Szencorp Pty Ltd v Clean Energy Council Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Szencorp Pty Ltd v Clean Energy Council Limited [2009] FCA 40

CORPORATIONS – oppression claim brought by member of not‑for‑profit company – plaintiff claimed that objectives of the company were not being pursued and that company conducted its affairs in the interests of a sub‑set of members to the exclusion of others – where winding‑up claim by plaintiff not pursued at trial – whether abandoned winding‑up claim abuse of process – order sought that an accountant be appointed to prepare a report for the members of the defendant as to its affairs.

Held:  No abuse of process – conduct of defendant’s affairs did not constitute oppression within the meaning of s 233 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – conduct of concern to the plaintiff had been ameliorated by the time of the final hearing – the relief sought by plaintiff not appropriate in circumstances.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth): ss 232, 233

Re Spargos Mining NL (1990) 3 ACSR 1, cited
Shelton v NRMA Limited (2005) 51 ACSR 278, considered
Turnbull v NRMA Limited (2004) 50 ACSR 44, cited
Campbell v BackOffice Investments Pty Ltd (2008) 66 ACSR 359, cited
John J Starr (Real Estate) Pty Ltd v Robert R Andrew (Australasia) Pty Limited (1991)
6 ACSR 63, considered
Gamlestaden Fastigheter AB v Baltic Partners Ltd [2007] 4 All ER 164, cited
Williams v Spautz (1992) 174 CLR 509, cited
Fexuto Pty Ltd v Bosnjak Holdings Pty Ltd (1998) 28 ACSR 688, cited

SZENCORP PTY LTD v CLEAN ENERGY COUNCIL LIMITED

VID 534 of 2008

GOLDBERG J
2 FEBRUARY 2009
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 534 of 2008

BETWEEN:

SZENCORP PTY LTD
Plaintiff

AND:

CLEAN ENERGY COUNCIL LIMITED
Defendant

JUDGE:

GOLDBERG J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 FEBRUARY 2009

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application filed by the plaintiff be dismissed.

2.The issue of the defendant’s costs of the application, and whether those costs be paid on an indemnity basis, be reserved for further consideration.

3.The defendant file and serve within seven days an outline of its submissions in respect of the costs order it seeks.

4.The plaintiff file and serve its submissions in reply within seven days of the filing and serving of the defendant’s submissions.

5.The costs hearing be adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules

The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 534 of 2008

BETWEEN:

SZENCORP PTY LTD
Plaintiff

AND:

CLEAN ENERGY COUNCIL LIMITED
Defendant

JUDGE:

GOLDBERG J

DATE:

2 FEBRUARY 2009

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. The plaintiff, Szencorp Pty Ltd, is a member of the defendant, Clean Energy Council Limited (“the Council”), an unlisted not‑for‑profit public company limited by guarantee. The plaintiff complains that the conduct of the Council’s affairs has…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Szencorp Pty Ltd v Clean Energy Council Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Szencorp Pty Ltd sought to have Clean Energy Council Ltd wound up on the grounds that it was just and equitable to do so. The plaintiff's application was dismissed by the Federal Court of Australia. The plaintiff, Szencorp Pty Ltd, a company that operates in the solar energy industry, initiated proceedings against Clean Energy Council Ltd, an association representing sustainable energy industry stakeholders. The plaintiff sought an order for the winding up of the defendant based on the "just and equitable" ground, alleging oppression of minority shareholders and a failure of the substratum of the Council. The plaintiff abandoned the winding up application at the commencement of the final hearing.

The court was required to determine whether the plaintiff's application for winding up the defendant should be granted. The central issue was whether the Council was just and equitable to be wound up due to the oppression of minority shareholders or a failure of the substratum. The court considered the circumstances surrounding the Council's formation, its operations, and the allegations made by the plaintiff. The Council was established through a merger of two industry associations, following a Memorandum of Understanding and affirmative votes by the members of the merging associations. The plaintiff's claims were based on the slow development of policies and the turnover of staff in the initial period of the Council's existence. However, the court found that the Council had become active in its liaison with the government and had taken steps to improve its operations and communications with its members.

The court dismissed the plaintiff's application for winding up the Council. The judge found that there was no evidence to support the plaintiff's claims of oppression of minority shareholders or a failure of the substratum. The court acknowledged the initial settling down period for the merged entities but noted that the Council had taken steps to address the issues raised by the plaintiff and had become active in its operations. The judge concluded that the Council was not just and equitable to be wound up. The issue of the defendant's costs of the application and whether those costs be paid on an indemnity basis was reserved for further consideration. The court ordered the defendant to file and serve an outline of its submissions in respect of the costs order it seeks, and for the plaintiff to file and serve its submissions in reply within seven days. The costs hearing was adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application filed by the plaintiff be dismissed.

2. The issue of the defendant’s costs of the application, and whether those costs be paid on an indemnity basis, be reserved for further consideration.

3. The defendant file and serve within seven days an outline of its submissions in respect of the costs order it seeks.

4. The plaintiff file and serve its submissions in reply within seven days of the filing and serving of the defendant’s submissions.

