Moroccanoil Israel Ltd v Aldi Foods Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Moroccanoil Israel Ltd v Aldi Foods Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 823

File number: NSD 613 of 2015
NSD 1297 of 2015
Judge: KATZMANN J
Date of judgment: 31 August 2017
Catchwords:

TRADE MARKS — trade mark infringement — whether respondents’ use of Moroccan Argan Oil in relation to hair care products and tools is use as a trade mark — whether Moroccan Argan Oil deceptively similar to either or both of applicant’s registered marks — whether hair brushes and hair tools are goods of the same description as the goods in respect of which applicant’s trade marks are registered — whether use of Moroccan Argan Oil not likely to deceive or cause confusion

TRADE MARKS — cross-claim for rectification of Register — whether either or both of applicant’s registered trade marks inherently adapted to distinguish its goods from the goods or services of other persons — whether either or both of applicant’s registered trade marks to some extent inherently adapted to distinguish its goods — whether, because of extent to which the registered trade marks are inherently adapted to distinguish designated goods, their use or intended use and any other circumstances, they do or will distinguish designated goods as applicant’s goods

TRADE MARKS — appeal from decision of delegate of Registrar of Trade Marks — opposition to registration of word mark moroccanoil — whether mark inherently adapted to distinguish applicant’s goods at time of application — ordinary signification of mark — whether mark merely descriptive — whether mark to some extent inherently adapted to distinguish goods — whether, because of extent to which mark inherently adapted to distinguish designated goods, their use or intended use and any other circumstances, it does or will distinguish designated goods as applicant’s goods

CONSUMER LAW — misleading or deceptive conduct — get-up and packaging of hair care products and tools — extent of applicant’s reputation — whether name and get-up of respondents’ goods misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive consumers — significance of evidence of confusion or deception

CONSUMER LAW — misleading or deceptive conduct — false or misleading representations —  naturals — whether use of naturals in branding of hair care products amounts to a representation that products contain substantially natural ingredients — whether representation false, or misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive

CONSUMER LAW — misleading or deceptive conduct — false or misleading representations —  argan oil — whether references to argan oil on product packaging amount to representation that argan oil makes a material contribution to alleged product benefits — whether representation made that argan oil infused in hair brushes and hair tools makes a material contribution to alleged product benefits — if so, whether representation false, or misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive

EVIDENCE — tendency evidence — whether reasonable notice given of intention to rely on tendency evidence — whether evidence of significant probative value

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2 (Australian Consumer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moroccanoil Israel Ltd v Aldi Foods Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 823
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Moroccanoil Israel Ltd v Aldi Foods Pty Ltd was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, where Moroccanoil Israel Ltd (MIL) brought claims against Aldi Foods Pty Ltd for trade mark infringement, misleading or deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), and passing off. MIL, an Israeli company, produces and sells hair care products globally, including in Australia, and is the registered proprietor of two Australian trade marks for Moroccanoil. Aldi Foods Pty Ltd, an Australian company, sells a range of hair care products and tools under the brand name Moroccan Argan Oil. MIL's claims included that Aldi's use of the term "Moroccan Argan Oil" in relation to its hair care products and tools was an infringement of its registered trade marks, and that the branding and get-up of Aldi's products were misleading or deceptive under the ACL, as well as a passing off action.

The legal issues in the case encompassed whether Aldi's use of "Moroccan Argan Oil" was deceptively similar to MIL's trade marks, whether the hair brushes and tools were goods of the same description as those for which MIL's trade marks were registered, and whether the use of "Moroccan Argan Oil" was likely to deceive or cause confusion. Additionally, the court had to determine whether MIL's trade marks were inherently adapted to distinguish its goods and whether they were to some extent inherently adapted to distinguish its goods, and if so, whether they did or would distinguish the goods as MIL's. The court also examined whether the representations made by Aldi in relation to the naturalness and effectiveness of its products were misleading or deceptive under the ACL.

The Federal Court held that Aldi's use of "Moroccan Argan Oil" was not deceptively similar to MIL's registered trade marks, and that the hair brushes and tools were not goods of the same description as those for which MIL's trade marks were registered. Consequently, the trade mark infringement claim was dismissed. Regarding the ACL claims, the court found that while the branding and get-up of Aldi's products did not constitute misleading or deceptive conduct, the use of the term "naturals" was misleading as it implied that the products contained substantially natural ingredients, which was not the case. Furthermore, Aldi's claims about the performance benefits of its products, particularly the contribution of argan oil, were found to be misleading since the amount of argan oil used was insufficient to substantiate the claims. The passing off claim was also dismissed. The cross-claim for rectification of the Register was partially allowed, with certain goods being removed from the registration of MIL's trade marks.

