Boomerang Investments Pty Ltd v Padgett (Liability)
Link copied
CaseCopied
81 min read
Full text
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Boomerang Investments Pty Ltd v Padgett (Liability) [2020] FCA 535
File number:
NSD 1738 of 2017
Judge:
PERRAM J
Date of judgment:
24 April 2020
Catchwords:
COPYRIGHT – musical works – identification of copyright work – whether sound of lyrics as sung forms part of musical work – ‘love is in the air’ as both lyric carrying meaning and phonetic instruction to vocalist – objective similarity between copyright work and allegedly infringing works – consideration of ordinary, reasonably experienced listener – relevance of expert evidence and chambers’ heightened familiarity with works – causal connection – whether conscious or unconscious copying – consideration of process of creation of allegedly infringing works – whether part taken a substantial part of copyright work – originality – whether sung lyric ‘love is in the air’ and accompanying music ‘essential air’ of copyright work – whether part taken ‘too short’ to be substantial
COPYRIGHT – musical works – where allegedly infringing works created outside Australia – where reproduction and communication rights alleged to have been infringed by streaming, downloading and telephone hold music – effect of assignment and licensing arrangements – whether authorisation infringement possible without primary infringement
COPYRIGHT – literary works – whether lyric reproduced in allegedly infringing works a substantial part of literary work – originality of lyric taken – whether ‘love is in the air’ an obvious, commonplace or prosaic expression
COPYRIGHT – moral rights – right not to have work subjected to derogatory treatment – meaning of ‘reputation’ and ‘honour’ – consideration of territoriality requirements
CONTRACTS – construction of assignment and licensing arrangements concerning rights in copyright work and allegedly infringing works involving Fourth and Fifth Applicants – relevance of extrinsic materials – effect on standing of First Applicant to sue
DAMAGES – whether sufficient prospect of entitlement to real pecuniary award to justify inquiry for damages or account of profits – entitlement to additional damages – whether copying flagrant – where further hearing as to relief necessary
EVIDENCE – standard of proof in civil proceedings – allegations of conscious copying and falsified evidence – gravity of allegations – Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to file rejoinder submissions – where various complaints made about nature and quality of Reply submissions – consideration of standard for leave to be granted
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Boomerang Investments Pty Ltd v Padgett (Liability) and more:
Boomerang Investments Pty Ltd, the assignee of The Easybeats, a well-known Australian pop group, initiated legal proceedings against Padgett and others for copyright infringement, moral rights infringement, and breach of contract. Boomerang Investments alleged that the defendants had infringed on their copyright by creating songs that bore striking similarities to "Love Is in the Air," a song composed by the Easybeats. The court was tasked with determining the extent to which the defendants' songs were derivative of the Easybeats' song and whether the defendants had infringed on the plaintiffs' copyright and moral rights.
The court examined whether the defendants' songs constituted an infringement of the plaintiffs' copyright in "Love Is in the Air," considering the originality of the song and whether the defendants' songs were substantially similar to the original work. Additionally, the court considered whether the defendants' songs constituted a derogatory treatment of the plaintiffs' work, which would infringe on the plaintiffs' moral rights. The court also needed to determine the effect of assignment and licensing arrangements on the plaintiffs' ability to sue for infringement and the relevance of extrinsic materials in interpreting those arrangements.
The court found that the defendants' songs did infringe on the plaintiffs' copyright in "Love Is in the Air." The court held that the defendants' songs were substantially similar to the original work and that the defendants had infringed on the plaintiffs' copyright by creating songs that closely resembled "Love Is in the Air." The court also found that the defendants had infringed on the plaintiffs' moral rights by subjecting their work to derogatory treatment. The court held that the assignment and licensing arrangements did not prevent the plaintiffs from suing for infringement and that extrinsic materials were relevant in interpreting those arrangements.
The court held that the plaintiffs were entitled to damages for copyright infringement and moral rights infringement. The court found that the defendants' conduct was flagrant and that the plaintiffs were entitled to additional damages. The court held that there was a sufficient prospect of entitlement to a real pecuniary award to justify an inquiry for damages or an account of profits. The court also held that further evidence was required to assess the quantum of damages and that a further hearing was necessary to determine the amount of damages to be awarded. The court further held that the plaintiffs were entitled to costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The parties bring in short minutes of order to give effect to these reasons within 14 days.
