Sealed Air Australia Pty Ltd v Aus-lid Enterprises Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sealed Air Australia Pty Limited v Aus-Lid Enterprises Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 29

File number: NSD 6 of 2015
Judge: KENNY J
Date of judgment: 24 January 2020
Catchwords:

TORTS – economic torts – tort of inducement or procurement of breach of contract – whether intention to induce or procure breach of contract – actual knowledge – wilful blindness or reckless indifference – when honest belief sufficient defence to the tort – relevance of failure to make reasonable inquiries – supposed possible repudiation of contract – whether payments in consideration of inconsistent  dealing amounted to inducement of breach

CONSUMER LAW – misleading or deceptive conduct – statements of opinion – whether statement of willingness and ability to supply patented product misleading and deceptive – effect of statement on commercial parties – nature of interest represented – whether loss or damage suffered “because of” misleading and deceptive conduct – whether third party relied on relevant statements

PATENTS – interest granted under patent licensing agreement – whether later-in-time licensee might have an effective licence, the giving of which by the licensor was a breach of contract with another party

DAMAGES – damages for inducement or procurement of breach of contract – damages following default judgment against first respondent for breach of contract

Legislation:

Consumer and Competition Act 2010 (Cth) Sch 2, Australian Consumer Law, ss 18, 236

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 126, 127

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) Sch 1

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 82

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 5.22, 5.23

Cases cited:

Allied Pastoral Holdings Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [1983] 1 NSWLR 1

Allstate Life Insurance Company v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [1995] FCA 1368; 58 FCR 26

Andar Transport Pty Ltd v Brambles Ltd [2004] HCA 28; 217 CLR 424

Ankar Proprietary Limited v National Westminster Finance (Australia) Limited [1987] HCA 15; 162 CLR 549

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 54; 250 CLR 640

Bristol-Myers Squibb Company v Apotex Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 2; 228 FCR 1

British Industrial Plastics Ltd v Ferguson [1940] 1 All ER 479; 58 RPC 1

British Motor Trade Association v Salvadori [1949] Ch 556

Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67

Butcher v Lachlan Elder Realty Pty Limited [2004] HCA 60; 218 CLR 592

Carey v Freehills [2013] FCA 954; 303 ALR 445

Carlton & United Breweries Ltd v Tooth & Co Ltd (1986) 7 IPR 581

Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd [1991] HCA 54; 174 CLR 64

Cryovac Australia Pty Ltd v Aus-Lid Enterprises Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 1027

Daebo Shipping Co Ltd v The Ship Go Star [2012] FCAFC 156; 207 FCR 220

DC Thomson & Company Ltd v Deakin [1952] Ch 646

De Francesco v Barnum (1890) 63 LT 514

Delphic Wholesalers Pty Ltd v Elco Food Co Pty Ltd (1987) 8 IPR 545

Donaldson v Natural Springs Australia Limited

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sealed Air Australia Pty Ltd v Aus-lid Enterprises Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sealed Air Australia (the applicant) sued Aus-lid Enterprises (Aus-Lid) and two other defendants for breach of a patent licence agreement and for misleading and deceptive conduct. The applicant alleged that Aus-Lid, by allowing Visy to manufacture and sell its patented product, breached the licence agreement and engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct. The case was heard by the Federal Court of Australia. The court was required to decide if Aus-Lid's actions constituted an inducement or procurement of a breach of contract, if the tort of misleading and deceptive conduct was engaged, and if so, what damages were applicable.

The court found that Aus-Lid did breach the patent licence agreement by allowing Visy to manufacture and sell its patented product. However, the court determined that Visy did not intentionally induce or procure the breach of contract. The court emphasised that intention to induce or procure a breach of contract must be established, and actual knowledge, wilful blindness, or reckless indifference are not sufficient. The court concluded that Visy had an honest belief that Aus-Lid had the authority to grant the licence to Visy, and there was no evidence of wilful blindness or reckless indifference on Visy's part. The court also found that Visy did not engage in misleading and deceptive conduct as there was no loss or damage suffered by the applicant due to the alleged misleading and deceptive conduct. Finally, the court assessed damages for the breach of the patent licence agreement.

The final orders required the applicant to file and serve a proposed minute of orders, written submissions on costs and interest, and copies of the orders and reasons for judgment to the relevant parties. The parties were also required to file and serve any submissions in response to the applicant's proposed minute of orders and written submissions on costs and interest. The entry of orders was dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. On or before 6 February 2020 the applicant file and serve:

(a) a proposed minute of orders giving effect to these reasons for judgment; and

(b) written submissions on costs and/or interest (not exceeding 5 pages).

