Sheward and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Sheward and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 3372 (20 September 2021)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/3473

Re:Julie Sheward

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

INTERLOCUTORY DECISION

Tribunal:Member Dr C Huntly

Date:20 September 2021  

Place:Perth

The directions made by the Tribunal on 25 August 2021, being that the Concurrent Witnesses must prepare a joint statement and file the joint statement with the Tribunal on or before 11 October 2021, shall stand.

..............[Sgd]..........................................................

Member Dr C Huntly

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) –– interlocutory decision –– directions regarding concurrent evidence –– objection made to use of concurrent evidence procedure –– Tribunal consideration –– General Practice Directions –– Use of Concurrent Evidence Guideline –– submissions not persuasive –– directions stand.

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 18B(1), 33, 68AA

CASES

Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha Ltd v Tomar (No 4) [2012] FCA 385

Fagenblat v Feingold Partners Pty Ltd [2001] VSC 454

Liverpool Roman Catholic Archdiocese Trustees Inc V Goldberg (No 3) [2001] 4 All ER 950

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Jia Legeng (2001) 205 CLR 507

Nagel v Clay (2020) Fam CA 326

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Administrative Appeals Tribunal, General Practice Direction (28 February 2019)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal, Persons Giving Expert and Opinion Evidence Guideline (30 June 2015)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal, Use of Concurrent Evidence in the AAT Guideline
(30 June 2015)

REASONS FOR INTERLOCUTORY DECISION

Member Dr C Huntly

20 September 2021

BACKGROUND

  1. On 25 August 2021 directions were issued by Member Dr Colin Huntly to the parties in the matter of Re: Sheward (Applicant) and National Disability Insurance Agency (Respondent) (No 2020/3473). 

  2. Those directions inter alia included directions relating to the hearing of expert witnesses nominated by the parties, Ms Dreyer for the Applicant and Ms Chandler for the Respondent (the Concurrent Witnesses), pursuant to the Tribunal’s General Practice Direction (General Practice Direction)[1] and the Tribunal’s relevant guidelines, namely “Use of Concurrent Evidence in the AAT” (Concurrent Evidence Guidelines)[2] (the concurrent evidence directions).

    [1]Administrative Appeals Tribunal, General Practice Direction (28 February 2019), ‘Expert and opinion evidence’ [2.15]-[2.17]; ‘Medical and other expert reports and witnesses’ [4.49]-[4.52].

    [2]Administrative Appeals Tribunal, Use of Concurrent Evidence in the AAT Guideline (30 June 2015).

  3. Parties were granted leave to make further submissions in respect of the concurrent evidence directions.  By written submission dated 1 September 2021 the Respondent objected to the concurrent evidence directions based on a number of factors, each of which appear to relate to two broad grounds, namely:

    (a)the Respondent appears to object to the Applicant’s choice of expert witness per se, due to perceived conflict of interest issues, that have been addressed at some length in prior written submissions of the Respondent; and

    (b)the Respondent suggests that the evidence of two of its preferred expert witnesses (namely Ms Chandler and Mr Willis) are equally relevant to any assessment of the expert evidence of the Applicant’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sheward and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 3372
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an interlocutory decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) in a proceeding between Sheward and the National Disability Insurance Agency. The dispute arose from an objection made by the National Disability Insurance Agency to the AAT's direction that expert witnesses for both parties should give their evidence concurrently.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the AAT's direction for concurrent evidence from expert witnesses should stand, despite the objection raised by the National Disability Insurance Agency. This involved considering the AAT's General Practice Directions and its Use of Concurrent Evidence Guideline, and how these provisions applied to the specific circumstances of the case, including concerns raised about potential conflicts of interest concerning expert witnesses.

The Tribunal reasoned that its General Practice Directions and the Concurrent Evidence Guideline indicated a clear expectation that expert witnesses traversing the same evidentiary territory would give evidence concurrently, unless otherwise directed. The Tribunal found that the submissions of the National Disability Insurance Agency were not persuasive in overcoming this default position. It noted that concerns regarding bias or conflict of interest in expert evidence were matters that went to the weight of that evidence, rather than precluding its admission or the procedure for its presentation. The Tribunal also observed that it was not bound by the strict rules of evidence applicable in courts, but that considerations of credibility were relevant.

