Monster Energy Company v Mixi, Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Monster Energy Company to extension of protection of International Registration 1242941 (9, 41) (Australian trade mark application 1687622) - MONSTER STRIKE - in the name of Mixi, Inc.

Delegate:

Jock McDonagh

Representation:

Opponent: Stephen Rebikoff of Counsel, instructed by Davies Collison Cave Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys

Holder: Written submissions prepared by Watermark IP Lawyers

Decision:

2017 ATMO 119

Trade Marks Act 1995, Trade Marks Regulations 1995 - Opposition to extension of protection under Reg 17A.33 – grounds pressed under sections 42(b) and 60 not established – IRDA to be granted protection

Background

  1. On 23 June 2014, Mixi, Inc. (‘the Holder’) applied for extension of protection to Australia of International Registration no. 1242941. The current details of the resulting International Registration Designating Australia (‘the IRDA’) are:

Application No:

International Registration:

1687622

1242941

Trade Mark

MONSTER STRIKE

Filing Date:

Convention Priority Date:

23.07.2014

27.12.2013

Goods & Services:

Class 9: Downloadable computer game programs; downloadable programs for personal computers; downloadable computer program for smart phones; downloadable computer programs for cellular phones; downloadable computer game programs for hand-held games with liquid crystal displays; downloadable arcade video game programs; downloadable consumer video game programs; electronic circuits, magnetic disks, optical disks, ROM cartridges, CD-ROMs, DVD-ROMs and other data media, all featuring recorded programs for personal computers; electronic circuits, magnetic disks, optical disks, ROM cartridges, CD-ROMs, DVD-ROMs and other data media, all featuring recorded programs for smart phones; electronic circuits, magnetic disks, optical disks, ROM cartridges, CD-ROMs, DVD-ROMs and other data media, all featuring recorded programs for cellular computers; electronic circuits, magnetic disks, optical disks, ROM cartridges, CD-ROMs, DVD-ROMs and other data media, all featuring recorded programs for hand-held games with liquid crystal displays; electronic circuits, magnetic disks, optical disks, ROM cartridges, CD-ROMs, DVD-ROMs and other data media, all featuring recorded programs for consumer video game programs; electronic machines, apparatus and their parts; telecommunication machines and apparatus; straps, covers, earphone jack and other accessories for cellular phones and tablet computers; stylus pen for telecommunication machines and electronic machines; downloadable image files; downloadable music files; downloadable character data; electronic publications (including also downloadable and recorded in electronic circuits, magnetic disks, optical disks, ROM cartridges, CD-ROMs, DVD-ROMs and other data media)

Class 41: Providing non-downloadable video games using communication by an electronic computer terminal, and consultation and providing information thereof; providing non-downloadable video games using communication by a PDA, and consultation and providing thereof; providing non-downloadable video games via a smart phone, and consultation and providing information thereof; providing non-downloadable video game using communication by hand-held games with liquid crystal displays, and consultation and providing information thereof; providing non-downloadable games for consumer video games and arcade video games via Internet, and consultation and providing information thereof; providing non-downloadable games via on-line, and consultation and providing information thereof; providing information about providing video games; providing amusement facilities; providing electronic publications about video games; providing electronic publications, and providing information thereof; services…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Monster Energy Company v Mixi, Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] ATMO 119
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition by Monster Energy Company (the Opponent) to the registration of an International Registration Designating Australia (IRDA) by Mixi, Inc (the Holder). The Opponent sought to prevent the extension of protection of the IRDA to Australia, relying on its own registered trade marks and use of the MONSTER and MONSTER ENERGY trade marks in relation to carbonated energy drinks. The Opponent argued that the proposed registration would be likely to cause confusion among consumers and that the Holder's application was an attempt to trade on the Opponent's reputation.

The primary legal issue before the Hearing Officer was whether the grounds of opposition, particularly those relating to sections 42 and 60 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth), had been established. Section 42 concerns the registration of trade marks that are identical or deceptively similar to earlier trade marks, while section 60 addresses the use of trade marks that are likely to cause confusion due to prior use and reputation. The critical question was whether the Opponent's use and registration of its MONSTER trade marks in Australia, prior to the priority date of the IRDA, established grounds for opposition.

The Hearing Officer found that the Opponent had not established the grounds on which the IRDA was opposed. While the Opponent demonstrated significant use and registration of its MONSTER trade marks in the USA and had commenced sales and marketing activities in Australia from 2006, acquiring rights from Bickford's Australia Pty Ltd in 2008, the evidence did not establish that the grounds of opposition were met. Regulation 17A.34N of the *Trade Marks Regulations 1995* (Cth) requires the Registrar to decide whether to refuse or extend protection based on the established grounds of opposition.

Consequently, the Hearing Officer decided to extend protection to the IRDA, subject to any appeal. The Hearing Officer also awarded costs against the Opponent in favour of the Holder, as the Holder was the successful party.

