TM Act – relevant time for considering whether use of mark would be likely to deceive or confuse under combined operation of s 234(2)(d) of 1995 TM Act and s 28(a) of 1955 TM Act – whether, on facts, use of mark likely to deceive or cause confusion at relevant time – marks used in relation to gymnasia services for young children – similarity of words “Gymbaroo” and “Gymboree”

TRADE MARKS – cancellation – whether mark should be cancelled for lack of ownership – whether marks substantially identical or deceptively similar – signficance of visual context in which similar words appear in the marks – whether mark should be cancelled on ground that it is substantially identical with or deceptively similar to a trade mark that has acquired a reputation in Australia – discretion to cancel mark – relevance of delay, copying and reputation to exercise of discretion

TRADE MARKS – cancellation – whether mark should be cancelled for non-use – whether registered owners authorised use of mark by franchisees in the relevant period – construction of franchise agreement – circumstances surrounding franchise agreement – degree of control exercised by franchisors over operations of franchisees – whether actual use that was made by franchisees was authorised use – whether marks were used by franchisees in relation to the services in respect of which the marks were registered – relevance of decided cases concerning use in relation to goods

TRADE MARKS – infringement – whether marks are deceptively similar

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading or deceptive conduct – conduct of offering franchises and providing gymnasia services for young children – consideration of evidence that members of public making inquiries about services of respondent knew of services of applicant – relevant time for considering conduct alleged to be misleading and deceptive – relevant sections of public – nature of business – similarity of names

TRADE PRACTICES – injunctions – whether injunction should be granted to restrain offering of franchises – whether injunction should be granted to restrain provision of services – relevance of delay – relevance of copying of mark

TORTS – passing off

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) ss 7, 8, 10, 27, 33, 40, 41, 44, 57, 58, 60, 88, 92, 94, 100, 101, 120, 233, 234
Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth) (repealed) ss 22, 28, 61
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 53, 80, 82

Campomar Sociedad, Limitada v Nike International…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Toddler Kindy Gymbaroo Pty Ltd v Gymboree Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 618
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Toddler Kindy Gymbaroo Pty Ltd v Gymboree Pty Ltd, the Federal Court of Australia was tasked with resolving a dispute between two companies engaged in the business of providing parent-child interactive play programs. Gymboree Pty Ltd, a franchisee of Gymboree Corporation, a United States-based company, brought an action against Toddler Kindy Gymbaroo Pty Ltd (TKG), alleging breaches of the Trade Practices Act and the Fair Trading Act, as well as claims of passing off. Gymboree sought injunctive relief and orders under the Trade Marks Act to address the use of certain trade marks by TKG. The case focused on the alleged misappropriation of trade marks and the potential for consumer confusion between the two entities.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether TKG had engaged in conduct that contravened the Trade Practices Act, particularly sections 52, 53(c), and 53(d), and whether the use of certain trade marks by TKG constituted misleading or deceptive conduct or passing off. Additionally, the court had to determine whether Gymboree was entitled to injunctive relief and the cancellation of trade marks under the Trade Marks Act. The central factual dispute involved the origins of the trade marks "Gymbaroo" and "Toddler Kindy Gymbaroo," and whether TKG had improperly adopted these names based on information obtained from Gymboree Corporation during a meeting in 1983.

The court examined the evidence provided by both parties and found that there was significant divergence in their accounts of a meeting between Mrs. Sasse of TKG and Mr. Jacob of Gymboree Corp. While Mr. Jacob testified that Mrs. Sasse had expressed interest in a Gymboree franchise and was provided with literature about the Gymboree program, Mrs. Sasse maintained that no such franchise discussion took place. The court concluded that the proceedings were initiated almost by chance and noted a willingness from both parties to resolve the issues amicably. However, the court found that TKG had indeed adopted the names "Gymbaroo" and "Toddler Kindy Gymbaroo" after the meeting with Mr. Jacob, which led to the conclusion that TKG's conduct was misleading and deceptive under the Trade Practices Act.

The court granted Gymboree Pty Ltd injunctive relief, restraining TKG from using the contested trade marks, and ordered the cancellation of these trade marks. The matter was stood over to allow the parties to file orders to give effect to the court's reasons and to file submissions on the question of costs within the specified timeframes.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Parties to file within 21 days short minutes to give effect to these reasons.

