Brick Lane Brewing Co Pty Ltd v Torquay Beverage Co Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Brick Lane Brewing Co Pty Ltd v Torquay Beverage Co Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 66

File number: NSD 1342 of 2021
Judgment of: STEWART J
Date of judgment: 8 February 2023
Catchwords: CONSUMER LAW – misleading or deceptive conduct – whether similar get-up of beer products is likely to be misleading or deceptive or has a tendency to lead into error, or represents an association between them – ss 18 and 29 of the Australian Consumer Law – identification of the relevant class of persons – the extent to which the applicant must establish a reputation in its get-up at the relevant date – whether the relevant date is when the respondents first commenced using their similar get-up or whether it is only when their goods first became available for sale – consideration of similarities and differences, in particular the names of the products – the extent to which “thirsty folk want beer, not explanations”
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 75B, Sch 1 ss 18, 29

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 76(1)

Cases cited:

ACCC v Employsure Pty Ltd [2021] FCAFC 142; 392 ALR 205

ACCC v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 54; 250 CLR 640

ACCC v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2020] FCAFC 130; 278 FCR 450

Cadbury Schweppes Pty Ltd v Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 70; 159 FCR 397

Cadbury Schweppes Pty Ltd v Pub Squash Co Pty Ltd (1980) 2 NSWLR 851

Campbell v Backoffice Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 25; 238 CLR 30

Campomar Sociedad, Limitada v Nike International Ltd [2000] HCA 12; 202 CLR 45

Hansen Beverage Co v Bickfords [2008] FCA 406; 75 IPR 505

Hashtag Burgers Pty Ltd v In-n-Out Burgers Inc [2020] FCAFC 235; 385 ALR 514

Homart Pharmaceuticals Pty Ltd Careline Australia Pty Ltd [2018] FCAFC 105; 264 FCR 422

Homart Pharmaceuticals Pty Ltd v Caroline Australia Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 403; 349 ALR 598

In-N-Out Burgers Inc v Hashtag Burgers Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 193; 377 ALR 116

Interlego AG v Croner Trading Pty Ltd [1992] FCA 992; 39 FCR 348

Mars Australia Pty Ltd v Sweet Rewards Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 606; 81 IPR 354

Mars Australia Pty Ltd v Sweet Rewards Pty Ltd [2009] FCAFC 174; 84 IPR 12

McWilliam’s Wines Pty Ltd v McDonald’s System of Australia Pty Ltd [1980] FCA 188; 33 ALR 394

Montgomery v Thompson [1891] AC 217

Natural Raw C Pty Ltd v Maicap Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 51

Norman Kark Publications Ltd v Odhams Press Ltd [1962] 1 WLR 380

Optical 88 Ltd v Optical 88 Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCA 1380; 275 ALR 526

Parkdale Custom Built Furniture v Puxu [1982] HCA 44; 149 CLR 191

Registrar of Trade Marks v Woolworths [1999] FCA 1020; 93 FCR 365

S & I Publishing Pty Ltd v Australian Surf Life Saver Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brick Lane Brewing Co Pty Ltd v Torquay Beverage Co Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 66
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court heard a case between Brick Lane Brewing Co Pty Ltd and Torquay Beverage Co Pty Ltd concerning allegations of misleading or deceptive conduct under sections 18 and 29 of the Australian Consumer Law. Brick Lane alleged that the respondents' use of a similar packaging design for their beer products led consumers to believe there was an association between the two brands, misleading them into thinking the products were related or part of the same range. The respondents argued that the products belonged to different market segments and that consumers would not be confused by the similar get-up.

The court had to decide whether the respondents' use of a similar get-up for their beer products was likely to mislead or deceive consumers or falsely represent an association between the products. The key issue was identifying the relevant class of consumers and whether the respondents needed to establish a reputation for their packaging design by a specific date. The court also considered the similarities and differences in the products' names and designs, as well as the general principle that consumers primarily seek beer rather than detailed explanations.

The court found that by the time the respondents launched their products, both Brick Lane's Sidewinder and the respondents' Better Beer brands had established reputations. The similarities in the get-up of the products were not likely to cause confusion among consumers who were already familiar with both brands. The court concluded that the respondents' conduct was not misleading or deceptive, nor did it falsely represent any association between the parties' products. Consequently, the proceeding was dismissed, and the applicant was ordered to pay the respondents' costs. The court left open the possibility for an application to vary the costs order within 14 days if there were relevant matters to justify a different order.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs of the proceeding.

