A V Jennings Ltd ACN 004 601 503 v Bogdan

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

A V Jennings Ltd ACN 004 601 503 v Bogdan [2009] FCA 307

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – consideration of an appeal from the Magistrates Court of Queensland exercising federal jurisdiction in relation to relief arising out of the contended infringement by the respondents of the copyright subsisting in the appellant’s house plan – consideration of the extent to which objective similarity in the absence of direct evidence of actual use of a plan might give rise to an inference of use and reproduction of a substantial part of the work in which copyright is said to subsist – consideration of the approach to damages

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), ss 10, 14, 31, 36, 115

Tamawood Ltd v Henley Arch Pty Ltd (2004) 61 IPR 378 – cited and quoted
S W Hart & Co Proprietary Limited v Edwards Hot Water Systems (1985) 159 CLR 466 - cited
Francis Day & Hunter Ltd v Bron (1963) 1 Ch. 587 - cited
Clarendon Homes (Aust) Pty Ltd v Henley Arch Pty Ltd (1999) 46 IPR 309 - cited
Inform Design and Construction Pty Ltd v Boutique Homes Melbourne Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 912 – cited and quoted
Dixon Investments Pty Ltd v Hall 18 IPR 490 - cited
Autodesk Inc. v Dyason [No. 2] (1993) 176 CLR 300 - cited
Eagle Homes Pty Ltd v Austec Homes Pty Ltd (1999) 161 ALR 503 – cited
New England Country Homes Pty Limited v Bradley Moore [1998] FCA 345 - cited
Sutherland Publishing Co. Ltd v Caxton Publishing Co. Ltd [1936] 1 Ch. 323 - cited
Microsoft Corporation v Atifo Pty Ltd (1997) 38 IPR 643 - cited
Autodesk Australia Pty Ltd v Cheung (1990) 94 ALR 472 - cited
Interfirm Comparison (Australia) Pty Ltd v Law Society of New South Wales (1975) 6 ALR 445 - cited
Australasian Performing Rights Association v Grebo Trading Co. Pty Ltd (1978) 23 ACTR 30 - cited
Amalgamated Mining Services Pty Ltd v Warman International Ltd (1992) 111 ALR 269 at 285 - cited
Microsoft Corporation v TYN Electronics Pty Ltd (in liq) (2005) 63 IPR 137 - cited
Columbia Pictures Industries Inc. & Anor v Luckins (1996) 34 IPR 504 – cited
Eagle Rock Entertainment Ltd & Anor v Caisley (2006) 66 IPR 554 - cited
Fenning Film Service Limited v Wolverhampton, Walsall and District Cinemas Limited [1914] 3 KB 1171 – cited
Gaunt v Hille [2007] FCA 2017 - cited

A V JENNINGS LTD ACN 004 601 503 v VESNA BOGDAN and TIBERIU BOGDAN

QUD410 of 2007

GREENWOOD J
1 APRIL 2009
BRISBANE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

QUD410 of 2007

BETWEEN:

A V JENNINGS LTD ACN 004 601 503
Appellant

AND:

VESNA BOGDAN
First Respondent

TIBERIU BOGDAN
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

GREENWOOD J

DATE OF ORDER:

1 APRIL 2009

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal from that part of the judgment of Ms Payne SM of the Magistrates Court of Queensland given on 20 March…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A V Jennings Ltd ACN 004 601 503 v Bogdan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 307
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of A V Jennings Ltd ACN 004 601 503 v Bogdan, the dispute primarily concerned allegations of copyright infringement in relation to the design of a residential property. Jennings claimed that the defendants, Mr and Mrs Bogdan, had used their copyrighted architectural plans without permission in the construction of their home. The case was initially heard in the Magistrates Court of Queensland, with the appeal subsequently heard by a higher court. The key legal issues focused on whether the defendants had indeed infringed Jennings' copyright, whether they were aware of the infringement, and the assessment of Jennings' losses if infringement was found.

The court's reasoning involved a detailed analysis of the similarities and differences between the Bogdans' house plan and Jennings' copyrighted plans. Expert witnesses provided evidence on the distinctive features of Jennings' designs, such as elevated ceilings and splayed walls. Magistrate Payne concluded that while there were similarities, they did not reach the threshold of a substantial part of Jennings' work being reproduced. The court found that the Bogdans did not have direct access to Jennings' plans and that the similarities could be attributed to common design ideas rather than copying.

