Shea v TRUenergy Services Pty Ltd (No 6)

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Shea v TRUenergy Services Pty Ltd (No 6) [2014] FCA 271

Citation: Shea v TRUenergy Services Pty Ltd (No 6) [2014] FCA 271
Parties: KATE SHEA v ENERGYAUSTRALIA SERVICES PTY LTD
File number: VID 289 of 2012
Judge: DODDS-STREETON J
Date of judgment: 25 March 2014
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – employment – adverse action – respondent employer dismissed applicant employee for redundancy – adverse action taken by respondent against applicant under s 342(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)

INDUSTRIAL LAW – employment – complaints – whether adverse action taken against applicant because applicant exercised workplace rights under s 340 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – whether applicant exercised workplace rights by making any of five successive complaints in relation to her employment under s 341(1)(c)(ii) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – first and second complaint related to allegation of sexual harassment by senior colleague in Hong Kong – third complaint related to allegations of further misconduct by the senior colleague and other employees in the course of the investigation into the Hong Kong incident – fourth complaint related to the alleged deficiencies in the investigation and investigator’s report and included further allegations of misconduct by colleagues, including the respondent’s managing director – fifth complaint related to the managing director’s alleged attempt unlawfully to terminate the applicant’s employment – meaning of complaints that employee is able to make in relation to employment – whether an instrumental basis required for a complaint under s 341(1)(c)(ii) – whether complaint must be made in good faith – whether complaints made by applicant were genuine grievances made in good faith for a proper purpose – relevance of and evidence for the applicant’s allegations of misconduct by colleagues (including the respondent’s managing director) and of corporate culture tolerant of sexual harassment made in the fourth complaint and at trial

INDUSTRIAL LAW – employment – redundancy – whether restructure of the respondent’s business units and the applicant’s dismissal for redundancy were genuine – whether complaints made by the applicant a substantial and operative reason for the decision to terminate her employment for redundancy

Legislation: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140(1)
Equal Opportunity Act 1995 (Vic)
Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic)
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 340, 341, 342, 360, 361, 539(2), 545, 551
Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 (Vic) s 48(b)
Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (Vic)
Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) s 9(2)
Cases cited: Australian Postal Corporation v Stephens [2011] FCA 947
Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha Ltd v Tomar (No 4) [2012] FCA 385
BHP Coal Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining andEnergy Union [2013] FCAFC 132
Blackadderv Ramsey Butchering Services Pty Ltd (2005) 221 CLR 539
Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay (2012) 290 ALR 647; [2012] HCA 32
Brannigan v Commonwealth of Australia (2000) 110 FCR 566; [2000] FCA 1591
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) v BHP Coal…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shea v TRUenergy Services Pty Ltd (No 6) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 271
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Shea v TRUenergy Services Pty Ltd (No 6) involved Ms Shea, a former employee of TRUenergy Services Pty Ltd, who sought relief under the Fair Work Act 2009 for alleged contraventions by her former employer. Ms Shea, who had a distinguished career in public affairs and corporate relations, was dismissed by the respondent on 6 February 2012 after being employed for approximately five years. The respondent, a significant player in the energy sector with operations across multiple Australian states and a vast customer base, maintained a relatively flat management structure during the relevant period. The primary legal issues in this case centred on whether TRUenergy Services Pty Ltd contravened the Fair Work Act 2009 by making Ms Shea's position redundant under circumstances that were, in part, a response to her making protected disclosures. Additionally, the court had to determine if the employer had properly justified the redundancy and assess the credibility and weight of expert evidence presented.

In evaluating the evidence, the court noted that the expert witness, Mr Farrow, had not disclosed certain details that could have impacted his independence, such as his past work for the respondent and the fact that he prepared his reports without charge. While his evidence was helpful, the omissions affected his credibility and the weight of his testimony. The court concluded that the roles held by Ms Shea and her successor, Ms Savage, were not substantially identical, which undermined the argument that Ms Shea's redundancy was manufactured. Furthermore, the court found that TRUenergy Services Pty Ltd had adequately demonstrated that Ms Shea’s termination was not influenced by her alleged protected disclosures but was a genuine redundancy arising from operational changes.