3. There be liberty to apply for a variation of order 2 within 14 days of these orders.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For reasons I will come to, the relevant date for the case in relation to Sidewinder Hazy Pale is 26 July 2021 being the date of Mighty Craft’s announcement of the launch of Better Beer to the ASX. The relevant date for the case in relation to Sidewinder XPA Deluxe is April 2022 being the date that the respondents launched their Better Beer ginger beer.The facts in detailDevelopment, promotion, sale and reputation of the Sidewinder range Brick Lane started working on a no to low alcohol beer range in September 2020. From late November 2020, concepts for the new range were developed. By February 2021, a mood board for the proposed new Sidewinder range had been developed and sent to a design agency for further development. The mood board included the ultimate brand “Sidewinder” as well as the concept of three curved stripes in the colours that are reflected in the ultimate packaging (as depicted in Figures 1 to 6 in the Schedule). The name Sidewinder was chosen as a reference to 1960s and 70s jet boats and the stripes are a reference to GT racing stripes featured on muscle cars and jet boats from that era. A “retro” feel or mood was apparently sought. In May 2021, Brick Lane submitted copies of the final mock-ups for the cans and packaging to Brick Lane’s can manufacturer and its two packaging manufacturers. Mr Hall, Brick Lane’s head of brand and innovation, testified that he chose the name Sidewinder. The name struck him as being particularly captivating, having power, energy and uniqueness. He also described it as evoking freedom, excitement, possibility and fun, even hedonism, as a deliberate counterpoint to the compromise that drinking no or low alcohol beer might otherwise represent. Mr Hall regarded the curved flared striped design as being unique in the beer market. On 9 July 2021, Brick Lane registered the Instagram handle @sidewinderlife and the domain name With reference to correspondence about the content and launch of the Sidewinder Instagram account, Mr Hall accepted that the Instagram page did not “go live” until 30 July 2021. Mr Bowker, however, explained that the account was publicly accessible from inception as no privacy settings were ever applied to it, and that from that time the profile picture showed a Sidewinder Hazy Pale can. He was not challenged on that and I accept it. As explained by Mr Bowker, Mr Hall’s reference to “going live” is properly to be understood as a reference to content being posted to the account page, rather than the inception of the account and anything included from that time in the profile. In an email on 27 July 2021, there is a reference to the page still being prepared to be launched, and in an email late on 30 July 2021, a particular curved depiction of the can was chosen over a flat version and the “bio” for the page was approved. Also on 30 July, the first images were posted to the page, being a series of nine images as “tiles” (ie, intended to be viewed 3 x 3 as a single image) which together showed a “skater-girl” and no part of the Sidewinder get-up. Mr Hall accepted that prior to that point the choice of profile photograph and the wording of the bio had not yet been finalised and that the launch of the page was still imminent. As explained, that is to be understood as a reference to when material would first be posted to the page.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Despite recognising similarities between the get-up of the Sidewinder products and the Better Beer products, Mr Cogger accepted that the respondents did nothing to further distinguish the products once they knew about the Sidewinder products. Mr Cogger also accepted that there were “definitely similarities between the colour schemes” of the Hazy Pale and Better Beer lager products and that the orange colours used for the XPA Deluxe and Better Beer ginger beer products “have some resemblance”. Evidence of confusion Brick Lane sought to prove incidents of actual confusion by consumers between the Sidewinder and Better Beer products because of the similar get-ups. It relies on two separate incidents which it submits amount to evidence of such confusion. The first incident is explained in the evidence of Mr Emans, the Experience Manager for Brick Lane. He explained that there is an annual “Great Australasian Beer SpecTAPular” craft beer festival, known as the GABS Festival, which is one of the world’s largest craft beer festivals. In May 2022, the GABS Festival was held in Brisbane, Sydney and Melbourne. Mr Emans attended and operated the Brick Lane stall at the GABS Sydney event which featured the Sidewinder get-up. He promoted and facilitated tastings of the Sidewinder range with the attendees at the event. Late one afternoon as he was cleaning the Brick Lane stall, Mr Emans was approached by a male cleaner who was attending to the area generally. Mr Emans gave the cleaner a few samples of the Sidewinder range of low alcohol beer and they had a conversation in which the cleaner said “Woah, that’s so great that you guys from Better Beer are doing low-alcoholic options now.” Brick Lane submits that the inference arising from the incident is that the man was led into error so as to believe that Better Beer products were associated with or part of the range of Brick Lane’s products. It is said that the confusion arises solely because the respondents have marketed a beer in strikingly similar get-up to the Sidewinder beer. The second incident is explained in the evidence of Mr Lampard, an area manager for Brick Lane. Mr Lampard’s role includes visiting Dan Murphy’s stores in his area on a monthly to quarterly basis to meet with store representatives to discuss Brick Lane’s products. On 31 January 2022, Mr Lampard attended the Dan Murphy’s Parkwood store on the Gold Coast in Queensland. He entered the store carrying a four-pack cluster of the Sidewinder Hazy Pale product and approached a Dan Murphy’s staff member, showing him the cluster and saying that he was from Brick Lane and wanted to discuss the minimum product levels for Sidewinder. The staff member said that they had the product on display and led Mr Lampard to a display of the canned Better Beer lager product. The Sidewinder product was stocked in the store, but at a different place, namely in the low alcohol fridge section. Brick Lane submits that the inference arising from the incident is that the Dan Murphy’s staff member confused the Sidewinder and Better Beer products. It is said that a Dan Murphy’s staff member is likely to be better informed about the different products than an ordinary consumer would be, such that the incident gives rise to an inference that consumers would be confused about the two products being associated because of their similar get-up.