2. The matter be listed for a case management hearing on Friday 8 May 2020 at 9.30 am.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
There will need to be a further hearing to assess damages. I will hear the parties on costs.THE EVIDENCEThe Applicants’ witnesses The Applicants relied upon the evidence of three witnesses.Mr Johannes van den Berg Mr Vanda swore an affidavit dated 14 September 2018 and a supplementary affidavit dated 30 January 2019 on the eve of the trial. He was cross-examined on the first day of trial, Monday 4 March 2019. Mr Vanda, together with the late Mr Young, are the composers of Love and a large number of other well-known pop songs. He and Mr Young formed The Easybeats in 1964 whilst residing at the Villawood Migrant Hostel, after Mr Vanda emigrated from The Netherlands to Australia the previous year. He gave evidence of the history of The Easybeats including the band’s runaway hits, ‘She’s So Fine’ and ‘Friday On My Mind’, the band’s sojourn in the United Kingdom in the 1970s, and its subsequent breakdown there. He also explained the role of their publisher, Alberts, and its record label Boomerang in the pop music industry generally. Mr Vanda gave evidence of how he and Mr Young had composed Love, the role of Mr John Paul Young who performed the original recording, and the role of Alberts in the song’s promotion and distribution. He told the Court of his longstanding membership of the collecting society APRA and gave evidence about the licensing of Love. It was, in his opinion, the most valuable song that he and Mr Young had written and he was clear that although they were happy for the song to be licensed by their publisher, Alberts, to third parties, they never once agreed to a change in its lyrics. He was shocked when he first heard Warm and France and he reported that the late Mr Young had also been shocked, indeed shocked enough to swear.Mr David Robert Albert Mr Albert swore an affidavit dated 17 September 2018. A second affidavit of Mr Albert, sworn 1 April 2019, was also read. Mr Albert is a Director and the Chief Executive Officer of the Albert Group of Companies which includes Boomerang. He explained the history of the Albert family in music publishing in Australia which commenced in 1894 with the work of his great-great-grandfather, Jacques Albert, and his son, Michel Francois (Frank) Albert. He explained the role of the Boomerang trade mark in the various Alberts businesses, the setting up of the Boomerang sound recording studio on King Street in Sydney and the construction by Frank Albert of Boomerang House in Elizabeth Bay in Sydney. His evidence was that his family had worked with Mr Vanda and the late Mr Young for over 50 years. His uncle, the late Mr Ted Albert, had been instrumental in setting up Albert Productions in 1964, an entity which had been focussed on signing up and producing Australian artists. It was Mr Albert’s view that Mr Vanda, the late Mr Young and his family members Malcolm and Angus Young, together with Bon Scott, are the most successful Australian songwriters of all time. Mr Albert also explained the process by which Alberts was sold to BMG in 2016 and the decision that the family would retain, through Boomerang, the Vanda and Young back catalogue including Love. He gave evidence about the licensing of Love including for very many covers by well-known artists as disparate as Tom Jones and Richard Clayderman, its significant commercial success and its place in various charts around the world. He also gave evidence about Strictly Ballroom, his uncle’s decision to invest heavily in that film and the use of Love as part of its soundtrack. He also gave brief evidence about the roles of APRA and AMCOS and, like Mr Vanda, he reported statements by the late Mr Young consistent with considerable anger on his part about the Air France campaign. Mr Albert was called on Tuesday 5 March 2019 and cross-examined that day.Dr Nicholas Paul Vines
Decision
Reasons for decision
The case against Glass Candy for authorising an infringement of moral rights under s 195AQ(2) does not therefore arise. Had it arisen I would have accepted it for the reasons I have already given since they authorised Air France’s conduct by licensing the use of France.CONCLUSIONThe rejoinder debate Glass Candy submitted that it is entitled to file a rejoinder to the reply submissions on four bases, being that they contain new submissions in chief; submissions that mischaracterise their submissions; submissions for which there is no evidence; or submissions which ‘are otherwise not properly in reply’. Kobalt sought leave on a slightly more confined and continent basis. I am not aware of any principle which would give Glass Candy or Kobalt an entitlement to file a rejoinder in the first two of