Metricon Homes Pty Ltd v Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Metricon Homes Pty Ltd v Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd [2008] FCAFC 46

COPYRIGHT – copyright in plans and drawings of project homes and houses built to their design – infringement – s 14(1) Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) – “substantial part” – meaning – quality rather than quantity – whether work copied was a substantial part of the work in suit – whether sufficient similarity – role of appellate Court in relation to primary judge’s factual findings

Held: primary judge’s findings upheld – appeal dismissed

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 13(2), 14(1), 32(1), 36(1), 36(1A)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 54
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 24

Autodesk Inc v Dyason (No 2) (1993) 176 CLR 300 followed
Barrett Property Group Ltd v Metricon Homes Pty Ltd (2007) 74 IPR 52 affirmed
Barrett Property Group Ltd v Metricon Homes Pty Ltd (No 2) [2007] FCA 1823 cited
Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd v Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 375 cited
Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd (2001) 117 FCR 424 considered
Cooper v Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd (2006) 156 FCR 380 cited
Eagle Homes Pty Ltd v Austec Homes Pty Ltd (1999) 87 FCR 415 considered
LB (Plastics) Ltd v Swish Products Ltd [1979] RPC 551 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Jia Legeng (2001) 205 CLR 507 cited
Tamawood Ltd v Henley Arch Pty Ltd (2004) 61 IPR 378 cited
University of New South Wales v Moorehouse (1975) 133 CLR 1 cited
WEA International Inc v Hanimex Corp Ltd (1987) 17 FCR 274 cited

Lahore J, Copyright and Designs (looseleaf, Butterworths, 1996)

METRICON HOMES PTY LTD (ACN 005 108 752), ROSS PALAZZESI AND ADRIAN GRAHAM POPPLE v BARRETT PROPERTY GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 088 015 267) AND SRS PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 096 513 218)
VID 978 OF 2007

BRANSON, SUNDBERG AND KENNY JJ
1 APRIL 2008
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 978 OF 2007

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

METRICON HOMES PTY LTD (ACN 005 108 752)
First Appellant

ROSS PALAZZESI
Second Appellant

ADRIAN GRAHAM POPPLE
Third Appellant

AND:

BARRETT PROPERTY GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 088 015 267)
First Respondent

SRS PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 096 513 218)
Second Respondent

JUDGES:

BRANSON, SUNDBERG AND KENNY JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

1 APRIL 2008

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.The appellants pay the respondents’ costs.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 978 OF 2007

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

METRICON HOMES PTY LTD (ACN 005 108 752)
First Appellant

ROSS PALAZZESI
Second Appellant

ADRIAN GRAHAM POPPLE
Third Appellant

AND:

BARRETT PROPERTY GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 088 015 267)
First Respondent

SRS PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Metricon Homes Pty Ltd v Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCAFC 46
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Metricon Homes Pty Ltd v Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd involved a dispute over alleged copyright infringement. The Barrett Parties alleged that Metricon Homes had infringed their copyright by authorising the reproduction of substantial parts of their architectural designs in several residential homes. The primary judge found in favour of the Barrett Parties, concluding that Metricon Homes had reproduced a substantial part of the Copyright Works within the meaning of s 14(1) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth). This decision was appealed by Metricon Homes.

The appeal raised several legal issues, primarily whether Metricon Homes had reproduced a substantial part of the Barrett Parties’ architectural designs. The court had to determine if the "alfresco quadrant" in the Seattle plan and house was a substantial part of the Copyright Works. The appeal also considered whether the primary judge correctly assessed the design history and the extent to which Metricon Homes had reproduced the Seattle design. Another issue was whether the primary judge had erred in not giving sufficient weight to the evidence presented by Metricon Homes regarding the limited design options for houses with certain configurations.

The court examined the design history and concluded that the alfresco quadrant was not created in a single drawing but was the product of considerable design evolution. The court found that the primary judge did not confuse the time and work involved in developing the Seattle plan as a whole with the time and work for the development of its alfresco quadrant. The court rejected Metricon Homes' argument that the alfresco quadrant was not a substantial part of the Copyright Works because it did not involve substantial time and work. The evidence supported the primary judge's conclusion that the alfresco quadrant was indeed a substantial part of the Copyright Works. The court also found that the primary judge appropriately considered and dismissed the argument concerning the limited design options for houses with certain configurations.

