Crossing v Anglicare NSW South, NSW West & ACT [2021] FCA 1112
File number:
NSD 452 of 2019
Judgment of:
ABRAHAM J
Date of judgment:
14 September 2021
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – adverse action – where applicant failed to establish any alleged adverse actions – where even if established, the adverse actions were not taken for any unlawful reason – where applicant employed as a Financial Counsellor on basis that he would be “imminently qualified” for the position – where applicant failed to hold required qualifications for the position – application dismissed
INDUSTRIAL LAW – whether applicant exercised workplace rights under s 341(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) – whether adverse action taken against applicant because he made a complaint in relation to his employment – whether applicant made a “complaint” within meaning of s 341(1)(c) of the FW Act – Shea v TRUenergyServices Pty Ltd (No 6) [2014] FCA 271; (2014) 314 ALR 346 considered – no complaint found – whether adverse action taken against applicant because he held certain rights to consultation under the applicable enterprise agreement – whether applicant entitled to rely on those rights – applicant not entitled to rely on those rights – whether adverse action taken against applicant contrary to s 346 of the FW Act because he had a right not to be, or not be, a member of an industrial association –whether the Financial Counsellor’s Association of New South Wales (FCAN) is an “industrial association” within meaning of s 12 of the FW Act – FCAN not an industrial association – whether adverse action taken against applicant because he has a mental disability, contrary to s 351 of FW Act – no adverse action established – application dismissed
Australian Securities and Investment Commission Corporations Act 2001 – Paragraph 991A(2)(l) – Exemption (ASIC Class Order [03/1063])
ASIC Corporations (Financial Counselling Agencies) Instrument 2017/792 s 5(2)
Cases cited:
Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (The Bay Street Case) [2018] FCA 83; (2018) 260 FCR 564
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Crossing v Anglicare NSW South, NSW West & Act and more:
The applicant, Mr Richard Crossing, sought relief from the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia against Anglicare NSW South, Anglicare NSW West and Act (collectively referred to as Anglicare), alleging that they had taken adverse actions against him in contravention of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The crux of the case was whether the actions taken by Anglicare were indeed adverse actions and if they were taken for any unlawful reason, such as discrimination or retaliation for exercising workplace rights. The court had to determine whether Mr Crossing's employment termination and other actions were adverse actions as defined under the Fair Work Act, and if so, whether they were taken for any unlawful reason.
The court examined the evidence presented by both parties, including affidavits, witness testimonies, and documentary evidence, to assess the nature of the adverse actions and the reasons behind them. The court found that Mr Crossing was employed under the condition that he would be "imminently qualified" for the position, a condition he did not meet. The court also found that even if the actions taken by Anglicare were adverse actions, they were not taken for any unlawful reason. Mr Crossing's termination was due to his failure to meet the job requirements, specifically the qualifications required by the ASIC Class Order [CO 03/1063] and the Funding Agreement. The court did not find any evidence that Mr Crossing exercised workplace rights, such as the right to complain or the right to be a member of an industrial association, or that he was discriminated against due to his mental health issues.
The court concluded that Mr Crossing had not established any adverse actions taken by Anglicare, or if they were, that they were not taken for any unlawful reason. Therefore, the application was dismissed. The court's decision was based on the evidence that Mr Crossing was not qualified for the position he was hired for, and that the actions taken by Anglicare were legitimate and not retaliatory or discriminatory. The court found no merit in Mr Crossing's claims and dismissed his application in its entirety.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The application is dismissed.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
It is claimed that Mr Addison had taken no adverse action prior to 22 March 2013.Factual background Anglicare is a not for profit organisation that provides a range of services for individuals, families and communities across regional New South Wales and the Australian Capital Territory, including financial counselling for individuals who are in financial difficulty. Anglicare employs a number of financial counsellors for its financial counselling services. Although a person who carries on a financial services business must hold an Australian financial services licence covering the provision of the financial services: s 911A(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), Anglicare is presently exempt from that requirement: s 5(2) of the ASIC Corporations (Financial Counselling Agencies) Instrument 2017/792 (ASIC Instrument). At the time of Mr Crossing’s employment with Anglicare, Anglicare was exempt from the requirement to hold an Australian financial services license by virtue of the “Australian Securities and Investment Commission Corporations Act 2001 – Paragraph 991A(2)(l) – Exemption” (ASIC Class Order [03/1063]). Relevantly, paragraph (f) of the ASIC Class Order [03/1063] requires, inter alia, that the financial counselling agency takes all reasonable steps to ensure each person who provides the financial services on its behalf:(i)is a member of, or is eligible to be a member of, a financial counselling association; and(ii)has undertaken appropriate training to ensure that they have adequate skills and knowledge to satisfactorily provide the financial services… Anglicare's financial counselling services are funded by NSW Fair Trading through the Financial Counselling Services Program (FCSP). This program is administered by NSW Fair Trading operating within the Department of Finance and Services. At the relevant time, Anglicare's financial counselling services were funded under an agreement between the Commissioner for Fair Trading and Anglicare Regional Alliance for the period from 1 December 2012 to 30 June 2015 (Funding Agreement). Clause 5.2 of the Funding Agreement sets out certain matters that Anglicare must ensure which includes, inter alia, that financial counsellors are sufficiently competent and appropriately trained. Appropriately trained in that clause means “that the financial counsellor has successfully completed training in financial counselling provided by a person recognised by: Financial Counsellors’ Association of NSW Inc; or such other person approved by the Office”. FCAN is the peak membership body that represents and supports financial counsellors in New South Wales. The Fair Trading Financial Counselling Services Program Guidelines 2012 (FCSP Guidelines) describes the role of FCAN, noting that “its key role is training of financial counsellors. FCAN trains and accredits all financial counsellors who wish to work as a financial counsellor in New South Wales. All financial counsellors, including volunteers, providing financial counselling must be trained and eligible for accreditation by the Financial Counsellors Association of NSW”. Evidence relied on
