The Environment Centre NT Inc v Minister for Resources and Water (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

The Environment Centre NT Inc v Minister for Resources and Water (No 2) [2021] FCA 1635

File number: NSD 758 of 2021
Judgment of: GRIFFITHS J
Date of judgment: 23 December 2021
Catchwords:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review challenge to legislative instrument and decisions arising from the Beetaloo Strategic Basin Plan – decision to prescribe the Beetaloo Cooperative Drilling Program by statutory instrument for the purposes of s 33(1) of the Industry, Research and Development Act 1986 (Cth) (IRD Act) (the Instrument) – where Program provides for up to $50 million in funding for gas exploration activities in Beetaloo sub-basin – decision by Minister to approve approximately $21 million in funding under the Program to third respondent (Approval Decision) – whether the phrase “after making reasonable inquiries” in s 71 of the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (Cth) (PGPA Act) is an objective jurisdictional pre-condition before making the Instrument or Approval Decision – whether Minister required to make reasonable inquiries into climate change and related risks arising from gas exploration and production – where Minister did not make inquiries into climate change or related risks – whether Minister contravened the Commonwealth Grants Rules and Guidelines 2017 in making Instrument or Approval Decision

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – whether Instrument or Approval Decision legally unreasonable – where Minister did not make inquiries into climate change and related risks – consideration of higher threshold of legal unreasonableness for delegated legislation – Instrument not legally unreasonable in appropriate legal sense – whether Approval Decision exercise of statutory or non-statutory power – Approval Decision amenable to judicial review for legal unreasonableness whether statutory or non-statutory power exercised  – held: no legal unreasonableness

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – two alleged factual errors in Department’s Brief to Minister before Approval Decision – held: no jurisdictional error
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – challenge to Commonwealth’s decision to enter into three contracts with third respondent on 9 September 2021 (Contracts Decision) on grounds of legal unreasonableness, irrationality or illogicality – consideration of outcome-focussed unreasonableness where no reasons for decision available – where no evident and intelligible justification for timing of Contracts Decision in context of the current proceedings and correspondence between the parties – where Commonwealth did not adduce any evidence at final hearing as to the timing of the Contracts Decision – whether Court can take into account affidavit filed at interlocutory stage but not read – consideration of common law model litigant obligations – where the Commonwealth accepted that entering into the contracts with no prior notice to the applicant in the context of the proceedings and correspondence was in breach of common law model obligations – where Commonwealth accepted that its conduct denied the applicant an opportunity to seek interlocutory injunctive relief – breach of common law model litigant obligations relevant to legal unreasonableness –whether Court should refuse relief in exercise of its discretion – held: timing of Contracts Decision legally unreasonable – declaratory relief granted and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Environment Centre NT Inc v Minister for Resources and W... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 1635
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, The Environment Centre NT Inc brought a judicial review challenge against the Minister for Resources and Water regarding the Beetaloo Strategic Basin Plan. The applicant sought to contest the decision to prescribe the Beetaloo Cooperative Drilling Program and the decision to approve funding for gas exploration activities in the Beetaloo sub-basin. The primary issues revolved around whether the Minister was required to make reasonable inquiries into climate change and related risks before making these decisions and whether the decisions were legally unreasonable. The court determined that the phrase "after making reasonable inquiries" in the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (PGPA Act) was not an objective jurisdictional pre-condition. The court also held that the Minister was not required to make inquiries into climate change and related risks before approving the funding. However, the court found that the timing of the Commonwealth's decision to enter into three contracts with the third respondent was legally unreasonable, as it breached common law model litigant obligations by entering into the contracts without prior notice to the applicant. The court granted declaratory relief and set aside the Contracts Decision. The court ordered that the Commonwealth's decision dated 9 September 2021 to enter into three contracts with the third respondent is invalid and void. The decision is set aside, and the further amended originating application is dismissed. The parties are directed to seek to agree on orders for costs, with a specific timeline provided for submitting written outlines of submissions on costs if an agreement cannot be reached.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Court declares that the Commonwealth’s decision dated 9 September 2021 to enter into three contracts with the third respondent is invalid.