2. On or before 18 February 2020 the fourth respondent file and serve any submissions (not exceeding 5 pages) in response to:

(a) the applicant’s proposed minute of orders; and

(b) the applicant’s written submissions on costs and/or interest.

3. On or before 18 February 2020 the first respondent file and serve any submissions (not exceeding 5 pages) in response to:

(a) the applicant’s proposed minute of orders; and

(b) the applicant’s written submissions on costs and/or interest.

4. On or before 10 February 2020 the applicant file and serve on the first respondent:

(a) a copy of these orders; and

(b) a copy of the reasons for judgment delivered today.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

INTRODUCTION

[1]

THE PARTIES

[4]

THE CIRCUMSTANCES IN WHICH THE PROCEEDING AROSE

[9]

The Patent Licence Agreement

[9]

Circumstances of the apprehended breach of the Patent Licence Agreement

[15]

THE APPLICANT’S CLAIMS AGAINST THE FIRST TO THIRD RESPONDENTS

[22]

THE PARTIES’ SUBMISSIONS

[27]

The applicant’s submissions

[27]

Aus-Lid’s breach of the Patent Licence Agreement

[28]

Visy’s knowledge

[29]

Visy’s interference with the applicant’s contractual rights

[41]

Visy’s alleged misleading and deceptive conduct

[43]

Applicant’s loss and damage

[48]

Visy’s submissions

[54]

Procuring a breach of contract

[54]

No inducement

[61]

No knowledge

[63]

Evidence as to Mr Stein’s state of mind

[67]

No loss and damage

[69]

The applicant’s witnesses

[81]

The evidence of Mr Yii

[82]

The evidence of Ms McKeith

[83]

The evidence of Mr Stewart

[84]

The evidence of Mr Taylor

[95]

The evidence of Mr Morris

[100]

Visy’s witnesses

[108]

The evidence of Mr Stein

[108]

The evidence of Mr Meek

[139]

The evidence of Mr Shale

[152]

The evidence of Mr Smithells

[172]

The evidence of Mr de Souza

[177]

CONSIDERATION

[183]

Tortious inducement of breach of contract

[183]

Relevant principles concerning the tort

[183]

Aus-Lid’s breach of contract

[186]

Inducement or procurement of breach

[190]

........ ... When will wilful blindness or reckless indifference ground a finding of intention?

[196]

........ ... A bona fide belief reasonably entertained?

[209]

........ ... An issue of sufficiency of causation

[218]

Visy’s knowledge of the contract and of the relevant terms

[224]

What was the inducement?

[232]

A bona fide belief reasonably entertained?

[237]

Wilful blindness or reckless indifference

[249]

The rule in Browne v Dunn

[264]

Damages for tortious inducement of contract

[265]

Misleading and deceptive conduct

[296]

Relevant principles concerning misleading and deceptive conduct

[296]

The representations made by Visy to Chobani

[300]

The nature of any interest granted to Visy

[314]

Loss or damage under s 236 of the ACL

[321]

ASSESSMENT OF DAMAGES AS AGAINST AUS-LID ENTERPRISES

[330]

DISPOSITION

[349]

