Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd v Metricon Homes Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd v Metricon Homes Pty Ltd
[2007] FCA 1509

COPYRIGHT – designs and constructed homes – whether infringement by copying – Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 14(1) and 31(1)(b)(i) – sufficient objective similarity – substantial part of the whole – common place features – subjective copying overlap – causal connection – derivation of works – access

COPYRIGHT – personal liability – whether authorisation - Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 36(1) and 13(2)

Copyright Act (1968) (Cth), ss 14(1), 31(1)(b)(i), 13(2), 35, 36(1)

Adelaide Corporation v Australia Performing Right Association Ltd (1928) 40 CLR 481 cited
Ancher, Mortlock, Murray & Woolley Pty Ltd v Hooker Homes Pty Ltd [1971] 2 NSWLR 278 applied

Australasian Performing Right Association Ltd v Jain (1990) 26 FCR 53 cited
Autodesk Inc v Dyason (No 2) (1993) 176 CLR 300 cited
Chabot v Davies [1936] 3 All ER 221 cited
Clarendon Homes (Aust) Pty Ltd v Henley Arch Pty Ltd (1999) 46 IPR 309 applied
Cooper v Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd [2006] FCAFC 187 applied
Data Access Corp v Powerflex Services Pty Ltd (1999) 202 CLR 1 applied
Dixon Investments Pty Ltd v Hall (1990) 18 IPR 490 cited
Eagle Homes Pty Ltd v Austec Homes Pty Ltd (1999) 87 FCR 415 cited

Falcon v Famous Players Film Co [1926] 2 KB 474 cited

Francis Day & Hunter Ltd v Bron [1963] Ch 587 cited
Henley Arch Pty Ltd v Clarendon Homes(Aust) Pty Ltd (1998) 41 IPR 443 cited
Ibcos Computers Ltd v Barclays Mercantile Highland Finance Ltd [1994] FSR 275 cited
Kenrick & Co v Lawrence & Co (1890) 25 QBD 99 applied
King v Milpurrurru (1996) 66 FCR 474 referred to
Klissers Bakeries v Harvest Bakeries (1985) IPR 533 cited
Ladbroke (Football) Ltd v William Hill (Football) Ltd [1964] 1 WLR 273 cited
LED Builders Pty Ltd v Eagle Homes Pty Ltd (1996) 35 IPR 215 applied
Lend Lease Homes Pty Ltd v Warrigal Homes Pty Ltd [1970] 3 NSWR 265 applied
Milpurrurru & Ors v Indofurn Pty Ltd (1994) 30 IPR 209 cited
Nationwide News Pty Ltd v Copyright Agency Ltd (1996) 34 IPR 53 cited
Nine Network Australia Pty Ltd v IceTV Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 1172 cited
Pacific Gaming Pty Ltd v Aristocrat Leisure Industries Pty Ltd (2001) 116 FCR 448 applied
Root Quality Pty Ltd v Root Control Technologies Pty Ltd (2000) 177 ALR 231 referred to
Skybase Nominees Pty Ltd v Fortuity Pty Ltd (1996) 36 IPR 529 cited
Spectravest Inc v Aperknit Ltd [1988] FSR 161 cited
S W Hart & Co Pty Ltd v Edwards Hot Water Systems (1985) 159 CLR 466 applied
Tamawood v Henley Arch (2004) 61 IPR 378 applied
TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd v Network Ten Pty Ltd (2001) 184 ALR 1 cited
University of New South Wales v Moorhouse (1975) 133 CLR 1 cited
Winstone v Wurlitzer Automatic Phonograph Co of Australia Pty Ltd [1946] VLR 338 cited

McCutcheon, Property in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd v Metricon Homes Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 1509
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd v Metricon Homes Pty Ltd, the plaintiff sought a declaration of copyright infringement against the defendant, Metricon Homes, as well as against two of its employees, Palazzesi and Popple. The plaintiff claimed that Metricon and its employees had infringed upon their copyright by designing a house that closely resembled the plaintiff's copyrighted house design. The court had to determine whether Metricon and its employees had indeed infringed upon the plaintiff's copyright and whether the defendant's employees had authorised such infringement. The court also had to decide on the appropriate relief and costs for the plaintiff.

The court examined the evidence presented by the four key witnesses called by the respondents, who were all involved in the development of the Prada 35. The court found that the similarities between the Prada 35 and the plaintiff's copyrighted design were not coincidental, but rather intentional. The court found that the defendants had copied the plaintiff's design, including both objective and incidental features, and that this copying was authorised by Popple, who had direction and control over Bugeja, who actually drew the design. The court also found that the defendants' argument that the kitchen position and layout was the same as between Prototype 20A and Prototype 20B was unconvincing.

