Blackie & Sons Ltd v Lothian Book Publishing Co Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read
29 CLR 396

BLACKIE &SONS LIMITED

THE LOTHIAN BOOK PUBLISHING COM-

PANY PROPRIETARY LIMITED Copyright-Literary - pork-Infringement-Annotated edition of play of Shakeapeare

-Notes copied-Order limited to notes which were copied-Copyright Act 1911 (1 &2 Geo. F. c. 46), secs. 1, 2-Copyright Act 1912 (No. 20 of 1912), sec. 8. Mar. 9-12,22,

A book, being an annotated edition of one of Shakespeare's plays, first published in Great Britain by the plaintiff in 1895, consisted of an introduction, the text of the play, notes thereon and a glossary. In the preparation of the book resort was had to the accumulation of information due to the industry of prior commentators and scholars, but its preparation involved much inde- pendent labour and research, and it was not a mere copy of written matter already published.

Held, that the plaintiff was entitled to copyright in respect of the book under the law prior to the British Copyright Act 1911 and under that Act.

Walter v. Lane, (1900) A.C., 539 Leslie v. Young de Sons, (1894) A.C., 335; Savory Ltd. v. World of Golf Ltd., (1914) 2 Ch., 566, followed.

The object of the Copyright Act 1911 is not to accord protection to ideas but to the particular form of expression in which an author conveys his ideas or information to the world.

In an annotated edition of the same play first published in Australia in 1918 by the defendant, the arrangement of which was similar to, but not copied from, that of the plaintiff's book. parts of the introduction and of the notes were taken from the plaintiff's book either under a colourable disguise or

Held, that in the circumstances the defendant had appropriated a substantial and valuable portion of the plaintiff's book, and was therefore liable in an action for infringement of copyright.

29 CLR 397

The parts of the defendant's book which were copied from the plaintiff's H. C. OF book being capable of separation from the parts which were not so copied, the Court limited its order prohibiting the use of the defendant's book to the parts which were so copied.

HEARING of action.

An action was brought in the High Court by Blackie &Sons Ltd. against the Lothian Book Publishing Co. Proprietary Ltd. for breach of copyright. The action was heard by Starke J., in whose judgment hereunder the material facts and the nature of the argu- ments appear.

Campbell K.C. and Latham, for the plaintiff. Owen Dixon, for the defendant.

Cur. adv. vult.

STARKE J. delivered the following written judgment: - The plaintiff, Blackie &Sons Ltd., is a well-known English publishing company, and the defendant, the Lothian Book Publishing Co. Proprietary Ltd., is an Australian publishing company. The plain- tiff published a number of Shakespeare's dramatic works under the name of "The Warwick Shakespeare." One of the works SO pub- lished was the historical play called "The Life of King Henry the Fifth." It was prepared for the plaintiff by Dr. G. C. Moore Smith, Professor of English…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Blackie & Sons Ltd v Lothian Book Publishing Co Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1921] HCA 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Blackie & Sons Ltd. (the plaintiff) brought an action in the High Court against The Lothian Book Publishing Co. Proprietary Ltd. (the defendant) for breach of copyright. The dispute concerned an annotated edition of Shakespeare's play "The Life of King Henry the Fifth." The plaintiff had published its annotated edition in the United Kingdom in 1895, which comprised an introduction, the play's text, notes, and a glossary, involving significant independent labour and research. The defendant subsequently published its own annotated edition in Australia in 1918.

The court was required to determine two primary issues: first, whether the plaintiff was entitled to copyright in its annotated edition, and second, whether the defendant's edition infringed upon that copyright. The plaintiff contended that its work was original and protected under copyright law, while the defendant argued that its own publication was the result of independent research and resort to common sources.

Starke J. held that the plaintiff was entitled to copyright in its annotated edition, finding that it involved substantial independent labour and research beyond merely compiling existing material. The court affirmed that the object of copyright law is to protect the specific expression of ideas, not the ideas themselves. Regarding infringement, the court found that while the defendant's book was not a mere copy and involved independent research, it had appropriated a substantial and valuable portion of the plaintiff's work, particularly in parts of the general introduction and certain textual notes, either verbatim or under a colourable disguise. The court noted that the defendant's arrangement and text of the play were not copied, and much of the notes and glossary were independently derived. However, the appropriation of the plaintiff's labour and research in specific sections was deemed substantial and material, constituting an infringement.

Consequently, the court ordered that the defendant be perpetually restrained from publishing or selling the parts of its book that infringed the plaintiff's copyright, specifically identifying passages in the general introduction, introductory comments to Act I, Scene 1, and certain textual notes. The court also ordered an inquiry into damages sustained by the plaintiff, at the plaintiff's risk as to costs, and awarded the plaintiff its costs of the action.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.