Bohemia Crystal Pty Ltd v Host Corporation Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bohemia Crystal Pty Ltd v Host Corporation Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 235

File number: NSD 495 of 2016
Judge: BURLEY J
Date of judgment: 6 March 2018
Catchwords:

TRADE MARKS – cross-claim for revocation of trade marks pursuant to ss 41 and 88 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – whether marks capable of distinguishing the relevant goods or services – trade marks not inherently adapted to distinguish – insufficient use to distinguish the designated goods from the goods of others – trade marks to be revoked

TRADE MARKS – whether trade marks “BOHEMIA” and “BOHEMIA CRYSTAL” infringed pursuant to s 120 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – whether marks used as a trade mark or to describe geographical origin and quality of goods – whether marks used in good faith pursuant to s 122 – infringement found in some cases

CONSUMER LAW – misleading or deceptive conduct in contravention of ss 18 and/or 29 of the Australian Consumer Law – whether various impugned uses amounted to the making of misrepresentations – held no contravention of the Australian Consumer Law

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Schedule 2, ss 18, 29

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) ss 7, 17, 24, 41, 87, 88, 120, 122, 126

Cases cited:

Anchorage Capital Partners Pty Ltd v ACPA Pty Ltd (No 3) [2015] FCA 1436; (2015) 331 ALR 512

Anchorage Capital Partners Pty Ltd v ACPA Pty Ltd [2018] FCAFC 6

Anheuser-Busch, Inc v Budějovický Budvar, Národní Podnik [2002] FCA 390; (2002) 56 IPR 182

Apple Inc. v Registrar of Trade Marks [2014] FCA 1304; (2014) FCR 511

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dukemaster Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 682; (2009) ATPR 42-290

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 54; (2013) 250 CLR 640

Australian Health & Nutrition Association Limited trading as Sanitarium Health Food Company v Irrewarra Estate Pty Ltd trading as Irrewarra Sourdough [2012] FCA 592; (2012) 292 ALR 101

Baume & Coy Ltd v Moore (A H) Ltd [1958] RPC 226

Bavaria NV v Bayerischer Brauerbund eV [2009] FCA 428; (2009) 177 FCR 300

Blount Inc v Registrar of Trade Marks [1998] FCA 440; (1998) 83 FCR 50

British Sugar plc v James Robertson & Sons Ltd [1996] RPC 281

Britt Allcroft (Thomas) LLC v Miller (t/as the Thomas Shop) [2000] FCA 255; (2000) 49 IPR 7

Cadbury Schweppes Pty Ltd v Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Ltd (No 4) [2006] FCA 446; (2006) 69 IPR 23

Cadbury Schweppes Pty Ltd v Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Ltd [2007] FCAFC 70; (2007) 72 IPR 261

Campomar Sociedad, Limitada v Nike International Limited [2000] HCA 12; (2000) 202 CLR 45

Cantarella Bros Pty Ltd v Modena Trading Pty Ltd [2014] HCA 48; (2014) 254 CLR 337

Clark Equipment Co v Registrar of Trade Marks [1964] HCA 55; (1964) 111 CLR 511

Coca-Cola…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bohemia Crystal Pty Ltd v Host Corporation Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 235
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court, Bohemia Crystal Pty Ltd (BCP) sought to revoke trade marks owned by Host Corporation Pty Ltd (Host) and to establish that certain uses by Host of the term "Bohemia" constituted infringement and misleading or deceptive conduct. The primary dispute centred around the distinctiveness of the trade marks "BOHEMIA" and "BOHEMIA CRYSTAL" and whether Host's use of these terms infringed upon BCP's rights and/or constituted misleading or deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The court had to determine whether the marks were inherently adapted to distinguish the goods and if they had been used in a way that distinguished them from other goods. Additionally, the court examined whether Host's use of the term "Bohemia" amounted to trademark infringement or misleading or deceptive conduct.

The court found that neither the "BOHEMIA" nor the "BOHEMIA CRYSTAL" trade marks were capable of distinguishing the goods in question from those of other persons. The marks were not inherently adapted to distinguish the goods, and there was insufficient evidence to demonstrate that they had been used to distinguish Host's goods. Consequently, the court concluded that the registrations of these trade marks should be cancelled. The court also found that some of Host's uses of the term "Bohemia" constituted trademark infringement, while others did not. No use by Host was found to contravene the ACL.

