Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd v Ubisoft Entertainment, Societe Anonyme

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd to extension of protection of International Registration Designating Australia 1819967 (International Registration: 1328045) (Class 9, 28, 41) - FOR HONOR - in the name of UBISOFT ENTERTAINMENT, Societe Anonyme.

Delegate: Aaron Walters
Representation: Opponent: No Submissions
Holder: No Submissions
Decision: 2019 ATMO 54
Trade Marks Act 1995 and Trade Marks Regulations 1995 - Regulation 17A.33 opposition to protection under ss 42(b), 44, 58, 59 and 60 – s 44 partially established for some goods – no other ground established.

Background

  1. On 25 November 2015, UBISOFT ENTERTAINMENT, Societe Anonyme (‘the Holder’) filed an application under the Madrid Protocol to extend to Australia the protection of International Registration 1328045. Such an application in known as an International Registration Designating Australia (‘IRDA’). Details of the IRDA are as follows:

    IRDA number: 1819967

    IR Number: 1328045

    Trade Mark:

    (‘the Trade Mark’)

    Class 9:

    Apparatus for recording, transmitting, receiving, reproducing and processing sound and images; magnetic, optical, digital and electronic recording media; magnetic, optical and digital disks; computer programs; digital personal assistants, computer memories; printed circuits; computers; computer peripheral devices, namely screens, keyboard, control consoles and levers, magnetic, optical and digital disk and diskette drives; telephony and telecommunication apparatus; recorded computer programs; computer game software; software (recorded programs); computer software for playing video games, computer games and on-line games; interactive multimedia software; computer software on mobile telephones and tablet personal computers; magnetic, optical and digital media for computer programs; CD-ROMs; compact discs; computer games; downloadable electronic publications; software containing music and soundtracks from cinematographic films; cinematographic films; mouse pads; component parts for all the aforesaid goods

    Class 28:

    Apparatus for electronic games other than those designed for use with television receivers only; audiovisual games on computer platforms; action figures; miniature figures; board games; dolls; clothing for dolls; automatic game machines other than prepaid ones and those for use solely with a television set; toys, coin-operated games, playing cards; electronic game consoles; game apparatus designed for use with a television set; video and audio games

    Class 41:

    Education; teaching; tuition; training; entertainment; sporting and cultural activities; organization of competitions relating to video games, education and/or entertainment; organization and conducting of colloquiums, conferences, congresses, organization of exhibitions for cultural or educational purposes; organization of exhibitions in the field of entertainment; editing of entertainment, educational and teaching texts; publication of press magazines, publication of newspapers, editing of books, editing of newspapers, editing of magazines, publication of books; training services relating to information and telecommunication technologies, information services on on-line computer games and other on-line entertainment; game services provided online (from a computer network); game services via cellular telephones; game services via mobile telephones or for use thereon; film production (other than advertisements), shows, film studios, rental of films, rental of video and sound recordings; entertainment services in the form of an amusement park, namely a themed area; amusement park and theme park services; operation of fairground…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd v Ubisoft Entertainment, Societe... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] ATMO 54
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court concerned an opposition by Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd (the Opponent) to the registration of trade marks by Ubisoft Entertainment, Societe Anonyme. The dispute centred on whether the Opponent's trade marks, specifically those featuring the word ‘HONOR’, were sufficiently similar to Ubisoft's proposed marks and whether the goods and services were closely related, as required by section 44 of the relevant Act. The court was required to determine the rights of the parties as at the Convention Priority Date of 11 June 2015.

The primary legal issue was whether the Opponent had established grounds for opposition under section 44 of the Act, which requires a demonstration that the applicant's trade mark is identical or deceptively similar to an earlier trade mark owned by the Opponent, and that the goods or services for which registration is sought are closely related to the goods or services in respect of which the earlier trade mark is registered. The court also considered whether the Opponent had adequately discharged the onus of proof, resting on the civil standard of the balance of probabilities, to establish this close relationship.

The court reasoned that while the Opponent owned a suite of ‘HONOR’ trade marks, the evidence presented did not adequately establish the necessary close relationship between the Opponent's registered services and Ubisoft's proposed goods. The Opponent relied on evidence of a third-party retailer, JB Hi-Fi, marketing and retailing its products, and third-party reviews of its smartphones. However, the court found that this evidence did not demonstrate that the services for which the Opponent's trade marks were registered were closely related to the goods for which Ubisoft sought registration. The court distinguished between the registration of services for advertising and marketing generally, and the specific goods or services in respect of which those services might be supplied.