Ultimately, the appeal court determined that the primary court's findings were sound, and the appeal was dismissed in part and allowed in part. The court found that while the respondents did not intentionally infringe Jennings' copyright, damages were assessed against the respondent Tiberiu Bogdan. The appeal court also directed the distribution of costs between the parties, with Jennings bearing the costs for the unsuccessful part of the appeal and the Bogdans responsible for the costs of the successful part of the appeal.

The final orders included dismissing the appeal concerning Vesna Bogdan, allowing the appeal concerning Tiberiu Bogdan, assessing damages against him, and directing the payment of costs between the parties in accordance with the appeal's outcome.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal from that part of the judgment of Ms Payne SM of the Magistrates Court of Queensland given on 20 March 2007 in respect of the respondent Vesna Bogdan is dismissed.

2. The appeal from that part of the judgment of Ms Payne SM of the Magistrates Court of Queensland given on 20 March 2007 in respect of the respondent Tiberiu Bogdan is allowed.

3. Damages awarded against the respondent, Tiberiu Bogdan, are assessed in the amount of $3,536.00.

4. The appellant shall pay the costs of the respondent, Vesna Bogdan, of and incidental to the appeal to this Court and the costs of the respondent, Vesna Bogdan, in the Magistrates Court of Queensland of and incidental to the proceedings in that Court.

5. The respondent, Tiberiu Bogdan, shall pay the costs of the appellant of and incidental to the appeal to this Court and the costs of the appellant as plaintiff of and incidental to the proceedings in the Magistrates Court of Queensland.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr and Mrs Bogdan commissioned a house design from Igor Designs, Architects and Draftsmen, which they used to build their house. The design was based on a detailed drawing prepared by Mr Florien Bogdan, incorporating specific requests from Mrs Bogdan. The respondents took this drawing to Igor Designs for finalization by Mr Dan Djako, who was not available to give evidence as he was overseas. Mrs Bogdan testified that the ceiling arrangement in the house matched a feature from a magazine, though she admitted the ceiling over the central area and entry area was flat, contrary to the magazine picture. The respondents did not present evidence to challenge the availability of Mr Djako, nor did they provide photographs that Mrs Bogdan claimed she had taken to support her testimony.