The court's decision was based on a detailed analysis of the evidence provided by both parties, including dictionary definitions and expert testimony. The court emphasised the importance of the distinctiveness of trade marks and the need for continuous use to maintain their distinctive character. The court also highlighted the need for clarity in the representation made by the use of a term to determine whether it constitutes trademark infringement or misleading or deceptive conduct.

The final orders required the parties to endeavour to agree on the appropriate form of orders, including costs, within 14 days. If an agreement could not be reached, the parties were to notify the Court of their respective contentions and provide written submissions within 21 days. The entry of orders was to be dealt with in accordance with Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 14 days of the date of this order, the parties endeavour to agree as to the appropriate form of orders (including as to costs) to be made reflecting the conclusions expressed in these reasons. If no agreement is reached, the parties are within 21 days of the date of this order to notify the Court as to the orders for which they each contend and supply written submissions of no more than 5 pages in length addressing their respective contentions and indicating whether they desire to be heard on the issues addressed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The parties adduced a significant body of evidence relating to the meaning to be ascribed to the terms “Bohemia” and “Bohemia Crystal”. Set out below is a summary of the evidence and my findings in this regard. The agreed facts There is no dispute between the parties that there is a region in what is now known as the Czech Republic (or, more recently “Czechia”) that was known as “Bohemia” and that glassware was produced in that region. Nor is there any dispute as to the meaning of “crystal” in the context of glass. Specifically, the parties agreed to the following facts in an Agreed Statement of Facts. First, that “glass” is a term that includes normal glassware and fine quality glassware known as crystal (which contains lead oxide and other materials to enhance strength and malleability) and other fine quality glassware that contains a variety of additional materials, including lead, to enhance brilliance or other features of the glass. The term “crystal” refers to clear, colourless glass, but not only lead crystal. Accordingly, while there may be a tendency to use “crystal” to refer to high quality glassware, and “glass” to refer to normal quality glassware, the terms may be interchanged to refer to any sort of clear glass product. Secondly, glass and crystal products were manufactured for several hundred years in a region known, prior to 1914, as Bohemia. It is now part of the Czech Republic. Thirdly, from about the 16th century the generic geographic descriptive terms “Bohemian Crystal” and “Bohemian Glass” were used by various manufacturers in the region then known as Bohemia to indicate that their products had been manufactured in that region so as to distinguish them from glass coming from other parts of the world. Fourthly, from 1925 until about the start of World War II (in 1939), the terms “Bohemian Crystal” and “Bohemian Glass” were also used to refer to a particular Art Deco style of highly decorative and colourful glassware.An admission In [10] and [11] of its Defence to the Cross-Claim, BCP states the following “in further answer” to the Statement of Cross-Claim as a whole:(b) [BCP] says that prior to about 1975 [each of the Bohemia marks] was not to any extent inherently adapted to distinguish the designated goods of the cross-respondent from the goods of other persons;The defence goes on to say that because of the extent to which BCP used those trade marks, it did as at the relevant dates distinguish the relevant goods as being those of BCP. The Australian evidence The parties tendered and draw attention to a number of dictionary definitions of the word “Bohemia” and “Bohemian”. The Macquarie Dictionary, 3rd edition, 1997 provides the following:bohemia … noun a social milieu in which a bohemian atmosphere is prevalent. …Bohemia … noun a region in the Czech Republic in the western part; in the Middle Ages an independent kingdom, later part of the Austrian Empire (1526 – 1918); …Bohemian … 1 a person with artistic or intellectual tendencies or pretensions who lives and acts without regard for conventional rules of behaviour…2 a gipsy – adjective 3 relating to or characteristic of bohemians [from BOHEMIA, in medieval times thought of as the original home of the gipsies]Bohemian Forest …a low forest-covered mountain range on the boundary between the south-western part of the Czech Republic and south-eastern Germany…