The court concluded that there should be declarations of infringement as against Metricon and declarations of authorisation of that infringement as against each of Palazzesi and Popple. The court also noted that it would hear counsel as to the precise terms of these declarations, the consequential relief sought by the applicants, the further disposition of the case, as well as costs. The court's decision highlights the importance of protecting intellectual property rights and the need for companies to ensure that their employees do not infringe upon the copyright of others.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There were four key witnesses called by the respondents who, in one way or another were involved in the development of the Prada 35. They were:·Jeffrey Mark Bugeja – who worked with Metricon since 1988 as a contractor, became an employee in 2002 and in May 2005 Design Manager;·Adrian Graham Popple – the Product Development Manager of Metricon who has worked with Metricon since 1987;·Ross Palazzesi – the Managing Director of Metricon, whom has been employed by Metricon since 1999; and·Jason Berin Biasin – the General Manager of housing for Queensland and New South Wales divisions of Metricon since March 2006. In 2002, he was employed by Metricon in Melbourne as a Design Sales Manager. Bugeja’s Evidence When asked whether he was aware that the effect of instructing the changes to Prototype 20A was to create a design similar to the Seattle 31 design in connection with the alfresco quadrant, Popple did not initially deny doing so. He said that he “didn’t tell him (Bugeja) how to do that. I just suggested those – those things needed to be addressed and he addressed them.” In light of my view that Popple was generally an unreliable witness, the concession of copying in respect to the Pavillion, and the striking similarity between the back half of Seattle 31 and the back half of the Prada 35, I find this evidence to be quite unconvincing. The fact Popple and Bugeja were prepared to keep the front half of Prototype 20A, designed as it was by direct reference to the Pavillion, as well as to copy the back half of the Seattle 31, leads me to conclude that the primary reason for the modifications to Prototype 20A was not because of any perceived problem with similarity to the Pavillion. I find that the similarity was intended from the outset. It was not something which only occurred to Popple after it had been drawn. Rather, the Seattle 31 design, which created a covered alfresco area under a single roof-line, was seen by both as a cost effective remedy to counter the more expensive alfresco arrangement found in the Pavillion. Accordingly, the amendment to Prototype 20A to produce Prototype 20B had to do with money and not with virtue. Both were prepared to retain in Prototype 20B what was copied from the Pavillion in the front half of Prototype 20A. The objective similarities between Prototype 20B and the Seattle 31 plan and display home are indicative of copying. In particular, there is a marked similarity in the features of the alfresco quadrant, the location and relationship of rooms in this part of the house design and room dimensions relative to each other, and the single roof-line in both designs. There are also some incidental features of similarity (and which were not needed for functional purposes), which indicate copying, for example: (i)the location of the windows and fireplace in the lounge of both Prototype 20B and the Seattle 31 display home (though this feature is not shown on the Seattle 31 plan). This was a feature which Popple could recall from his visit to the Seattle 31 display home. Bugeja could not recall whether this feature in the design was discussed with Popple; and(ii)the change in the kitchen island feature in Prototype 20B, compared with Prototype 20A, which had the island adopt a return toward the wall (which follows the direction and angle of the return in the Seattle 31 display home and plan, although the return there runs to the wall). Popple had a recollection of the kitchen feature from the Seattle 31 display home. Bugeja could not recall whether this design change was discussed with Popple. The respondents contended that the kitchen position and layout is the same as the between Prototype 20A and Prototype 20B and that, accordingly, could not have been coped from the Seattle 31. I do not accept this. Whilst the position is similar, the layout has obviously been changed and is very close to the angular design of the Seattle 31 kitchen although a walk through has been provided for in Prototype 20B. In that respect it is a colourable change to the Seattle 31 kitchen. While these incidental features might have limited utility in isolation in making the case on usage, they should be considered in combination and as reflective of an overall reference to the Seattle 31 plan and house. Popple agreed that none of his company’s prior designs had these features in combination.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GILMOUR J
I find that Popple authorised each of these by his direction and control over Bugeja who actually drew them. I make this finding too, in respect to the Coburn, although as I outlined earlier that this raised some different considerations but not such as to dispel my finding. CONCLUSION For these reasons there should be declarations of infringement as against Metricon and declarations of authorisation of that infringement as against each of Palazzesi and Popple. However I will hear counsel as to the precise terms of these. I will also hear counsel as to the consequential relief sought by the applicants, the matter of directions for the further disposition of this case as well as costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GILMOUR J