This case involves an appeal from the decision of Ms Payne SM of the Magistrates Court of Queensland given on 20 March 2007. The appeal was heard by the court, which reviewed the evidence and legal arguments presented by both parties. Key procedural steps include the submission of various exhibits and testimonies, and the consideration of expert evidence from Mr Deshon, an expert witness called by Jennings. The appeal process involved examining the findings of Magistrate Payne and determining whether Jennings had successfully proven the infringement of their copyright by the respondents.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondents contend that the detailed drawing prepared by Mr Florien Bogdan (Annexure D1 to Exhibit 4) based upon contributions made by Mr Bogdan and the requests by Mrs Bogdan for particular features, was taken to Igor Designs, Architects and Draftsmen for the preparation of a final detailed drawing (Annexure E to Exhibit 4). The particular individual who prepared that drawing, Mr Dan Djako, was not called to give evidence by the respondents. The explanation for that failure was that Mr Djako was regrettably overseas at the time of the trial visiting a sick relative and was simply not available to give evidence. That position which emerged at trial, was not able to be tested by Jennings. One further matter relating to the availability of evidence should be mentioned. Mrs Bogdan gave evidence of the identicality of the ceiling arrangement in the Bogdan house as built and a raked feature of the ceiling shown in the photograph (Exhibit 6) she collected from the magazine mentioned in evidence, although in cross‑examination Mrs Bogdan accepted that the ceiling over the central area (lounge/dining) and the entry area is flat consistent with the sectional line shown on the drawing depicting a flat ceiling. Mrs Bogdan in earlier evidence said she had taken photographs showing the identicality with the magazine picture but had forgotten to bring the photographs to Court. The evidence before the primary court Before turning to the findings of Magistrate Payne, it is necessary to examine further the evidence put before the court below. Mr Henesey‑Smith in his report (Exhibit 2) expressed the opinion that the Bogdan plan “most resemble[d]” the plan and elevations of the Cortona 290 (Portico). He identified the two features of elevated ceilings and identically angled walls to the outdoor living areas and those other features described at [18] as the basis for that opinion. In oral evidence, he accepted that the Dixon plan had “some fundamental similarities” to the Cortona 290 plan “in the basis of a rear central patio and the raised ceilings through the patio and the living area … that’s really the main distinguishing feature”. Mr Henesey‑Smith said that he was familiar with some house products offered in the market by competitors but it was not his function to undertake competitor analyses or to become intimately familiar with the plans of competitors of Jennings. With that limitation in mind, he said that he was not aware of any competitor that offered a home in the marketplace with a portico area at the rear of the house with splayed or angled walls. Mr Henesey‑Smith identified a range of differences between the Cortona 290 and the Bogdan plan on the one hand and the Dixon plan on the other. In cross‑examination. Mr Henesey‑Smith said that although the Cortona 290 and Bogdan plans were not identical, “they’ve got what I’d say, very, very significant similarities”. The witness accepted that there was “a slight difference” between the Bogdan plan and the Cortona 290 in relation to the entrance area and that there are some differences in the size of rooms. The witness accepted that there was a “subtle difference” between the two plans due to the different roofline. The witness described the roofline as “very similar” apart from the fact that “the access to the roofline over the garage was slightly different”. The witness added “however, I don’t believe that it changes the overall fundamental similarity”. Mr Henesey‑Smith described the similarity between the two plans as “comprehensive” and said they were “very, very strong similarities”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GREENWOOD J
As to aspects of the layout, Mrs Bogdan accepted that bedroom 4 as described on Annexure C is identical in shape and configuration to bedroom 4 on the Jennings plan. As to the toilet and bathroom arrangement below bedroom 4, Mrs Bogdan accepted that they have the same shape and that bedrooms 2 and 3 are in the same position in Annexure C as in the Jennings plan. As to the nib walls, Mrs Bogdan accepted that nib walls are present in both plans. In Annexure C to Exhibit 4, the nib walls do not show any cut‑out section yet in the final Bogdan plan a cut‑out section is shown for the nib walls. The Jennings plan exhibits nib walls with a cut‑out section. As to that idea of cut‑out sections in a nib wall, Mrs Bogdan said she got that cosmetic idea from her head. She just “came up with [it] … from a magazine”. As to the elevated ceilings, Mrs Bogdan accepted that the ceiling over the front patio, living, dining and back patio area is elevated at 3.6m, higher than other ceilings in the house. Mrs Bogdan accepted that the Jennings plan depicts elevated ceilings at 3.3m higher than the rest of the Jennings house ceilings at 2.7m. As to the configuration of the U shaped kitchen, related pantry and position of the refrigerator, Mrs Bogdan accepted that that particular configuration was not evident in the Canberra plan. She said that she chose that configuration as an idea she conceived. Mrs Bogdan said that the Canberra plan did not assist her in conceiving the U shaped kitchen and that “not everything came from the Canberra design”. The configuration of the kitchen “just made sense, you have your laundry, you have your kitchen and you have the window along the wall”. The primary decision Magistrate Payne noted that some matters were not in issue before her. The defendants admitted by their pleading that Jennings is the owner of the copyright in plans described as the Cambridge 245, the Verona 245 and the Cortona 245 and further, by para 2(c) of their defence, the respondents admitted that at all material times they were in day to day control of the house design and plan used by them to build their house and that they were in control of the construction works carried out on site. Magistrate Payne perceived the issues to be whether the respondents had infringed the appellant’s copyright; whether they did so with knowledge; and, if so, the assessment of the true measure of the appellant’s loss. Magistrate Payne noted that Jennings had called Mr Deshon as an expert witness. Her Honour noted that part of Mr Deshon’s evidence in which he said that the distinguishing features of the plan are the higher ceilings and splayed walls. Magistrate Payne noted that Mr Deshon examined the Dixon plan and compared it with the Bogdan plan and the Cortona 290 and gave evidence that the same planning policy applied to all three, that is, the same “design strategies” evident in the two plans in issue are evident in the Dixon plan with “some similarities within the layout”. Magistrate Payne also noted Mr Deshon’s evidence that the raised ceiling is a distinguishing feature of “all three houses”. At p 4 of the judgment, her Honour made this finding:The evidence of the defendants was given by Mrs Bogdan. She said that she had not seen an A V Jennings plan before she was faxed one by the plaintiff’s solicitor. I accept Mrs Bogdan’s evidence in this regard and also her evidence that to her knowledge the Bogdan plans were not a copy of any A V Jennings plan.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GREENWOOD J

Magistrate Payne then expressed the view set out in para 2 quoted below, which resonates with the reservation expressed by Wilcox and Lindgren JJ in the last sentence of [111] in Tamawood:I note also that Mr and Mrs Bogdan did little to assist me other than to say that Mrs Bogdan in her evidence had never heard of AV Jennings and had never seen one of their plans and she said she had not seen one of their homes until she was contacted by AV Jennings. … However, despite this little assistance the onus rests on the plaintiff in this matter. When considering all of those similarities and dissimilarities which I have done and then, in applying the law, I do not consider that the plaintiff has discharged its burden of proof.I find that the displayed walls and raised ceiling to be that of a common idea and not sufficient to sustain a conclusion of reproduction of the whole or a substantial part of the AV Jennings Verona plan or Cortona plan by either or both of the first or second defendant. [emphasis added]Consideration of the issues on appeal There is no doubt that Jennings bears the onus of proving on the balance of probabilities that the respondents made actual use of the work in suit and having used the work, they brought into existence a plan that either takes a substantial part of the plan in suit, shown to be an essential or material feature of the whole (although perhaps a quantitatively small part) or takes substantially the whole plan, viewed quantitatively, assuming that an exact copy of the plan in suit has not been made. As to the last matter, no such claim is made. In this case, actual use is sought to be established as an inference arising out of contended striking similarities between the two plans. Those striking similarities then speak to reproduction of the plan in suit and thus infringement. In Francis Day & Hunter Ltd v Bron, Willmer LJ at p 614 noted, apart from the observations mentioned at [54] of these reasons, these further matters:(3)Where there is a substantial degree of objective similarity, this of itself will afford prima facie evidence to show that there is a causal connection between the plaintiffs’ and the defendants’ work; at least it is a circumstance from which the inference may be drawn.(4)The fact that the defendant denies that he consciously copied affords some evidence to rebut the inference of causal connection arising from the objective similarity, but is in no way conclusive. As to subconscious copying, Willmer LJ noted in Francis Day & Hunter at p 613 that, “if subconscious copying is to be found, there must be proof (or at least a strong inference) of de facto familiarity with the work alleged to be copied”. In the absence of any direct evidence of use of or access to the Jennings plan in suit, the causal link can be established by inference. The greater the degree of objective similarity between the two plans, the more likely it is that an inference of actual use might be drawn (S W Hart & Co (supra) per Gibbs CJ at 472; Clarendon Homes (Aust) Pty Ltd v Henley Arch Pty Ltd (1999) 46 IPR 309 per Heerey, Sundberg and Finkelstein JJ). Exact copying is rarely the conduct in controversy. Normally an inference is sought to be drawn in the face of quantitative features of the plan in suit, present in the plan under challenge, or by correspondence with a substantial part qualitatively of the plaintiff’s plan, or both. If the contention is that a substantial part of the plan in suit has been taken, a question of “fact and degree” arises (Inform Design and Construction Pty Ltd v Boutique Homes Melbourne Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 912 per Weinberg J at [71]) and the “protected element may arise out of a combination of elements, any one of which considered individually might not qualify as sufficiently original to attract copyright” (Inform Design, per Weinberg J at [71] [emphasis added]). An allegation of substantial reproduction of the work by reproduction of a substantial part will be made out if what is taken is an essential or material part of the work in suit. The phrase “substantial part” refers to the quality of that taken and the importance it bears to the work as a whole (Tamawood v Henley Arch at [50], [52] and [54]; Dixon Investments Pty Ltd v Hall 18 IPR 490 at 494 per Lockhart, Spender and Ryan JJ; Autodesk Inc. v Dyason [No. 2] (1993) 176 CLR 300 per Mason CJ at 305). It may be that a particular orientation and layout of rooms which draws a user through a structure in a particular way is an essential or material part of a plan (Eagle Homes Pty Ltd v Austec Homes Pty Ltd (1999) 161 ALR 503 at [74]). Essentiality is a question of fact and degree.