FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Energy Beverages LLC v Cantarella Bros Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 113
File numbers: NSD 1711 of 2019
NSD 1858 of 2019
NSD 63 of 2021Judgment of: HALLEY J Date of judgment: 18 February 2022 Catchwords: TRADE MARKS – appeal from two decisions of the delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks (delegate) to refuse opposition to application for removal of appellant’s trade marks (MOTHERLAND mark and MOTHER LOADED ICED COFFEE mark, together marks) – hearing de novo – whether appellant had an intention in good faith to use MOTHER LOADED ICED COFFEE mark pursuant to s 92(4)(a) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (Act) – whether appellant had demonstrated genuine commercial use of the MOTHERLAND mark during relevant period pursuant to s 92(4)(b) of the Act – whether facts and circumstances warrant exercise of discretion pursuant to s 101(3) of the Act to allow marks to remain on Register – where no intention in good faith to use MOTHER LOADED ICED COFFEE mark – where no genuine use of MOTHERLAND mark during relevant period – where insufficient facts or circumstances to warrant exercise of discretion – appeal dismissed
TRADE MARKS – appeal from decision of the delegate to refuse opposition to registration application of trade mark by respondent (MOTHERSKY mark) – hearing de novo – whether MOTHERSKY mark is substantially identical or deceptively similar to appellant’s marks or MOTHER marks pursuant to s 44 of the Act – whether goods in registration application are goods of the same description to appellant’s registrations – whether respondent’s use of MOTHERSKY likely to deceive or cause confusion due to appellant’s reputation in MOTHER marks pursuant to s 60 of the Act – where MOTHER marks had acquired a significant reputation in Australia for energy drinks – appeal dismissed
CONSUMER LAW – whether use of the MOTHERSKY mark contrary to law pursuant to ss 19 or 29 of the Australian Consumer Law due to appellant’s reputation in the MOTHER marks – appeal dismissed
Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Schedule 2 (Australian Consumer Law) ss 18, 29
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) ss 42, 44, 52, 60, 92, 101
Cases cited: Accor Australia & New Zealand Hospitality Pty Ltd v Liv Pty Ltd (2017) 124 IPR 264; [2017] FCAFC 56
Advantage-Rent-A-Car Inc v Advantage Car Rental Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 683
Allergan Australia Pty Ltd v Self Care IP Holdings Pty Ltd (2021) 393 ALR 595; [2021] FCAFC 163
Apple Inc v Registrar of Trade Marks (2014) 227 FCR 511; [2014] FCA 1304
Aston v Harlee Manufacturing Co (1960) 103 CLR 391
Austin, Nichols & Co Inc v Lodestar Anstalt (2012) 202 FCR 490; [2012] FCAFC 8
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited (2014) 317 ALR 73; [2014] FCA 634
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd (2013) 250 CLR 640; [2013] HCA 54
Australian Competition…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Energy Beverages LLC v Cantarella Bros Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] FCA 113
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal held that the evidence did not establish that EB had an intention in good faith to use the MOTHER LOADED ICED COFFEE mark or that it had demonstrated genuine commercial use of the MOTHERLAND mark during the relevant period. The Court also held that the facts and circumstances did not warrant the exercise of discretion to allow the marks to remain on the Register. The Court further held that the MOTHERSKY mark was substantially identical or deceptively similar to the other marks owned by EB, and its use was likely to deceive or cause confusion due to EB's reputation in the MOTHER marks.
The Court of Appeal dismissed the amended notice of appeal and ordered that EB pay Cantarella's costs, as taxed or agreed. The Court held that the appeals from the Registrar of Trade Marks were de novo hearings, and the onus was on EB to prove its case on the balance of probabilities. The Court considered the evidence and submissions of both parties and found that EB had not discharged the onus of proof on any of the grounds of appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The amended notice of appeal be dismissed.