those bases. The third does not identify an actual ground and is therefore empty. As the Applicants submitted, and Glass Candy and Kobalt accepted, leave to file rejoinder submissions will only be granted in ‘very exceptional circumstances’: Eastman v Director of Public Prosecutions (ACT) [2003] HCA 28; 214 CLR 318 at 330 [29]. Ultimately, these three bases impugned many paragraphs not on the basis that they are not in reply but rather on the basis that they are wrong or weak. I disregard those submissions. As to the fourth basis, the paragraphs of the reply submissions which were said not to be in reply were [23], [33]-[34], [36]-[37] and [91]. There was a related spat about chronologies which I have resolved by ignoring both. Turning to those actual paragraphs attacked as not being in reply, the first is [23]. It is a response to [171] of Glass’s Candy’s submissions. They say this:If there ever was a person who had the power to drill down deep into the public performance income figures to find individual returns showing where public performances took place and the income generated by them, conceivably down to the level of individual cities, it is a publisher in the position of Alberts and a music publishing collecting society like APRA. Yet the information provided by the Applicants here, which now include APRA, all of whom have the ability to request more granular information from overseas collecting societies such as BMI, never descends to a level below that of “United States of America”. At [23] the Applicants say this:Contrary to GCCS [171] and thereabouts, as explained in oral address (T 744.44-746.39) it a was condition of joinder of APRA and AMCOS that they led no evidence, and in any event, APRA records obtained from US collecting societies are not granular enough to indicate the precise location of the playing of copyright works (see eg Ex 4 tab 35). However, the evidence plainly shows that Love was well known and often played beyond Australia and well after 1978, including extensively in the US in the early-mid 2000s. This evidence included:(a)a plethora of evidence summarised at ACS [213] including records showing that royalties for performances of Love in the US exceeded Australian royalties (and Glass Candy accept that Love is a “very popular”, even “iconic” song here: T 755.22-3) and a number licenses of the song for ads on US television;(b)the fact that Boomerang’s (Alberts’) business records show that in 2005, Love was the top royalty earning work over a host of other well-known songs: see Ex DA-9 to Albert#2. Even if (as contended at [GCCS [163]), some of the figures in the Albert#1 exhibits include synchronisation fees for US recordings of Love Ex 4 tab 14 shows the APRA performance royalties alone for Love broken down by the top 10 earning countries in the years since 1993. When considered with the more granular records at Ex 4 tab 35 which give a sense of the small fee payable per performance (some entries record a royalty of only a few cents), it is apparent that for example, a total of $88,230 in 2002 represents many thousands of performances. Ex 4 tab 14 also shows that the royalties over that period for US performances exceeded those for both Australia and France;(c)the fact that M. Caurret, a professional music director working in advertising in France, described Love as a “famous track”: T 624.36;(d)the fact that many covers of Love have been performed all over the world by singers as famous as Tom Jones (see T 757.30-36 and ACS [212]);(e)the use of Love’s opening vocal phrase alone in an episode of the US sitcom Gilmore Girls in 2002/3: see ACS [136] and T 747.14-46;(f)its prevalence in US television programs and films broadcast in the US over the past more than 2 decades, as demonstrated by the APRA records from one of the US collecting societies, ASCAP, at Ex 4 tab 35: see ACS [213(c)];(g)he fact that the co-owner in Italians Do it Better at the relevant time, Mike Simonetti, a DJ, played Love at a 2007/8 New Years’ Eve event in New York City at midnight: see ACS [194] (GCCS at [116] criticise the applicants for not adducing evidence from Mr Simonetti but he is not in the applicants’ camp);(h)the fact that the reviewer of Warm in the 2013 article in ‘Popmatters’ described it as “[r]ising from the ashes of John Paul Young’s ‘Love is in the Air’”: ACS [203] and [211]; and(i)the fact that following the launch of the ‘France is in the Air’ signature, at least two French journalists associated the phrase ‘France is in the air’ with Love even before the France film was created to the music of Warm: see ex 11 tabs 7 and 8 and ACS [244], ACS Supp [7]-[17] (see also below at [121] onwards) and the Adage journalist who attended the launch of the film described it at Ex 9 as “to the tune of” Love.