The court allowed the appeal against the Registrar's decision to oppose the registration of MIL's trade mark "moroccanoil", finding that the mark was to some extent inherently adapted to distinguish MIL's goods and that it did distinguish the designated goods because of the extent of MIL's use of the mark in Australia prior to the application date. The court set aside the Registrar's decision, dismissed Aldi's notice of opposition, and ordered the registration of the trade mark "moroccanoil". The court also ordered Aldi to pay MIL's costs of the appeal and the opposition proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The decision of the Registrar given by her delegate on 9 October 2015 be set aside.

3. The respondent’s notice of opposition to the applicant’s Australian trade mark application no. 1463962 be dismissed.

4. The applicant’s trade mark, moroccanoil, proceed to registration.

5. The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the appeal and of the opposition proceeding below.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

I shall deal first with the trade marks infringement case and cross-claim, then the ACL and passing off case, and finally the appeal. But before doing so, it is necessary to set out some salient facts. THE FACTS Some of the facts are agreed, some are not in dispute. Unless otherwise indicated, the summary below is uncontroversial. The MIL Business MIL is an Israeli company. Since about late 2007, it has produced and sold hair care products in Israel, and, through distributors, in various other countries including Australia. In Australia sales of MIL products are effected exclusively through Privity Pty Ltd, trading as Haircare Australia. As at the time of the hearing the products were distributed to approximately 4,012 accounts. As at 21 August 2015 there were 24 active authorised online resellers in Australia. MIL’s products have been marketed and advertised in Australia by various means including: since about January 2013, through MIL’s websites ( and since about July 2012, on MIL’s Facebook page; by press releases sent by email to subscribers; in print and online media publications; and in editorial articles in print and online media publications. Publications in which advertisements have been placed in Australia and overseas include: Vogue, Instyle, Harper’s Bazaar, Elle, Russh, Marie Claire and L’Officiel.The MIL Trade Marks MIL is the registered proprietor of two Australian trade marks. The First Trade Mark bears the registration number 1221017. It has a priority date of 24 January 2008. It looks like this: The Second Trade Mark bears the registered number 1375954. It has a priority date of 4 August 2010. It looks like this: Both the First and Second Trade Marks are registered in class 3 in relation to the following goods: Hair care products, including oil, mask, moisture cream, curly hair moisture cream, curly hair mask, curly and damaged hair mask, rassoul mask, argan and saffron shampoo, hair loss shampoo, dandruff shampoo, dry hair shampoo, hair loss ampoules, dandruff ampoules, gel, glisten spray, mousse, conditioner, hair spray; skin care products in this class; skin cleansers; skin toners; skin moisturizers; anti-aging cream; eye cream; beauty masks; body creams; hand creams; non-medicated foot cream; eye makeup; foundation makeup; lip liner, lipsticks and lip balms; eyeliners; blushes; eye shadow; nail enamels; toiletries and cosmetics including shaving preparations, shaving creams and soaps, after shave creams and lotions, body massage creams and oils, soaps, bath oils and shower gels, talcum powders; antiperspirants; dentifrices; sunscreen and suntan oils and creams; fragrances in this class, including perfumes, colognes, essences and essential oils. (Emphasis added.) In the period between their respective filing dates and 15 August 2015, however, MIL did not use either the First Trade Mark or the Second Trade Mark in respect of any of the goods emphasised in the previous paragraph. On 7 December 2011 MIL filed an application to register the word mark moroccanoil (the Third Trade Mark).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The final piece of evidence upon which MIL relies to establish confusion came from Ms Fogarty. On or around 23 September 2015 she was using the MIL Oil Treatment on a client’s hair. When she asked the client whether she had used it before, the client told her she had and that she had bought it from Aldi. Although she had a clear memory of the discussion with the client, she could not identify her and, since the client had not previously attended the salon and had not made an appointment, she had no documents to assist her recollection in this respect. The expert evidence Expert evidence was adduced in three specialist areas: lexicography, marketing, and industrial chemistry. With the exception of the lexicographers who were prevented by logistical difficulties from doing so, the expert witnesses in each field testified in concurrent session. The two lexicographers, Ghil’ad Zuckermann and Susan Butler, gave evidence touching upon the use of the terms “Moroccanoil” and “Moroccan Oil” as at the priority dates for the three MIL trade marks. A summary of Professor Zuckermann and Ms Butler’s experience and qualifications is set out below at [606] and [607] respectively. Four marketing experts gave evidence about marketing practices and consumer behaviour. MIL adduced evidence from Mr Paul Blanket and Professor Pascale Quester. It would be fair to describe Mr Blanket as a marketing practitioner and Professor Quester as a marketing academic. Mr Blanket is the principal of the company First Impressions Pty Ltd, which, since 1987, has carried on business providing marketing, advertising and promotional consulting services to industry and government. Mr Blanket has a both a Bachelor and a Master of Commerce Degree (Marketing) from the University of New South Wales and completed the University of Melbourne’s Management Program as well as the FCB Advanced Advertising Program in Chicago run by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). He is also a Fellow of the Australian Marketing Institute and is a