Halal Certification Authority Pty Ltd v Flujo Sanguineo Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Halal Certification Authority Pty Ltd v Flujo Sanguineo Holdings Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 1399

File number: NSD 1706 of 2018
Judgment of: BROMWICH J
Date of judgment: 12 November 2021
Catchwords:

TRADE MARKS – trade mark registered by Halal Certification Authority Australia Pty Ltd (HCA) in respect of classes 42 and 45 of services – where trade mark used as a packaging logo on artificial sweetener products by respondents – where products certified halal by HCA at various times and certificates issued – where products manufactured by contract manufacturer who held agreement with HCA – where certification had lapsed at two times – where no permission was given to use the trade mark on packaging – where there was no direct agreement between HCA and respondents – whether trade mark infringement occurred because packaging was substantially identical or deceptively similar to the goods or services of registration per s 120(1) of Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – whether the trade mark was used as a sign that was substantially identical or deceptively similar to the goods or services of registration per s 120(2)(c) or (d) of the Act – whether respondents could rely on good faith exception in s 122(1)(b)(i) of the Act for use of the trade mark on the products – held: trade mark not being used on products as a trade mark for services – held: trade mark not used in respect of services of the same description, or closely related to registered services – held: no infringement within s 120 of the Act – held: even if infringement had been made out, good faith exception applied – claims dismissed

CONSUMER LAW – where submitted that HCA, by the existence and use of the trade mark, had acquired a substantial and valuable reputation and that the respondents had made representation to traders and consumers in relation to HCA and halal certification – whether use of trade mark contravened ss 18 and 29(a), (b), (g) and (h) of the Australian Consumer Law – whether respondents engaged in tort of passing off – held: ordinary consumer would not have perceived necessary connection to HCA through the use of the trade mark on the products – claims dismissed

TRADE MARKS – cross-claim – whether the register of trade marks should be rectified by cancelling the trade mark pursuant to s 88(2)(a) of the Act as likely to deceive or cause confusion – whether cancellation should occur on the basis that registration could have been successfully opposed at the time sought pursuant to s 88(2)(c) of the Act – whether the mark should be removed for non-use pursuant to s 92(4)(b) of the Act – where trade mark used in a way to convey authoritative status, and not just to denote private company name – where submitted by cross-claimants that trade mark was being used as a certification mark – where trade mark made up of entirely descriptive components without any sufficient reputation to distinguish…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Halal Certification Authority Pty Ltd v Flujo Sanguineo Hold... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 1399
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Halal Certification Authority Pty Ltd (HCA) commenced proceedings against Flujo Sanguineo Holdings Pty Ltd and others, seeking an injunction against the respondents using the term "Halal Certification Authority" in relation to their products. The respondents counterclaimed for rectification of the register of the Trade Mark to cancel the registration of the Trade Mark, as they argued it was not used in relation to the sale of goods or services as claimed in the registration. The Federal Court of Australia was required to decide whether the Trade Mark was used in relation to the sale of goods or services, as claimed in the registration, and whether the registration of the Trade Mark should be rectified to cancel the registration.

The Court found that the Trade Mark was used in relation to the sale of goods or services, albeit in a limited capacity. The Court found that the Trade Mark was used as a watermark on the certificates that HCA issued, which operated to authenticate the certificates, which is a legitimate use of a trade mark. The Court also found that the use of the Trade Mark was not fleeting or pretended, as the respondents had already made good their case for rectification of the register. However, the Court found that the Trade Mark was not used in relation to the sale of the Natvia Products and the Raw Earth Products, as claimed in the registration. The Court found that the respondents were not involved in the business of the sale of those products, and that the products were sold by other companies under different trade marks.

