Sunlec International Ltd v Carroll Australasia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   SUNLEC INTERNATIONAL LTD -v- CARROLL AUSTRALASIA PTY LTD [2001] WASC 354

CORAM:   WHEELER J

HEARD:   4 DECEMBER 2001

DELIVERED          :   20 DECEMBER 2001

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1387 of 1997

BETWEEN:   SUNLEC INTERNATIONAL LTD

Plaintiff

AND

CARROLL AUSTRALASIA PTY LTD
Defendant

Catchwords:

Costs - Offer to compromise - Consent to judgment - Meaning of offer "not more favourable" - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Supreme Court Rules, O 24A

Result:

Orders made

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr R J L McCormack

Defendant:     Mr S M Davies

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Phillips Fox

Defendant:     Corrs Chambers Westgarth

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Timms v Clift (1998) 2 Qd R 100

Case(s) also cited:

Alltrans Express Ltd v CVA Holdings Ltd [1984] 1 WLR 394

Anglo-Cyprian Trade Agencies Ltd v Paphos Wine Industries Ltd [1951] 1 All ER 873

Blackie & Sons Ltd v Lothian Book Publishing Co Pty Ltd (1921) 29 CLR 396

Canterbury Park Racecourse Co Ltd v Hopkins (1932) 49 WN (NSW) 27

Colgate Palmolive Ltd & Anor v Markwell Finance Ltd & Anor [1990] 8 RPC 197

Evans Marshall & Co v Bertola SA [1973] 1 All ER 992

Fortuity Pty Ltd v Barcza (1995) 32 IPR 517

Hawkes & Son (London) Ltd v Paramount Film Services Ltd (1934) 1 Ch 593

Maclean v Rottnest Island Authority [2001] WASCA 323

Permanent Building Society v Wheeler (1993) 10 WAR 569

Prior v Lansdowne Press Pty Ltd [1977] VR 65

Roache v News Group Newspapers Ltd & Ors [1992] TLR 551

Sydney Organising Committee for the Olympic Games v Clarke (1998) 41 IPR 403

Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd v Placer (Granny Smith) Pty Ltd [2001] WASCA 166

University of London Press Ltd v University Tutorial Press Ltd (1916) 2 Ch 601

WHEELER J:

Background

  1. The present application is concerned solely with the costs of this action, orders with respect to liability and damages having been made by consent.

  2. The plaintiff is a company incorporated to market and distribute Grafoplast, an electrical wire marking product, in Australia.  Since 1989 the plaintiff has distributed Grafoplast in Australia under an exclusive licence from the parent manufacturing company in Italy.  In 1989 the plaintiff contacted a number of distributors and agents around Australia to set up a distribution network.  One of those ultimately appointed as distributor and agent was the defendant.

  3. In 1990 the plaintiff held a national conference in Sydney to train agents and distributors in marketing Grafoplast.  It produced a brochure dated 18/19 June 1990 entitled "Grafoplast – Training Including Marketing Warfare".  Another brochure entitled "Grafoplast – 1995 – Conference – Closing the Loop" was distributed among attendees of a further conference held in 1995.

  4. In 1996 the defendant's distribution agreement with the plaintiff was terminated and, it seems, the defendant became a distributor for a rival wire marking product.  Later that year the plaintiff came into possession of a document produced by the defendant entitled "The Fast Solution to Cable Marking" which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sunlec International Ltd v Carroll Australasia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] WASC 354
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sunlec International Ltd v Carroll Australasia Pty Ltd is a case concerning a dispute between two companies, Sunlec International Ltd and Carroll Australasia Pty Ltd, which originated from an alleged infringement of copyright. The matter was heard and determined by Wheeler J in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The central issue was the determination of the costs associated with the proceedings, particularly in light of the parties' offers to compromise under O 24A of the Supreme Court Rules.

The court had to decide whether the plaintiff's costs should be awarded up to the date of the defendant's initial offer to compromise, or if the plaintiff, having been successful in the proceedings, should be awarded costs for the entirety of the litigation. Additionally, the court examined whether the judgment obtained by the plaintiff was "not more favourable" than the defendant's initial offer of compromise, and if the plaintiff's conduct during the litigation warranted a different costs outcome.

The court reasoned that while the plaintiff was successful in establishing the defendant's infringement of copyright and obtaining injunctive relief and a declaration, the damages awarded were significantly less than those initially sought or offered by the defendant. The court found that the plaintiff's primary concern was not injunctive relief but the quantum of damages. As such, the court determined that the plaintiff should bear the costs associated with the issue of quantum, while the defendant should bear the costs related to liability. This approach aimed to balance the costs fairly without a rigid separation that might result in further expense and inconvenience.

