Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha Ltd v Tomar (No 6)

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha Ltd v Tomar (No 6) [2013] FCA 284

Citation: Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha Ltd v Tomar (No 6) [2013] FCA 284
Parties: ANANDA MARGA PRACARAKA SAMGHA LTD (ACN 003 193 897), DEVENDHRAN VADIVELOO PILLAY and PRABANJAMURTHI PILLAI v SUNIL KUMAR SINGH TOMAR, CLAUDIA ALISTER, RICHARD PFEIFFER, TIWARI DAYASHANKAR, PAUL ALISTER, DIETER DAMBIEC, JAKE KARLYLE, LUKE DEACON, MIRAI DEACON, MICHAEL TOWSEY and DHARANENDRAN PARTHY
File number: VID 208 of 2010
Judge: DODDS-STREETON J
Date of judgment: 3 April 2013
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – Company limited by guarantee – objects include “to propagate the ideals, the philosophy and practice” of the Ananda Marga religion – all members typically directors – worldwide schism in Ananda Marga movement and emergence of two competing central administrations in Ranchi and Kolkata, India – company’s board resolves not to follow without scrutiny any directives of central administration – dispute over identity of members of company – defendants resolve to remove plaintiff directors – defendants allege membership of plaintiffs and their associates in breach of corporate objects and implied terms of constitution due to loss of good standing with Ranchi administration – whether membership of plaintiffs and their associates terminated - construction of company’s constitution – whether Ranchi administration and office holders hold legitimate authority in Ananda Marga – whether plaintiffs and their associates deprived of good standing in Ananda Marga – whether plaintiffs and their associates members of company – whether third to eleventh defendants members of company.

CORPORATIONS – Oppression – s 232 of Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – whether plaintiffs’ membership or control of company contrary to the legitimate expectations of members and purposes of incorporators – whether plaintiffs withheld financial information from first defendant or held meetings on short notice.

CORPORATIONS – whether just and equitable to wind company up – ss 233 and 461(1)(k) of Act – whether failure of company’s substratum – whether deadlock – whether practically impossible for company to carry out its activities due to bifurcated board and incapacity to identify members – effect of multiple contraventions of Act – whether alternative to winding up.

Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 46, 53, 168(1), 169(1), 231, 232, 233(1)(a), 234, 248C, 248D, 292, 301, 314, 317, 461(1)(k), 465A, 1322(4)
Charitable Collections Act 1934-41 (NSW)
West Bengal Societies Registration Act 1961 (India)
Cases cited:

Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha (ACN 003 193 897) v Tomar [2010] FCA 565 cited
Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha Ltd v Tomar (No 2) [2010] FCA 1342 cited
Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha v Tomar (No 4) [2012] FCA 385 cited
Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha v Tomar (No 5) [2012] FCA 390 cited
Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha & Ors v Acarya Raghunath Prasad & Ors (Unreported, Court of the Civil Judge (Senior Division) Purulia, West Bengal Title Suit No 305 of 2003, 18 March 2006) considered
Bentley v Anglican Synod of the Diocese of New Westminster (2010) 326 D.L.R. (4th) 280 discussed
Bratton Seymour Service Co Ltd v Oxborough [1992] 13 BCLC 693…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha Ltd v Tomar (No 6) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 284
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha Ltd v Tomar (No 6) involved a dispute within the Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha, a company limited by guarantee founded on the teachings of Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar. The company's objectives included propagating the ideals, philosophy, and practices of the Ananda Marga religion. The court was required to address several key issues, including the legitimacy of the defendants' actions in attempting to remove certain directors, the interpretation of the company's constitution, and whether the plaintiffs and their associates remained members of the company. Additionally, the court examined whether the plaintiffs' control of the company was oppressive and if it was just and equitable to wind up the company.

The court's reasoning was centred on the interpretation of the company's constitution, the authority of the Ranchi administration, and the membership status of the plaintiffs and their associates. The court found that the plaintiffs' actions did not breach the company's objects or implied terms of its constitution. The court also held that the Ranchi administration did not possess legitimate authority in Ananda Marga, and that the plaintiffs and their associates had not lost their good standing in the organisation. Consequently, the plaintiffs and their associates were determined to be members of the company, while the defendants were not. The court dismissed the defendants' claims regarding oppression and the just and equitable winding up of the company, finding that the plaintiffs' conduct, while not exemplary, did not warrant such drastic remedies.

The court's outcome was largely in favour of the plaintiffs, affirming their entitlement to relief as sought in their amended application. The defendants' allegations regarding membership, breach of objects, oppression, failure of the substratum, and practical impossibility of achieving the company's objectives were not upheld. The court deferred the decision on winding up the company on the just and equitable ground, seeking a report from an independent expert on compliance and future measures to ensure statutory compliance and governance. The court also invited submissions on the form of orders reflecting the reasons for judgment, and directed the parties to confer on the proposed minutes of orders and the selection of experts for the report.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties are directed to confer and in the event of agreement file and serve on or before 4.00pm on 24 April 2013 joint proposed minutes of orders (including as to costs) reflecting the reasons for judgment published on 3 April 2013 in relation to:

a. the plaintiffs’ amended application dated 16 April 2012; and

b. the defendants’ further amended cross claim dated 4 November 2011 (save in relation to the relief sought pursuant to s 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) referred to in paragraph C(2) of the prayer for relief).