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In [10] and [11] of its Defence to the Cross-Claim, BCP states the following “in further answer” to the Statement of Cross-Claim as a whole:(b) [BCP] says that prior to about 1975 [each of the Bohemia marks] was not to any extent inherently adapted to distinguish the designated goods of the cross-respondent from the goods of other persons;The defence goes on to say that because of the extent to which BCP used those trade marks, it did as at the relevant dates distinguish the relevant goods as being those of BCP. The Australian evidence The parties tendered and draw attention to a number of dictionary definitions of the word “Bohemia” and “Bohemian”. The Macquarie Dictionary, 3rd edition, 1997 provides the following:bohemia … noun a social milieu in which a bohemian atmosphere is prevalent. …Bohemia … noun a region in the Czech Republic in the western part; in the Middle Ages an independent kingdom, later part of the Austrian Empire (1526 – 1918); …Bohemian … 1 a person with artistic or intellectual tendencies or pretensions who lives and acts without regard for conventional rules of behaviour…2 a gipsy – adjective 3 relating to or characteristic of bohemians [from BOHEMIA, in medieval times thought of as the original home of the gipsies]Bohemian Forest …a low forest-covered mountain range on the boundary between the south-western part of the Czech Republic and south-eastern Germany… For the capitalised word “Bohemian” the Macquarie Dictionary, 6th edition, 2013 provides:Bohemian … 1. a native or inhabitant of Bohemia. 2. The Czech language – adj. 3. relating to Bohemia, its people or their language. For the word “bohemian” the same dictionary provides: bohemian … 1. a person with artistic or intellectual tendencies or pretensions who lives and acts without regard for conventional rules of behaviour … 2. a Romani person. – adj. 3. relating to or characteristic of bohemians. [from Bohemia, a region in central Europe, now part of the Czech Republic, in medieval times thought of as the original home of the Gypsies]… The Oxford English Dictionary 2nd edition, 2004, provides the following:Bohemia … 1. A kingdom of central Europe, forming part of the Austrian Empire … 2. Gipsydom … 3. The community of social “Bohemians”, or the district in which they chiefly live . …Bohemian … 1. A native of Bohemia…2. A gipsy. … 3. A gipsy of society; …Bohemian glass, a fine kind of glass, originally made in Bohemia, in which potash is the alkali used. … The Australian Oxford Dictionary, 1st edition, 1999, provides:Bohemia … a region forming the western part of the Czech Republic. Formerly a Slavonic kingdom, it fell under Austrian rule in 1526, and by the Treaty of Versailles in 1919 became a province of the newly formed Czechoslovakia. Prague was the capital of Bohemia from the 14th century.Bohemian … 1. a native of Bohemia. 2. (also bohemian) a socially unconventional person, esp. an artist or writer. adj 1. of, relating to, or characteristic of Bohemia or its people. 2. socially unconventional. …