The final orders were that the defendant was to pay the plaintiff's costs of the action up to a certain date, and from another specified date until judgment, while the plaintiff was to pay the defendant's costs for the intervening period. This decision reflects a nuanced approach to costs in light of the parties' offers and the ultimate outcome of the litigation.

Background

Background to the litigation

Sunlec International Ltd is a company that markets and distributes Grafoplast, an electrical wire marking product in Australia. Since 1989, Sunlec has operated under an exclusive licence from its Italian parent company. In 1990, Sunlec held a national conference to train agents and distributors, producing a brochure titled "Grafoplast – Training Including Marketing Warfare." Another brochure, "Grafoplast – 1995 – Conference – Closing the Loop," was distributed in 1995. In 1996, Sunlec terminated its distribution agreement with Carroll Australasia Pty Ltd, one of its distributors, who subsequently became a distributor for a rival product. In the same year, Sunlec discovered that Carroll had produced a document, "The Fast Solution to Cable Marking," which allegedly copied substantial parts of Sunlec's 1990 and 1995 brochures. Following legal advice, Sunlec demanded that Carroll cease publication and deliver the materials. Carroll did not respond, leading Sunlec to issue a writ in mid-1997, seeking injunctive relief, an order for delivery up of infringing copies, and an enquiry into damages or an account of profits. Carroll filed a defence and later made settlement offers, which Sunlec rejected. After various negotiations and offers, the parties reached a consent judgment in 2001, which ordered Carroll to pay damages of $350, deliver up the infringing materials, and cease publication, while also declaring Carroll's infringement of Sunlec's copyright.

The case began when Sunlec issued a writ against Carroll in mid-1997, claiming infringement of copyright in its 1990 and 1995 brochures. Carroll filed a defence, and the matter proceeded with several settlement offers. Initially, Carroll offered to pay $2,000 plus costs to date, which Sunlec rejected. Sunlec subsequently made a counter-offer through the Supreme Court's offer to compromise procedure, which Carroll also rejected. Further negotiations occurred, culminating in a consent judgment in 2001, which resolved the issues of liability, damages, injunctive relief, and delivery up of the infringing materials. The only remaining issue was the costs of the action, which the court heard on 4 December 2001.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff should have its costs of the whole action or if the defendant should bear some or all of the costs post the date of the first offer to compromise.
2. Whether the judgment obtained by the plaintiff is "not more favourable" than the defendant's original offer to compromise.
3. Whether the plaintiff's conduct during the litigation justifies penalising it for costs incurred post the initial offer to compromise.

Held
1. The court held that the plaintiff should bear the costs associated with the issue of quantum of damages from 1 July 1998 to 21 February 2000. The defendant should bear the costs associated with the issue of liability from 21 February 2000 until judgment. The defendant should bear the costs of the action up to 1 July 1998.
2. The court held that the judgment obtained by the plaintiff was more favourable than the defendant's original offer to compromise.
3. The court rejected the plaintiff's conduct during the litigation as a reason to penalise it for costs incurred post the initial offer to compromise.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by noting that the plaintiff had been broadly successful in its claims and should therefore have its costs up to the date of the defendant's first offer to compromise. The difficult question was what costs should be awarded after that date. The court considered whether the plaintiff, as the successful party, should bear all the costs of the whole action, or if the defendant should bear some or all of the costs post the date of the first offer to compromise. The court rejected the defendant's argument that the judgment obtained by the plaintiff was "not more favourable" than the defendant's original offer to compromise. The court held that the injunctive relief obtained by the plaintiff was of considerable value, and the plaintiff should bear the costs associated with the issue of quantum of damages. However, the court held that the defendant should bear the costs associated with the issue of liability. The court rejected the plaintiff's conduct during the litigation as a reason to penalise it for costs incurred post the initial offer to compromise. The court held that the purpose of the offer to compromise rule was to encourage early and realistic offers and consideration of offers of compromise. The court held that the plaintiff should bear the costs associated with the issue of quantum of damages, while the defendant should bear the costs associated with the issue of liability.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court can order costs to be borne by a party for specific issues in a case, rather than the entire action, if it is in the interests of justice to do so. The court can also reject a party's conduct during the litigation as a reason to penalise it for costs incurred post the initial offer to compromise, if the purpose of the offer to compromise rule is to encourage early and realistic offers and consideration of offers of compromise.