Donaldson v Natural Springs Australia Limited [2015] FCA 498
Citation:
Donaldson v Natural Springs Australia Limited [2015] FCA 498
Parties:
GORDON BRUCE DONALDSON v NATURAL SPRINGS AUSTRALIA LIMITED, JURGEN CHRISTIAN KURT SCHLOTZER, WOLFGANG ZINK, PETER ROSE and PRIME LOG BROKERS LTD
File number:
VID 1178 of 2011
Judge:
BEACH J
Date of judgment:
22 May 2015
Catchwords:
CORPORATIONS – sale of shares by ex-director to third party – oral sale agreement – deficiencies in process for share transfers – incomplete share transfers forms – alleged interference in transfer of shares – alleged failure to register share transfers – alleged oppression – s 232 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – oppressive conduct not established
CONTRACT – Constitution as a contract – alleged breach of express or implied terms in Constitution – no breach established
TORT – economic torts – tort of interference with contractual relations – direct interference – inducing breach of contract – indirect interference – unlawful means – broader English tort – tort claims fail
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Donaldson v Natural Springs Australia Ltd and more:
The Federal Court of Australia presided over a case between Donaldson and Natural Springs Australia Ltd, where the former sought relief on multiple grounds including alleged breaches of the company's constitution, interference with contractual relations, and oppressive conduct under the Corporations Act. Donaldson, originally the sole director and shareholder of Natural Springs, claimed that subsequent share transfers and company operations were improperly managed, leading to a series of legal disputes.
The court was tasked with determining whether Donaldson had established a breach of the company's constitution, if there had been any interference with contractual relations, and if the conduct of the company's directors amounted to oppression under s 232 of the Corporations Act. Additionally, the court examined Donaldson's claims against other defendants related to economic torts, specifically interference with contractual relations, and whether these claims were substantiated.
The court found that Donaldson's claims were without merit. It concluded that there was no breach of the company's constitution, no actionable interference with contractual relations, and no oppressive conduct by the company's directors. The court also determined that the economic tort claims failed as Donaldson did not demonstrate any damage resulting from the alleged torts. Consequently, the court dismissed all of Donaldson's claims and ordered him to pay the defendants' costs. Additionally, the defendants were granted liberty to apply for costs against other parties involved in the case.
The orders made by the court were clear and decisive: Donaldson's originating application was dismissed, he was ordered to pay the defendants' costs, and the defendants were granted the right to seek additional costs from other parties. These orders reflected the court's findings that Donaldson's claims were unfounded and that he had not demonstrated any damages resulting from the alleged breaches or torts.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The plaintiff’s originating application be dismissed.
2. The plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to the proceeding including any reserved costs.
3. The defendants have liberty to apply for an additional order for costs against David Graer and Hakel Investments Pty Ltd.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
For the reasons that follow, in my view Donaldson’s originating application should be dismissed.FACTUAL BACKGROUND The background to this matter is protracted. Natural Springs was a company that exported spring water to Asian markets including Singapore. Natural Springs initially operated by sourcing Australian spring water and bulk shipping it to Albatross International Pty Ltd (Albatross) in Singapore, its agent for a time, for bottling. On 21 May 2001, Donaldson acquired the issued capital of Natural Springs (then called “Your Team Pty Ltd” and later “Liquid Bulk Solutions Pty Ltd” until its name change to Natural Springs as part of the 22 March 2005 restructure). Until 22 March 2005, Donaldson was the sole director and shareholder. From 2002, the second defendant Jurgen Schlotzer (Schlotzer) was an employee of Natural Springs. Schlotzer was also a director of Albatross from 1 June 2004. On 22 March 2005, Natural Springs was restructured. Schlotzer and the third defendant Wolfgang Zink (Zink) were appointed as directors, with Donaldson continuing as a director. Schlotzer was also made the manager of finance and logistics; Schlotzer was also an alternate director for Zink. At that time, each of Donaldson, Schlotzer and Zink effectively acquired 11.96 million shares in Natural Springs. Schlotzer's shares were held by the fifth defendant, Prime Log Brokers Pty Ltd (Prime Log), a company of which he was the majority shareholder and managing director. Zink was based in British Columbia, Canada and at all relevant times was absent from Australia. Zink’s shares