Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samagha Ltd v Tomar (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha Ltd v Tomar (No 4) [2012] FCA 385

Citation: Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha Ltd v Tomar (No 4) [2012] FCA 385
Parties: ANANDA MARGA PRACARAKA SAMGHA LTD (ACN 003 193 897) & ORS (ACCORDING TO THE ATTACHED SCHEDULE) v SUNIL KUMAR SINGH TOMAR & ORS (ACCORDING TO THE ATTACHED SCHEDULE); SUNIL KUMAR SINGH TOMAR & ORS (ACCORDING TO THE ATTACHED SCHEDULE); ANANDA MARGA PRACARAKA SAMGHA LTD (ACN 003 193 879) & ORS (ACCORDING TO THE ATTACHED SCHEDULE)
File number: VID 208 of 2010
Judge: DODDS-STREETON J
Date of judgment: 2 April 2012
Catchwords: EVIDENCE – Objections to competence of proposed expert witnesses – Whether evidence relevant – Whether witnesses lacked specialised knowledge – Whether independence required
Legislation: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 76, 79, 135
Cases cited: Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar (2011) 243 CLR 588 cited
FGT Custodians Pty Ltd (formerly Feingold Partners Pty Ltd) v Fagenblat [2003] VSCA 33 followed
Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles (2001) 52 NSWLR 705 cited
Milirrpum v Nabalco Pty Ltd (1971) 17 FLR 141 cited
Pan Pharmaceuticals Limited (in liquidation) v Selim [2008] FCA 416 discussed
R v Silverlock [1894] 2 QB 766 cited
SmithKline Beecham  (Australia) Pty Ltd v Chipman (2003) 131 FCR 500 cited
Date of hearing: 2 April 2012
Date of publication of reasons: 18 April 2012
Date of last submissions: 2 April 2012
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 55
Counsel for the Plaintiffs/Cross-Defendants: Mr C Gunst QC with Mr M Irving
Solicitor for the Plaintiffs/Cross-Defendants: Holding Redlich
Counsel for the Defendants/Cross‑Claimants: Mr BE Walters SC with Mr TR Messer
Solicitor for the Defendants/Cross‑Claimants: Moores Legal

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 208 of 2010

BETWEEN:

ANANDA MARGA PRACARAKA SAMGHA LTD (ACN 003 193 897) & ORS (ACCORDING TO THE ATTACHED SCHEDULE)
Plaintiffs

SUNIL KUMAR SINGH TOMAR & ORS (ACCORDING TO THE ATTACHED SCHEDULE)
Cross-Claimants

AND:

SUNIL KUMAR SINGH TOMAR & ORS (ACCORDING TO THE ATTACHED SCHEDULE)
Defendants

ANANDA MARGA PRACARAKA SAMGHA LTD (ACN 003 193 879) & ORS (ACCORDING TO THE ATTACHED SCHEDULE)
Cross-Defendants

JUDGE:

DODDS-STREETON J

DATE:

2 APRIL 2012

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 2 April 2012, I, for the reasons set out below, dismissed the defendants’ objection, made during the course of the trial, to the giving of evidence by two witnesses, Squadron Leader Tanner and Professor Sohail Inyatullah, whom the plaintiffs sought to call as experts.

  2. Rather than objecting to the admissibility of particular aspects of the witnesses’ evidence, the defendants disputed their competence to give opinion evidence on the basis that each witness lacked:

    (a)the requisite specialised knowledge; and

    (b)the requisite independence,

    to be permitted to give expert evidence.

  3. Section 76 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (“Evidence Act”) sets out a general rule (“the opinion rule”) excluding opinion evidence tendered to prove the existence of a fact. It states:

    76       The opinion rule

    (1)Evidence of an opinion is not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samagha Ltd v Tomar (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 385
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samagha Ltd v Tomar (No 4) dealt with objections to the competence of proposed expert witnesses in a legal dispute concerning the eligibility for membership and office within a religious organisation. The case was heard in an Australian court. The defendants in the case alleged that non-members of Ananda Marga in good standing should not maintain membership or director status in the company, arguing that Ananda Marga is a hierarchical religion requiring absolute obedience to its leaders. The plaintiffs disputed this, claiming that membership eligibility does not depend on Ananda Marga membership and that there are rival claimants to the leadership of the organisation. The nature of Ananda Marga, its scriptures, and its practices were central to the dispute.