2. The appellant is to pay the respondent’s costs, as taxed or agreed.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION
[1]
THE TRADE MARKS
[4]
MOTHERLAND mark
[4]
MOTHER LOADED ICED COFFEE mark
[8]
MOTHERSKY mark
[12]
MOTHER marks
[15]
ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION
[20]
MLIC and MOTHERLAND appeals
[20]
MOTHERSKY appeal
[21]
PRINCIPAL CONCLUSIONS
[25]
PRELIMINARY ISSUES
[26]
Appeals from the Registrar of Trade Marks
[26]
Onus and standard of proof
[36]
THE WITNESSES
[40]
Witnesses for EB
[40]
Witnesses for Canterella
[49]
EVIDENTIARY BACKGROUND
[53]
MOTHER energy drinks
[53]
Cantarella’s coffee products
[56]
Origin of “MOTHERSKY” name
[61]
Distribution channels for MOTHER energy drinks
[62]
Advertising, marketing and promotion of MOTHER energy drinks
[65]
Brand pillars for MOTHER energy drinks
[69]
MOTHER energy drinks brand image
[70]
Promotion of MOTHER energy drinks on social media accounts
[72]
MOTHER-derivative marks and taglines
[73]
Display and sale of energy drinks and other beverages, particularly coffee
[76]
Sale of coffee and tea flavoured energy drinks
[79]
Energy drinks as an alternative to coffee
[81]
Competitive landscape for energy drinks in the United States
[83]
Competitive landscape for energy drinks in Australia
[87]
Competitive landscape for coffee in Australia
[91]
Product innovation for MOTHER energy drinks
[94]
Recent EB Planning Documents
[98]
Sale of energy drinks and coffee products
[100]
Marketing of energy drinks and coffee products
[107]
Scope of use of Cantarella’s pure coffee brands
[116]
MOTHERLAND marketing campaign
[123]
MOTHER-derivative trade marks
[129]
MARKET ISSUES AND EB’S REPUTATION IN MOTHER
[137]
EB submissions
[138]
Cantarella submissions
[140]
Consideration
[144]
LACK OF USE OR INTENTION TO USE
[158]
Section 92(4) of the Act and relevant legal principles
[158]
Submissions – MOTHER LOADED ICED COFFEE mark
[172]
Consideration – MOTHER LOADED ICED COFFEE mark
[183]
Submissions – MOTHERLAND mark
[190]
Consideration – MOTHERLAND mark
[201]
EXERCISE OF DISCRETION
[225]
Section 101 of the Act and relevant legal principles
[227]
EB submissions
[238]
Cantarella submissions
[247]
Consideration
[250]
MOTHERSKY MARK – DECEPTIVE SIMILARITY
[261]
Section 44 of the Act and relevant legal principles
[261]
EB submissions
[277]
Goods of the same description
[278]
Priority dates
[289]
Deceptively similar
[290]
Cantarella submissions
[297]
Goods of the same description
[297]
Priority dates
[300]
Deceptively similar
[301]
Consideration
[305]
Goods of the same description
[305]
Priority dates
[317]
Deceptively similar
[318]
MOTHERSKY MARK – LIKELIHOOD OF DECEPTION OR CONFUSION
[331]
Section 60 of Act and relevant legal principles
[331]
EB submissions
[339]
Cantarella submissions
[345]
Consideration
[350]
MOTHERSKY MARK – UNLAWFULNESS
[369]
Section 42(b) of the Act and relevant legal principles
[369]
EB submissions
[382]
Cantarella submissions
[387]
Consideration
[388]
DISPOSITION
[393]
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
EB was also the owner of the registered trade mark “MOTHER LOADED ICED COFFEE” under Australia trade mark registration number 1408011 (MLIC registration) with respect to the following goods:Class 29:Milk and milk products; flavoured milk beverages; dairy products including milk and yoghurt based products and beverages with or without fruit additives; yoghurt; food supplements and nutritional supplements (other than for medicinal use); natural products in this class incorporating herbal preparations (other than for medicinal use); food supplements with herbs (other than for medicinal use); drinks flavoured with herbs and having a milk baseClass 30:Coffee; tea; cocoa; chocolate; artificial coffee; ice cream; beverages in this class including coffee based beverages, tea based beverages and chocolate based beverages; herbal extracts (other than for medicinal purposes); herbal infusions (other than for medicinal use) and herbal tea (other than for medicinal use) EB now seeks to limit the scope of the goods and services covered by the MOTHER LOADED ICED COFFEE mark to the following goods and services:Class 29:flavoured milk beverages; milk based beverages with or without fruit additives; liquid food supplements and nutritional supplements (other than for medicinal use); liquid food supplements with herbs (other than for medicinal use); drinks flavoured with herbs and having a milk baseClass 30:Coffee; cocoa; chocolate; artificial coffee; beverages in this class including coffee based beverages and chocolate based beverages; herbal infusions (other than for medicinal use)(together MLIC Protected Goods.) On 13 February 2018, Cantarella applied for removal of the MLIC registration pursuant to ss 92(4)(a) and (b) of the Act. On 30 April 2018, EB filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose, and a rectified Statement of Grounds and Particulars on 20 June 2018. Cantarella filed its Notice of Intention to Defend the removal application on 6 August 2018. On 24 September 2019, the Delegate found that Cantarella’s application for removal pursuant to s 92(4)(b) of the Act was successful due to non-use, and directed that the MLIC mark be removed from the Register: see Energy Beverages LLC v Cantarella Bros Pty Ltd [2019] ATMO 140 (MLIC decision).MOTHERSKY mark On 11 January 2017, Cantarella applied for registration of “MOTHERSKY” in class 30 in respect of coffee, coffee beans and chocolate, and in class 41 in respect of coffee roasting and coffee grinding under Australia trade mark registration number 1819816 (MOTHERSKY application). Originally, Cantarella had also applied for coffee beverages and chocolate beverages in class 30, but deleted those items after EB filed its Notice of Intention to Oppose. On 31 July 2017, EB opposed acceptance of the MOTHERSKY application pursuant to s 52 of the Act. The grounds of the opposition were ss 44, 60 and 42(b) of the Act, which deal with deceptive similarity or marks that are identical, reputation in a trade mark, and whether use of the mark would be contrary to the law, respectively. EB filed a Statement of Grounds and Particulars on 30 August 2017, and Cantarella filed a Notice of Intention to Defend on 16 October 2017.