IceTV Pty Limited v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ

ICETV PTY LIMITED & ANOR  APPELLANTS

AND

NINE NETWORK AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED  RESPONDENT

IceTV Pty Limited v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited [2009] HCA 14
22 April 2009
S415/2008

ORDER

1.        Appeal allowed with costs.

2.Set aside the order of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 8 May 2008, as varied on 20 August 2008, and in place thereof order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

J M Ireland QC with S C G Burley SC and J S Cooke for the appellants (instructed by Bartier Perry)

A J L Bannon SC with R Cobden SC and J M Hennessy for the respondent (instructed by Gilbert & Tobin)

D K Catterns QC with A J Ryan and S M Rebikoff intervening as amicus curiae on behalf of Telstra Corporation Limited (instructed by Mallesons Stephen Jaques)

R J Webb SC intervening as amicus curiae on behalf of Australian Digital Alliance Limited (instructed by Baker & McKenzie)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. The respondent, Nine Network Australia Pty Limited ("Nine"), is engaged in the business of acquiring, distributing, selecting and scheduling programmes to be broadcast by various free-to-air television stations within the "Nine Network".  The scheduling of programmes to be broadcast involves the use of a database on Nine's computer network ("the Nine Database").  Approximately two weeks prior to the commencement of each week of broadcasting, an employee of Nine supplies certain third parties known as "Aggregators" with a schedule of programmes to be broadcast on Nine Network stations in that week (a "Weekly Schedule").  Each Weekly Schedule is produced from the Nine Database.

  2. Each Weekly Schedule contains various elements, including particulars of the time and title of programmes to be broadcast ("time and title information").  The Aggregators use the Weekly Schedule, together with comparable material provided by other Australian television broadcasters and independently obtained material, to produce "Aggregated Guides", which are schedules of programmes to be broadcast on various television stations, for publication in various media. 

  3. The first appellant, IceTV Pty Limited ("IceTV"), commenced trading in 2005.  It is a wholly owned subsidiary of the second appellant, IceTV Holdings Limited ("IceTV Holdings").  They are not broadcasters.

  4. The primary business of IceTV is the provision, via the Internet, of a subscription-based electronic programme guide for television known as the "IceGuide".  When downloaded onto certain devices, which are available for purchase by consumers in Australia, the IceGuide displays details of programmes scheduled to be broadcast by free-to-air television stations for the coming six to eight days, including stations in the Nine Network. 

  5. Over the period relevant to this appeal, when preparing the information to be included in the IceGuide for a given day, employees of IceTV used information included in the IceGuide for a previous…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read IceTV Pty Limited v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] HCA 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered an appeal by IceTV Pty Limited and IceTV Holdings (together "Ice") against a decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court. The dispute concerned allegations by Nine Network Australia Pty Limited ("Nine") that Ice had infringed copyright in Nine's weekly television programme schedules. Nine contended that Ice had reproduced a substantial part of these schedules, which were admitted to be original literary works, to create its own electronic programme guide.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether the time and title information extracted from Nine's weekly programme schedules constituted a "substantial part" of those compilations for the purposes of copyright infringement, and whether the skill and labour involved in creating the schedules were relevant to this determination. The Court also considered the nature of originality in compilations and the distinction between information and expression in copyright law.

The High Court, allowing the appeal, reasoned that the reproduction of the time and title information by Ice did not amount to the reproduction of a substantial part of Nine's weekly schedules. The Court clarified that while originality in compilations can arise from the skill and labour of selection and arrangement, the focus for infringement must be on the qualitative and quantitative significance of the reproduced material in relation to the original work. The Court found that the extracted information, while derived from Nine's schedules, did not represent a substantial taking of the copyright work itself.

Consequently, the High Court set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court and reinstated the decision of the primary judge, which had found no infringement. The appeal to the Full Court was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside the order of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 8 May 2008, as varied on 20 August 2008, and in place thereof order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of IceTV Pty Limited v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited revolves around the alleged infringement of copyright in weekly television programme schedules by IceTV. Nine Network Australia Pty Limited produces weekly schedules of television programs to be broadcast on its stations, which are collectively referred to as the "Weekly Schedules." These Weekly Schedules contain information about the time, title, and broadcast details of the television programs. Third parties use the information from these Weekly Schedules, with a license from Nine, to create "Aggregated Guides," which are compilations of program schedules for various television stations. IceTV, on the other hand, uses information from these Aggregated Guides to produce its own electronic program guide, known as the "IceGuide."

