Inform Design and Construction Pty Ltd v Boutique Homes Melbourne Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 62 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Inform Design and Construction Pty Ltd v Boutique Homes Melbourne Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 912

COPYRIGHT – copyright in project home designs – infringement – objective similarities in designs – allegations of conscious or subconscious copying – reproduction of substantial part of designs – protection of idea or expression of idea

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), ss 14(1)(b), 31(1)(a)(i)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s 52

Francis Day & Hunter Ltd v Bron [1963] 1 Ch 587 cited
SW Hart & Co Pty Ltd v Edwards Hot Water Systems (1985) 159 CLR 466 cited
Clarendon Homes (Aust) Pty Ltd v Henley Arch Pty Ltd (1999) 46 IPR 309 cited
LED Builders Pty Ltd v Eagle HomesPty Ltd (1996) 35 IPR 215 cited
Tamawood Ltd v Henley Arch Pty Ltd (2004) 61 IPR 378 cited
Eagle Homes Pty Ltd v AustecHomes Pty Ltd (1999) 87 FCR 415 considered
Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd v Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 375 cited
Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd v Metricon Homes Pty Ltd (2007) 74 IPR 52 cited
British Northrop Ltd v Texteam Blackburn Ltd [1974] RPC 57 cited
Autodesk Inc v Dyason [No 2] (1993) 176 CLR 300 cited
Dixon Investments Pty Ltd v Hall (1990) 18 IPR 490 cited
Ancher, Mortlock, Murray & Woolley Pty Ltd v Hooker Homes Pty Ltd [1971] 2 NSWLR 278 cited
Ladbroke (Football) Ltd v William Hill (Football)Ltd [1964] 1 All ER 465 cited
Henley Arch Pty Ltd v Clarendon Homes (Aust) Pty Ltd (1998) 41 IPR 443 cited
Metricon Homes Pty Ltd v Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd [2008] FCAFC 46 cited
Autodesk Inc v Dyason (1992) 173 CLR 330 cited

Oscar Wilde, The Importance of Being Earnest (1895)

INFORM DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (ACN 058 414 592) v BOUTIQUE HOMES MELBOURNE PTY LTD (ACN 081 136 281)

VID 681 OF 2006

WEINBERG J
18 JUNE 2008
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 681 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

INFORM DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD
(ACN 058 414 592)
Applicant

AND:

BOUTIQUE HOMES MELBOURNE PTY LTD
(ACN 081 136 281)
Respondent

JUDGE:

WEINBERG J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 JUNE 2008

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed with costs.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 681 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

INFORM DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD
(ACN 058 414 592)
Applicant

AND:

BOUTIQUE HOMES MELBOURNE PTY LTD
(ACN 081 136 281)
Respondent

JUDGE:

WEINBERG J

DATE:

18 JUNE 2008

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. Inform Design and Construction Pty Ltd (“Inform”) is a well-known designer and builder of high-quality project homes in Victoria.  The homes it designs and builds are targeted at the upper end of the volume housing market.  It builds around eighty homes a year.  While it provides a customised design service in addition to its project homes, it…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Inform Design and Construction Pty Ltd v Boutique Homes Melb... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 912
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Inform Design and Construction Pty Ltd initiated proceedings against Boutique Homes Melbourne Pty Ltd, alleging copyright infringement and misleading or deceptive conduct. Inform claimed that Boutique had copied its Urban and Seasons designs to create the Villa View. The dispute was heard in a court which found that the similarities between the two sets of designs were coincidental. The court had to determine whether Boutique had used Inform’s designs to create the Villa View, if the Villa View reproduced a substantial part of the Urban and Seasons designs, and whether the designs were amenable to copyright protection. The court concluded that Boutique did not copy Inform’s designs, and therefore, there was no infringement of copyright. The evidence presented by Inform was not sufficient to establish copying, either deliberate or subconscious. The court found that Boutique had designed the Villa View independently. As a result, Inform’s claims under the Trade Practices Act were dismissed. The court ordered that the application be dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This means that there are three issues to determine. The first is whether Boutique made use of any of Inform’s designs or buildings to create the Villa View. The second is whether, if it did, the Villa View reproduces a substantial part of the Urban and Seasons designs. The third is whether, even if that be the case, that which Inform is seeking to protect is amenable to copyright protection. THE EVIDENCE Since 1998, Inform has on occasion retained Mr Leon Meyer, an architect, to design a series of two-storey project homes. These commenced with a design known as the Core and then developed progressively through the Urban (designed in May and June 2001 and opened as a display home in June 2002) and the Seasons (designed in 2002 and opened in April 2003). Mr Meyer expressly assigned copyright in these three designs to Inform. According to Mr Meyer, these designs share certain conceptual characteristics, the main element of which is a modern plan layout along a rectilinear spine with a central freestanding staircase. Ground-level service areas, such as the kitchen, bathrooms and laundry, are collected around that staircase. These service areas are referred to as “wet areas” by virtue of the fact that water spillage is likely to occur there on a regular basis. Bedroom and living areas are located upstairs and, wherever possible, upstairs bathrooms are clustered as close to the staircase as practicable. The evidence establishes that since their introduction, the Core, Urban and Seasons have been highly successful, selling well and receiving industry recognition. In 1999 the Core was a finalist in a Housing Industry Association (“HIA”) award for Victorian display home design. In 2000 it was runner-up in the category of display homes selling for over $250,000. In 2002 the Urban won the HIA’s Victorian Display Home of the Year in the $300,000 and above category. In 2003 it won the HIA’s national awards for Display Home of the Year in the $250,000 and above category and the Australian Home of the Year, which is the association’s highest award for housing. In 2003-04 Seasons won the award for Best Victorian Display Home between $350,000 and $500,000. These awards generated considerable publicity. All three homes featured in various newspaper articles. In addition, Inform promoted its homes extensively in newspapers and magazines and built and operated display homes. There is no dispute about the fact that it has acquired a substantial reputation and goodwill in its designs. Plainly, those designs are extremely valuable. Inform claims that Boutique infringed its copyright in the building plans and buildings themselves. It claims that Boutique, through the design and construction of its Villa View home, particularly a home known as the Villa View 4300, has substantially reproduced its Urban and Seasons designs. The evidence establishes that the Villa View comes in three sizes: 33 squares, 36.5 squares and 43 squares. Boutique admits to having designed and built a version of unspecified dimension in July 2004 and having designed and built a 43-square version (the Villa View 4300) at Wyndham Waters Estate, Truganina, in the outer western suburbs of Melbourne, in about April 2005. Another Villa View 4300 with a modified design has been built in North Balwyn.

