Hansen Beverage Company v Bickfords (Australia) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hansen Beverage Company v Bickfords (Australia) Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 406

TRADE PRACTICES - misleading and deceptive conduct - where applicant sells and promotes energy drink overseas using certain mark - where respondent commences using that mark without licence to sell energy drink in Australia - where applicant does not conduct business in Australia but alleges that it has reputation amongst target market in Australia on basis of exposure of its mark and that consumers would be misled or deceived - cross-claim by respondent that it has established requisite reputation - whether either party has established sufficient reputation - establishment of date at which reputation should be assessed

TORT - passing off - where applicant sells and promotes energy drink overseas using certain mark - where respondent commences using that mark without licence to sell energy drink in Australia - where applicant does not conduct business in Australia but alleges that it has reputation among target market in Australia on basis of exposure of its mark - whether sufficient reputation established

EVIDENCE - hearsay - business records exception - where television ratings data is sought to be tendered - where data is produced by computer extrapolating human representation - whether data is hearsay - where data is produced by third party as a product of its business - whether data falls within business records exception - whether data should be otherwise admitted under discretion in s 190(3) of Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 59(1), 69, 76, 79, 146, 190(3)
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) s 27(1)(b)(i)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 52

10th Cantanae Pty Ltd v Shoshana Pty Ltd (Sue Smith Case) (1987) 79 ALR 299 followed
Arnotts Ltd v Trade Practices Commission (1990) 97 ALR 555 discussed
ASIC v Rich (2005) 216 ALR 320 applied
.au Domain Administration Ltd v Domain Names Australia Pty Ltd (2004) 207 ALR 521 not followed
Cadbury Schweppes Pty Ltd v Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Ltd (2007) 239 ALR 662 followed
Cadbury-Schweppes Pty Ltd v Pub Squash Co Pty Ltd (1980) 32 ALR 387 followed
Colorado Group Ltd v Strandbags Group Pty Ltd (2006) 67 IPR 628 distinguished
Compafina Bank v ANZ Banking Group Ltd [1982] 1 NSWLR 409 cited
ConAgra Inc v McCain Foods (Aust) Pty Ltd (1992) 33 FCR 302 followed
McCormick & Company Inc v McCormick (2000) 51 IPR 102 cited
National Exchange Pty Ltd v Australian Securities & Investments Commission (2004) 61 IPR 420 cited
Natural Waters of Viti Limited v Dayals (Fiji) Artesian Waters Limited (2007) 71 IPR 571 cited
R v Wood (1982) 76 Cr App Rep 23 distinguished
Roach v Page(No 15) [2003] NSWSC 939 applied
Rook v Maynard (1993) 126 ALR 150 distinguished
R W Miller & Co Pty Ltd v Krupp (Australia) Pty Ltd (1991) 32 NSWLR 152 cited
Shoshana Pty Ltd v 10th Cantanae Pty Ltd (1987) 11 IPR 249 cited
Supetina Pty Ltd v Lombok Pty Ltd (1984) 5…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hansen Beverage Company v Bickfords (Australia) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 406
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hansen Beverage Company, the owner of the MONSTER ENERGY trademark, brought a case against Bickfords (Australia) Pty Ltd, alleging that Bickfords' use of a similar name and branding for their energy drinks constituted passing off and a breach of the Trade Practices Act (TPA). The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether Hansen had established sufficient reputation for its MONSTER ENERGY brand in Australia to warrant an injunction against Bickfords' use of similar branding. The central legal issue was whether Hansen had demonstrated that a substantial number of Australian consumers were aware of the MONSTER ENERGY brand prior to Bickfords' use of similar branding. Hansen argued that its extensive marketing efforts, including sponsorship of athletes and events, had created a reputation for MONSTER ENERGY in Australia, even without direct sales or advertising in the country. Bickfords, on the other hand, contended that Hansen had not provided sufficient evidence to show that a significant number of Australian consumers were aware of the MONSTER ENERGY brand prior to their use of similar branding.