2. In the event that the parties cannot agree as to the appropriate minutes of orders, each party shall file and serve on or before 4.00pm on 24 April 2013 proposed minutes of orders together with written submissions (not to exceed 10 pages) in support.

3. The parties are directed to confer and in the event of agreement shall on or before 4.00pm on 24 April 2013 file a minute proposing a maximum number of three experts to prepare the report referred to in paragraph 620 of the reasons for judgment, together with a brief statement of the experts’ qualifications and estimated fees and costs.

4. In the event the parties are unable to reach the agreement referred to in order 3, each party is directed to file and serve on or before 4.00pm on 24 April 2013 a minute proposing a maximum number of two experts together with a brief statement of the experts’ qualifications and estimated fees and costs.

5. The further hearing of the proceeding is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Due to the time that has elapsed since the hearing of this matter and the publication of these reasons, I record that I formed and maintained my opinion of the above witnesses at the time of trial.BACKGROUND FACTSWhat is Ananda Marga? It was common ground that Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha was founded in India in 1955 by Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar, who is known to adherents (and referred to in these reasons) as “the Founder”. “Ananda Marga” means “the Path of Bliss”, “Pracaraka” indicates “propagation” and “Samgha” denotes an organisation. Ananda Marga is described in the company’s memorandum as amended as “an autonomous religion, faith and social system based upon the teachings of the Founder and Preceptor of Ananda Marga, Shri PR Sarkar also known as Shrii Shrii Anandamurti”. It was also common ground that the Founder of Ananda Marga wrote prolifically and published over 260 works, including a seminal, three‑part text or scripture known as “Carya Carya”, which was first published in India in April 1956. (The first English edition of Carya Carya Part I was published in 1962). Carya Carya Part I commences with “The Supreme Command” which states, inter alia:Those who perform sadhana twice a day regularly… their liberation is a sure guarantee. Therefore every Ananda Margi will have to perform sadhana twice a day invariably; verily is this the command of the Lord. … It is the bounden duty of every Ananda Margi to endeavour to bring all to the path of bliss. Part I of Carya Carya otherwise deals, broadly speaking, with ritual and conduct (including ceremonies for naming infants, marriage, initiation in yoga and appropriate dress) and “social punishment”. It also prescribes a bureaucratic organisation (including boards, committees and their members and officers) relevant to this case. Carya Carya Part II deals with moral precepts and instructions. Carya Carya Part III deals with yoga and meditation. It was common ground that an elaborate, multi‑tiered organisation based on Carya Carya was established in India during the Founder’s lifetime. The organisation includes a large number of committees and boards expressly referred to in Carya Carya Part I, which exercise different authority and perform different functions at a number of descending levels. The highest governing bodies based in India include a legislative‑like body called the Central Committee, which is elected every five years by the purodhas (persons of the highest spiritual rank) of Ananda Marga, and a Central Executive Committee, the members of which are appointed from Central Committee members by a President. The President is typically also the head purodha (known as the Purodha Pramukha) and may appoint three persons from outside the Central Committee, which also has a five year term. The organisation has 42 departments which operate under, and the heads of which are drawn from, the Central Executive Committee. Each of the 42 departments has a board, which may be either an ACB (general board) or named after the department involved.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The evidence did not permit me to determine whether there was a failure consistently to take minutes and to update the members’ register, a failure to keep such records secure, or a combination of both deficiencies. I accept, however, that Mr Pillay was able to reconstruct a members’ register which accurately reflects the company’s membership. In contrast to British-Israel, there is no irretrievable mess. The members of the company have been ascertained.CONCLUSION In my opinion, the plaintiffs have established their entitlement to relief broadly in the terms sought in their amended application dated 16 April 2012. The defendants’ allegations made by the further amended cross‑claim dated 4 November 2011, including in relation to membership of the company, breach of objects, oppression, failure of the substratum and the practical impossibility of achieving the company’s objects or carrying on its business were not established. Nevertheless, while dishonesty or serious misconduct was neither alleged nor established, the court cannot overlook the long‑standing pattern of multiple contraventions and lack of adequate procedures to ensure compliance with statutory requirements, which emerged on the evidence at trial, particularly given the company’s nature and scale of operation. I am not, however, at this stage persuaded that the company should be wound up on the just and equitable ground pursuant to s 461(1)(k) of the Act. While the matter is not without difficulty, I consider that the deficiencies exposed by the evidence may be addressed by means other than winding up (which is a drastic remedy of last resort) or a referral to ASIC. Accordingly, I propose to defer determination of the application under s 461(1)(k) for a short period in order that the court may receive evidence in the form of a report to the court by an appropriately qualified independent expert (such as a relevantly experienced senior legal practitioner or liquidator) on whether, and to what extent, in his or her opinion:(a)the company and the directors have, from 13 December 2010 (subject to the requirements of the interim regime established by the orders made on 13 December 2010) complied with all applicable statutory requirements in relation to meetings, keeping minutes, financial reports and audit, the lodging of returns and the keeping of books and records; and(b)the company has taken or is implementing satisfactory measures and procedures to ensure future compliance with statutory obligations and requirements and appropriate standards of governance, whether by the retention of an appropriately qualified person or staff to assist and advise the committee and/or training for the directors and secretary or otherwise. I shall invite submissions on the form of orders reflecting these reasons in relation to the amended application dated 16 April 2012 and (save for the application for relief under s 461(1)(k) of the Act) the further amended cross‑claim dated 4 November 2011.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.