2. Parties to file within 14 days submissions on the question of costs.

3. Matter stood over to 7 June 2000.

Background

Background to the litigation

Gymboree cross claimed against TKG and Mr and Mrs Sasse alleging they had engaged in conduct contravening ss 52, 53(c) and 53(d) of the TP Act, and provisions of the Fair Trading Act 1989 (Qld), and had tortiously passed off their business as that of Gymboree. Orders removing and cancelling certain trade marks associated with TKG were also sought as were related orders arising from the use of the trade marks by TKG. Gymboree Corporation (“Gymboree Corp”) also cross-claimed raising similar issues concerning the use of trade marks by TKG. This judgment deals only with liability, injunctive relief and the proceedings under the 1995 TM Act.B: Background – an overview TKG is a company incorporated in Australia and the second applicants, Mr and Mrs Sasse, are the sole directors and shareholders. Gymboree is a company incorporated in Australia and the second respondent, Gymboree Corp is a company incorporated in the United States. What follows is an overview of events leading to the present proceedings. Some of the factual matters referred to are contentious and the evidence on these matters is considered in more detail later and findings made. However this overview does refer to facts which, if not later canvassed in detail, constitute findings about events leading to these proceedings.B: (i) Margaret Sasse Mrs Sasse is the managing director of TKG and is a trained nurse. She married Mr Harry Sasse in 1951. From 1969 to 1973 Mrs Sasse taught secondary school, with a particular interest in teaching remedial English. While teaching remedial English she trialed motor sensory development techniques that focussed on developing a motor base in young children considered essential for higher levels of learning. In 1973 she became a director of ANSUA (A New Start for the Under-achiever Association) a charitable organisation formed to aid children with learning difficulties or delayed development caused by minor nervous system dysfunction. Through ANSUA Mrs Sasse became involved in new approaches to the treatment of children with developmental, learning and/or behavioural difficulties, organised seminars in Melbourne and Sydney for teachers and parents, and initiated the establishment of a school for intelligent underachievers. She promoted the notion the organisation should establish ANSUA centres throughout Australia but resigned in 1982 because it would not. She believed it was important to establish centres to provide children (from birth to early school age) and their parents with the education and skills necessary to prevent the development of learning difficulties at school age. She also believed that apart from traditional kindergartens and play groups there was no-one else providing a service of this type in Australia. Her research at the time revealed only one “Kindy Gym” in South Australia. However this was a play centre only and did not accord with her focus on parent/child development and education. The first centre Mrs Sasse established was in 1982 in East Kew, Victoria, and it was aimed at enhancing motor development through assisting children to learn to their potential; to provide a means of preventing later school learning difficulties; to foster an awareness among parents of the importance of early childhood development, health, behaviour and learning; and to provide a watchdog early intervention service and guidance to parents.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The business of Gymboree Corp had its origins in a business established in the United States by Mrs Joan Barnes in 1976 providing parent and child interactive play programmes. Gymboree Corp was first incorporated in California in 1979 and floated as a publicly listed company in 1993. It first franchised its play programs domestically in 1980 and outside the United States in 1984. Companies have been incorporated in Canada, Ireland, the United Kingdom, Japan and Hong Kong to facilitate international expansion. From 1994 the franchising of the program was undertaken by Gymboree Play Programs, Inc. (“Gymboree Inc”). Gymboree Corp and Gymboree Inc operate or franchise three hundred centres in the United States and ninety elsewhere, namely in Canada, Mexico, Colombia, Korea, Taiwan, France, Singapore, Indonesia and Australia. C: The evidence on material questions of fact The following is a consideration of the evidence concerning what I view as material facts and, in particular, material facts in issue. In the proceedings the parties relied on extensive affidavit evidence and many volumes of documents were tendered. I have not referred to all this material and I have endeavoured to address only facts in issue which bear upon the ultimate issues presented for determination. C: (i)Mrs Sasse’s 1982/83 trip to the USA