Given these findings, the court did not find any contravention of the Fair Work Act 2009 by TRUenergy Services Pty Ltd. Consequently, the application for relief by Ms Shea was dismissed as it was predicated on the assumption of a contravention that the court did not uphold. The court did not delve deeply into the specifics of potential relief since no contravention was found, thus rendering the discussion of relief largely speculative.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Farrow gave expert evidence in relation to steps that could be taken and the probable time required to find a position comparable to the applicant’s position with the respondent and the likelihood of finding such a position. He also gave evidence in relation to the impact of termination for redundancy and litigation against a former employer on an individual’s reputation and ability to find such a position. While his evidence was of assistance, Mr Farrow failed to disclose in his expert reports that he prepared the reports without charge, paid for his own travel and attendance at Court and had undertaken work for the respondent in the past year or two. The omission of matters relevant to his independence may reflect on Mr Farrow’s judgment or candour and went to weight. Independence is not a necessary qualification for an expert witness: Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha Ltd v Tomar (No 4) [2012] FCA 385.The Facts The applicant The applicant, Ms Shea, who at the time of trial was aged 47, has post‑graduate degrees in arts and marketing and a diploma from the Australian Institute of Company Directors. Prior to her employment with the respondent, she was employed by a number of different organisations as a consultant in or manager of public affairs, public relations and corporate and investor relations, including in senior level positions in prominent companies. Ms Shea was employed by the respondent for a total of about five years, initially pursuant to a contract dated 8 December 2006. She commenced her employment in January 2007 and was dismissed on 6 February 2012. The respondent The respondent is the employer entity within an Australian corporate group (“EnergyAustralia”) which is a large producer and retailer of energy engaged in the business of power generation. For convenience, in these reasons, unless otherwise indicated, reference to the respondent includes the EnergyAustralia group. The group’s ultimate parent company, CLP Holdings Ltd (“CLP”), is listed on the Hong Kong stock exchange. The respondent has operations in at least four Australian states and employs approximately 2,500 people in its Australian operations. It has approximately 2.8 million Australian customers. The respondent holds significant power generation assets. Its total asset value in Australia is about $9 billion and its net assets total about $4.4 billion. At all material times, the respondent’s managing director was Mr McIndoe. Mr McIndoe, who was aged 48 at the time of trial, commenced his employment with the respondent in 2006. Prior to joining the respondent, Mr McIndoe ran CLP’s international business from 2002 to 2006. Prior to that, he was employed by various organisations including an investment bank and a power development company in Hong Kong. At all material times, the respondent’s relatively flat management structure consisted of, at the apex, a managing director with wide management powers to whom seven or eight senior executives, each heading a separate business unit, reported directly. Together, the managing director and senior executives (referred to as “Directors”), comprised the executive management team. While there was some change in the names and scope of the functions of the respondent’s business units over time, broadly speaking, between 2008 and February 2012, they were as follows:(a)the Finance unit, headed by the Chief Financial Officer, who, from October 2009, was Kevin Holmes. Mr Holmes’ employment with the respondent commenced in October 2009. After entering a separation agreement in July 2011, he ceased to work for the respondent in March 2012. (b)the General Counsel and Company Secretary unit, headed by the General Counsel and Company Secretary, who, from about mid-2010, was, and at the time of trial remained, David Lambert; (c)the Operations and Construction unit, headed by its Director, Michael Hutchinson (who maintained that position at the time of trial);(d)the Energy Markets unit, headed by its Director, Mark Collette (who maintained that position at the time of trial);(e)the Retail unit, headed by its Director, who, from May 2011, was, and at the time of trial remained, Adrian Merrick;(f)the Corporate Risk (which became Information Services) unit, headed by its Director, Gary Martin, whose position was made redundant in 2013; (g)the Corporate and Government Affairs unit, headed by its Director, Kate Shea; and(h)the Human Resources unit, headed by its Director, David Purvis, who was employed from February 2008 until his resignation in March 2012.