The dispute began when Nine Network alleged that IceTV's use of information from the Weekly Schedules in creating the IceGuide constituted an infringement of copyright. Specifically, Nine claimed that IceTV had reproduced a "substantial part" of the Weekly Schedules, which are literary works protected by copyright under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth). The primary issue in this case was whether the reproduction of the time and title information in the IceGuide constituted a reproduction of a "substantial part" of the Weekly Schedules. The case proceeded through various courts, with the Full Court of the Federal Court initially ruling in favour of Nine, a decision that was later appealed to the High Court. The High Court was tasked with determining the correct interpretation of "substantial part" in the context of copyright law and whether the use of the Weekly Schedules by IceTV constituted an infringement of Nine's copyright.

The case of IceTV Pty Limited v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited originated in the Federal Court of Australia, where the appellants, IceTV and IceTV Holdings, challenged a decision made by the Full Court. Initially, Nine Network Australia Pty Limited had filed a lawsuit against IceTV, alleging copyright infringement regarding the use of its weekly television programme schedules. The primary judge, Bennett J, dismissed Nine's claim, finding no infringement of copyright in the reproduction of the programme schedules by IceTV. Dissatisfied with this outcome, Nine appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court, which, on 8 May 2008, allowed the appeal and found that IceTV had indeed reproduced a substantial part of Nine's copyrighted compilations. IceTV subsequently appealed to the High Court, seeking to overturn the Full Court's decision. The High Court granted leave for Telstra Corporation Limited and the Australian Digital Alliance to appear as amici curiae, reflecting the broader implications of the case on digital broadcasting and intellectual property rights. The matter before the High Court was thus an appeal from the Full Court's decision, focusing on the interpretation of copyright law as it pertains to the reproduction of substantial parts of copyrighted compilations.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ GUMMOW, HAYNE AND HEYDON JJ
In the light of these reasons, it is not necessary to consider the relevance of any animus furandi on the part of IceTV or IceTV Holdings[84].[84]Reasons of Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ at [171]ff. Cf Baigent v Random House Group Ltd (2007) 72 IPR 195 at 222 [95]-[97] per Lloyd LJ; Garnett, Davies and Harbottle, Copinger and Skone James on Copyright, 15th ed (2005), vol 1 at 389 [7-28(d)].Conclusion Any reproduction of the time and title information in the IceGuide was not a reproduction of a substantial part of any of the Weekly Schedules (or the Nine Database). We agree with the orders proposed by Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ. These reasons in favour of allowing the appeal are organised as follows:Introduction [58]‑[64]The construction of Pt III of the Act [65]‑[71]Compilations and "substantial part" [72]‑[76]The Spicer Committee [77]‑[78]The transition to digital television [79]‑[83]The IceGuide [84]‑[90]The litigation [91]‑[94]Authorship and material form [95]‑[106]The pleadings and the evidence [107]‑[121]The holdings of the primary judge and the Full Court [122]‑[129]Misappropriation of skill and labour "of Nine" [130]‑[134]The EU Database Directive [135]‑[139]The submissions on "substantial part" [140]‑[153]Treatment of "substantial part" by the Full Court [154]‑[171]"Prediction" of time and title information [172]‑[184]Conclusions [185]‑[188]Orders [189]Introduction The commercial interest which has given rise to this appeal is the control sought by the respondent ("Nine") over the use of the programme schedules for television transmissions by its network ("the Nine Network"). The appellants (together "Ice") challenge the decision on 8 May 2008 of the Full Court of the Federal Court (Black CJ, Lindgren and Sackville JJ)[85] that there has been reproduction of a "substantial part" of original literary works in which copyright subsisted under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ("the Act"). These works were compilations represented by the television programme schedules for the Nine Network. The "substantial part" was the programme title, date and time of broadcast, including the episode title where relevant ("time and title information").[85]Nine Network Australia Pty Ltd v IceTV Pty Ltd (2008) 168 FCR 14. The primary judge (Bennett J) dismissed the action brought by Nine[86] and so made no finding as to whether the second appellant ("Ice Holdings") was jointly liable for any infringement by the first appellant ("IceTV"). In a supplementary judgment[87] delivered on 20 August 2008 the Full Court indicated that among the issues remitted to the primary judge was that of infringement by Ice Holdings.[86]Nine Network Australia Pty Ltd v IceTV Pty Ltd (2007) 73 IPR 99.[87]Nine Network Australia Pty Ltd v IceTV Pty Ltd (No 2) [2008] FCAFC 154. This Court granted leave to Telstra Corporation Limited and to Australian Digital Alliance Limited ("the Digital Alliance") to appear each as amicus curiae. Ice seeks the reinstatement of its success at first instance in the Federal Court. Bennett J held that there had been no reproduction of a substantial part of the compilations. For the reasons which follow, her Honour reached the correct result and her decision should not have been set aside in the Full Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE AND HEYDON JJ

The High Court in IceTV v Nine Network was tasked with determining whether IceTV's reproduction of time and title information from Nine Network's Weekly Schedules constituted an infringement of copyright, specifically, a reproduction of a "substantial part" of those schedules. The Court began by examining the definition of a "substantial part" within the context of literary works. The majority found that the reproduction of the time and title information by IceTV did not constitute a reproduction of a "substantial part" of the Weekly Schedules. The Court considered that the reproduction of such a limited aspect of the schedules did not infringe upon the core creative elements or the expression of ideas that constituted the schedules as literary works.