The appeal was dismissed, and Metricon Homes were ordered to pay the respondents' costs. The court upheld the primary judge's decision that Metricon Homes had reproduced a substantial part of the Barrett Parties' architectural designs in their residential homes.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellants pay the respondents’ costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Nonetheless, we give consideration to the argument that his Honour should have found that the alfresco quadrant was not a substantial part of the Copyright Works as its design did not involve substantial time and work because:(a)Mr Studdert created the arrangement of rumpus, family, kitchen and meals rooms around an outdoor space or alfresco in a single sketch on 30 July 1999; and(b)the outdoor space or alfresco was included under the single roof-line in a single drawing on 20 August 1999.The evidence The evidence discloses the following design history of the Seattle plan. In June 1999 Mr Studdert, a director of the Barrett Parties, met with Mr Fuller, a contract designer, and explained to him that he wanted to create a single storey project home which had the large master bedroom suite usually associated only with double storey house designs. Mr Fuller prepared some sketches but ultimately Mr Studdert and another director of the Barrett parties decided to engage another designer. They engaged Mr Pye, who was then self-employed, and gave him the sketches prepared by Mr Fuller. A designer employed by Mr Pye prepared initial concept drawings which Mr Pye discussed with Mr Studdert. Thereafter Mr Pye provided to Mr Studdert four draft floor plan concepts. One of the draft floor plan concepts includes recognisable features of what became the Seattle design. It has bedrooms three and four plus a rumpus room at the rear of the house and a family and meals areas facing to the side. On 30 July 1999 Mr Studdert made refinements to the draft floor plan described above and passed his drawings back to Mr Pye. Mr Studdert’s drawings were even closer than Mr Pye’s draft floor plan to what ultimately became the Seattle design. In particular, the alfresco quadrant had been realigned so as to allow it to be included under a single roof-line. There were further exchanges of drawings between Mr Pye and Mr Studdert until on about 20 August 1999 the basic floor plan for the Seattle house was settled. On that day, after discussion between Mr Studdert and Mr Pye concerning options for the roof of the Seattle house, it was decided to cover the alfresco dining area with the main roof. Mr Studdert and his co-director thought that this was a great idea and were additionally impressed by the fact that it was cheaper to keep the roof-line straight.Consideration The Metricon Parties’ argument that Mr Studdart created the floor plan for the alfresco quadrant of the Copyright Works on a single sketch on 30 July 1999 is refuted by the history outlined above. Examination of the drawings and plans exhibited to the affidavits sworn respectively by Mr Studdart and Mr Pye reveals that the alfresco quadrant of the Seattle design was itself the product of considerable design evolution. The evidence does not support the suggestion that, while the other aspects of the Seattle design were the product of labour, skill and judgment, the alfresco quadrant emerged fully formed in a single drawing. We therefore see no reason to conclude that his Honour confused the time and work for the development of the Seattle plan as a whole with the time and work for the development of its alfresco quadrant.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BRANSON, SUNDBERG AND KENNY JJ
The case against Messrs Palazzesi and Popple respectively was that each had infringed the Barrett Parties’ copyright in the Copyright Works by authorising the infringing conduct of Metricon.CONCLUSIONS OF THE PRIMARY JUDGE Aspects of the reasons for judgment of the primary judge are considered in more detail below in the context of our consideration of the issues raised by the appeal. Nonetheless it is convenient to summarise his Honour’s reasons for judgment here. The primary judge was not required to determine whether copyright subsists in the Copyright Works. The subsistence of copyright in the Copyright Works was ultimately conceded by the Metricon Parties. Nor was his Honour required to determine whether Metricon had reproduced the whole of either or both of the Copyright Works. The Barrett Parties did not seriously press their pleaded case that the whole of the Copyright Works had been reproduced by Metricon. The principal issue for his Honour’s determination was thus, in respect of each of the Copyright Works, whether Metricon had reproduced a substantial part of that work within the meaning of s 14(1) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) (“the Act”). The case before his Honour was conducted on the basis that this issue was to be determined, at least initially, by reference to the plan for the Seattle and a constructed Seattle house, on the one hand, and the plan for the Prada and a constructed Prada house, on the other hand. As discussed below, the plan for the Prada was taken from a drawing known as Prototype 20B which was itself a modification of a drawing known as Prototype 20A. Although all of the plans in suit are annexed to the reasons for judgment of the primary judge, for convenience, we have annexed to these reasons for judgment the critical plans, namely the Seattle plan, the Prada plan (otherwise known as Prototype 21A) and the Prototypes 20A and 20B drawings. As indicated above, his Honour concluded that, by drawing the plan for the Prada and by constructing the Prada house, Metricon had reproduced a substantial part of the plan for the Seattle and the Seattle house. The substantial part identified by the primary judge was the portion of the plan and house which his Honour called the “alfresco quadrant”. We will use the same expression to describe, where applicable, that portion of the respective houses and plans that his Honour described as the “hub of the home”; that is, the kitchen/meals area, the family living area, the alfresco (ie a covered outdoor area) and the rumpus room. In the Seattle plan and the Seattle House and the Prada plan and the Prada house the entire alfresco quadrant is under a single “hip” roof-line. After reaching his conclusion concerning the Prada plan and the Prada house, the primary judge turned to consider the remaining Metricon Houses and their plans. His Honour found that there was a striking similarity between their respective alfresco quadrants and the Seattle alfresco quadrant, both at the plan level and so far as the constructed houses were concerned. He accepted the expert evidence of Dr John Cooke to the effect that:(a)the alfresco quadrant in each of the Tyrell, the Connolly and the Streeton plans and houses were, subject to minor modification, essentially the same as the Seattle plans and house; and(b)the rear sections in the Coburn plan and house were derived by reference to the Seattle plan and are modified copies of the Memphis plan and house.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BRANSON, SUNDBERG AND KENNY JJ