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I concluded that while there were some areas of overlap between Ms Shea’s position and the current position of Ms Savage, including, principally, in corporate affairs and sustainability, the positions were not substantially identical. Corporate strategy, government relations and policy in the wholesale electricity industry, wholesale regulation functions and reporting functions comprised substantial elements of Ms Savage’s role, but were not formerly undertaken by Ms Shea. Sustainability was not a major component of Ms Shea’s responsibilities and the function of corporate affairs was reallocated to Ms Savage following a staff change about a year after Ms Shea’s dismissal. Accordingly, the functions undertaken by Ms Savage did not support the contention that Ms Shea’s redundancy was manufactured.Conclusion In my opinion, assuming that (contrary to my conclusion above) the applicant made any of the alleged complaints that was a complaint that she was able to make in relation to her employment within the meaning of s 341(1)(c)(ii) of the Act, the respondent discharged the burden of proving that none of the alleged complaints (or any variant thereof) was a substantial and operative factor in, or an operative or immediate reason for, the decision to take adverse action against the applicant by making her position redundant.The relief sought by the applicant Given the finding that there was no contravention of the Act, it is unnecessary to consider the question of relief. Moreover, it is, in many respects, impossible to divorce a consideration of relief from the factual findings that I have made. While the consideration of relief is consequently speculative and somewhat artificial, for completeness, in broad terms only, I consider the parties’ evidence and submissions on that issue. The applicant’s submissions The applicant alleged that, by reason of the respondent’s contravention, she suffered loss and damage as follows: (a)Lost opportunity to work for the Respondent up to and after November 2012 when it is anticipated the Respondent will publicly list on the Australian Stock Exchange;(b)Lost remuneration and benefits, including shares/options, which would otherwise have been received, or were likely to be received, if her employment had continued until or after the public listing referred to in paragraph (a);(c)Damage to reputation and career prospects; and(d)Damage by way of distress, anxiety and disappointment. The applicant primarily sought reinstatement to her former position under s 545(2)(c) of the Act, together with compensation for loss and damage suffered from the date of the termination of her employment (6 February 2012) until the date of her reinstatement under s 245(2)(b) of the Act. Alternatively, the applicant sought compensation for loss and damage suffered from 6 February 2012 until the end of the proceeding, compensation for future loss and damage for a period of five years, compensation for damage to her reputation and the imposition of the maximum penalty against the respondent payable to the applicant (under sub-s 546(1) and (3)(c) of the Act). The applicant made no submissions in relation to damages for distress, anxiety and disappointment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Shea’s contract, made on 8 December 2006, relevantly provided: 6. RemunerationYour Fixed Annual Remuneration (FAR) is set out in the attached Schedule. You acknowledge that your remuneration generally is paid to you in satisfaction of any entitlement to allowances, overtime payments or other penalty rates that you may have arising from any industrial instrument that may be applicable to you.The Base Salary component of your Fixed Annual Remuneration will be payable in arrears.Fixed Annual Remuneration is reviewed annually in accordance with Company policy. Any increases in your Fixed Annual Remuneration (FAR) will be primarily dependent on your overall performance in the opinion of the Managing Director and/or relevant Manager in fulfilling role requirements and performance objectives. Adjustments will also take into consideration relevant salary market movement, organisational effectiveness and capacity to pay.…8. RewardYou will be eligible to be considered for and participate in the Company’s Annual Incentive Plan (AIP) in accordance with Company Policy at the nominated target % detailed in the attached Schedule. Incentives are pro rated from date of eligibility/entry during a Plan cycle and targets are set in consultation with you and your manager at the start of a Plan year. The Annual Incentive Plan – 2007 (excluding Retail), scheduled to Ms Shea’s contract, provided that her incentive plan would be determined when the respondent’s financial results were released and approved. The amount was calculated, usually in April, on the basis of Ms Shea’s fixed annual remuneration as at 31 December and was referable to the preceding plan year of 1 January to 31 December. A pro rata adjustment would be made if Ms Shea’s target value changed during a plan year. On or about 1 April 2007, Mr McIndoe wrote to Ms Shea confirming that her current level of remuneration and all other terms of employment would remain unchanged. He confirmed her total annual reward of $312,686. The letter attached a remuneration statement that set out Ms Shea’s remuneration, effective on 1 April 2007, as an annual base salary of $250,000 and employer superannuation contribution of $12,686 (totalling a fixed annual remuneration of $262,686) and an annual incentive plan, at a target of 20% of base salary, of $50,000. On or about 1 April 2008, Mr McIndoe confirmed that Ms Shea’s 2007 annual incentive payment (referable to the calendar year 1 January to 31 December 2007) would total $75,000 to be paid on 15 April 2008. The letter also provided details of the annual incentive plan for 2008, increased Ms Shea’s annual incentive plan entitlement at target to 25% effective on 1 April 2008 and confirmed that her fixed annual remuneration would increase to $275,000 per annum effective on 1 April 2008. The letter enclosed a total annual reward schedule, which set out Ms Shea’s remuneration effective on 1 April 2008 as an annual base salary of $275,000 and employer superannuation contribution (at 10%) of $25,000 (a total fixed annual remuneration of $275,000) and an annual incentive plan, at a target 25% of base salary, of $62,500, giving Ms Shea a total annual reward (fixed annual remuneration plus her annual incentive plan at target) of $337,500.