The court assessed the evidence provided by Hansen and concluded that, despite Hansen's substantial global marketing efforts, there was insufficient evidence to demonstrate that a substantial number of Australian consumers were aware of the MONSTER ENERGY brand prior to April/May 2006. The court found that Hansen's marketing strategy, which relied on indirect methods such as sponsorships and events, was not sufficient to establish the necessary level of brand awareness in Australia. The court also noted that there were no direct sales or advertising of MONSTER ENERGY drinks in Australia at the relevant time. As a result, Hansen's claim for passing off and breach of the TPA was dismissed. The court ordered that the application and cross-claim be dismissed and that the parties confer on the costs associated with the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application and cross-claim be dismissed.

2. The parties confer and thereafter file and serve any agreed order as to costs, and in the event of no agreement, any submissions as to costs, within 14 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

I make one further introductory remark. Hansen has led evidence (which was uncontested) that it definitely intends to sell MONSTER ENERGY drinks in Australia. However, no evidence was led of any definite business plan or of any intended sales in Australia in the near or immediate future. Nevertheless, the issue of Hansen’s present intention was not raised in this proceeding, and I proceed on the basis that Hansen intends to sell MONSTER ENERGY drinks in Australia, and the principal issue in this proceeding is as I have described it above.BACKGROUNDHansen and MONSTER ENERGY Hansen has, since 1992, developed, marketed, sold and distributed non-alcoholic beverages, including carbonated drinks, energy drinks, fruit juice smoothies, lemonades and juice cocktails in the United States. As at November 2006, Hansen had over 700 employees, with the annual revenue for the 2005 financial year being US$415,417,282. In 1996, in response to the success of energy drinks in the United Kingdom, Hansen began consumer testing of its own energy drink, Hansen’s Energy Smoothie. The primary demographic for Hansen’s energy drinks was, and remains, 18 to 30 year old males. This is to be contrasted with the primary demographic for its natural soft drinks and juice products, being 25 to 40 year old affluent college educated females. Hansen’s management, in 2002, decided to launch a new energy drink which would be targeted to the 18 to 30 year old male demographic, to compete with Red Bull, the leading energy drink in the world at the time. Hansen created, in conjunction with an independent design firm, the MONSTER ENERGY brand name, and decided to sell the drink in 16 oz (473 mL) cans. Hansen’s intention was to create, by using MONSTER ENERGY, a completely separate ‘identity’ and ‘personality’ from the Hansen brand, thus enabling it to focus on the young male target market. To this end, Hansen developed a website at which was separate from, and contained no reference to, Hansen. The official United States launch of MONSTER ENERGY drinks by Hansen was in April 2002. In 2003, Hansen introduced a low carbohydrate version of the energy drink, and in 2004 it began selling MONSTER ENERGY in 4-packs. During 2005 other variations of the MONSTER ENERGY drink and packing were introduced, which included Khaos (with 70% juice) and Assault. Hansen attempts to distinguish its MONSTER ENERGY drinks by, among other things, using ingredients such as taurine, L-carnitine, panax ginseng, guarana, B vitamins, inositol, glucuronolactone, sodium, glucose and caffeine. All varieties of the MONSTER ENERGY drinks contain these ingredients and are carbonated. Further, all varieties of the drinks are sold in 16 oz (473 mL) cans which:·are predominantly black, with an ‘M’ claw design;·refer to the website;·include the MONSTER ENERGY slogan ‘Unleash the Beast!’, which is a registered trademark of Hansen;·list certain of the ingredients around the top of the can; and·emphasise the ‘O’ in MONSTER and MONSTER ENERGY.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

