Universal Music Publishing Pty Ltd v Palmer (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 83 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Universal Music Publishing Pty Ltd v Palmer (No 2) [2021] FCA 434

File number:

NSD 161 of 2019

Judgment of:

KATZMANN J

Date of judgment:

30 April 2021

Catchwords:

COPYRIGHT— Infringement — musical work and literary work constituted by a famous rock song used in multi-media advertisements for a political party in an election campaign — where no issue that each work was an original work and applicants were respectively licensor and owner of the copyright in each work, whether copyright in each was infringed by the use in the advertisements of a cover version of the chorus of the rock song — whether the parts that were taken were objectively similar — whether the impugned works were taken, copied or derived from the copyright works — whether a substantial part of the copyright works was reproduced — where the musical work shared a melodic contour with a well-known Christmas carol and other features that were typical of its genre, whether that part which was reproduced could be classed as substantial — whether the use of the song was “fair dealing for the purpose of parody or satire” within the meaning of s 41A of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth)

COPYRIGHT— Damages — where a licence would not have been issued, whether damages under s 115(2) may be awarded under the “user principle” — where infringer entered into negotiations with licence holder before engaging in infringing conduct but did not agree to its terms and where discovery incomplete, whether additional damages under s 115(4) should be paid and, if so, in what amount

Legislation:

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 10, 14, 21, 31, 36, 40, 41, 41A, 42, 103AA, 103B, 115, 116

Copyright Amendment Act 2006 (Cth)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 23

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) s 126

Copyright (International Protection) Regulations 1969 (Cth) r 4(1)

Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 (UK) s 30

International Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works concluded at Berne on 9 September 1886

Cases cited:

ACHOS Pty Ltd v Ucorp Pty Ltd (No 5) [2013] FCA 1006; 103 IPR 51

Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v DAP Services (Kempsey) Pty Ltd (in liq) (2007) 157 FCR 564

Attorney-General (UK) v Blake [2001] 1 AC 268

Australasian Performing Rights Association Ltd v Monster Communications Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1806; 71 IPR 212

Autodesk Australia Pty Ltd v Cheung [1990] FCA 121; 94 ALR 472

Autodesk Inc v Yee (1996) 68 FCR 391

Autodesk, Inc. v Dynason (No 2) (1993) 176 CLR 300

Bailey v Namol Pty Limited (1994) 53 FCR 102

Beloff v Pressdram Ltd [1973] 1 All ER 241; [1973] RPC 765

Blayney v Clogau St David’s Gold Mines Ltd [2003] FSR 19 (CA)

Boomerang Investments Pty Ltd v Padgett (Liability) [2020] FCA 535; 383 ALR 202; 155 IPR 196

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Broome v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Universal Music Publishing Pty Ltd v Palmer (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 434
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Universal Music Publishing Pty Ltd v Palmer (No 2) involved a dispute over copyright infringement of the song "We're Not Gonna Take It" by Twisted Sister. The plaintiff, Universal Music Publishing, sought relief for copyright infringement by the defendant, Mr Palmer. The court had to determine whether the defendant had infringed the plaintiff's copyright in the song's lyrics and music, and if so, to what extent and what relief should be granted.

The legal issues before the court included whether the defendant's works were substantial reproductions or adaptations of the plaintiff's copyrighted works, whether the defence of fair dealing under s 41A of the Copyright Act was applicable, and what relief the plaintiff was entitled to, including damages, additional damages, and injunctive relief. The court also had to assess the appropriate amount of damages under the user principle.

In its reasoning, the court found that there was a sufficient degree of objective similarity between the plaintiff's copyrighted works and the defendant's impugned works, such that the latter were reproductions of the former. The court held that the defendant had failed to establish the defence of fair dealing. The court further found that the plaintiff had established its case for damages under s 115(2) of the Act, which should be assessed according to the user principle. The court granted the plaintiff an amount of $500,000 for the value of a notional or hypothetical licence fee for the use of the copyrighted works during the period of the infringements, and an additional $1,000,000 in additional damages. The court also granted the plaintiff a permanent injunction in the terms proposed by the plaintiff.