Decision

Reasons for decision

WEINBERG J
I was invited to view the Seasons and the Villa View. The similarities between these two homes were obvious. At the same time, there were significant differences. They are both modern homes, apparently well designed and with clean lines. At the entry to each house, a person’s vision is drawn through the length of the house towards the rear. There is no staircase immediately visible to interfere with the line of sight. Beyond that, I did not experience, as Mr Wines had suggested I might, a sense of déjà vu when entering the Villa View having just seen the Seasons. It may be that my perception was not as well attuned as his. At the same time, however, I am conscious of his having gone out on a limb when describing the Contemporary Villa Grand and Villa View as radical departures from the Villa Grand and then retreating from that opinion. In my view, he had no choice but to do so. CONCLUSION I am not persuaded that anyone associated with Boutique copied any Inform design. I accept the evidence of Mr Di Natale, Mr de Weerd and, in particular, that of Mr Lazarovski to the contrary. I was impressed by Mr Lazarovski’s account of how the Contemporary Villa Grand came to be designed over several months and with hundreds of changes based on trial and error. That is hardly consistent with a case of copying, whether conscious or subconscious. I do not attribute to Mr Di Natale a sophisticated form of plagiarism whereby he pretended to be working towards a solution that he knew had already been achieved by Inform. I am unable in the face of this evidence to draw the inference for which Inform contends. Whatever similarities there are between the Seasons and the Villa View are fully and rationally explained. I am therefore not persuaded that the Villa View was not the product of independent creation. Inform’s claim under the Trade Practices Act must stand or fall on the basis of my finding as to copying. If Boutique did not copy Inform’s designs, it can hardly be said to have engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct by representing the Villa View as its own design. Boutique only raised issues of “substantial part” and “idea” to cater for the possibility that I might find that there had been copying. Because Inform’s allegations of copying have not been made out, it is unnecessary for me to deal with Boutique’s additional answers to Inform’s claim. It follows that this application must be dismissed. The applicant must pay the respondent’s costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: WEINBERG J

Boutique referred to Ancher, Mortlock, Murray & Woolley Pty Ltd v Hooker Homes Pty Ltd where Street J said (at 284):“An architect may legitimately inspect an original plan or house and then, having absorbed the architectural concept and appreciated the architectural style represented therein, return to his own drawing board and apply that concept and style to an original plan prepared by him and in due course to a house built to such plan. There is a dividing line separating such a legitimate process from an inspection followed by a later copying of a substantial part of the physical object inspection, even though the copying be from memory; the latter exercise does infringe. In many instances it will be difficult to state categorically whether the dividing line has been crossed. Cases will not always be black or white where the alleged coping is from memory. The borderline area is clouded by a band of grey within which opinions and conclusions may differ. Within this grey band conflicting answers could without error be given to the questions – is that plan or house only a copy of the concept or style of the original and hence legitimate?, or is it a copy of the author’s manifestation of that concept or style and hence an infringement?”CONSIDERATION Despite the significant body of evidence led in this case, and the copious citation of authority, the real dispute between the parties turns largely upon a simple question of fact. Has Inform established by reliance upon inference that those involved in the design and construction of the Villa View copied central elements of the Urban or Seasons? Inform’s case turns primarily upon subconscious rather than deliberate copying. It does not invite me to find that any of Mr Di Natale, Mr de Weerd, Mr O’Dwyer or Mr Lazarovski has given untruthful evidence as such. Rather, it submits that it is simply inconceivable that two such similar designs as the Seasons and Villa View could have been independently arrived at. It says that someone associated with the design of the Villa View must have seen and digested the essential features of either or both of the Urban or Seasons, each of which achieved considerable publicity at about the time the Villa View was being planned. The seeds of the Inform designs must have been planted in the minds of those who conceived the Villa View and influenced the design of that home. Inform says that any other conclusion would strain the bounds of credulity. Weighed against that view is the emphatic evidence given by Mr Di Natale, Mr de Weerd, and Mr Lazarovski in particular, denying any knowledge of the Urban or Seasons at the time in question. Their evidence is supported by a detailed documentary trail, which shows the evolution of the different Boutique homes from the one at Mawson Lakes to the various Villa Grand versions, including the Contemporary Villa Grand, and ultimately the Villa View. That evidence, which included transparencies of the plans of each of these homes, was said to controvert Mr Wine’s opinion to the extent that he did not resile from it in any event under cross-examination.