Decision

Reasons for decision

Host is an importer and supplier of catering goods and equipment that supplies a range of goods including crockery, cutlery, glassware, kitchenware and appliances to the catering trade. It was started in 1999 by Mr Sullivan as a sole trader. In 2003 the business was transferred to Host, and Mr Sullivan became its sole director and secretary. Host conducts its business from premises in Perth and Sydney. It currently offers about 2,500 different product lines.1.3 Summary of conclusions I have found that the cross claim brought by Host succeeds and that the Bohemia marks are liable to be removed from the Register. More particularly, for the reasons set out in section 2 of these reasons, I have found that as at the relevant dates, neither was capable of distinguishing the goods in respect of which they were registered from the goods or services of other persons. In section 3 of these reasons I find that the Register should be rectified by cancelling the registration of each of the Bohemia marks pursuant to subsection 88(1) of the TM Act. In section 4 I note that in light of my conclusion in section 2, it has not been necessary for me to consider the merits of Host’s cross-claim for revocation pursuant to ss 87 and 24 of the TM Act. In deference to the skilfully presented arguments of the parties, and against the prospect that my conclusion in relation to validity of the Bohemia marks is incorrect, I have considered in section 5 whether or not the impugned Host uses would have amounted to infringing trade mark use. In relation to the BOHEMIA mark, I conclude that some, but not all, of the uses would have infringed. In relation to the BOHEMIA CRYSTAL mark, I conclude that none of the impugned uses is substantially identical with or deceptively similar to that mark in accordance with subsection 120(1) of the TM Act. In section 6 I conclude that a defence under subsection 122(1)(b)(i) of the TM Act would not apply in the event that the Host uses did otherwise amount to infringements. In section 7 I consider and reject the claim advanced by BCP for breach of the ACL. In light of my primary findings in relation to liability it has not been necessary to consider the personal liability of Mr Sullivan or BCP’s entitlement to pecuniary or other relief. 1.4 The witnesses The hearing was conducted over 7 days and the evidence of 15 witnesses was read, many of whom were cross-examined. I generally consider that all of the witnesses made a genuine attempt to assist the Court by giving evidence honestly and, where cross-examined, that they frankly answered questions of them. The exceptions to this general finding are identified in these reasons. 1.4.1BCP’s witnesses Paul Hesse has since March 1990 been the managing director of BCP and has worked as an employee with BCP since 1980. Mr Hesse was employed by S. Hoffnung & Company Limited from 1965 to 1980, first as a commercial traveller selling products including glassware and giftware and later as a manager of marketing and promotions for its giftware department. He gives evidence about BCP’s history, BCP’s relationship with Skloexport, action taken by BCP to protect the BCP marks over the years, the conduct of Host, the goods sold by BCP and the channels through which they are sold. He was cross-examined.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

A further distinction is between BCP’s commercial and retail customers. I infer that the former represent a small subset of BCP’s customers. 7.7 Consideration of the impugned uses I now turn to consider each of the impugned uses by Host. The October 2015 catalogue use includes the phrase “Banquet Crystal by Bohemia”. Immediately beneath it is the Banquet logo. At the foot of each page are the words “Buy online – hostdirect.com.au”. The reader will immediately note from this, and the front of the catalogue, that the seller is Host and that Host is promoting a range of products for sale. The products promoted come from a variety of sources. Focussing on the glassware section, which covers pages 2 – 21, it may be seen that a large number of branded products are identified. The brands are generally depicted by logos within rectangular boxes in colouring different to the background colour of the page on which they appear. Brands identified as the supplier of glassware include LIBBEY, ARCOROC, DURALEX and BORMIOLI ROCCO. The logos of these brands sometimes take the appearance of composite trade marks, with stylised features. Also present in the glassware section are plain text references to these brands and promotional tag lines like “Nob Hill Tumblers by Libbey”, “Islande Tumblers by Arcoroc” and “Picardie Tumblers by Duralex – Fully Toughened”. It is apparent that Host also packages glassware, and so (for example) “Host Economy Tumblers” are promoted next to a logo featuring the word “HOST”. The prices advertised indicate that individual glasses may be purchased for approximately $1 each if purchased in lots of 48 (for Host economy tumblers). Other brands of glasses reach a maximum price of $7 per wine glass or flute if purchased by the dozen. The “Banquet Crystal by Bohemia” glasses (which include flutes, wine glasses, beer glasses and tumblers) are advertised at $2 each if bought in quantities of 24. The impression gained from reading the October 2015 catalogue is that it is fairly dense in detail. A typical Host customer is likely to peruse the section relating to the type of product that he or she wishes to buy, consider price and product claim comparisons and then place an order. In my view the representation made by the impugned use in the October 2015 catalogue is that a purchaser can acquire “Banquet Crystal by Bohemia” glassware from Host. Having regard to the use of the Banquet logo, in my view the representation is that the entity that produces the product is called “Banquet Crystal by Bohemia” or “Bohemia”. The analysis is the same whether the October 2015 catalogue use is viewed online or in hard copy. The January 2016 catalogue adopts the same broad format as the October 2015 catalogue, although the impugned use appears on a single page 5 pages into the publication. The banner headline on the page is “Czech Crystal by Bohemia” followed by “Exclusive to HOST outstanding prices”. The Banquet logo appears below the heading. The glasses promoted sell for $2 each and are sold in boxes of 24. Otherwise my broader observations in relation to the October 2015 catalogue use apply equally here.