Decision

Reasons for decision

That ultimate conclusion applies equally to the XPA Deluxe / Better Beer ginger beer case as it does to the Hazy Pale / Better Beer lager. Although by April 2022, when the ginger beer was launched, it can be accepted that the Sidewinder XPA Deluxe had a reasonably established reputation such that the reasonable beer consumer can be taken to have some familiarity with the XPA Deluxe get-up, by that time that consumer would also have familiarity with the Sidewinder Hazy Pale get-up and the Better Beer lager get-up. As both the Sidewinder and Better Beer brands were reasonably established by then, the consumer would not be likely to confuse them as a consequence of the similarities in their respective get-ups.Conclusion On account of having found that the respondents’ relevant conduct was not misleading or deceptive, and did not falsely represent any relevant association between the parties’ respective products, the proceeding falls to be dismissed. I am not aware of any reason why the usual rule with regard to costs should not apply, and the applicant should therefore pay the respondents’ costs of the proceeding. However, since I have not heard the parties on costs, in the event that there is some relevant matter with regard to costs that may justify a different order, the party contending for such an order can apply for a variation of the costs order within 14 days.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Both incidents reflect a person being confused between the Sidewinder and Better Beer products. Although there is no direct evidence as to the reason for the confusion, the relevant person in each case not having been a witness, there does not appear to be any credible reason for the confusion other than the similarity in the get-ups of the different products. For that reason, I infer that the cleaner at the GABS Sydney event and the Dan Murphy’s Parkwood staff member were at least momentarily confused between the Sidewinder and Better Beer products because of the similarity of their get-ups. ConsiderationThe relevant class The respondents emphasise that the Sidewinder products are no or low alcohol products whereas the Better Beer products are full alcohol but low carbohydrate products. They submit that these are different segments of the beer market. They rely in particular on the statement by Ms Harp Kennealy (referred to at [79] above) that the purchase triggers in each market segment are different. On that basis they submit that the relevant class of person in considering Brick Lane’s claim is consumers purchasing no or low alcohol beer. I accept that the market segments are different. However, I do not consider that that is particularly significant. The reality is that consumers considering possible purchases online or in a retail store are faced with an extraordinary array of beer products that vary in many different respects. Those include with respect to alcohol (full strength, mid-strength and no or low or ultra-low) and carbohydrate (low carb or light) content, as well as in many other ways including as to the type of beer (eg, lager, pale ale, IPA, XPA, stout, pilsner, wheat beer, craft or not craft, draught, etc.) and the origin (eg, domestic or imported). The relevant information is presented in a variety of different ways, and the ways in which the products are categorised or grouped for presentation for sale may vary considerably. Also, particular brands, of which Sidewinder and Better Beer serve as good examples, may have many different beer types in their range which are branded similarly. In the circumstances, if two products had identical get-ups but were in different segments of the beer market, I have no doubt that consumers would be likely to be confused differentiating them or to consider that they are related; the fact of them being in different segments would not prevent that or even particularly detract from it. Also, although no alcohol and low carbohydrate products may be considered as separate segments of the market, together they might be considered as part of a “health-conscious” segment. That that is so is demonstrated by the fact that a low alcohol Better Beer lager was introduced by the respondents in June 2022. That product is part of the Better Beer range although it is not specifically the subject of complaint in this case. It is nevertheless promoted by the respondents as another health-conscious beer choice. In short, there are many instances of related products being in different segments of the market, of which the Better Beer low carbohydrate and low alcohol products are prime examples. This shows that it would be wrong to consider this case on the basis of identifying a hypothetical consumer in only one segment of the market. A broader approach is necessary.