2. The said three contracts dated 9 September 2021 are declared void.

3. The Commonwealth’s decision referred to in order 1 is set aside.

4. The further amended originating application filed on 24 September 2021 otherwise be dismissed.

5. In the light of these reasons for judgment and orders the parties should seek to agree orders for costs. If they are unable to do so:

(a) within 28 days hereof, each party is to file and serve a written outline of submissions, not exceeding three pages in length, in support of their respective positions on costs;

(b) within a further 7 days thereof, each party is to file and serve a written outline of submissions in response, not exceeding two pages in length; and

(c) the Court will then determine the issue of costs on the papers and without a further oral hearing.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before addressing each of those four grounds in turn, it is desirable to summarise some relevant background facts and set out some relevant statutory and other provisions.Summary of background facts The applicant is the peak community-sector environment organisation in the Northern Territory. It has a particular interest in the topic of climate change and the effect of gas exploration and extraction activities in the Northern Territory generally (and in the Beetaloo sub-basin) on biodiversity and climate change. There was no dispute that the applicant had standing to bring the present proceedings. As mentioned above, in January 2021 the Government published the Strategic Plan, which has given rise to the Program. An express aim of the Strategic Plan is to grow the onshore gas industry in the Northern Territory by “unlocking” and “enabling” the exploration of the Beetaloo sub-basin and extracting and using gas from that area. The Program was prescribed by the Instrument which was made by the Minister on 11 May 2021 under s 33(1) of the IRD Act. On 17 June 2021, the Minister made the Approval Decision, which involved granting approximately $21 million to Imperial in respect of three new exploration wells located in Imperial’s “EP187 exploration zone”. Imperial held an exploration permit under s 20 of the Petroleum Act 1984 (NT) which authorised it to conduct exploration in that zone. Exploration Permit 187 (EP187) covers approximately 3-4% of the Beetaloo sub-basin. The original term of EP187 was extended to 19 March 2022 (and then subsequently to September 2022), following a moratorium on hydraulic fracturing of onshore unconventional shale reservoirs in the Northern Territory pending a report by an independent scientific panel on that topic (the Pepper Inquiry). The moratorium was lifted in April 2018 after the Pepper Inquiry released its final report, which found that if 135 recommendations to mitigate the risks of hydraulic fracturing were implemented, the risks could be minimised “to an acceptable level”, and in some instances “avoided all together”. The applicant commenced its judicial review challenge on 28 July 2021, at which time it challenged the lawfulness of the Instrument and the Approval Decision. It will be necessary to describe in some detail the subsequent course of that litigation and, in particular, the events leading up to the Commonwealth’s decision to execute three contracts with Imperial on 9 September 2021 (the Imperial Contracts). As noted above, the lawfulness of the Contracts Decision is challenged under ground 5, on grounds of legal unreasonableness, irrationality and/or illogicality. The burden of that challenge turns on the timing of the Contracts Decision and the context in which it was made, with particular reference to an exchange of correspondence between the applicant’s solicitors and the Commonwealth. That correspondence concerns the timing of the Contracts Decision and the Commonwealth’s failure to provide a substantive response to the applicant’s request that the Commonwealth undertake not to enter into any contracts with Imperial pending finalisation of the judicial review challenge. (a) The Program