Background

Background to the litigation

Monster Energy Company, previously known as Hansen Beverage Company, is an American corporation that owns and uses the trademark "MONSTER" in relation to, among other things, carbonated energy drinks. The company has a significant number of registered trademarks in Australia, comprising or consisting of the word "monster" in relation to "carbonated energy drinks." The company first used these trademarks in the United States in 2002, and sales grew rapidly, with the company occupying approximately 35% of the market for carbonated energy drinks in the United States at the time when the relevant declaration was made. Monster Energy Company's "MONSTER" energy drinks are sold in numerous countries worldwide, including Australia, through more than 300,000 retail stores and outlets, and extensively through the Internet.

In Australia, "MONSTER" energy drinks were first sold in 2006 by an Australian company named Bickford’s Australia Pty Ltd. Bickford’s undertook advertising and marketing activities, including a media campaign, for "MONSTER" brand energy drinks and secured extensive distribution and sales of "MONSTER" brand energy drinks throughout Australia. In December 2008, Monster acquired from Bickford’s all of Bickford’s rights in the "MONSTER" trademark, including all trademark applications lodged by Bickford’s for the "MONSTER" trademark. As a result of this acquisition, Monster is also entitled to the benefit of all sales made and reputation developed through Bickford’s sales and marketing of "MONSTER" brand energy drinks from April 2006 through April 2009.

The case of Monster Energy Company v Mixi, Inc came before the Australian Registrar of Trade Marks as an opposition to the international registration of Mixi, Inc’s trademark application. The proceedings began when Mixi, Inc applied for international registration of its trademark, leading the Opponent, previously known as Hansen Beverage Company, to file an opposition under section 42 and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The Opponent relied on its own extensive use and registration of the "MONSTER" and "MONSTER ENERGY" trademarks in Australia and internationally, particularly in relation to carbonated energy drinks, to argue against the registration of Mixi, Inc’s trademark. The matter proceeded with the Opponent filing grounds of opposition and supporting declarations. The Registrar, Jock McDonagh, heard the case and considered the evidence presented by both parties, ultimately determining that the Opponent had not established the grounds for opposition. Consequently, the Registrar decided to extend protection to Mixi, Inc’s international registration, with the condition that if an appeal was lodged, protection would be withheld until the appeal was resolved.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The time at which the grounds of opposition must be established is the Priority Date.[2][2] See Southern Cross Refrigerating v Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd (1953) 91 CLR 592 at 595Evidence The evidence consists of the following declarations: The Opponent was previously called Hansen Beverage Company and owns and uses the trade mark MONSTER in relation to, inter alia, carbonated energy drinks (‘the Opponent’s Goods’). The Opponent has a number (over 60) of registered trade marks in Australia which comprise or consist of the word ‘monster’ in relation to ‘carbonated energy drinks’ and which are listed in the First Sacks declaration, and in the grounds under sections 42 and 60 the Opponent relies on the use of its MONSTER and MONSTER ENERGY trade marks (‘the Opponent’s Trade Marks’) in Australia. The most common portrayal of the Opponent’s Trade Marks comprise one or more of the three elements shown below: The Opponent first used the Opponent’s Trade Marks’ in the USA in 2002 and sales grew rapidly: sales of the Opponent’s Goods under the Opponent’s Trade Marks occupied approximately 35% of the market for carbonated energy drinks in the USA at the time when the First Sacks declaration was made. In the First Sacks declaration , Mr Sacks states:Today, my Company sells its MONSTER energy drinks to consumers throughout the United States, and approximately 114 nations and territories throughout the world, including:Australia, French Polynesia (including Tahiti), New Zealand, New Caledonia, Wallis and Futuna, Angola, Botswana, Kenya, Lesotho, Mauritius, Madagascar, Mozambique, Namibia, Reunion, Seychelles, South Africa, Swaziland, Tanzania, Uganda, Panama, Belize, Bolivia, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Ecuador, El Salvador, French Guiana, Guatemala, Guyana, Honduras, Nicaragua, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Suriname, Venezuela, Uruguay, Antigua, Barbados, Bahamas, Bermuda, Cayman Islands, Dominica, French Guiana, Grenada, Guadeloupe, Jamaica, Martinique, Netherlands Antilles (including Aruba, Curacao, and Saint Maarten), Puerto Rico, St. Lucia, St. Maarten, Trinidad/Tobago, U.S.A. Virgin Islands, Albania, Andorra, Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Gibraltar, Greece, Greenland, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Liechtenstein, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Macedonia, Malta, Monaco, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, San Marino, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, Ukraine, the United Kingdom, Canada, Mexico, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Russia, Slovenia, Guam, Hong Kong, India, Japan, Korea, Macau, Philippines, Singapore, Afghanistan, Kuwait, and United Arab Emirates. In the United States, my Company’s MONSTER energy drinks are sold to consumers in all 50 states through more than 300,000 retail stores and outlets, and extensively through the Internet. Concerning the use of the Opponent’s Trade Marks in Australia in relation to the Opponent’s Goods, Mr Sacks states in the First Sacks declaration:MONSTER energy drinks were first sold in Australia in 2006 by an Australian company named Bickford’s Australia Pty Ltd. Commencing in 2006, Bickford’s undertook advertising and marketing activities, including a media campaign, for MONSTER brand energy drinks and secured extensive distribution and sales of MONSTER brand energy drinks throughout Australia, including in Coles chain of retail stores, in "On the Run" convenience stores (Adelaide), and in Woolworths chain of stores. I do not have a full report of Bickford’s sales of MONSTER brand energy drinks, but did receive a report from Bickford’s that from June 2006 through February 2007, they sold more than 480,000 cans of MONSTER brand energy drinks in Australia. As the result of an agreement between Monster (then Hansen Beverage Company) and Bickford’s reached in December 2008, Monster acquired from Bickford’s all of Bickford’s rights in the MONSTER trade mark, including all trade mark applications lodged by Bickford’s for the MONSTER trade mark. Bickford’s first lodged trade mark applications to register the MONSTER trademark in Australia in May 2005. As a result of Monster's acquisition from Bickford’s of the MONSTER brand, Monster is also entitled to the benefit of all sales made and reputation developed through Bickford’s sales and marketing of MONSTER brand energy drinks from April 2006 through April 2009.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Regulation 17A.34N provides:17A.34N Decision on opposition(1)Unless the opposition proceedings are discontinued or dismissed, the Registrar must decide:(a)to refuse protection in respect of all of the goods or services listed in the IRDA; or(b)to extend protection in respect of some or all of the goods or services listed in the IRDA (with or without conditions or limitations);having regard to the extent (if any) to which the grounds on which the IRDA was opposed have been established.(2)The Registrar must notify the International Bureau of the Registrar’s decision. The Opponent has not established the grounds on which the IRDA was opposed and it is appropriate that the Registrar decides to extend protection to the IRDA. The IRDA may then proceed to protection one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that protection shall not occur until the appeal has been decided or discontinued and the disposition of the IRDA be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction.Costs The parties sought their costs. I see no reason to depart from the general rule that costs follow the event. As the Holder has been the successful party, I award costs against the Opponent at the scale set out in Schedule 8 to the Regulations.Jock McDonaghHearing Officer18 October 2017