The court examined the admissibility of expert evidence under section 79 of the Evidence Act, considering whether the proposed witnesses had the requisite specialised knowledge based on their training, study, or experience. Squadron Leader Tanner, one of the proposed expert witnesses, claimed to have specialised knowledge of Ananda Marga due to her training, studies, and experience, despite her academic and professional background not directly relating to the religion. The court acknowledged that the expertise of a witness need not stem from their business or profession.

The court found that the witnesses were qualified to give opinion evidence due to their specialised knowledge, based on their training, study, and experience. It was emphasised that expert witnesses can disagree with other experts, criticise their assumptions, and highlight weaknesses in their research. However, opinion evidence that is argumentative or lacks a basis in the witness's expertise may be objected to or given reduced weight. The court concluded that the witnesses were qualified to provide expert evidence and that their lack of independence, if proven, would not preclude them from doing so.

The court's decision ensured that the proposed expert witnesses could present their opinions on the nature of Ananda Marga, its practices, and the eligibility for membership and office within the organisation. The final orders of the court would likely permit the witnesses to testify, subject to the conditions outlined in the ruling.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

More recently, in Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar (2011) 243 CLR 588 (“Dasreef”), the majority (French CJ, Gummow, Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ) stated (at [32]):To be admissible under s 79(1) the evidence that is tendered must satisfy two criteria. The first is that the witness who gives the evidence “has specialised knowledge based on the person’s training, study or experience”; the second is that the opinion expressed in evidence by the witness “is wholly or substantially based on that knowledge”. WHETHER EVIDENCE RELEVANT As the majority stated in Dasreef (at [31]), because the opinion rule directs attention to why the party tendering the evidence says it is relevant, it is necessary, in considering the operation of s 79(1), to identify the fact in issue which the tenderer asserts the opinion will prove, or assist in proving. In the present case, the defendants allege, inter alia, that it would breach the objects of the corporate first plaintiff (“the company”) if persons who are not members of Ananda Marga in good standing maintain the status of members and/or directors of the company. The defendants allege that the second and third plaintiffs and certain other persons have, inter alia, disobeyed the orders and directives of the validly constituted authority of the Ananda Marga global organisation based in India and have consequently, ipso facto, vacated or lost any office or membership status within the company. The defendants contend, in that context, that Ananda Marga is a hierarchical religion in which authority vests in various office holders, committees or organs established pursuant to the founder’s writings, the orders or directives of which adherents must unquestioningly obey. The plaintiffs dispute that the eligibility for membership of the company depends on a person’s status as a member of the Ananda Marga religion in good standing. Further and alternatively, they dispute that Ananda Marga is a hierarchical religion in which absolute obedience is owed to higher or supreme authorities or office holders. They further dispute that the persons and bodies recognised by the defendants are the validly appointed or validly constituted office holders or authorities within the Ananda Marga organisation, as there are at least two “rival” claimants, and the plaintiffs and the defendants recognise different “camps”. The nature of the Ananda Marga religion, organisation, scripture, founder’s writings and practice, are thus relevant issues in the proceeding.WHETHER SPECIALISED KNOWLEDGESquadron Leader Tanner Squadron Leader Tanner deposed that she has specialised knowledge of Ananda Marga based on her training, studies and experience. Squadron Leader Tanner, an Engineering Officer and qualified military pilot, has a number of formal academic degrees, diplomas and certificates, including a Bachelor of Engineering and two Masters degrees from Australian universities. Those formal academic qualifications and profession do not relate to Ananda Marga (although Squadron Leader Tanner deposed that her longstanding service in a military organisation inspired her interest in the Ananda Marga founder’s ideas on leadership). It is, however, unnecessary that the expertise of a witness be gained in the course of his or her business or profession (see R v Silverlock [1894] 2 QB 766).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Nevertheless, as the plaintiffs submitted, expert witnesses are entitled to disagree with other experts, to criticise their assumptions, weaknesses or lacunae in their research and to expose defects in their reasoning. Robust dissent from or criticism of the assumptions, quality and extent of research and reasoning of other experts is a frequent and sometimes necessary feature of expert testimony. Opinion evidence which is merely argumentative or lacks any evident basis in the expertise of the witness, may, however, be the subject of discrete objection, or accorded reduced or no weight.CONCLUSION I concluded that, in the present case, the relevant witnesses were qualified to give opinion evidence by reason of specialised knowledge, based on their training, study and experience, and that a lack of independence, partiality or an interest in the outcome would not, if established, preclude them from doing so.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.