Accordingly, the Tribunal determined that its previous directions, requiring the concurrent witnesses to prepare and file a joint statement by a specified date, would stand. A further directions hearing was to be held after the receipt of this joint statement to discuss the manner in which the expert evidence would be presented at the substantive hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Similarly, the General Practice Direction addresses “Medical and other expert reports and witnesses”[5] in the following terms:If you and the decision-maker both want to call experts to give oral evidence at a hearing, unless we direct otherwise, the experts are to give their evidence concurrently. We will usually make a direction relating to the procedures to be followed. For more information, see the AAT’s Use of Concurrent Evidence in the AAT Guideline.You and the decision-maker must use your best endeavours to facilitate the concurrent evidence procedure, including ensuring that an expert:(a)is given a copy of the guideline; or(b)already has a copy of that document.(emphasis added).[5][4.51]-[4.52]. Accordingly, the concurrent evidence guideline to which the Respondent refers in its submissions must be read in terms of them being an expectation. This is not how the Respondent’s written submissions are drafted and that misconception necessarily colours those submissions. Parties are further referred to the President’s “Practice Direction: Review of National Disability Insurance Scheme Decisions” at [7.4]-[7.5]. Specifically:If there are expert witnesses, such as specialist doctors, we will expect them to give their evidence at the same time. For more information about this, see the “Use of Concurrent Evidence in the AAT Guideline”.(emphasis added) Accordingly, parties to an application lodged in the Tribunal, pursuant to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) governing legislation should understand that the default position with respect to expert witnesses traversing the same expert evidentiary territory is that the Tribunal’s concurrent evidence procedure will apply. For these reasons, the submissions of the parties are not persuasive.CONSIDERATION For the avoidance of any doubt, parties are advised that the substance of the Respondent’s written submissions of 1 September 2021 has been considered. Firstly, with respect to the conflict of interest concerns raised repeatedly by the Respondent in submissions to date with respect to the Applicant’s expert witness. The Respondent’s written submissions state:[6]… the Respondent considers that Ms Dreyer has a financial interest in recommending the support in issue which was not disclosed to the respondent and this is a central issue in this case. It is uncertain the extent to which the interest was disclosed to the applicant.”[6]Respondent’s Written Submissions (01 September 2021) [7]. Notwithstanding the ambiguity of this contention, the expert technical witness relied upon in this matter by the Respondent (Mr Willis) appears to have a financial interest with respect to the technical solution favoured by that witness. This financial interest appears to be similar to that to which the Respondent takes objection regarding the Applicant’s expert witness. Accordingly, any decision-maker considering the facts in issue in this application will need to address their mind to the question of the qualifications of relevant expert witnesses and any mitigating factors that must be taken into consideration when weighing what value to give to that evidence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given that the Tribunal is not bound by the rules of evidence, it would be inappropriate to adopt a view of expert evidence that was more restrictive than that adopted by the Courts.[9] That is not to say that such considerations and other related matters relevant to the credibility of evidence are irrelevant in all cases, particularly regarding the weight that might be placed on such evidence. Merely that the questions are not the same and must be rationally addressed. [9]AAT Act s 33.CONCLUSION In conclusion, parties are reminded that expert witnesses will be required to attest to their qualifications, accreditation, and experience relevant to the making of their therapeutic assessments in this instance. They should also be reminded that their overriding duty, when appearing in these proceedings will be to the Tribunal and not to their clients, and that they will be required to give sworn evidence. As to countervailing considerations such as bias and conflict, these clearly go to weight and are a question of fact for the Tribunal. Submissions may of course be made at the relevant times by any party wishing to express particular concerns. In the event that there might be a suggestion that the proceedings of the Tribunal itself would be infected by bias on the part of an expert witness, parties are referred to the discussion by Gleeson CJ and Gummow J in Minister for Immigration And Multicultural Affairs v Jia Legeng (2001) 205 CLR 507 at 531-532.DETERMINATION Accordingly, the directions made by the Tribunal on 25 August 2021, being that the Concurrent Witnesses must prepare a joint statement and file the joint statement with the Tribunal on or before 11 October 2021, shall stand. Following receipt of the joint statement produced by the Concurrent Witnesses, a further telephone directions hearing will be held with the parties, to discuss the way in which these witnesses will be taken through their evidence by the Tribunal at the hearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established