and the adoption of the names “Gymbaroo” and “Toddler Kindy Gymbaroo” The Kew centre commenced operations in June 1982 as a pilot scheme conducted in a Uniting Church hall. The business name “Toddler Kindy Gyms (Victoria)” had been registered on 31 May 1982 by Mrs Sasse. During the 1982/83 Christmas period, Mrs Sasse visited the United States. It is clear from letters in evidence that Mrs Sasse had, from probably early 1982, been corresponding with individuals in the United States in the same general field of interest as hers and was doing so with a view to travelling to the United States. It is common ground that during this trip, Mrs Sasse met with a representative of Gymboree Corp. It was Mr Robert Jacob who was then the Director and Vice-President of Franchising for Gymboree Corp. His duties included the marketing of franchises. There was a marked divergence in the evidence of Mrs Sasse and Mr Jacob as to what happened at the meeting. Mr Jacob’s evidence was comparatively detailed. He said, in an affidavit sworn on 28 September 1998, he believed they met on 14 February 1983. He had been telephoned by Mrs Sasse in the preceding week from Los Angeles to arrange a meeting. Mrs Sasse brought with her extensive material on Gymboree which was the type of material available for distribution at Gymboree Corp franchised and owned centres. It was brochures, pamphlets and other material explaining the Gymboree Corp play program. He said Mrs Sasse tried to pick up a lot of printed material when she was with him. Mr Jacob’s affidavit contains either one version of two parts of the conversation with Mrs Sasse or two versions of the one part. His account involved Mrs Sasse indicating an interest in obtaining a Gymboree Corp franchise for Australia and indicating she had visited a number of Gymboree Corp centres around Los Angeles and San Francisco. Mr Jacob then indicated that Gymboree Corp was not in a position to issue franchises in Australia at that time. Mr Jacob’s evidence was that the next time he heard of Mrs Sasse was in “approximately 1986 or 1987” when Gymboree had commenced trading in Australia as a Gymboree Corp franchisee. He was sent a brochure on TKG by Mrs Graham. Mr Jacob annexed to his affidavit a letter to Baker & McKenzie in Chicago dated 26 March 1986. It read:“Re: Gymbaroo – AustraliaDear Marty:Enclosed is a copy of an article which appeared in March 1985 about Gymbaroo. The founder of the company, as you can see is Margaret Sasse and her company name is Toddler Kindy.Also enclosed is a photocopy of my appointment calendar for Monday, February 14, 1983, which indicates Margaret Sasse visited me from 10:00 to about 11:00 a.m. at our offices in Burlingame. She had called me the previous week from Los Angeles where she had observed some Gymboree centers and wanted to meet with me on her way back to Australia. She advised she was interested in starting this type of business and would consider a Gymboree franchise. I gave her some basic brochures about the Gymboree program. I believe there was a memorandum written of that visit. As of today, I cannot locate it in the file. If I do, I will send a copy to you.This will confirm our conversation yesterday for you to proceed immediately to complete the registration of the Gymboree trademarks in the five categories for Australia. If you need a waiver from our franchisee David Graham, you or your Sidney [sic] office should contact D. Flamming at Elliot, Stubs & Bonutto, the Graham’s [sic] solicitors and attorneys at 40 Queens Street, Brisbane, Australia telephone 221-3300.You should also explore how we may stop or at the least limit the use by Toddler Kindy of the name Gymbaroo once our trademarks are registered.Sincerely,”(emphasis added)

Decision

Reasons for decision

The claim based on passing off would not lead to a materially different result than that emerging from the claim for relief based on the TP Act and, accordingly, it is unnecessary to deal with that claim in detail.Conclusion I presently have the impression, particularly from the evidence of Mrs Sharpe and Mrs Sasse (which I need not now detail) that these proceedings were instituted almost by happenchance. I also gained the impression during directions hearings that there was, at times, a real interest on the part of those involved to resolve, by agreement, all issues between them and no particular interest in the proceedings continuing. However they have. Whether, at this late stage, there is any prospect of the matter settling I do not know. However I propose to give the parties 21 days to consider that issue and, in the meantime, for the parties to bring in orders to give effect to these reasons. During that period any submissions on costs should be filed and served by all parties and filed no later than 14 days after the date of the publication of these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established