On 30 July 1999 Mr Studdert made refinements to the draft floor plan described above and passed his drawings back to Mr Pye. Mr Studdert’s drawings were even closer than Mr Pye’s draft floor plan to what ultimately became the Seattle design. In particular, the alfresco quadrant had been realigned so as to allow it to be included under a single roof-line. There were further exchanges of drawings between Mr Pye and Mr Studdert until on about 20 August 1999 the basic floor plan for the Seattle house was settled. On that day, after discussion between Mr Studdert and Mr Pye concerning options for the roof of the Seattle house, it was decided to cover the alfresco dining area with the main roof. Mr Studdert and his co-director thought that this was a great idea and were additionally impressed by the fact that it was cheaper to keep the roof-line straight.Consideration The Metricon Parties’ argument that Mr Studdart created the floor plan for the alfresco quadrant of the Copyright Works on a single sketch on 30 July 1999 is refuted by the history outlined above. Examination of the drawings and plans exhibited to the affidavits sworn respectively by Mr Studdart and Mr Pye reveals that the alfresco quadrant of the Seattle design was itself the product of considerable design evolution. The evidence does not support the suggestion that, while the other aspects of the Seattle design were the product of labour, skill and judgment, the alfresco quadrant emerged fully formed in a single drawing. We therefore see no reason to conclude that his Honour confused the time and work for the development of the Seattle plan as a whole with the time and work for the development of its alfresco quadrant. The argument that the outdoor space forming part of the alfresco quadrant was included under the single roof in a single drawing on 20 August 1999 is, in part, accurate. It was on that day that the design decision was taken to cover the outdoor area with the main roof thus giving rise to a straight, and therefore inexpensive, roof-line. However, the design that made possible that choice had evolved over a significant period of time. The conclusion of the primary judge that the alfresco quadrant was a substantial part of the Copyright Works within the meaning of s 14(1) of the Act was based on matters of impression and degree. It would be inappropriate for the Court to depart from his Honour’s conclusion unless persuaded that his Honour erred in principle or reached a conclusion that is plainly or obviously wrong. We are not so persuaded. Indeed, having considered for ourselves the evidence adduced before his Honour we have formed the view that his Honour was correct. The complaint of the Metricon parties that the primary judge disregarded, or gave insufficient weight to, the evidence adduced by them about the configuration of houses that “live to the side” is difficult to address as the evidence relied upon was not identified. However, it is clear that the primary judge addressed an argument made by the Metricon Parties concerning the limited design options open for a house so configured. At [59]-[60] his Honour observed:In short, so the respondents’ argument goes, in the ordinary course, a Melbourne project home that lives to the side and which includes an alfresco, rumpus, family and dining or meals rooms would be designed inevitably in the same way as the Seattle 31 plan. This is a proposition which, in my opinion, ought to have been the subject of expert opinion testimony. It was not. I do not accept the respondents’ contention. The evidence is to the contrary. For example, Bugeja identified five examples of alfrescos living to the side from the Perth trip. He also identified a further ten alfrescos that lived to the rear and side. Not one of these is essentially the same as the alfresco in the Seattle 31. Not one of the twelve prior art items cited particularly by the respondents discloses an alfresco, as expressed in the Seattle 31 design, under a single roof-line.