Re: VISA INTERNATIONAL SERVICE ASSOCIATION
And: BEISER CORPORATION PTY. LIMITED; MARK BEISER; JACK BEISER
No. G167 of 1983
Trade Practices
COURT
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Beaumont J.
CATCHWORDS
Trade Practices - Application for suspension of operation of interim injunction restraining respondents from using the word "Visa" in connection with business name - Application to use word "Visa" with disclaimer of association - Consideration of effectiveness of disclaimer - Consideration of balance of convenience - Mitigation of interim loss of goodwill.
Trade Practices Act, s.52
Travel Agents Act, 1973 (N.S.W.)
HEARING
SYDNEY
#DATE 16:8:1983
ORDER
1. I grant leave to the first respondent to use the name "World Visa Travel Service" in connection with its registration as a travel agent under the provisions of the Travel Agents Act, 1973 (N.S.W.) or under any similar legislation and in connection with its accreditation with International Air Transport Association ("I.A.T.A."). Leave is otherwise refused.
2. I suspend the operation of the injunction (being Order 1 made on 25 July, 1983) up to and including 22 August, 1983.
3. I order that the costs of this application be the applicant's costs in the proceedings.
4. I fix 16 August, 1983 as the date within twenty one days after which any notice of appeal shall be filed and served for the purposes of Order 52 Rule 15(1)(a)(iii).
JUDGE1
In the principal proceedings in this matter on 25 July, 1983, I granted an interim injunction, pending a final hearing, restraining the respondents from using the word "Visa" in or in connection with their business name without the consent of the applicant or the leave of the Court. The operation of the injunction was suspended until 12 August, 1983. I reserved to any party general liberty to apply and I further reserved to the respondents specific liberty to apply in respect of the further suspension of the operation of the injunction. Pursuant to the leave reserved to them, the respondents have filed a notice of motion seeking the leave of the Court to use the name "World Visa Travel Service" provided that the words "not associated with Visa International Service Association" appear immediately beneath the said name wherever that name may be used by the respondents.
The present application has, to some degree, involved an attempt by the respondents to agitate again matters determined adversely to them upon the application for interlocutory relief. In particular, the respondents again submitted that the appropriate interim relief, if any, in the present case would be the grant of a limited injunction which restrained the use of the word "Visa" except where it clearly distinguished its business from that of the applicant.
In my earlier judgment, I referred to the difficulties of correcting first impressions in this context (at p.13). I had in mind the evidence proferred at the time of proposed additions to the letterhead of the first respondent. That evidence failed to convince me then, as it does now, that members…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Visa International Service Association v Beiser Corporation... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1983] FCA 214
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
1. I grant leave to the first respondent to use the name "World Visa Travel Service" in connection with its registration as a travel agent under the provisions of the Travel Agents Act, 1973 (N.S.W.) or under any similar legislation and in connection with its accreditation with International Air Transport Association ("I.A.T.A."). Leave is otherwise refused.
2. I suspend the operation of the injunction (being Order 1 made on 25 July, 1983) up to and including 22 August, 1983.
3. I order that the costs of this application be the applicant's costs in the proceedings.
4. I fix 16 August, 1983 as the date within twenty one days after which any notice of appeal shall be filed and served for the purposes of Order 52 Rule 15(1)(a)(iii).
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi