Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd v Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd v Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 375

COPYRIGHT – alleged copyright in substantial part of house plans and built houses – al fresco quadrant – subsistence of copyright – whether “logical development” of existing plans of third party –  whether substantial part – whether actual copying – significance of lies as to derivation of respondent’s design – whether sufficient similarity

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 14(1), 31(1)(b)(i)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 55(1)

Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd v Metricon Homes Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 1509 cited
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336 applied
Clarendon Homes (Aust) Pty Ltd v Henley Arch Pty Ltd (1999) 46 IPR 309 applied
Eagle Homes Pty Ltd v Austec Homes Pty Ltd (1999) 43 IPR 1 applied
Edwards v The Queen (1993) 178 CLR 193 applied
Kipling v Genatosan Ltd [1917-1923] MacG Cop Cas 203 referred to
Tamawood Ltd v Henley Arch Pty Ltd (2004) 61 IPR 378 applied

Le Corbusier, Vers une architecture (1923)

BARRETT PROPERTY GROUP PTY LTD AND SRS PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD v CARLISLE HOMES PTY LTD
VID 1245 OF 2005

HEEREY J
20 MARCH 2008
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 1245 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

BARRETT PROPERTY GROUP PTY LTD
First Applicant

SRS PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD
Second Applicant

AND:

CARLISLE HOMES PTY LTD
Respondent

JUDGE:

HEEREY J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 MARCH 2008

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The parties bring in minutes of orders to give effect to these reasons.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 1245 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

BARRETT PROPERTY GROUP PTY LTD
First Applicant

SRS PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD
Second Applicant

AND:

CARLISLE HOMES PTY LTD
Respondent

JUDGE:

HEEREY J

DATE:

20 MARCH 2008

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ .... [1]

The parties’ designs........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ...... [8]

subsistence of copyright........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ....... [10]

Barrett’s development of the Seattle design........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ....... [10]

Carlisle’s use of Seattle design........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ [37]

Access to Seattle design........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ..... [37]
Whether Carlisle used the Seattle design – its case at trial........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ [48]
The conference at Mallesons........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ...... [52]
Retainer of expert by Carlisle........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ .... [64]
Carlisle’s defence and amendments........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ... [65]
Untruthful evidence as to early mention of Rochester........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ....... [72]
Relevance of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd v Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 375
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd initiated proceedings against Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd, seeking damages for copyright infringement. The dispute centred around the alleged copying of a design element from Barrett’s Seattle plan by Carlisle Homes. The trial took place in the Federal Court of Australia, where Justice Gilmour presided over the case. The key legal issues that the court had to address included whether the design element in question was original and protected by copyright, whether Carlisle Homes had indeed copied the design, and if so, whether this copying was intentional or inadvertent. Additionally, the court had to evaluate the credibility of the evidence provided by both parties, particularly focusing on the claims made by Carlisle Homes' representatives about the source of their design.

The court found that the al fresco quadrant design in question was original and protected by copyright. It was established that Mr Doulgeridis from Carlisle Homes had copied this design from Barrett’s Seattle plan. The court was particularly persuaded by the evidence that indicated the Rochester design was not the true source of Carlisle Homes' Provence design, as they had falsely claimed. The court was satisfied on the balance of probabilities that Messrs Doulgeridis, Taylor, and Morrison had deliberately given false evidence about the mention of the Rochester at the Mallesons conference. This false testimony suggested collusion among them to conceal the true source of the design. The court concluded that their lies were deliberate and material, implying that they were conscious of the fact that the truth would be damaging to their case.

Based on the findings, Justice Gilmour ruled in favour of Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd. The court determined that Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd had infringed Barrett’s copyright by copying the al fresco quadrant design. The court ordered the parties to bring in minutes of orders to give effect to these reasons, ensuring that the judgment would be implemented accordingly.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties bring in minutes of orders to give effect to these reasons.

Background

Background to the litigation

Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd, a developer of residential properties, alleged that Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd, another property developer, infringed its copyright by copying the design of a particular property known as Provence. The dispute centred around a design element called the al fresco quadrant, which was part of a larger property design. Barrett claimed that Carlisle had copied this design from their Seattle property, which had been on the market for several years. Carlisle initially argued that the design was commonplace and not original. When unable to produce pre-existing examples of the design, Carlisle then claimed that the design had originated from a property known as the Rochester, which they asserted was the true source of the design. However, there was no record indicating that the Rochester was mentioned at a conference held by Mallesons, an Australian law firm that had been involved in the development of both the Seattle and Provence properties.

The matter proceeded through the Federal Court of Australia, where it was determined on the basis of written submissions and evidence presented by both parties. The Court examined the credibility of the witnesses, particularly the directors of Carlisle, and considered whether they had deliberately given false evidence about the Rochester being mentioned at the Mallesons conference. The Court also assessed the arguments regarding the originality and copyrightability of the al fresco quadrant design.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Further, I am satisfied on the balance of probabilities, while having regard to the seriousness of such a finding (see Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336), that Messrs Doulgeridis, Taylor and Morrison gave consciously untrue evidence when they said that the Rochester was mentioned at the Mallesons conference. It inevitably follows that they must have colluded in so doing.Relevance of untruthful evidence In the criminal law there is extensive jurisprudence as to the evidentiary use that can be made of lies. The leading case is Edwards v The Queen (1993) 178 CLR 193. Deane, Dawson and Gaudron JJ, after noting that ordinarily the telling of a lie will merely affect the credit of the witness who tells it, said at 209:It is only if the accused is telling a lie because he perceives that the truth is inconsistent with his innocence that the telling of the lie may constitute evidence against him. In other words, in telling the lie the accused must be acting as if he were guilty. It must be a lie which an innocent person would not tell. That is why the lie must be deliberate. Telling an untruth inadvertently cannot be indicative of guilt. And the lie must relate to a material issue because the telling of it must be explicable only on the basis that the truth would implicate the accused in the offence for which he is charged. It must be for that reason that he tells the lie. To say that the lie must spring from the realization or consciousness of guilt is really another way of saying the same thing. It is to say that the accused must be lying because he is conscious that “if he tells the truth, the truth will convict him”. (Citations omitted.) Although I am not aware of any consideration in civil cases of the probative effect of lies, the probative logic remains the same (see Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 55(1)), subject of course always to the application of a different standard of proof with the Briginshaw qualification. In the present case, the most likely explanation for Messrs Doulgeridis, Taylor and Morrison telling lies about what was said at the Mallesons conference is that they realised that the failure to mention the Rochester would tend to show that Rochester was not the true source of their Provence design. If they invented an untrue source, the most likely explanation for that is that they knew the source alleged by Barrett was the true one. The evidence points to the following conclusion, which I find. Mr Doulgeridis did copy the al fresco quadrant from Barrett’s Seattle plan, which had been on the market for several years. Probably he did so without much thought and assumed, because the plan had been around for a while, that it was in the public domain, especially in Western Australia. When challenged, the Carlisle directors first raised the argument that the al fresco was commonplace and devoid of originality. The initial versions of the defence reflect this. When the directors were unable to produce any concrete examples of the design pre-dating the Streeton, they fell back on the Rochester argument. When faced with the difficulty that there was no record of mentioning the Rochester on the first opportunity to do so, they falsely claimed that they did.

Decision

Reasons for decision

HEEREY J
Issues
1. Whether Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd infringed Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd's copyright by copying the design of the Provence property, specifically the al fresco quadrant design.
2. Whether the al fresco quadrant design is original and thus protected by copyright.
3. Whether the directors of Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd deliberately gave false evidence about the Rochester being mentioned at the Mallesons conference, and if so, what are the implications of this for the case.

Held
1. The court held that Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd infringed Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd's copyright by copying the design of the Provence property, specifically the al fresco quadrant design.
2. The court held that the al fresco quadrant design is original and thus protected by copyright.
3. The court held that the directors of Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd deliberately gave false evidence about the Rochester being mentioned at the Mallesons conference. This evidence has implications for the case, making it more likely that they knew the true source of the design was Barrett's Seattle plan.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: HEEREY J

The court addressed the issue of whether Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd infringed Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd's copyright by copying the design of the Provence property. The court found that Mr Doulgeridis did indeed copy the al fresco quadrant from Barrett’s Seattle plan. This conclusion was based on the fact that Barrett's plan had been on the market for several years, which Mr Doulgeridis assumed meant it was in the public domain. When challenged, the Carlisle directors initially argued that the design was commonplace and devoid of originality but could not provide examples of it pre-dating the Streeton. They then falsely claimed that they mentioned the Rochester at the Mallesons conference to provide an alternative source, which they knew was not true.

Regarding the originality of the al fresco quadrant design, the court determined it to be original and thus protected by copyright. This was based on the evidence that the design was unique and not commonly found in the public domain, as the Carlisle directors could not produce any examples pre-dating the Streeton.

The court also found that the directors of Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd deliberately gave false evidence about the Rochester being mentioned at the Mallesons conference. This conclusion was based on the probative effect of lies, drawing on the principles established in Edwards v The Queen. The court reasoned that the most likely explanation for the false testimony was that the directors realised the failure to mention the Rochester would indicate that it was not the true source of their Provence design. By falsely claiming they mentioned the Rochester, they likely knew the true source was Barrett's Seattle plan. The court applied the Briginshaw standard of proof, finding on the balance of probabilities that the evidence indicated deliberate untruthfulness. The binding legal principle here is that deliberate false evidence can be used to infer guilt, especially when the lie is material and the accused must be conscious that telling the truth would incriminate them.