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Underwood candidly acknowledged that these decisions were made by Imperial’s parent company in full awareness of the current judicial review challenge. Accordingly, the parent Board appreciated that there was some risk that Imperial would not receive the Government grants. Mr Underwood stated, however, that the parent Board considered the risks to be acceptable on the basis that it considered inter alia that the Commonwealth had acted in accordance with its obligations and no injunction had been sought restraining any party from entering into the Imperial Contracts. Mr Underwood said that Imperial was pursuing a strategy focussed on bringing EP187 into commercial production promptly, which requires drilling multiple wells. Finally, Mr Underwood said that he was unable to say whether the parent Board would have acted as it did in progressing the works if it did not have the benefit of the Imperial Contracts. He said that this “would have been a finely balanced judgment for the [parent] Board”. Mr Underwood was not required for cross-examination and I accept his evidence. (c) Applicant’s evidence regarding climate change The applicant relied on the following three expert reports which described the risks presented by climate change and related matters, including in relation to the extraction and use of gas from the Beetaloo sub-basin:(a)a report by Dr Hugh Saddler, who is a consultant in the general fields of energy policy, economics and technology assessment. Dr Saddler’s report provided estimates of the potential total greenhouse gas emissions arising from the exploration and exploitation of gas fields in the Beetaloo sub-basin;(b)a report by Professor Nerilie Abram. Professor Abram is a professor of Climate Science at the Australia National University and a current member of the International Climate Crisis Advisory Group chaired by Sir David King from the University of Cambridge. In her report, Professor Abram described the threats posed by climate change to the environment and the economy, as well as the relationship between estimated GHG emissions from the extraction and consumption of gas from the Beetaloo sub-basin with Australian and international global targets for limiting global temperature rise; and(c)a report by Ms Nicki Hutley, economist (the Hutley Report). In her report, Ms Hutley described the current and likely future economic costs of anthropogenic climate change and the economic costs and benefits of the anticipated development of the Beetaloo sub-basin as described in the Program. None of the experts was required for cross-examination. It is necessary to summarise the key matters which emerge from this expert evidence. Significantly, however, it should be noted at the outset that the expert evidence was substantially directed to climate change and related risks posed by the Program as a whole and was not specifically directed to the climate change implications of the exploration and appraisal activities which are the subject of the Imperial Contracts.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Nor do I accept that the Minister was required to make “reasonable inquiries” into the risks associated with the economic viability of the extraction of gas from the Beetaloo sub-basin as outlined in the Hutley Report. In the particular circumstances of this case, these economic risks (as well as the related climate change risks) were not directly relevant to whether the grants to Imperial were a “proper” use of relevant money at the time of the making of the Approval Decision. The Minister in making the Approval Decision was merely required to be satisfied that the grant or grants to Imperial were a “proper use” of relevant money in the context of the Program and its outcomes and objectives, or as opposed to some other application for funding by another company holding an exploration permit in the Beetaloo sub-basin. (d) Did the Minister contravene the 2017 Guidelines in making the Approval Decision? The applicant advanced three alternative submissions in support of its claim that there were contraventions of the 2017 Guidelines in making the Approval Decision (as opposed to the Instrument). I will explain why I reject each of those contentions in turn. First, the applicant contended that if there was a contravention of s 71(1) of the PGPA Act, there must necessarily be a contravention of cl 3.3 of the 2017 Guidelines which, in effect, reaffirms that statutory provision. For the reasons given above, I do not accept there was a contravention of s 71(1) of the PGPA Act in making the Approval Decision. Secondly, the applicant contended that, even if there was no contravention of s 71(1), there would be a breach of cl 4.10 of the 2017 Guidelines (when read together with cl 4.6(d)) because none of the advice given to the Minister related to the climate change risks or economic risks associated with the viability of gas extraction described in the Hutley Report. The applicant contended that this meant there was a failure to give the Minister advice on the merits of the proposed grants relative to the key principle of achieving value with relevant money. For similar reasons as set out at [89]-[90] above, I reject the proposition that the Minister needed to be briefed on the climate change risks or economic risks advanced by the applicant in relation to “achieving value with relevant money” in making the Approval Decision. The relevant question was whether the grants were “achieving value with relevant money” in the context of the Program objectives and outcomes. The assessment committee assessed and found that Imperial’s applications met this requirement, subject to certain conditions (Attachment A to the Department’s Brief) (see [120]-[122] below). Thirdly, in oral address, Mr Herzfeld SC submitted that there had been a failure to comply with cl 4.10 of the 2017 Guidelines because, in making the Approval Decision, no advice was given to the Minister regarding the outline of the selection process followed, how the allocation method was developed, how implementation issues were considered and an outline of risk mitigation strategies (see footnote 35 to cl 4.6(c), which applies to “demand-driven grant opportunities”). The Commonwealth did not appear to contest that the Program is a “demand-driven” grant opportunity. It is arguable that the Department’s Brief did not contain all of the information identified in footnote 35 to cl 4.6(c). However, the fact that the statement that advice under cl 4.6(c) should include such information is contained in a footnote rather than a substantive clause, contains ambulatory phrases of imprecise meaning (eg. “implementation issues” and “risk mitigation strategies”), and uses the imperative “should” instead of “must”, strongly suggests that it was not intended to be a mandatory requirement for compliance with cl 4.6(c). In my view, it is better seen as an indicator of “best practice”, which accords with other uses of footnotes within the 2017 Guidelines (see, eg, footnotes 31, 37 and 39). As such, any failure of the Department’s Brief to comply with footnote 35 does not constitute a jurisdictional error, or invalidate the Approval Decision.(e) The effect of any non-compliance