The Court ordered that the originating application be dismissed, and that the cross-claim be granted in respect of the aspect of seeking rectification of the register, by way of cancellation of the registration of the Trade Mark. The Court stayed the rectification order for 28 days, or until such a proceeding is heard and determined if an appeal proceeding is brought within that time. The Court also ordered that HCA pay the respondents' costs in respect of both the originating application and the cross-claim, and that each of the parties has leave to bring an application for a different costs order, or to vary the other orders made, within 14 days of delivery of this judgment, or such further time as may be allowed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Specifically, and independently of the legal arguments advanced in the overall denial of liability, the respondents also rely upon the following in relation to the sale of the Natvia Products and the Raw Earth Products:(a)Flujo Sanguineo, although the parent company of the other three respondents, was not involved in the business of the sale of those products;(b)Stevia (formerly Natvia) sold the Natvia Products and Raw Earth Products under the NATVIA trade mark from 2010 until July 2019;(c)Raw Earth sold the Raw Earth Products under the RAW EARTH trade mark from 1 August 2018 onwards; and(d)Natvia IP sold the Natvia Products and Raw Earth Products under the NATVIA trade mark from 1 August 2019 onwards.The key facts as agreed or established by the evidence On 8 June 2004, HCA: (a)changed its name from Halal Certification Services Pty Ltd to Halal Certification Authority Pty Ltd;(b)filed an application for registration of the Trade Mark; and(c)applied for registration of the words “Halal Certification Authority Australia”. The application for registration of the Trade Mark was subsequently granted with effect from the filing date, by reference to classes 42 and 45 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) sch 1 pt 2 – Classes of services, which refer to:(a)class 42: “Scientific and technical services; issuing halal certification to businesses and individuals for goods and services if religious and technical requirements are met”; and(b)class 45: “Personal and social services rendered by others to meet the needs of individuals”. The application for registration of the words “Halal Certification Authority Australia” was refused. The trade mark examiner’s report in relation to that application included the following: (a)in the section titled “My reasons for not accepting your application”:Your trade mark consists of the words HALAL CERTIFICATION AUTHORITY AUSTRALIA.This indicates that you provide HALAL CERTIFICATION services within AUSTRALIA.Other traders should be able to use HALAL CERTIFICATION AUTHORITY AUSTRALIA in connection with goods or services similar to yours.(b)in the section titled “The action you can consider” (emphasis in original):As the trade mark is completely descriptive you will need to provide overwhelming evidence for this trade mark to be considered for acceptance. The evidence will need to show that the ordinary meaning of the word/s has been overshadowed in the marketplace by its significance as your trade mark. The application for registration of the words “Halal Certification Authority Australia” was apparently not taken any further, and automatically lapsed on 12 January 2006, being 15 months from the date of the examiner’s adverse report. HCA’s clients from time to time included companies that manufacture products that are distributed and sold by other companies. That is the situation in this case. In her affidavit of 13 September 2019, Ms El-Mouelhy described such companies as contract manufacturers. She referred to Techniques Incorporated Pty Ltd and Hellay Australia Pty Ltd, who manufactured the products in issue in this proceeding, as examples of contract manufacturers.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The application for registration of the words “Halal Certification Authority Australia” was refused. The trade mark examiner’s report in relation to that application included the following: (a)in the section titled “My reasons for not accepting your application”:Your trade mark consists of the words HALAL CERTIFICATION AUTHORITY AUSTRALIA.This indicates that you provide HALAL CERTIFICATION services within AUSTRALIA.Other traders should be able to use HALAL CERTIFICATION AUTHORITY AUSTRALIA in connection with goods or services similar to yours.(b)in the section titled “The action you can consider” (emphasis in original):As the trade mark is completely descriptive you will need to provide overwhelming evidence for this trade mark to be considered for acceptance. The evidence will need to show that the ordinary meaning of the word/s has been overshadowed in the marketplace by its significance as your trade mark. The application for registration of the words “Halal Certification Authority Australia” was apparently not taken any further, and automatically lapsed on 12 January 2006, being 15 months from the date of the examiner’s adverse report. HCA’s clients from time to time included companies that manufacture products that are distributed and sold by other companies. That is the situation in this case. In her affidavit of 13 September 2019, Ms El-Mouelhy described such companies as contract manufacturers. She referred to Techniques Incorporated Pty Ltd and Hellay Australia Pty Ltd, who manufactured the products in issue in this proceeding, as examples of contract manufacturers. While Ms El-Mouelhy did not specifically refer to either Techniques or Hellay as being toll manufacturers, the affidavit evidence of Mr Hanna further referred to Techniques and Hellay as being contract manufacturers who produced Natvia products on a toll manufacturing basis. For the purposes of this matter, nothing much turns on the distinction, albeit somewhat fluid, that can be drawn between contract manufacturers and toll manufacturers. Mr Hanna’s evidence sets out that toll manufacturers do not ordinarily supply raw materials or even packaging when manufacturing products for a customer. As a matter of logic, therefore, under such arrangements toll manufacturers have less input into the appearance of the final product because, on the evidence, the packaging is provided by the customer rather than being provided by the manufacturer. That was the situation in this case. Importantly, toll or contract manufacturers are not retailers, and do not produce public-facing products of their own. Techniques produced the Natvia Products on a toll manufacturing basis, with Stevia (formerly Natvia) sourcing all ingredients and packaging. Techniques blended the ingredients in accordance with the formulation and packaged the product into finished goods at their site. The finished product was delivered to Flujo Group’s warehouse ready for distribution. The first retail sales of the Natvia Products were in October 2009.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is no need to spend any substantial amount of time on this issue, not least because the cross-claimants have already made good their case for rectification of the register. It is not in doubt that the Trade Mark was used as a water mark on the certificates that HCA issued, albeit that this was apparently not visible when printed out. Rather, it operated also to authenticate the certificates, which is a legitimate use of a trade mark, assuming that this constitutes use as a trade mark in the first place. While this is a limited use, it is sufficient to defy the description of only fleeting or pretended use. This aspect of the cross-claimant’s case must fail.Conclusion The originating application must be dismissed. The cross-claim must succeed in respect of the aspect of seeking rectification of the register, by way of cancellation of the registration of the Trade Mark. However, in the circumstances it is appropriate to stay the rectification order for 28 days, or if an appeal proceeding is brought within that time, until such a proceeding is heard and determined. HCA must pay the respondents’ costs in respect of both the originating application and the cross-claim. Each of the parties has leave to bring an application for a different costs order, or to vary the other orders made, within 14 days of delivery of this judgment, or such further time as may be allowed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the use of the trade mark in the context of the certificates issued by Halal Certification Authority Pty Ltd (HCA). Although the trade mark was used as a watermark on the certificates, which was not visible when printed, it also served to authenticate the certificates. This use was deemed legitimate and sufficient to constitute use as a trade mark, thus rejecting the argument of fleeting or pretended use. The court found that the cross-claimants had made a compelling case for the rectification of the register by way of cancellation of the trade mark registration. The court further decided to stay the rectification order for 28 days or until any appeal proceedings brought within that time are heard and determined. The court ordered HCA to pay the respondents' costs for both the originating application and the cross-claim, and allowed each party to apply for a different costs order or to vary the other orders within 14 days of the judgment delivery. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that even limited use of a trade mark, such as in authenticating certificates, can constitute sufficient use to maintain its registration. The court also highlighted the importance of rectification of trade mark registrations when there is clear evidence of improper registration.