The court's final orders included the grant of damages in the amount of $1,500,000, and a permanent injunction restraining the defendant from infringing the plaintiff's copyright in the future. The court also ordered the defendant to deliver up all copies of the impugned works and any materials used in the creation of those works for destruction.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Palmer, on the other hand, was a most unimpressive witness. In significant respects his evidence was inconsistent with the contemporaneous records and the evidence of both Mr Wright and Mr McDonald. I deal with his evidence at some length later in these reasons. It is sufficient to observe at this point that he was an unreliable witness whose evidence was at times incredible.The facts Many of the relevant facts were either admitted or not in dispute. Unless otherwise indicated, none of the facts set out below was controversial and I make findings accordingly. A good deal of the narrative is drawn from Universal’s meticulous written submissions which in these respects were not contradicted.WNGTI The WNGTI music is an original musical work and the WNGTI lyrics are an original literary work within the meaning of those terms in the Copyright Act. Mr Snider is the author and composer of WNGTI. He started writing it in 1980. He finished it in 1984. Mr Snider joined Twisted Sister in 1976 as its lead singer. He was also the band’s sole songwriter. Twisted Sister was active until 1987, when it broke up. It reunited in 1988 and its members continued to work together and perform publicly throughout the 2000s. It disbanded in 2016, shortly after the death of its drummer. Since then, Mr Snider has continued touring, both on his own and with a backup band, playing Twisted Sister songs as well as songs from his solo work. Mr Snider has also been involved in many solo projects, including hosting radio programs, appearing on several reality TV shows, and doing voice-over work for television, animation and computer games. Until 1987, Mr Snider wrote all the music and lyrics to the songs he performed. Thereafter he wrote a number of albums in partnership with other songwriters. He gave unchallenged evidence, which I accept, that songwriting always came naturally to him. He explained that he felt he had something to say and knew how to say it. He also gave unchallenged evidence, which I also accept, that the integrity of his songwriting was, and remains, very important to him. Mr Snider’s songwriting process almost always began with two elements: a title, which usually features prominently in the lyrics, and a short melodic idea, which is the first thing he would record. He would then flesh out the rest of the song musically, on a guitar, and write the other lyrics, which were strongly inspired by its title. The process involved in the writing of WNGTI was no different. Mr Snider deposed:In my usual process, working from a list of potential song titles that I had thought up, I sang the entire chorus of We’re Not Gonna Take It into a tape recorder – that is, the words “We’re not gonna take it. No we ain’t gonna take it. We’re not gonna take it, anymore”. At that point I could not come up with a satisfactory verse and bridge for the song so I put it to one side for future development and use. I knew I had something special in this song (even telling my band and our producer at the time Eddie Kramer that I had a “hit” in the works), so I needed to make sure the rest of the song was as strong as the chorus.Over the next few years, whenever I was working on new song ideas, I would return to the chorus I had written for We’re Not Gonna Take It and try again to finish it properly. It was only in the winter of 1982 that I finally was able to complete it. Generally, while Twisted Sister was recording one release, I would be working on the songs for the following album. Throughout 1982 and 1983, I continued to “flesh out” We’re Not Gonna Take It (along with all the other songs for what was to become the album Stay Hungry, released in 1984). I did not present the song to the rest of the band until late in 1983, when we began demoing new songs for Stay Hungry. At no stage did any other person (including the other members of Twisted Sister) contribute to writing the music and lyrics of We’re Not Gonna Take It.As with all my songs, the combination of words in the title of We’re Not Gonna Take It inspired everything else about the song, especially its lyrical content. As an angry, frustrated, younger man (I was 25 in 1980) I wanted to write a song to express not only my emotional state, but one which I felt was shared by our audience. I wanted it to be an anthem that everyone could sing or shout along to when they heard it.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the absence of any submissions on the question or evidence to suggest that the additional relief should not be granted, I propose to exercise my discretion in Universal’s favour. I should make it clear, however, that I am also satisfied that the orders Universal proposed are appropriate. In particular, I am satisfied that, if unrestrained by an injunction, there is a real risk that Mr Palmer would again infringe Songs’ copyright in the literary and musical works. No undertaking not to do so was offered to the Court. A claimant who establishes infringement of copyright is normally entitled to a permanent injunction to restrain future infringements (Copinger at [21-229]). There was no suggestion here of any disentitling conduct.Conclusion In summary, there is a sufficient degree of objective similarity between the copyright works and the impugned works such that the latter are properly to be regarded as reproductions or adaptations of the former and that the infringing works were taken or derived from the copyright works. Mr Palmer failed to make out his defence under s 41A of the Copyright Act. It follows that Mr Palmer infringed Songs’ copyright in both the literary work and the musical work. Damages under s 115(2) of the Act can and should be assessed in accordance with the user principle. I consider the appropriate amount to be $500,000, representing the value of a notional or hypothetical licence fee for the use of the copyright works during the period of the infringements. Universal has also established a case for additional damages which, having regard to all the relevant circumstances, I have assessed at $1,000,000. Finally, the other orders Universal sought should also be made. They include a permanent injunction in the terms Universal proposed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.