were held on trust. The fourth defendant Peter Rose (Rose) was an investor who, along with his wife Leisa Rose, acquired a shareholding of 3.12 million shares held on trust for the Rose Family Trust. The 11,959,900 shares issued to Donaldson on 22 March 2005 were issued to him in his capacity as trustee of the Donaldson Family Trust. At that time, Donaldson already personally held 100 shares in Natural Springs, which shareholding pre-dated the restructure. The fact that Donaldson’s shares were held in two different parcels and in two different capacities is relevant to an issue which I will later address concerning the forms of share transfers that he later proffered for registration under cl 51 of Natural Springs’ Constitution. On 19 May 2005, Natural Springs was converted to an unlisted public company and adopted a new Constitution. Relevantly, cll 2, 6, 11(a), 18, 20, 23, 24, 45, 46 and 51 to 53 of the Constitution provided:Effect as a Contract2. This Constitution is as a contract between:(a) the Company and each Member, and(b) the Company and each Director and each Secretary, and(c)a Member and each other Member; and each person agrees to observe perform and be bound this Constitution.…Management of Company6.The Company is managed by its Directors, who may delegate their powers.…Powers & Entitlements11.The Directors may do anything permitted by law, including each of the following:(a)exercise all of the powers of the Company which are not required to be exercised by the Members in General Meeting;…Calling of Meetings18.A Director may call a Directors' Meeting at any time, and the Secretary will call a meeting of Directors if asked to do so by a Director.…Quorum20.At least 2 Directors must be present before business can be transacted at a Directors’ Meeting.…Voting at Directors’ Meetings23.A question that arises at a Directors' Meeting will be decided by a vote. The Chairperson of the meeting may not cast a second vote. A decision reached by vote is treated as the decision of all the Directors. In the event of equal votes, the question will be deemed to have been decided in the negative.Method of Meeting24.The Directors may hold a meeting in person, or by telephone, video conference or any other means of communication, provided everyone can hear and be heard throughout the meeting. If the meeting is not held in person, each of the following conditions are to be met for the meeting to be valid:(a)each of the Directors has received notice of the fact that the meeting is to be held; and(b)each Director who is present must announce, at the beginning of the meeting, that he or she is present.…Share Certificates45.The Company will give each Member, free of charge, a Share Certificate. In the event that Company maintains a Seal, the Directors may determine if it is to be affixed to a certificate issued. If the Company does not maintain a Seal, or if the Directors have not determined that the Seal be affixed, then a Share Certificate will be signed by a Director or Secretary of the Company. If the shares are jointly owned, it is sufficient to give a Share Certificate to one of the joint Members.Recognition of Interests in Shares46.Except where required at law, the only interest in shares that the Company recognises is the registered Member's absolute right to the whole of the share.…Transfer Of Shares51.A Member may transfer shares to another person by completing a written transfer document in a common form or a form approved by the Directors, signed by or on behalf of the Member and the purchaser. To have the transfer registered by the Company, the transferor or transferee must give the written transfer document and the relevant share certificates to the Company. The Directors may require additional evidence of the transferee's entitlement to be registered before registering the transfer. The transferee becomes the holder of the shares when the transfer is registered and his or her name is entered in the Register of Members. The Company retains the transfer document.Suspension Of Registration52.The Directors may suspend registration of shares at any time for any reason, however the total period of suspension must not exceed 30 days in any year.No Right To Refuse To Register Transfer53.Except as permitted by the Act or at law, the Directors may not refuse to register any transfer.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
In summary, Donaldson has not made out a claim that he suffered damage, even if he had otherwise established one or more of his causes of action on the liability elements.CONCLUSION Donaldson has failed on all claims. His proceeding will be dismissed. Further, there is no good reason why costs should not follow the event. Further, I will give the defendants the opportunity to also apply for a costs order against Hakel Investments and Graer. First, they and/or Young partially funded Donaldson’s proceeding. Second, some time was taken up pursuing an issue concerning Hakel Investments’ capacity to pay, which time and expense appears to me to have been largely caused by the unsatisfactory nature and evolution of Graer’s evidence on this question.