5. The costs hearing be adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Initially the plaintiff claimed, in the alternative, an order that the Council be wound up pursuant to s 233(1)(a), or alternatively s 461(1)(k) of the Act on the grounds that it was just and equitable to do so. Pursuant to a directions order the plaintiff filed particulars of the grounds relied upon in support of its winding up application on 20 August 2008 and its Outline of Contentions of Fact and Law filed on 1 October 2008 included submissions as to why the Council should be wound up on the just and equitable ground due to oppression of the minority or a failure of the substratum of the Council. The plaintiff abandoned that relief when the final hearing of the proceeding commenced. BACKGROUND The Council was incorporated on 24 August 2007 for the purpose of effecting the merger of two existing sustainable energy industry associations, the Australian Wind Energy Association (“AusWind”) and the Australian Business Council for Sustainable Energy Inc (“BCSE”). The merger was implemented as a result of a Memorandum of Understanding made on 31 August 2007 between the Council, BCSE and AusWind. The Memorandum of Understanding noted that the BCSE and AusWind were peak industry associations “representing a range of energy supply and demand side technologies” and that the objective of the merger was to ensure that the “sustainable” energy sector was represented by a single entity that clearly and articulately presented a uniform message to external stakeholders. The Memorandum of Understanding set out the provisions by which the Council, BCSE and AusWind were to implement the merger of the two organisations. The members of BCSE and AusWind had been provided with an Information Memorandum which they had considered at a special general meeting of the members of each organisation. The members of each organisation had voted affirmatively to amalgamate the two organisations. A copy of the Information Memorandum was attached to the Memorandum of Understanding. The Memorandum of Understanding set out the obligations, activities and conduct to be undertaken by the Council upon the merger. The Council agreed that it would undertake the following, amongst other undertakings:(a)commence operations using the principles and basis outlined in the Information Memorandum;(b)establish a limited and manageable number of technology directorates covering priority issues and in the different industry segments as outlined in the Information Memorandum;(c)develop and document policies that covered all sectors of the sustainable energy industry;(d)ensure that the current level of activities was maintained and advocate policy positions that were in the best interests of all the membership. The reference in the Memorandum of Understanding to “supply and demand side technologies” is not a reference to “supply side” and “demand side” as those expressions are ordinarily used in an economic sense or in any economic context. Mr Szental, a director of the plaintiff, explained that the sustainable energy sector can be understood as being made up of companies and organisations on the “supply side” and companies and organisations on the “demand side”. Companies and organisations on the “supply side” are concerned with the generation of sustainable energy for sale by energy retailers to individual consumers. Companies and organisations on the “demand side” are concerned with products and services to be used by individual consumers to reduce their use of energy or to use it more efficiently. An example of a “supply side” participant is a company which generates electricity. An example of a “demand side” participant is a manufacturer of photovoltaic cells for domestic use, for example, a solar panel which can be installed on the roof of a suburban house.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GOLDBERG J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GOLDBERG J

Although issues of the solvency of the Council were raised in the affidavit material filed in support of the application, it was not suggested in the course of the hearing that there is an issue as to the solvency of the Council. CONSIDERATION It is apparent that after the merger took effect there was a settling down period for the merged entities. There were hiccups along the way. The original chairman resigned in October 2007 and the original chief executive officer resigned at the end of March 2008. The development of policies in the sustainable energy field was an important issue for the Council. The development of these policies was slow in coming. For example, on 8 May 2008 the Council conducted a strategy day attended by its directors, and a further strategy day for staff members on 20 May 2008. At the latter meeting, the Council agreed upon a “Strategic Framework and Action Plan 2008–9” which sought to identify the strategic priorities of the Council. It is important to note that in relation to “influential policies” the immediate strategic priority identified was to re‑confirm positions on existing policies and accelerate planning on new policies. This did not occur for a considerable period of time. The establishment of the Technology Directorates was also slow in coming. A draft of a proposed review of the Technology Directorates’ structure was tabled at an April 2008 Board meeting of the Council. On 1 July 2008 the CEO of the Council sent a letter to members advising that the review of the directorate structure was complete and that seven directorates would be established. Whatever may have been the position in the first seven or eight months of the Council’s existence, since at least May 2008 the Council has been active in its liaison and relationship with Government. For example, in a letter dated 7 May 2008 the Minister for Climate Change and Water, the Honourable Penny Wong MP wrote to Mr McIndoe and stated, inter alia: “… my Department welcomes the role the Council is playing in putting forward ideas on design of the emissions trading system (ETS) and again I encourage you to continue to put your views forward”. The turnover of staff and the initial settling down issues faced by the Council were acknowledged in a letter sent by the Council’s Chief Executive Officer to all members of the Council on 8 July 2008. This letter stated, inter alia: “Internally, we lost many familiar faces and, for a period of time, we were exceedingly short staffed. This, I know, caused some frustration and angst to members, as we not only seemed to be losing our intellectual property, but to many, it appeared that we had disappeared off the radar screen.I trust that you see us re‑emerging.…Out stakeholder communications have also been boosted. You will have received a letter from the Chairman, Richard McIndoe, and myself advising members of the strategy day that was held with the Board and the executive team in May. Repopulation of the staff was our key first step in going forward. Since May you will have received two newsletters updating you on activities and there is another coming mid July. You will also have noticed the significant increase in our presence in press articles.…In addition, to improve communications and input on technology specific issues, we have refreshed our directorate structure and meetings with the new directorates will commence in August.”