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the question of whether the Opponent had established the grounds on which the International Registration Designating Australia (IRDA) was opposed. The court found that the Opponent had not established these grounds. In assessing the grounds of opposition, the court looked to the Priority Date as the time at which the grounds of opposition must be established. This aligns with the principle established in Southern Cross Refrigerating v Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd (1953) 91 CLR 592 at 595. The Opponent relied on its use of the MONSTER and MONSTER ENERGY trade marks in Australia, but the court found that this was not sufficient to establish the grounds of opposition. The Opponent's trade marks were used in relation to carbonated energy drinks, and the Opponent had a significant number of registered trade marks in Australia for these goods. However, the Opponent's sales and marketing activities in Australia were not enough to establish the grounds of opposition. The court found that the Opponent had not demonstrated that it had a trade mark right that was entitled to protection under Australian law.

The court then turned to the question of whether it was appropriate for the Registrar to decide to extend protection to the IRDA. The court found that it was appropriate for the Registrar to extend protection to the IRDA, as the Opponent had not established the grounds on which the IRDA was opposed. The court noted that the Registrar must decide whether to refuse protection in respect of all of the goods or services listed in the IRDA or to extend protection in respect of some or all of the goods or services listed in the IRDA, having regard to the extent to which the grounds on which the IRDA was opposed have been established. In this case, the Opponent had not established any grounds of opposition, so it was appropriate for the Registrar to extend protection to the IRDA.

The court then considered the question of whether the IRDA may proceed to protection one month from the date of the decision if no appeal had been served on the Registrar. The court found that it was appropriate for the IRDA to proceed to protection in this way, as the Opponent had not established the grounds on which the IRDA was opposed. The court noted that the parties had sought their costs, and the court found that it saw no reason to depart from the general rule that costs follow the event. As the Holder had been the successful party, the court awarded costs against the Opponent at the scale set out in Schedule 8 to the Regulations.

Finally, the court considered the question of whether the disposition of the IRDA should be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction if an appeal had been served on the Registrar before the one-month period. The court found that if an appeal had been served on the Registrar before the one-month period, the disposition of the IRDA should be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction. This aligns with the principle established in Regulation 17A.34N, which provides that the Registrar must notify the International Bureau of the Registrar’s decision and that protection shall not occur until the appeal has been decided or discontinued.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that if an opponent has not established the grounds on which an IRDA was opposed, it is appropriate for the Registrar to decide to extend protection to the IRDA. If no appeal has been served on the Registrar before the one-month period, the IRDA may proceed to protection in this way. However, if an appeal has been served on the Registrar before the one-month period, the disposition of the IRDA should be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction. This decision aligns with the principles established in Regulation 17A.34N and Southern Cross Refrigerating v Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd (1953) 91 CLR 592 at 595. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by finding that the Opponent had not established the grounds on which the IRDA was opposed, and it followed prior authority in finding that it was appropriate for the Registrar to extend protection to the IRDA in these circumstances.