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is also relevant to note footnote 35 to cl 4.6, which provides that “[f]or demand-driven grant opportunities, this advice should include: how the allocation method was developed; how implementation issues were considered; and an outline of risk mitigation strategies”.Consideration and determination To avoid adding unduly to the length of these reasons for judgment, rather than summarise the parties’ primary submissions, I will address those submissions in considering and determining the four remaining judicial review grounds. Ground 1 – Failure to comply with s 71 of the PGPA Act and/or the Guidelines when making the Instrument and the Approval Decision The following issues arise:(a)Whether the phrase “after making reasonable inquiries” in s 71(1) of the PGPA Act involves a jurisdictional pre-condition which must be satisfied objectively before the Minister can approve the proposed expenditure of relevant money?(b)Whether s 71(1) of the PGPA Act applied at all to the making of the Instrument?(c)If s 71(1) applied to either the Instrument or the Approval Decision, to what extent did it, or the 2017 Guidelines, oblige the Minister to make reasonable inquiries in relation to various matters associated with climate change?(d)If the 2017 Guidelines applied to either the Instrument or the Approval Decision, did they comply with cll 4.6 and 4.10 of the Guidelines (independently of s 71 of the PGPA Act)?(e)If there was non-compliance with s 71(1) and/or the 2017 Guidelines, was the effect of the non-compliance to invalidate the Instrument or the Approval Decision? I shall now address each of these issues in turn.(a) Is the making of reasonable inquiries under s 71(1) of the PGPA Act an objective jurisdictional pre-condition? The applicant contended that s 71(1) has two steps. The first is that the Minister makes reasonable inquiries. The second is that the Minister is satisfied, after doing so, that the expenditure would be a proper use of relevant money. The applicant contended that the first step under s 71(1) relating to the making of reasonable inquiries is framed as an objective requirement and not as a requirement which turns merely on the Minister’s subjective judgment or opinion. The applicant contended that, because the first step in s 71(1) is objective (and not subjective), it is a matter for the Court to determine whether reasonable inquiries had in fact been made in all the circumstances, rather than the scope of judicial review being confined to the review of the Minister’s subjective opinion on the matter. In short, the applicant contended that the requirement that there be “reasonable inquiries” was an objective pre-condition to an exercise of power to which s 71 applied (citing inter aliaPlaintiff M96A v Commonwealth [2017] HCA 16; 261 CLR 582 at [39] per Gageler J). The applicant relied upon the following five primary matters in support of that contention. First, it pointed to [347] of the Revised Explanatory Memorandum to the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Bill 2013 (Cth) (PGPA EM) which states:A Minister must make reasonable inquiries to determine whether a proposed expenditure is a proper use of relevant money.