However, it is clear that in dealing with Hansen’s claim and assessing the evidence of reputation, I should not take, and have not taken, into account evidence of reputation after April/May 2006. hansen’s market strategy, and court’s general view of and approach to the evidence It is helpful, in addition to describing Hansen’s market strategy, to outline my general view of and approach to the evidence. Mr Rodney Sacks, the Chief Executive Officer of Hansen, gave uncontested evidence about Hansen’s market strategy, the target market for the MONSTER ENERGY product and the way in which the product was to be brought to the attention of that market. I accept this aspect of his evidence. The evidence set out below of Mr Sacks details the way in which the Hansen product was to be brought to the attention of young male adults in Australia. As I have indicated, Hansen described its target market as males between the ages 18 to 30. Bickfords described its target market as males between the ages of 18 to 24. The parties accepted that it was convenient to refer to the target market as young adult males in Australia. Whilst the focus of the parties and of my review of the evidence has been upon this target market, the reputation that is sought to be established is a reputation to potential customers in Australia. This may include persons outside the target market. However, I have proceeded on the basis that unless Hansen establishes the required reputation amongst the target market, it cannot and does not demonstrate sufficient persons outside that target market (being other potential customers) have been sufficiently exposed to or are sufficiently aware of the mark MONSTER ENERGY or MONSTER. Whilst the evidence given by Mr Sacks talks in terms of market strategy, it says nothing about, in my view, whether that strategy was in fact successful, or if successful, the extent of its success in Australia. I do not consider that I can infer (nor do I) that just because the marketing strategy was put in place globally, even if a strategy adopted by others (including Bickfords) as being a good and appropriate strategy, this in itself proves the implementation of that strategy and more importantly in this case, the extent of its success in Australia. This is particularly so considering that the strategy is of relatively recent origin insofar as its connection to Australia is concerned, when viewed in light of the relevant date (April/May 2006), its ‘word of mouth’ and indirect nature, and where there are no actual sales or direct advertising in Australia of the Hansen product. One must recall that the strategy being adopted is to sponsor athletes and events, so as to create the required image of MONSTER ENERGY, and render it attractive to the target demographic. In this way, the target demographic over some period become familiar with the product before it is in fact launched. The strategy itself recognises that public recognition is a staged process and may take some time to be implemented successfully.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MIDDLETON J
There is no dispute that the similarities between the products could relevantly mislead or deceive for the purposes of the TPA and the tort of passing off.the full court decision in conagra v mccain In ConAgra Inc v McCain Foods (Aust) Pty Ltd (1992) 33 FCR 302 the Full Court considered a case having some similarities with the present proceeding. Both parties rely on the Full Court authority of ConAgra. It is useful to first refer to the salient facts of that case: ·the applicant ConAgra had marketed its HEALTHY CHOICE frozen dinner product in the United States from January 1989 and had achieved sales of HEALTHY CHOICE products from January 1989 to March 1991 amounting to $US458,210,000, accounting for 7.6% of the overall frozen food, dinner and entrée market in the United States;·ConAgra had obtained trade mark registration of HEALTHY CHOICE in the United States;·ConAgra had spent very substantial sums of money on advertising its HEALTHY CHOICE product in the United States;·ConAgra had not manufactured its HEALTHY CHOICE products other than in the United States, but had sold the products in Canada and Central America;·McCain had been manufacturing and marketing frozen food dinners in Australia;·in October 1989, the Australian marketing director of McCain travelled to the United States and Canada and noticed ConAgra’s HEALTHY CHOICE product in supermarkets, obtained five examples of the packaging, took them back to Australia and reported to McCain senior management that ‘The … product ‘Healthy Choice’ (low cholesterol) is getting very favourable comments in the US. We should look closely at this one.’;·from May 1990, McCain conducted market research and product development for its own HEALTHY CHOICE product;·in July 1990, McCain applied for trade mark registration in Australia for HEALTHY CHOICE together with the McCain logo;·in February 1991, McCain launched three varieties of its HEALTHY CHOICE product in Australia; and·on 8 April 1991, ConAgra commenced proceedings against McCain in the Federal Court claiming that McCain’s adoption of the name and get-up of ConAgra’s products amounted to passing off or breach of ss 52 or 53(c) of the TPA. At first instance Hill J found that McCain’s packaging suggested, to a person familiar with the ConAgra product, that there is a relationship of some kind between ConAgra and McCain or their respective products. However, both at first instance and on appeal to the Full Court, ConAgra failed to establish that McCain’s sale of its HEALTHY CHOICE product in Australia amounted to passing off or breach of s 52 or s 53(c) of the TPA because ConAgra was unable to establish that there was a substantial or sufficiently substantial number of persons in Australia who were aware of ConAgra’s products and for whom HEALTHY CHOICE would have signified ConAgra’s product. ConAgra’s evidence of reputation included affidavits from ten people who had some recent connection with the United States. Some were United States citizens visiting or residing in Australia and others were Australian citizens who had spent time in the United States. To varying degrees, each deponent recognised ConAgra’s HEALTHY CHOICE product. It was ultimately found that no extrapolation of any value could be made from those deponents to the Australian population in general (including foreign citizens in Australia) whether as likely buyers of frozen foods or as likely to be aware of ConAgra’s product in the United States.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MIDDLETON J

Full text does not contain this section.