Ultimately, the court found that the Opponent had failed to establish the grounds of opposition under section 44 of the Act. Consequently, the opposition was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The onus of proof rests with the Opponent,[3] the standard being the civil standard on the balance of probabilities.[4] The rights of the parties are generally determined as at the date of filing of the application.[5] Here, however, a right of priority is claimed as per reg 17A.15 of the Regulations, rendering the rights of the parties being determined as at the Convention Priority Date, being 11 June 2015 (‘the relevant date’). [3] Food Channel Network Pty Ltd v Television Food Network GP [2010] FCAFC 58, [32].[4] Pfizer Products Inc v Karam [2006] FCA 1663; Telstra Corporation Limited v Phone Directories Company Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 156, [132].[5] Southern Cross Refrigerating Co v Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd [1953] HCA 73.The EvidenceThe Yafang Declaration The Opponent owns a suite of trade marks featuring the word ‘HONOR’, either solus or in combination with some form of additional material. Of the 20 trade marks detailed, only two trade mark registrations, being 1633444 and 1645168, have a priority date earlier than that of the relevant date. I have reproduced these below: Mr Yafang states the HONOR trade mark was first used in 2015.[6] I suspect this is intended to mean first used in Australia, though it is not specifically mentioned. Mr Yafang continues to state:The main retailer of [the Opponent’s] HONOR smart and mobile phones and associated goods in Australia is JB Hi-Fi, which is Australia’s largest home entertainment retailer.Attached and marked Exhibit-1 is a HUAWEI and JB Hi-Fi open channel report from 29 July to 22 October 2015, which provides details of the use of the HONOR trade mark.[7] [6] The Yafang Declaration, paragraph 5. [7] Ibid, paragraph 7-8. Exhibit-1 receives no further comment and segments of the exhibit itself are pixelated to the point of being illegible. From what is legible, it appears to me to be a report outlining the manner in which JB Hi-Fi advertised and marketed the Opponent’s products between July 2015 and October 2015, both instore and external advertisement media (‘the JBHF Report’). Perusing the contents, it is quickly apparent the JBHF report details a range of the Opponent’s products, not just those provided under the HONOR brand, and I observe much of the focus is on the HUAWEI P8 branded smart phone. I am able to identify the following references specific to the relevant registered Trade Marks:and; The JBHF Report also contains a graph entitled “Retail Sell Out” which appears to track, amongst other products, the “HUAWEI Honor 4X Black Outright Handset” over a period of 17 weeks. However, without further explanation I cannot be certain if this refers to product sales, or, even if such is the case, the specific quantity of products sold. On the topic of sales, the Yafang Declaration attaches Confidential Exhibit-2 described as the sale revenue for products bearing the HONOR trade mark in Australia.[8] Confidential Exhibit-2 simply contains a lump amount and it is not clear whether this is the total sales since 2015, or for a single financial year, prior to the relevant date. The Weir Declaration[8] The Yafang Declaration, paragraph 9.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Opponent has failed to establish the grounds of opposition under s 59 of the Act. Decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I acknowledge the Opponent has also registered services specific to the advertising or retailing of communication products. However, I would further highlight his Honour’s reasoning at [129]:The appellant’s registration of the 1984 kangaroo/tail fin mark for “advertising, marketing and merchandising services” is for those services as a class of services, and nothing else. It is not a registration for the goods or services in respect of which the services of advertising, marketing and merchandising using the 1984 kangaroo/tail fin mark might be supplied or provided. This is an important conceptual distinction to be borne in mind. This is the reason why, for the purposes of s 44(1) of the Act, it is necessary for the appellant to establish that its services (in respect of which the 1984 kangaroo/tail fin mark is registered) and the respondent’s goods (for which registration is sought) are “closely related”. [Emphasis added] The Opponent has made no attempt to establish any such relationship. Instead, the Yafang Declaration states JB Hi-Fi, a third party retailer, is the main retailer of the Opponent’s HONOR branded products. The accompanying JBHF Report shows a broad range of the Opponent’s goods being made available and promoted throughout JB Hi-Fi stores. The Weir Declaration suggests JB Hi-Fi has been retailing the Opponent’s goods since 2012. Relatedly, the CNET Reviews, published by a third party publisher, go into great detail regarding the Opponent’s smartphones, including technical specifications and information on performance and functionality, as well as how the Opponent’s smartphone compares to other devices. Noting too the CNET Reviews contain links to articles on a number of other devices from other manufactures, I presume the purpose of such reviews is to educate, inform and, in some ways, promote to consumers the products subject of the review. Such evidence indicates the services of a third party are the primary point at which a potential consumer is exposed to the retailing or promoting of the Opponent’s products, or is educated or informed in its capabilities.[42] Absent any further information available to me, I do not find the Opponent has adequately established the relationship between the goods and services should be designated as “closely related”. Conclusion in respect of section 44[42] Cf. Christian v Société Des Produits Nestlé SA (No 2) [2015] FCAFC 153, [93]-[94], where the Full Federal Court considered it unremarkable that the primary judge, having considered French J’s analysis in Woolworths, should conclude health and nutrition products were closely related to services for the instruction, education and information in relation to health and nutrition as “one of the functions for which the services are registered is the recommendation of the type of goods (supplements) to be used by the consumer, [is] a service likely to be provided at the same time as the goods are supplied, or combination with the supply.”