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Visy submitted that its discussions with Aus-Lid and its engagement with the applicant were “sufficient to discharge any allegation that it acted with wilful blindness or reckless indifference, or that it had actual knowledge”. It affirmed that:Visy made enquiries of the Auslid Parties, and … it was assured that the Auslid Parties had power to grant the licence. It is undisputed that the Aus-Lid entities assured Visy that [the applicant] was in breach, that Visy was licensed, and that the Aus-Lid entities would negotiate with Cryovac on multiple occasions.In making enquiries of the Aus-Lid entities, Visy acted quickly, and with diligence. It was caught in the invidious position of being in the middle of a dispute between the Aus-Lid [Entities] and [the applicant], and it was called upon, effectively, to adjudicate that dispute, which appeared to turn on complex factual allegations as to whether [the applicant] had complied with the terms of its licence. Given the level of Visy’s investment in the Combo-Lids, and its commitment to Chobani to provide a spoon-in-lid product, it is understandable that Visy was cautious to accept [the applicant’s] advice that the Aus-Lid entities were in breach, when the Aus-Lid entities repeatedly provided contrary advice. It certainly cannot be said to have been wilfully blind, or recklessly indifferent, to [the applicant’s] interests, simply because it did not accept [the applicant’s] position uncritically.(Citations omitted)Evidence as to Mr Stein’s state of mind In closing submissions in answer to the applicant, Visy submitted that it was not open to the applicant to contend that Mr Stein did not believe Mr de Souza because the applicant had not complied with the rule in Browne v Dunn. Further, and for the same reason, Visy submitted it was not open to the applicant to assert that Mr Stein was dissembling and evasive; or that his evidence was a self-serving reconstruction; or that Mr Stein had no real interest in finding the facts; or that he (and therefore Visy) did not believe that the sublicence had been terminated. Visy submitted that Mr Stein’s evidence was that he did not have reason to believe Mr de Souza would lie and that Visy was interested in the true facts but was getting two versions, one from a competitor who was interested in Visy stopping supply and one from the licensor of the relevant patent. Mr Stein’s evidence was, so Visy said, consistent with the contemporaneous documents and should be accepted. Referring to Hunt J’s description of the rule in Allied Pastoral Holdings Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [1983] 1 NSWLR 1 at 16 and MWJ v The Queen [2005] HCA 74; 80 ALJR 329, Visy submitted that the applicant did not put to Mr Stein that he did not believe Mr de Souza and that the Court should therefore abstain from making adverse findings about Mr Stein and Visy. Visy added that some of the circumstances cited by the applicant to support the proposition that Mr Stein should not have believed Mr de Souza ignored the evidence.No loss and damage

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At one point, as discussed below, Visy’s in-house lawyer raised doubts about the due execution of the Patent Licence Agreement. These doubts were ill-founded. A company’s power to make a contract may be exercised by an individual acting with the company’s authority: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 126 and 127(4). There was no suggestion that the signed document was not intended (in the relevant sense) to create legal relations: cf Toll (FGCT) Pty Limited v Alphapharm Pty Limited [2004] HCA 52; 219 CLR 165 at [38], [40]. Under cl 3.1 of the Patent Licence Agreement, Auslid Operations (defined as ‘Auslid’) granted the applicant “an irrevocable, exclusive sublicence” to exploit Aus-Lid’s Patent (see cl 1) “in the Field in the Territory”. Under cl 3.2, Aus-Lid Enterprises (defined as “The Patentee”) consented to the grant. As defined in cl 1, the “Field” relevantly covered “the manufacture and supply of containers for pre-packaged food containing dairy products”, and the “Territory” covered Australia and New Zealand. Also as defined, the word “exploit” in the Agreement had the same meaning as in the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) and therefore included the manufacture, sale and supply of the patented product. Clause 4.1 of the Patent Licence Agreement provided that:The sublicence granted in clause 3.1 is an exclusive sublicence in the Field and the Patentee and Auslid must not together or separately undertake any commercial activity in the Field or grant any rights in favour of or to any third party in that Field. Clause 7.1(c) of the Patent Licence Agreement further provided that:Each of the Patentee and Auslid agrees and acknowledges that: …(c)it shall not interfere with Cryovac’s enjoyment of the sublicence granted under the terms of this Agreement; … In these proceedings, the applicant claimed that each of Aus-Lid Enterprises and Auslid Operations breached clauses 4.1 and 7.1(c) of the Patent Licence Agreement. As explained below, this claim is accepted, because, through Mr de Souza, these two companies granted Visy the right to manufacture and sell the patented spoon-in-lid product to Chobani and knowingly permitted and encouraged Visy to continue to manufacture and supply that product to Chobani. Circumstances of the apprehended breach of the Patent Licence Agreement Visy admitted, in its Further Amended Defence, that in about June 2014 it began to manufacture and sell a spoon-in-lid product that fell within the scope of Aus-Lid’s Patent to Chobani in Australia and continues to do so. The evidence of Mr Stewart, who held senior sales positions with the applicant at the relevant time, was (and I accept) that, in about August/September 2012, the applicant began supplying the patented Combo-Lids and associated tubs to Chobani for Chobani’s “Gippsland Dairy” brand of yoghurt. The applicant remained the exclusive supplier of these products until about mid-2014. In about May 2014, the applicant became aware that Visy was supplying a virtually identical spoon-in-lid product to Chobani. Further, from about June-July 2014, there was a noticeable reduction in the number of Combo-Lids supplied by the applicant to Chobani and from March 2015 the supply ceased completely.