Further, the Court assessed the quality of the reproduced part to determine whether it was a "substantial part." The majority held that the quality of the reproduced information did not elevate it to a level that would constitute a "substantial part" of the Weekly Schedules. The time and title information was factual and did not encapsulate the creative expression or the arrangement of the schedules, which was the essence of the copyright protection afforded to the Weekly Schedules. The majority also underscored that the reproduction of factual content alone, without the accompanying creative expression, did not infringe upon the copyright of the schedules.

The Court also addressed whether it was necessary to identify the author and the time of making or first publication of the Weekly Schedules to determine the subsistence of copyright. The majority concluded that such identification was not imperative for establishing the subsistence of copyright, as the focus was on the originality and the creative effort invested in the schedules, rather than the identity of the author or the specific time of publication. This aligns with the principle that copyright protection arises from the originality and expression of the work, rather than from formal attributes such as authorship or publication date.

In considering the level of originality required for the Weekly Schedules to be considered literary works, the Court determined that the schedules needed to exhibit a degree of creativity in their arrangement and selection of content. The majority found that the Weekly Schedules did not possess the requisite originality because they were essentially factual compilations that did not go beyond what was necessary to get the job done. The schedules were a product of routine and mechanical processes rather than creative judgment, thus lacking the originality required to be protected as literary works.

The majority also examined the kind of skill and labour required to establish the subsistence of copyright in the Weekly Schedules. It was held that mere mechanical or routine effort does not suffice to establish copyright protection. The schedules required a degree of creative skill and labour that went beyond simple collection and arrangement of facts. The majority found that the effort invested in creating the schedules did not rise to the level of creative expression necessary to warrant copyright protection.

The Court then compared the "sweat of the brow" and "industrious collection" with "creativity" in the context of the Weekly Schedules. The majority held that while the schedules were the result of considerable effort, the lack of creativity in their production meant that they did not meet the threshold for copyright protection. The "sweat of the brow" doctrine, which recognizes protection for effort and labour, was not sufficient in the absence of creative expression. The majority found that the schedules did not exhibit the requisite creativity to be protected as literary works under the Act.

The Court also deliberated on whether the computer database used in the creation of the Weekly Schedules was a work in suit. The majority held that the database itself was not a literary work, as it did not possess the originality required to be protected. The database was merely a tool used in the creation process and did not embody the creative expression necessary for copyright protection.

In determining whether the Weekly Schedules were the same work as the database, the majority concluded that they were distinct. The Weekly Schedules represented the creative output and expression, whereas the database was merely an intermediary tool. The majority found that the schedules, as the final product, were what needed to be assessed for copyright protection, rather than the database itself.

The Court further examined the relevance of the skill and labour devoted to the programming decisions in the context of copyright subsistence. The majority held that while the programming decisions were skill-intensive, they did not elevate the schedules to the level of original literary works. The effort invested was routine and mechanical, lacking the creative input necessary to establish copyright protection.

The Court also considered whether competing interests and policy considerations were relevant in determining the subsistence of copyright in the Weekly Schedules. The majority found that while such considerations were important in the broader context of copyright law, they did not override the fundamental requirement of originality and creative expression for copyright protection. The Court held that the schedules did not meet the threshold for copyright protection based on the lack of originality, irrespective of competing interests and policy considerations.

Lastly, the Court determined that there was no relevance of animus furandi on the part of IceTV in this case. The majority held that the focus should be on the nature of the reproduction and the originality of the work, rather than the intent behind the reproduction. The Court concluded that the reproduction of the time and title information did not infringe upon the copyright in the Weekly Schedules, as it did not constitute a "substantial part" of the schedules.

In conclusion, the High Court found that the reproduction of the time and title information by IceTV did not constitute an infringement of copyright in the Weekly Schedules. The majority held that the schedules lacked the originality and creative expression necessary to be protected as literary works under the Act. The Court emphasized that copyright protection is contingent upon the originality and creative effort invested in the work, rather than upon routine or mechanical effort. The appeal was allowed, and the orders of the Full Court were set aside, reinstating the decision of the primary judge.