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The Fair Trading Financial Counselling Services Program Guidelines 2012 (FCSP Guidelines) describes the role of FCAN, noting that “its key role is training of financial counsellors. FCAN trains and accredits all financial counsellors who wish to work as a financial counsellor in New South Wales. All financial counsellors, including volunteers, providing financial counselling must be trained and eligible for accreditation by the Financial Counsellors Association of NSW”. Evidence relied on The applicant relied on a number of affidavits sworn by him, each of which exhibited a significant number of documents: the affidavits of Richard Crossing sworn 13 September 2019, 25 October 2019 and 24 June 2020. Those affidavits were read and the exhibits admitted subject to my rulings on objections. In particular, aspects of those affidavits, and corresponding exhibits (for example, in relation to Ms Carol Stackpoole) were objected to, inter alia, on the basis that they contained hearsay. That material was plainly hearsay and not admitted to prove the truth of its contents. In so far as the affidavits contain arguments or submissions (including as to what the evidence establishes) they were treated as such. Mr Crossing gave evidence and was cross-examined. The respondents relied on the affidavits of Brad Simon Addison sworn 11 October 2019 and Luke Vardanega sworn 11 October 2019, and the documents exhibited to those affidavits. Each gave evidence and were cross-examined by the applicant. In addition, each party filed written opening submissions, supplemented by detailed written closing submissions. By agreement between the parties the closing submissions were to only be in writing. I note that Mr Crossing’s written submissions were extensive, the closing submissions in chief and reply covering some 159 pages. This was in addition to his lengthy opening submissions. The witnesses Before discussing the evidence of events it is appropriate to record my findings in relation to each of the three witnesses who gave evidence. In light of the applicant’s submission, I note also as a general proposition, that not every inconsistency in a witness’ evidence, even if established, affects the witness’ credibility or reliability. Whether an inconsistency is established, and if so, what effect it might have on the witness’ evidence, involves an assessment of the evidence, considered as a whole. I am mindful that these events occurred many years ago, approximately seven years before the hearing of this matter. This is also in a context where Mr Addison and Mr Vardanega no longer work for Anglicare. For the reasons described below, I find that where there is a conflict in the evidence between the applicant and Mr Addison or Mr Vardanega, it is the evidence of Mr Addison and Mr Vardanega which is to be preferred. Their evidence is also supported by contemporaneous documents (including emails which, inter alia, record communications between relevant persons during the course of these events, and reflect on the basis of the actions undertaken). Those documents do not support the applicant’s version of the events. Mr Crossing
Decision
Reasons for decision
It follows that each of the purported adverse actions said to flow from the qualifications having been raised because of the complaint, cannot be established. Conclusion in relation to workplace rights As explained above at [212]-[227], there is evidence that the applicant had mental health issues, and that Mr Addison was aware of that, at least to some extent. I will address this further when considering each of the alleged adverse actions. That said, the applicant has not established that he was discriminated against by comparison to other employees, based on his mental disability. For the reasons given above, the applicant has not established any of the other alleged workplace rights: that is, that he exercised any workplace rights in relation to a complaint, membership of FCAN, or consultation under his Enterprise Agreement. Nonetheless, I propose to consider whether the alleged adverse actions have been established.Adverse actions The applicant’s claims are summarised above at [20]-[25]. As previously explained, adverse action is defined in s 342 of the FW Act. As will be plain from the discussion below, even if there were adverse actions as alleged, I am satisfied that the respondents have established that they were not for any unlawful reason. It is important to understand the import of the applicant’s decision as to the manner in which his case is pleaded. The applicant’s termination is not alleged to be an adverse action. That termination was by Mr Vardanega and on his evidence, which I accept occurred, the applicant’s employment was terminated because he did not fulfil the requirements of the position, as he had not completed the FCAN course in November 2012, as he said he would have at the time he was employed. He did not have the qualifications required for a Financial Counsellor employed by Anglicare by the ASIC Class Order [CO 03/1063] or the Funding Agreement. There was no change in the qualifications required for the position. Mr Vardanega gave evidence that the qualifications had not changed, and that he did not know of any purported change of position, as the applicant contended. The applicant’s pleadings do not allege otherwise. The applicant does not accept anything other than he was properly qualified for the position. Nor does he accept anything other than he was employed as a student member of FCAN simpliciter. His case is premised on that basis; he was qualified for the position and therefore these acts must have occurred for these other reasons, mental health, breach of workplace rights and discrimination. The qualifications were raised as a ruse to terminate his employment. However, his termination, which is not an adverse action, was because he was not qualified. In that context, it is difficult to understand how the applicant then frames his case. The adverse actions at their heart are focussed on, or are underpinned by, the assertion that Mr Addison raised the job requirements to seek the applicant’s termination from a position for which he was qualified. However, leaving aside that Mr Addison did not have the authority to change the qualifications required (and did not do so), that is not the basis on which he was terminated. The allegations of, inter alia, harassment and discrimination are all directed to an increase in qualifications, which as explained, was not what occurred. It was alleged that Mr Addison sought to terminate the applicant’s employment by raising his qualifications to avoid the applicant exercising his workplace rights (for example to complain etc), but again, that was not the basis of his termination. Required qualifications that he was not employed with