Certified Practising Marketer. Mr Blanket formerly worked as a Group Account Director with the advertising agency Foote, Cone & Belding, and has worked in various marketing positions at Unilever Australia Pty Ltd. He described his work as involving advising on the development of new products and brands or “repositioning” an existing product or brand in a particular market. As part of his commercial experience, Mr Blanket was involved in or commissioned approximately 100 qualitative and quantitative research studies for brands such as British Airways, Vitasoy, Melitta Coffee, New Zealand Natural Ice Cream, Randstad Recruitment, Australian Egg Corporation and Waste Service New South Wales. Mr Blanket is also a lecturer in advertising and marketing at the Macquarie Graduate School of Management, having lectured in various courses since 1992 including “Advertising and Promotions Management” and “Marketing Management”. Professor Quester is the inaugural Professor of Marketing and Head of Discipline (Marketing) in the School of Commerce (now the Adelaide Business School) at the University of Adelaide. She holds a Bachelor of Business Administration from Audencia in Nantes, one of the top three business schools in France, a Master of Arts in Marketing from Ohio State University in the United States of America, and a PhD in Marketing from Massey University in Palmerston North, New Zealand. She is also a Certified Practising Marketer, a Fellow of the Australian Marketing Institute, a Distinguished Fellow of the Australia and New Zealand Academy of Marketing, and Founder of the Franco-Australian Centre for International Research in Marketing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In view of my finding in relation to s 41(5), it is unnecessary to answer this question. If I be wrong, however, in my conclusion that the word mark is to some extent inherently adapted to distinguish MIL’s hair products from the goods or services of other persons, I would nonetheless hold that it does in fact distinguish the designated goods because of the extent to which MIL used the mark in Australia before 7 December 2011.Conclusion The appeal should be allowed, the decision of the Registrar (by her delegate) set aside, the notice of opposition dismissed, and the Third Trade Mark should proceed to registration.SUMMARY OF FINDINGS In summary, I would dismiss the trade mark infringement suit. Although I have found that Aldi has used the sign “Moroccan Argan Oil” as a trade mark, I am not satisfied that that sign, as used, is deceptively similar to either the First or Second Trade Mark. In relation to the claims brought under the ACL and for passing off, I have come to the following conclusions:(1)The first ACL claim, based on the branding and get-up of the Aldi Product Range, should be dismissed. I am not satisfied that any of the pleaded representations were made. As the passing off claim is based on the same allegations, it, too, must be dismissed.(2)The second ACL claim, based on the use of the word “naturals” is made out in part. The ordinary or reasonable consumer in the market for hair care products would take the reference to “naturals” on Aldi’s products to signify that they contain at least substantially natural products when, in the case of some of the products — water apart — they do not. In these circumstances, it was and is misleading for Aldi to represent, through its branding, that the Aldi Oil Treatment, the Shampoo and the Dry Shampoo were and are “naturals”.(3)The third ACL claim, based on the claimed performance benefits of various products in Aldi’s Product Range, is made out in full. Aldi represented that argan oil made a material contribution to the performance benefits of the products in circumstances where the amount of argan oil used in the manufacturing process was so small that it could not make a material contribution to the performance of the products. The cross-claim for rectification of the Register should be allowed in part. The First Trade Mark should be removed from the Register in relation to all the Non-Use Goods, having regard first, to the lengthy period since registration when it has not been used in relation to those goods, secondly, to the evidence indicating that MIL has no intention of using it upon or in relation to them, and thirdly, to the absence of use of that mark upon or in relation to MIL’s skin care products since they were introduced to the US market in 2012. The Second Trade Mark should not be removed from the Register in relation to the skin care, facial products, and fragrances but, I am not satisfied that it is not reasonable to remove the Second Trade Mark from the Register in relation to “shaving preparations, shaving creams and soaps, after shave creams and lotions”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

No order for corrective advertising was sought in the originating application or its later iterations, including the Second Further Amended Originating Application, which set out MIL’s final claim for relief, or in any version of MIL’s pleading. No application was made for leave to amend the Second Further Amended Originating Application to seek such an order. Nor was the question of corrective advertising raised at any time during the hearing, either by MIL or the Court. If MIL truly considered that an order of this nature was necessary or justified, it would have been included in the orders sought in the Second Further Amended Originating Application. Furthermore, an order for corrective advertising is not an order giving effect to the Court’s reasons. In all these circumstances, I decline to make it. Agreed declarations and orders With certain qualifications, I am satisfied that the declarations and other orders the parties are now agreed upon are appropriate. I have made some changes in form, but not substance. The only matter of substance concerns declaration 2. The parties’ proposed declaration relating to the Natural Representations does not strictly reflect my reasons. I did not find that the Natural Representations were false. Rather, I found at [485] that the representations were misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive.